Advertisement

Top Story - 29th May 2013 - ڈی این اے ٹیسٹ حتمی نہیں ہوتا

Advertisement
These mullas are disgrace and it proves beyond doubt that whatever sufis/mullas and taliban say is from quran and extremists from other religions, allege on Islam is not without foundation. All religions are enemy of science and its creations. May be their refusal to have various preventive vaccinations or Refuting validity and efficacy of DNA is like denying the role of mulla's mother in its birth. How come these followers of dark religions can hope to progress and improve their lives. They can only rot.
 
Advertisement
http://www.guardian.co.uk/law/2011/oct/02/formula-justice-bayes-theorem-miscarriage

Regardless of this debate, DNA testing itself is not considered as a conclusive evidence under the light of recent rulings in the English law.

Bechara koi molvi keh day to us ki shamat aa jati hai ...

What you said conclusive? My brother science is always evolving and for that read sura Nisa.At the present level of knowledge DNA is best so far, may be later something better can be found.
These Mullahs are those who were against loud speaker and pictures, but now they keep barking on loud speaker and love to be seen on TV, In past they were saying in loud speaker"Iblees " Speaks Now I say yes Iblees speaks but that iblees is mullah
 
What you said conclusive? My brother science is always evolving and for that read sura Nisa.At the present level of knowledge DNA is best so far, may be later something better can be found.
These Mullahs are those who were against loud speaker and pictures, but now they keep barking on loud speaker and love to be seen on TV, In past they were saying in loud speaker"Iblees " Speaks Now I say yes Iblees speaks but that iblees is mullah
kuch toh sharam karo yaar..
 
What you said conclusive? My brother science is always evolving and for that read sura Nisa.At the present level of knowledge DNA is best so far, may be later something better can be found.
These Mullahs are those who were against loud speaker and pictures, but now they keep barking on loud speaker and love to be seen on TV, In past they were saying in loud speaker"Iblees " Speaks Now I say yes Iblees speaks but that iblees is mullah


I have not listen the program.

But please you answer .

DNA would prove rape or sex??

Do we not need other forensic test to prove it is rape or only DNA test is enough??
 
Advertisement
These mullas are disgrace and it proves beyond doubt that whatever sufis/mullas and taliban say is from quran and extremists from other religions, allege on Islam is not without foundation. All religions are enemy of science and its creations. May be their refusal to have various preventive vaccinations or Refuting validity and efficacy of DNA is like denying the role of mulla's mother in its birth. How come these followers of dark religions can hope to progress and improve their lives. They can only rot.


Sceince always remain in evolving state. one theory that was consider as fact become obsolete when proven wrong.


any way
I have not listen the program.

But please you answer .

DNA would prove rape or sex??

Do we not need other forensic test to prove it is rape or only DNA test is enough??

please answer the question in educated manner
 
Last edited:
What you said conclusive? My brother science is always evolving and for that read sura Nisa.At the present level of knowledge DNA is best so far, may be later something better can be found.
These Mullahs are those who were against loud speaker and pictures, but now they keep barking on loud speaker and love to be seen on TV, In past they were saying in loud speaker"Iblees " Speaks Now I say yes Iblees speaks but that iblees is mullah
Wow Dude calm down. Dna Evidence can be placed or planted, there is a reason Islam asks for 4 witnesses.
 
Wow Dude calm down. Dna Evidence can be placed or planted, there is a reason Islam asks for 4 witnesses.

Read the sura before you comment, in quranic words four witness is not for zina, its for bay hayaee which leads to zina, and if you cannot think and have to listen to mullah then they will give you what they think. DNA can be planted yes you right but still forensics can seperate the planted and real stuff.But that is if we want to reach truth, but if we just want to follow and not use brain then I am sorry everyone is entitled to his opinion.Just look at the situation in just pakistan, if female is abducted and raped and she survives, how can she provide four witnesses? plus the powerful will always make sure that there are no four witnesses. Then what should be done.Now do not tell me that she should stay quiet and not say anything.She can be your or mine sister, mother etc too, will you wait or say oh sorry sister you should have four men watching you too so we can punish the rapist.. Sorry it do not work like that.God forbid no one should get in situation like this.
But read the whole thing about four witness, and I qoute"they should have seen it going in and disappearing and seeing the faces" now I leave it to your imagination to position your witnesses, Plus if these four idiots are watching it this closely why not they go ahead and help the girl? Are they part of the raping team? Sorry if I am offending you. I suggest read some Hadees books and read with open mind you will see how many questions will come in your head.
 
