Advertisement

State of Taliban in Afghanistan - Secret leaked ISAF report

I have been recently doing some reading on Afghanistan Taliban position.
Mainly work of the excellent Afghan Analysis Network. I cant recommend them enough for anyone actually interested in the real ground situation in Afghanistan.

Afghanistan Analysts Network | Independent non-profit research organisation

Recently a remarkable document from ISAF was leaked to the press. Firstly to BBC but then to NYT and other Outlets.




NYT published the full document.

www.s3.documentcloud.org/documents/296489/taliban-report.pdf

Alternative Link:

http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/world/asia/23atwar-taliban-report-docviewer.html

Do read it carefully if you are interested in the topic. It challenges many popular nations.

Will definitely alter the way you look at the conflict. Just 30 pages but packed with insight.
Which is very unusual for an official report which are usually long,meandering and tedious.

Highly recommend.
 
Last edited:
Advertisement
I did read it, why was it leaked, any insight? Al Qaeda seems more entrenched in TTP than Afghan Taliban?
 
Last edited:
I did read it, why was it leaked, any insight? Al Qaeda seems more entrenched in TTP than Afghan Taliban?

TTP is its own beast now . Remember AQ letter from Attiya & Al Libbi to Hakeemullah Masood.

TTP is basically a vacuum cleaner that has hovered up 30 yr of Pak Mil assets. From Kashmir Mujahadeen group to Sectarian groups.
Even AQ types felt they were being used up by TTP. One of the first action of TTP was to kill Col Imam and Khalid Khwaja.
Imagine how unnerving that was for ISI. (Kind like when the Dr. Moreus monster finally kill him in that HG Wells story:P)

BVjvaf5CQAIGECg.jpg:large


How the Mehsuds have achieved this is quite remarkable. Maybe it has to do with special tribal cohesiveness in Mehsud tribal thinking.
(exemplified by thier aphorism "Meizh dree Mehsid). But the fact Humam Khalil Abu Mulal ak Belawi carried out the worst attack on CIA in quarter of a century in Camp Chapman and then dedicated it to a Baitullah Mehsud & not Osama Bin Laden or Aymen Al Zawahiri is worth noting.

Afghan Taliban may tolerate TTP as leverage against ISI and Pak Mil who they dont trust at all (for good reason) but they know TTP is trouble in long run. Even in 90's if you read the stuff from National Security Archive. Afghan Taliban were sick of AQ types and were more then willing to get rid of them if they were given the opportunity of some minimal face saving.

Afghan Talib have TTP surrounded with Gul Buhader ,Mullah Nazir faction & Haqqanis all which are organizationally basically simply extensions of Afghan Taliban so they think they can risk this.
 
Last edited:
Advertisement
TTP is its own beast now . Remember AQ letter from Attiya & Al Libbi to Hakeemullah Masood.

TTP is basically a vacuum cleaner that has hovered up 30 yr of Pak Mil assets. From Kashmir Mujahadeen group to Sectarian groups.
Even AQ types felt they were being used up by TTP. One of the first action of TTP was to kill Col Imam and Khalid Khwaja.
Imagine how unnerving that was for ISI. (Kind like when the Dr. Moreus monster finally kill him in that HG Wells story:P)

Zhohaq read this report written in 2007, how much has come true? is frightining !! Source:http://www.globalresearch.ca/the-destabilization-of-pakistan/7705
 
Zhohaq read this report written in 2007, how much has come true? is frightining !! Source:http://www.globalresearch.ca/the-destabilization-of-pakistan/7705

I agree with some of the analyses of the situation but don't agree with the conclusions it comes to.

US wants Pakistan to be stable but neutered. It doesn't want it to break up but definitely want it weak ,dependent and pliant in the long run.
The drone programme targeting TTP leadership shows Pak Mil , US Mil are mostly on the same page.
This works for US Mil as Pakistan Army has slowly and steadily grown more and more pliant. Slowly & surely it has been infiltrated. So much so ability for independent thinking and actions have been lost to a great degree.
Pakistan Army has over ten year almost been almost "captured" institutionally. (Like Jordan Military or Egypt Military after Sadaat)

In the scheme of things US see India as its primary partner in S Asia, and the regional super power.
In US state dept thinking the supprot to Pakistan in 50 till 80's was a mistake that alienated it from the more competent country , India.

India on the other hand see supporting insurgencies in Pakistan as a low risk high reward operation.
ISAF presence & Taliban insurgency is actually only things that has stopped them from pursuing this in a large substantive scale yet. But NDS and RAW thinking is aligned in this front.
The leaked report clearly alludes to this cooperation with regards to TTP btw.

Origin of most of the problems described are not external rather its has more to do with short sightedness of our Military planners.

