Recent content by Tabrez

salam alaikum, I am not sure what fourteen centuries old "debate" you are referring to here. I am only aware of what the Book of God is saying: <Aw yakoona laka baytun min zukhrufin aw tarqa fee alssamai walan numina liruqiyyika hatta tunazzila AAalayna kitaban naqraohu qul subhana rabbee hal...

I would like to state up front that I am a Muslim and I attest that there is no god, except for Allah, and that the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) is His slave and messenger. I honor and love Prophet Muhammad more than words can explain. I have noticed that in the Pakistani society the love of the...

Salam Alaikum, Please elaborate your question. What do you mean when you ask me if I believe in the Ahadith of the Prophet Muhammad? What do you want me to believe about them? I believe what I know about them. Many years after the death of the Prophet, there were so many false ahadith in...

Salam Alaikum, You wrote: "na'uzobillah. Why would I even think that narrators of Ahadeeth are prophets??" Good. So we are on the same page with regards to that. So these people were not prophets, and therefore, they were NOT receiving revelations, and therefore, their works are works of...

Salam Alaikum, I think you did not read my message carefully. I never denied the Prophet or his Sunnah. In fact, I stated very clearly that things like salaat come to us from his sunnah. I learned salaat from my parents, who learned it from their parents, who, in turn learned it from their...

Salam Alaikum, Please elaborate, what you mean here? Do I "believe" in ahadeeth as what? As revelations from Allah or as books written by historians? I BELIEVE that Einstein wrote his paper on general relativity, and I BELIEVE that Bukhari (for example) wrote the volumes of ahadeeth that he...

Mr. Hamid says that he doesn't say things that are against the Qur'an. According to the Qur'an, the Prophet did not know the Ghaib, but Mr. Hamid is promoting war with India mased on hadeeth that allege - against the Qur'anic testimony - that the Prophet made statements about the ghaib - the...

Recently I was listening to a speaker who was talking about a war between Pakistan and India, and was quoting some hadeeth to support that the Prophet made predictions about the Muslim conquest of India. The speaker was promoting a dangerous philosophy advocating a deadly war between two nuclear...

Re: Zaid Hamid Here and After - An Observer and Inside Vie Recently I was listening to a speaker who was talking about a war between Pakistan and India, and was quoting some hadeeth to support that the Prophet made predictions about the Muslim conquest of India. The speaker was promoting a...

Recently I was listening to a speaker who was talking about a war between Pakistan and India, and was quoting some hadeeth to support that the Prophet made predictions about the Muslim conquest of India. The speaker was promoting a dangerous philosophy advocating a deadly war between two nuclear...