Advertisement

No apology, no dropping of charges, says US and India mellows down in Diplomats Case :)

Devyani Khobragade case: no apology, no dropping of charges, says US


PTI | Dec 20, 2013, 08.57 PM IST

devyani_sari_reuters360.jpg

New Delhi/Washington: The US has apparently hardened its stand on Indian diplomat Devyani Khobragade, who was arrested last week over alleged visa fraud. A US State Department spokesperson today rejected India's demand for dropping of charges against the diplomat, calling it a "law enforcement issue." India has said it will go only by conversations held at "senior levels" between New Delhi and Washington.




NEW DELHI: India on Friday spoke in conciliatory language on the issue of its senior diplomat Devyani Khobragade's case, saying that it was important to "preserve" the "valuable" India-US relationship even as the US ruled out the demand for dropping the charges against her.


External affairs minister Salman Khurshid sounded hopeful of finding a way out when he told reporters here, "We are going to find a solution. And I hope that we will find a solution."


A day after he demanded dropping of charges against Khobragade unconditionally, Khurshid on Friday said, "I am conscious of the fact that this is a valuable relationship between two countries" while dealing with the "hurtful" and "unacceptable" treatment meted out to our diplomat.


The two countries have been in touch during the last two days to resolve the diplomatic stand-off created by the arrest and strip-search of Khobragade, deputy consul general in New York who is now transferred to India's permanent mission at UN, on the charges of visa fraud. She has been accused of underpaying her maid as per the US law.


Wendy Sherman, under secretary of state for political affairs, has had lengthy conversation with foreign secretary Sujatha Singh on Wednesday and Thursday in a bid to find a way out. According to sources, they discussed "specific steps" to resolve the issue.


Talking to reporters, Singh said, "You do not treat an Indian diplomat in this manner whether it is in the US or any other country. We expect our diplomat to be given exactly the same courtesies that we extend to American diplomats or diplomat of any other country."


A 1999-batch IFS officer, Khobragade was arrested on December 12 on visa fraud charges as she was dropping her daughter to school and released on a $250,000 bond after pleading not guilty in court.


The ill-treatment of its diplomat evoked a sharp reaction from India which initiated a slew of steps to downgrade the privileges enjoyed by the US diplomats and their families including withdrawing airport passes and stopping import clearances.


Meanwhile, in Washington, the US State Department rejected India's demands of dropping visa fraud charges against Khobragade and apologising for mistreating her, saying the allegations were "very serious" and she would not be allowed to go scot-free.


State department spokesperson Marie Harf also made it clear that the immunity sought for 39-year-old Khobragade after her transfer to India's permanent mission to the UN is "not retroactive".


BJP praises govt


Government today earned a rare praise from senior BJP leader Yashwant Sinha who said it had shown "some courage" in dealing with the US over diplomat Devyani Khobragade issue.


Sinha, former external affairs minister, advocated tough action against US diplomats in India if they were found violating rules and laws, as a tit-for-tat measure.


"They (government) have shown some courage in taking some of the steps and there is commitment of the external affairs minister (Salman Khurshid) in Parliament to take further steps," he told PTI.


Angry over handcuffing and strip search of Khobragade, India's deputy consul general in New York, the government has retaliated strongly by initiating a series of reprisal steps to strip US diplomats and their families of privileges including withdrawing all airport passes and stopping import clearances for the embassy.


Sinha said the government should move legally against USA personnel here who are in violation of Indian laws.


"Its not only Section 377 of IPC, there are a number of laws. They have not paid Income Tax, they have done other illegal acts, then 377 of course is there. Whatever laws they have violated, the government should allow police to investigate and handcuff them and take them to Tihar jail," said the BJP leader.


India has been outraged over the arrest of Deputy consul general Devyani Khobragade, a 1999-batch IFS officer, on a street in New York over visa fraud charges as she was dropping her daughter to school.


http://www.ndtv.com/article/cheat-s...apology-no-dropping-of-charges-says-us-460894
 
Advertisement
(bigsmile)...Indeed a funny predicament. India needs to preserve their relationship with the US then why did it pretend to be a "Tarzan" in the first place ??

That was our whole point. Instead of supporting a spoilt brat who broke the law, if devyani had nothing to hide then India should have waited for the law proceedings to complete their course. Behaving like a tarzan while being a paper tiger is only going to lead to more humiliation.

Pakistan condemns in any kind of Tarzan-like behaviour and urges an ammicable solution to this issue. We are ready to provide mediation services at a cost if requested.

Our message of peace and love as always !:)
 
Advertisement
(bigsmile)...Indeed a funny predicament. India needs to preserve their relationship with the US then why did it pretend to be a "Tarzan" in the first place ??

That was our whole point. Instead of supporting a spoilt brat who broke the law, if devyani had nothing to hide then India should have waited for the law proceedings to complete their course. Behaving like a tarzan while being a paper tiger is only going to lead to more humiliation.

Pakistan condemns in any kind of Tarzan-like behaviour and urges an ammicable solution to this issue. We are ready to provide mediation services at a cost if requested.