Main problem is that Military thinking is now tied up in knots due to the imposed WoT paradigm.
Without mental chops to construct an alternative paradigm without succumbing to Islamic motifs which it is now wary of its stuck in a bind.
It has managed to alienate most popular political forces & currents in country & now sheepishly clings to support from the tiny allegedly "Liberal" class who demand that it gives more and more concessions to foreign interests.
This is a recipe for alienation from wider population in long run.
A frightening prospect for an institution so coddled through its history like Pakistan Army.

Much like Egypt and Syrian Arab Army its now even courting the idea of re branding its self image as a "protector" of minorities & secularism against the Islamic hordes lol. Same institution that was smuggling HJ-8 to Bosnian militants due to notions of Islamic brotherhood in 90's. Imagine that.


Robbed of any credible reason detre it to rely on paranoia & hysterical conspiracy theories to justify its essentially mercantile operations.
Its scared to the core of a day of reckoning at the hands of the population it has so abused, so will cling to US largesse no matter what the cost. This is the reason US pull out from Afghanistan frightens it.
 
Last edited:
Advertisement
[TABLE="width: 0"]
[TR="bgcolor: transparent"]
[TD="bgcolor: transparent"]یہ طالبان کے پاس پیسے کہاں سے آرہے ہیں جب پورا افغانستان امداد پر چل رہا ہے ؟ کیا ملا عمر اپنا ذاتی پیسہ لگا رہے ہیں ؟
[/TD]
[/TR]
[TR="bgcolor: transparent"]
[/TR]
[/TABLE]
 
[TABLE="width: 0"]
[TR="bgcolor: transparent"]
[TD="bgcolor: transparent"]یہ طالبان کے پاس پیسے کہاں سے آرہے ہیں جب پورا افغانستان امداد پر چل رہا ہے ؟ کیا ملا عمر اپنا ذاتی پیسہ لگا رہے ہیں ؟[/TD]
[/TR]
[TR="bgcolor: transparent"]
[/TR]
[/TABLE]

Agar app report parhain to us peh is pehlo par khasi roshni dali howi hai. (Report ka Page 13-15)

Taliban ka saalana Budget takreeban $150 million hay.

Afghanistan or Pakistan mein jo in kay hami hi woh chanda ikata kar kar yeh poora karatay hay.
Report kai Mutabiq Pakistan oar Afghanistan kay chootay baray aksar shehron mein Taliban chanda apnay hamion say ikatha kartay pirthay hai.

Gulf mumalik mein mukeem Afghan sai bhi yeh rakam chanday kay tor par wasool hota hay.
Yeh rakam Hawala network kay zaryay chootay amounts mein bejha jata ha. Is ka suragh lagana boht mushkal hai.

Is pooray process mein kabhi bhi Taliban Aam Bankari nizam ka istemal nahin kartay.
Kyon kay is par US ki kaari nazar hai.

Taliban jin ilaqon par Afghanistan mein qabiz hay wahan kay Makami kashtkar par bhi tax lagatay hai.

Report mein yeh bhi lika hay kay Afghanistan may mukeem Taliban koi tankhwa wasool nahin karta oar woh apna karobar aam sheriyon kay tarah jaari rakta hai. Albata woh Taliban jin ko Pakistan jaana parta hai unhein aik khas rakam bejhe jaati hai.

Jab makami jangjo kay hath Nato supplies lagta hai tou paanch hison mein aik hisa Taliban movement ko dena parta hai.

Is kai ilawa Tekaidar bhi apnay hifazat kay liye Taliban aik khas rakam dena parta hai.

Is pooray mali system ko chalanay kay "ground rules" Taliban apnay saalana jaari karda "Laaih" (Taliban ka Code of Conduct ka kitabcha) mein tayun kar deytay hai. Yeh "Laaih" har local Taliban commander kai pas hota hai. Oar is kay paband hotay hai.

Taliban ka central shura (Jisay Quetta Shura bhi kaha jata hai) saal mein aik ya do daafa Afghansitan kay har hisay mein apna "Inspection team" bejhti hai oar makami civilian rehnuma waghera sai pata karti hai kai aya us ilaqay kai Taliban apnay karawai Laaih kay mutabik kar rahi hai ya nahin. Agar Mali bezabtigi ka pata chal jaata hai tou us ilaqay kay Commander ko tabdeel kar diya jaat hai. Kuch salon sai aam shehri ko yehi inspection team aik contact number bhi se jati hai jis par un ko report kiya ja sakta hai.

Helmand kay ilaqay waadi Sangin may ISAF kay hath lagni 2010 ka Laih ka tarjuma :
www-tc.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/obamaswar/etc/mullahomar.pdf

Yad rakhain kay Amreka 2001 say Afghanistan par har Ghanta takreeban $10.45 million kharcha kar rahai hai.
Ithni bari rakam ko kharch kartay hoay "Leakages" hoti hai jis sai Taliban ka saalana $150 million budget Araam sai nikal aata hai. Report kai doosray hison mein yeh bhi likha hai kay Afghanistan mein kaafi ilaqon mein Afghansitan ki makami hakoomatein Taliban sai mil chuki hai. Mukhtalik kism kai jang bandi kay maudi kar chuki hai.
Kuch ilaqon mein hathyar oar jangi sazoo saman ko bhi inhein muahiday ki bina par Taliban kay hawaly kiya ja chuka hai,
 
Last edited:
I have read some of it. I am interested in the global picture which looks somewhat like this to me.