Advertisement
Read the sura before you comment, in quranic words four witness is not for zina, its for bay hayaee which leads to zina, and if you cannot think and have to listen to mullah then they will give you what they think. DNA can be planted yes you right but still forensics can seperate the planted and real stuff.But that is if we want to reach truth, but if we just want to follow and not use brain then I am sorry everyone is entitled to his opinion.Just look at the situation in just pakistan, if female is abducted and raped and she survives, how can she provide four witnesses? plus the powerful will always make sure that there are no four witnesses. Then what should be done.Now do not tell me that she should stay quiet and not say anything.She can be your or mine sister, mother etc too, will you wait or say oh sorry sister you should have four men watching you too so we can punish the rapist.. Sorry it do not work like that.God forbid no one should get in situation like this.
But read the whole thing about four witness, and I qoute"they should have seen it going in and disappearing and seeing the faces" now I leave it to your imagination to position your witnesses, Plus if these four idiots are watching it this closely why not they go ahead and help the girl? Are they part of the raping team? Sorry if I am offending you. I suggest read some Hadees books and read with open mind you will see how many questions will come in your head.
Ok well here i go,
First off Adultery and Rape are two different things all together, Zia made this stupid law calling it Sharia law ( sharia law is whole different debate ). Four witnesses are absolutely not needed in case of Rape. Four witnesses indeed are needed if one wants to accuse adultery on someone( now this does have lot of logic ).
So your whole argument becomes invalid, i cant refute something that does not exist.
And about DNA evidence, There is so much miss understanding about the role of DNA, on both sides of debate.
First off DNA is definite science is only partially true. There have been cases where one brother had to go jail because of his siblings DNA.
Second DNA is never used as sole evidence to convict anyone. It is actually definitely used to prove innocence.
Now back to RAPE , Yes DNA test will have to play a major role in court proceeding but not a definite one. There are so many ways DNA could be found on victim or supposed victim. ( consenting sex and one changed mind later on, now there is your DNA).
It is a long topic wish we could talk face to face.
 
Read the sura before you comment, in quranic words four witness is not for zina, its for bay hayaee which leads to zina, and if you cannot think and have to listen to mullah then they will give you what they think. DNA can be planted yes you right but still forensics can seperate the planted and real stuff.But that is if we want to reach truth, but if we just want to follow and not use brain then I am sorry everyone is entitled to his opinion.Just look at the situation in just pakistan, if female is abducted and raped and she survives, how can she provide four witnesses? plus the powerful will always make sure that there are no four witnesses. Then what should be done.Now do not tell me that she should stay quiet and not say anything.She can be your or mine sister, mother etc too, will you wait or say oh sorry sister you should have four men watching you too so we can punish the rapist.. Sorry it do not work like that.God forbid no one should get in situation like this.
But read the whole thing about four witness, and I qoute"they should have seen it going in and disappearing and seeing the faces" now I leave it to your imagination to position your witnesses, Plus if these four idiots are watching it this closely why not they go ahead and help the girl? Are they part of the raping team? Sorry if I am offending you. I suggest read some Hadees books and read with open mind you will see how many questions will come in your head.

One more thing four witnesses are only needed if someone wants to refute a woman's claim of being pure or innocence. and burden to provide those four witnesses is on the accuser . Again in Islam RAPE VICTIM absolutely DONOT , I repeat DONOT need four witnesses. And i can prove that from Quran and hadith also.

So i think you and i are on same page , our approach is different i guess.
 
