Now listen to him care fully my friend. You have to carefully indentify what Maulana said and what this munafiq alleges in his video.
I will break down his claims and allegations and see how was he lying on multiple accounts in this single little story of few lines.
1) Mirza alleged that Maulana ne apne mureed ko kalima parwaya tha ..... LIE a blatant one. Maulana never made him to recite a Kalima, Maulana only responded to his dream and post dream experince(will explain later) in the form of a possible taabeer .. There is a hell lot of difference between kisi se kalima parhana or kisi kay khawab or baad khawab kay experience par bat karna ya ussay tasali dena. How dare he lies to the public kay Maulana apne mureedon se kalima parhatay thay. Watch his videos, he said so many times kay ye deobandi or brelvi dono apna kalima parhatay thay. This is such a hypocrisy, to lie and cheat the public while playing with words. If you cant see it with your eyes, then i cant help it my friend. A man misquoting a sernior figure in Deoband and blaming him for what he had not done, it is a grave sin. This munafiq and a liar is not trust worthy. Maulana Thanvi ne kabhi mureed se apna kalima nahee parwaya. Mirza is a classic munafiq having all the features of a shia actually. Anyways move on ...
2) Mirza says in your video, the person who wrote this question to Maulana was his mureed. Another LIE my friend. Go to the text and check the background. That man was not the mureed at the time this happened. Read the whole story. He was only looking for to be one and saw in his dream, reciting this kalima and got very upset. Calling him already a Mureed at the time of this incidence gives a wrong impression as if he was already Maulanas student and Maulana lacked the capacity to teach him the true belifs, rather perhpas must have encouraged such unislamic things. Another dirty deception on Mirza part who is in habbit of lying and hiding facts from public. Go and read it all your self.
3) Mirza says, Maulana encouraged his students to say such things that is why they experience such things. LIE again. Maulana never encouraged. Answer was again twisted by this moron youtube molvi for his followers. Maulana tried to give him an islamic tabeer to a dream which made him very upset and he was frightened. What did he say, he said the person your are looking for (to be your sheikh) is completely with in the boundaries of Quran and Sunna. How clear Maulana was in his reponse to his Mureed to be, that the one you wish to have as your sheikh is not what you saw in your dreams, nor any thing out of strict boundaries of Shariaa but a follower of Shariaah but nothing more than that. Not a single word Maulana said to endorse what was witnessed in the dream, not a word he said to encourage the person. Mirzas munafiqat is that he puts his own words in to the story. Listen to him again and only pick up and focus on the words Maulana said. Not a single thing Maulana said was against shareeah. Mirza is deceitful and a liar.
4) The student who was not yet a mureed but wanted to be one, explained what he experienced. What he saw in his dream was not in his control. Maulana gave him tasali because he was clearly frightened knowing that what he said was Kufr. Maulana never said to him what you said was right. Maulana gaving him tasali, was based on the fact that he was not doing it wilfully as he was not in conrtol and it was only a bloody dream. Again Mirza tries to portray it in a deceitful way with his words .... Which he is master of ... deception
It is accepted asool of shareeah that one can not be held responsible for what he witnesses in his dreams. Otherwise there is so much nonsense people experience that you cant even imagine. Also you cant even influence ones dreams. Pure scientific phenomena which i am happy to talk about.
5) The only thing one can argue on, in this incidence is, whats the hukm on some one who has woken up but is still uttering such words of kufr. So this is a problem of little more knowledge of affects of a dream. It isnt a new phenomenon that dream has its affects, what we call, dream enactment behaviour. Ofcourse Mirza is a Jahil person who calls himself engineer but he knows nothing about physiology of dreams and dream enactment behaviour. One can act out of dreams and can have a perfect memory of the events after that but with no control. Anyways a students experience has nothing to do with Maulana Thanvi, and Maulana advised him in such a brilliant and short way ...... Jis ki tumen justaju hay, wo Shareeat ka paband hay. SubhanaALLAH.
Go my friend and read the whole incidence from the actual book. Read the text, you will find screen shots on google i am sure. Then listen to this hypocrite. Believe me if you have justice in your heart you will knows how wrong was he in his allegations. The reason i am descriptive here is because i already have discussed it all with one of Mirzas follower here in UK who posed me this question and i did a full research. He started it then when he came to know the whole story he tried to divert the topic not realising how he was misguided by this moron in the first place. This is called Mureedi my friend. Mirza has been made peer. When you cant see any flaw on your Peer, you defend everything he says and believe in everything he says .... He becomes your Peer.
Lastly take my answer to Mirza, and ask him to address each of these points. Anyone should take it to do us all a favour. I am sure you will only find his excuses. He would be disrespectful i am sure and will use his skills to divert from every point.
Cheers