Our message of peace and love as always !:)

[hilar] [hilar][hilar] ye to noore se bhi gaya guzra tiger huwa!!!
 
yaar fakir


this is what I call 'Roar like a lion but back off like a mouse (rat in case of India)' lol

JUst like we pakistanis do, they killed our soldiers and we resumed their supplies jus like acting the same way indians are doing it now..

"Dushman Mare Te Khushi Na Kariye Hoye Sajna Vee Mar Jana"
 
اے دوویں مل کے پاکستان نال گلی / ڈنڈا گھیڈ رۓ سن
گلی گئی گوچ تے ڈنڈا لے کہ اک دوجے نوں پے گۓ کہ
" دس گلی کھتے کیتی او " متبل بگھیاڑ پے گیا کتے نو
تےاو وی " لینڈی کتا " جس نواں نواں " پیو " لبیا سی
​
 
Aik US kay undersecretary nay phone ker kay demagh thikanay laga diya [hilar][hilar]

Salman Khurshid sahab tarzan ki rassi chore ker zameen per agaye hain ...

Humein to drones pay boht batein banayi jaati hain ...ab kerain deal america say !..kiya hua ??
:lol::lol:

yaar fakir


this is what I call 'Roar like a lion but back off like a mouse (rat in case of India)' lol
 
اے دوویں مل کے پاکستان نال گلی / ڈنڈا گھیڈ رۓ سن
گلی گئی گوچ تے ڈنڈا لے کہ اک دوجے نوں پے گۓ کہ
" دس گلی کھتے کیتی او " متبل بگھیاڑ پے گیا کتے نو
تےاو وی " لینڈی کتا " جس نواں نواں " پیو " لبیا سی
​

yaar, can you translate this Arabic in Urdu or English now?
 
Advertisement
"Diplomat" Raymond davis was allowed such easy out from his killing spree in Pakistana and US had a very different approach to that. Why not treat poor indians the way they treat their own Diplomat?

Government of Pakistan shame on you,shame!
 
Aik US kay undersecretary nay phone ker kay demagh thikanay laga diya [hilar][hilar]

Salman Khurshid sahab tarzan ki rassi chore ker zameen per agaye hain ...

Humein to drones pay boht batein banayi jaati hain ...ab kerain deal america say !..kiya hua ??
:lol::lol:

election season hai, be chara karey kia? Congress in trouble as it is
 
The right honourable iftikhar choudhary the champion of judiciary resided over that case too (bigsmile)

"Diplomat" Raymond davis was allowed such easy out from his killing spree in Pakistana and US had a very different approach to that. Why not treat poor indians the way they treat their own Diplomat?

Government of Pakistan shame on you,shame!
 
Advertisement
The right honourable iftikhar choudhary the champion of judiciary resided over that case too (bigsmile)

Did you miss the part where DG ISI Ahmed Shuja Pasha personally came to court when the case was being heard and kept texting his American colleagues updating them on the case. CJ followed the law of the land 'Dait' is a part and parcel of our legal system. Bigger question is why didn't ISI charged Raymond Davis with spying, a crime for which there is no 'Dait' or blood money.
 
yaar, can you translate this Arabic in Urdu or English now?

یہ دونوں مل کر پاکستان کے ساتھ گلی / ڈنڈا ** دہاتی کھیل ** کھیل رہے تھے
گلی گئی گم اور دونوں ایک دوسرے سے الجھ پڑے کہ نکال گلی کہاں چھپائی ہے
مطلب " بھیڑیا پڑ گیا کتے کو " اور کتا بھی وہ جو " کتے والی خصوصیات سے عاری " جس
نے امبریکا کو نیا نیا باپ بنایا تھا
​
 
Did you miss the part where DG ISI Ahmed Shuja Pasha personally came to court when the case was being heard and kept texting his American colleagues updating them on the case. CJ followed the law of the land 'Dait' is a part and parcel of our legal system. Bigger question is why didn't ISI charged Raymond Davis with spying, a crime for which there is no 'Dait' or blood money.

Do you remember what was the statement of CJ LHR on the arrest of Raymond? If not let me recall his statement. He said:

اس کیس سے کہی پاکستان کے لیے کوئی مصیبت نہ بن جائے؟

If he had already such mind then where is Law and where is land? BTW what law has he followed?

He could ordered in initial stage to register Terrorism case against him instead of just simple 302 by Punjab Police under Rana Sana and Showbaz.
 
Did you miss the part where DG ISI Ahmed Shuja Pasha personally came to court when the case was being heard and kept texting his American colleagues updating them on the case. CJ followed the law of the land 'Dait' is a part and parcel of our legal system. Bigger question is why didn't ISI charged Raymond Davis with spying, a crime for which there is no 'Dait' or blood money.

did he really?
 
Kamal hai ?? ...You were given access to such a classified court hearing and you didnt even tell us ?? [hilar]...can you please cook up fewer stories and talk actuality!

You sound like a GEO representative ![hilar]

Did you miss the part where DG ISI Ahmed Shuja Pasha personally came to court when the case was being heard and kept texting his American colleagues updating them on the case. CJ followed the law of the land 'Dait' is a part and parcel of our legal system. Bigger question is why didn't ISI charged Raymond Davis with spying, a crime for which there is no 'Dait' or blood money.