محترم آپسے اختلاف مقصد نہیں بس کچھ وضاحت ہے ۔ ظاہر ہے جو زباان نہیں آتی اس میں تعلیم کیسی! مگر کوئی بھی زبان پڑھائی سکھائی جا سکتی ہے، حتکہ کمپیوٹر یا سائن زبان وغیرہ بھی سکھائے جا سکتے ہیں اور تعلیم ہو سکتی ہے ۔!جو زبان ہی نہیں آتی اس میں کیا تعلیم دی جائے گی
I hope govt is not talking about teaching math and physics in Urdu.Well, I am not sure what exactly the new law is practically. It is a good thing to have a common syllabus for the whole country. But if it is really promoting Urdu over English, then this is the most stupid step of the government. All the present day knowledge is in English and weakness in English has already hurt Pakistan a lot. Even counties like China & Japan have started teaching English to their new generations. I am a die-heart supporter of PTI and will remain so. But surprised to see PTI ppl here blindly supporting this new step of government. Wake up PTI supporters, we are not expected to support blindly the bad things of our party.
Just a simple question why don't we declare English as our national language in place of Urdu?There is difference between "maadri zuban" and "qaumi zuban". Pakistan has dozens of maadri zubans like pashto sindhi, balochi, persian, seraiki, hindko, brushiski, shina, Gujari, chitrali, kalasha, etc etc,. As far as maadri zuban is concerned it is very limited and non practical.
As for qomi zuban 'Urdu', it is an imported language being a hodgepodge of many languages like persian, turkish, snskrit etc and has been imposed on Pakistan because of Indian connection.. One reason for the dissatisfaction/secession of East Pakistanis was the imposition of Urdu on them. Pakistan should adopt English as its official language (as 90 percent of the world ) and change qomi zuban to Arabic . At least we will know the meanings of our prayers and Holy Quran. What good is Urdu other than offering good poetry. As regards copying China or Japan or Russia, we cannot do that because they are a world different to us in discipline, hardwork, honesty and even hard work.. We should remember "kavva chala hans ki chaal, apni chaal bhi bhool gaya".
I support Asma Sherazi, here.
اس کو ذاتی رائے ہی سمجھیں۔ پنجابی، پشتو، سندھی، بلوچی سمجھنے والا انگلش کے مقابلے میں اردو آسانی سے سیکھ لیتا ہے۔Why English? For a Punjabi Child, Urdu is a 2nd language same for a Sindhi, Pashtoon or Baluchi.
If We think English is not good for a non English child to learn then why we want Urdu for a non Urdu speaking child?