Ok well here i go,
First off Adultery and Rape are two different things all together, Zia made this stupid law calling it Sharia law ( sharia law is whole different debate ). Four witnesses are absolutely not needed in case of Rape. Four witnesses indeed are needed if one wants to accuse adultery on someone( now this does have lot of logic ).
So your whole argument becomes invalid, i cant refute something that does not exist.
And about DNA evidence, There is so much miss understanding about the role of DNA, on both sides of debate.
First off DNA is definite science is only partially true. There have been cases where one brother had to go jail because of his siblings DNA.
Second DNA is never used as sole evidence to convict anyone. It is actually definitely used to prove innocence.
Now back to RAPE , Yes DNA test will have to play a major role in court proceeding but not a definite one. There are so many ways DNA could be found on victim or supposed victim. ( consenting sex and one changed mind later on, now there is your DNA).
It is a long topic wish we could talk face to face.
I do not need to argue but as you said"It is actually definitely used to prove innocence." then the case is done guilty and innocence are two sides of coin,if innocence then it means not guilty,, if not guil;ty then take the girl to jail for Tohmat.One in many millions case may be confusing DNA issue, but mostly it narrows down the list. Now you said consentual sex and change of mind, hell I agree with you, but in Pakistan there is no consentual sex, they will still be guilty but now both, on other hand there can be further investigation if claim of consentual sex is made, I never said that just put the man in jail after finding DNA evidence, see what is the source of DNA and where it is found and can it reach that place, plus few more interrogating techniques can be utilized, like Lie detector tests, and I mean both of them. My argument was just do not through science out of such a complicated case.
 
Put padlock on your mouth, I know well how much sharum you have, you want to sell the ignorant version of Islam go do it but stay civilized, do not dare to preach me as I live here too and know very well what my national bros do here.
Phir bhi yaar kuch toh sharam karo...
 
Advertisement
I have not listen the program.

But please you answer .

DNA would prove rape or sex??

Do we not need other forensic test to prove it is rape or only DNA test is enough??

DNA just narrow down the list of people to interrogation, and where was DNA found and how can it reach that place should be considered also, remember criminal think they are smart but they also leave behind leads just by acting smart.DNA is sure way of finding if something happend, after that sex happened claim is verified then the second part comes if it was consentual or not, or just she was fooling around and he over powered her and forced him in.Definately girl is guilty of going that far(fooling around) but this does not give the man right to go step ahead.
 
oh man you must have left Pakistan loooong time ago. trust me they have plenty consensual sex and more.

thats true its been a while may be 30 years now but then they need to change law accordingly, and leave this name "Islamic Republic" just name it "Republic of Pakistan", I know about Arab that they do everything behind walls, and we are just overdoing it Islam Islam, I lived few years in SA they do not give crap to this Muslim or Islam thing, thats why have no wish to ever visit. but any way you made me to visit pakistan now i have to go and see how much change is there
 
thats true its been a while may be 30 years now but then they need to change law accordingly, and leave this name "Islamic Republic" just name it "Republic of Pakistan", I know about Arab that they do everything behind walls, and we are just overdoing it Islam Islam, I lived few years in SA they do not give crap to this Muslim or Islam thing, thats why have no wish to ever visit. but any way you made me to visit pakistan now i have to go and see how much change is there
lol, the longest i was out of Pakistan was seven years, and when i went back it was some major cultural shock for me, You SHOULD visit , i can only imagine the look on your face when you land in Pakistan. It has changed like crazy in last decade
 
DNA just narrow down the list of people to interrogation, and where was DNA found and how can it reach that place should be considered also, remember criminal think they are smart but they also leave behind leads just by acting smart.DNA is sure way of finding if something happend, after that sex happened claim is verified then the second part comes if it was consentual or not, or just she was fooling around and he over powered her and forced him in.Definately girl is guilty of going that far(fooling around) but this does not give the man right to go step ahead.

So in short DNA can not be consider Primary or Confirm prove of Rape. but sex.

And other forensic tests should be taken care of right?