As per my weak knowledge but considerable observational skills Punjabi language seems to be a distorted version of the Urdu language with plus or minus certain words.
Punjabi is like the Texan version of Urdu. Twist urdu words a bit and one can get to speak Punjabi and vice versa.
Question of the week is
All Punjabi Pakistanis can speak in Urdu. Why can not all Urdu Speaking Karachite Pakistanis speak Punjabi?
Urdu is a link language like English, that's why Urdu is a national language of Pakistan. Can you tell me in what language a french and an arab communicate with each other? Off course in English. Same as with Urdu, a Sindhi Pakistani always speaks with a Pukhtoon Pakistani in a common language and that common language is Urdu.
As you said why not Urdu speaking people in Karachi speak Punjabi? The answer is simple, Urdu is their mother language and they are comfortable in urdu.They no need to speak any other language whaen their own language in spoken and understood in every inch of Pakistan.
Parveen Shakir was MA in English but she was a popular poetess of urdu, once she was asked why don't you write peotry in English? She replied, "I do poetry in the language of my thinking", means she always used to think in Urdu and so she used to do poetry in Urdu. She was urdu speaking person BTW.
Can you ask the same question to an English Speaking American that why dosn't he speak in Spanish or as per you say in Texan????????
Raise some issues that are valuable to Pakistanis, don't try to disintegrate them more my dear. They are already disintegrated. God bless you and all of us. Thanks
so someone again give you wrong information, not every punjabi can speak urdu. You go outside big cities of punjab and you will find that people cant' speak urdu they can only communicate in punjabi... so what you think about your knowledge and observation skills now:P
Urdu is the national language while Punjabi is regional. Dude if you are trying to flame some Urdu bashing then be warned Punjabis rarely get a boner on lingual/ racial issues (bigsmile)
Urdu is the national language while Punjabi is regional. Dude if you are trying to flame some Urdu bashing then be warned Punjabis rarely get a boner on lingual/ racial issues (bigsmile)