It seems as if the report is partly right only and there is a tilt or an angle to some how portray ISI and Pakistan as "Not friends "of Taaliban and by extension Afghans, so there can be a divide post 2014 between the two, leading to conflict which could continue even after ISAF has left in order to create another problem for Pakistan on the Western border in addition to the ongoing pressure from East by India. This could lead to a division in the Muslim world also with Afghanistan on one side supported by the heavy media from India and the West.In addition in my humble opinion Iran will side with India also because if Arab world sides with Pakistan then Iran historically will go the opposite way, besides Iran has never been a friend of Pakistan other than when Shah was in power. I will not be surprised for a second if the Western media starts to support the Taaliban government in Afghanistan against Pakistan in near future.

More Difficult times ahead I foresee.
 
Advertisement
I just read it, seems farsi speaking taliban has support of India, Russia, Iraq, Iran wow AND PASHTUN TRIBESMAN has only support ie PAKISTAN???? crazy situation presented here, but thankgod does not sound that chaotic as the good news is pashtun Taliban are hating Al qaeda. TTP we all know, they r describing as a weak force in south waziristan the why the hell its a BIG DEAL for PAKISTAN in NEWS? Plus ISAF had made deals in certain provinces where the war lords have their own rules and goverment ( Now they know what Pakistan army had been saying all along that these dinosuar era tribesman will die but will not CHANGE, took ISAF/NATO 12 years of war to understand. The FUNNY PART is THESE HOLY warriors are BUYING BRAND NEW GREEN FORd RANGER trucks and high garde USA weapons sold to Locals in Miranshah SOLD TO THEM BY NONE OTHER THAN ALLIE AFGHAN ARMY gosh these corrupt musalmaans, subh koe ullu bunnah rahaehein nuswar khaa kurrrrr?

Also huge distrust with Pakistan for openly manipulating TALIBAN leader ship
 
Last edited:
I just read it, seems farsi speaking taliban has support of India, Russia, Iraq, Iran wow AND PASHTUN TRIBESMAN has only support ie PAKISTAN???? crazy situation presented here, but thankgod does not sound that chaotic as the good news is pashtun Taliban are hating Al qaeda. TTP we all know, they r describing as a weak force in south waziristan the why the hell its a BIG DEAL for PAKISTAN in NEWS? Plus ISAF had made deals in certain provinces where the war lords have their own rules and goverment ( Now they know what Pakistan army had been saying all along that these dinosuar era tribesman will die but will not CHANGE, took ISAF/NATO 12 years of war to understand. The FUNNY PART is THESE HOLY warriors are BUYING BRAND NEW GREEN FORd RANGER trucks and high garde USA weapons sold to Locals in Miranshah SOLD TO THEM BY NONE OTHER THAN ALLIE AFGHAN ARMY gosh these corrupt musalmaans, subh koe ullu bunnah rahaehein nuswar khaa kurrrrr?

Also huge distrust with Pakistan for openly manipulating TALIBAN leader ship

Islam ke naam par logon ko bewaqoof karna, aur unnhi logon sey faida uthana, Muslim Ummah ki siasi/mazhabi elite ka qaumi khel hai :)
 
Agar app report parhain to us peh is pehlo par khasi roshni dali howi hai. (Report ka Page 13-15)

Taliban ka saalana Budget takreeban $150 million hay.

Afghanistan or Pakistan mein jo in kay hami hi woh chanda ikata kar kar yeh poora karatay hay.
Report kai Mutabiq Pakistan oar Afghanistan kay chootay baray aksar shehron mein Taliban chanda apnay hamion say ikatha kartay pirthay hai.

Gulf mumalik mein mukeem Afghan sai bhi yeh rakam chanday kay tor par wasool hota hay.
Yeh rakam Hawala network kay zaryay chootay amounts mein bejha jata ha. Is ka suragh lagana boht mushkal hai.

Is pooray process mein kabhi bhi Taliban Aam Bankari nizam ka istemal nahin kartay.
Kyon kay is par US ki kaari nazar hai.

Taliban jin ilaqon par Afghanistan mein qabiz hay wahan kay Makami kashtkar par bhi tax lagatay hai.

Report mein yeh bhi lika hay kay Afghanistan may mukeem Taliban koi tankhwa wasool nahin karta oar woh apna karobar aam sheriyon kay tarah jaari rakta hai. Albata woh Taliban jin ko Pakistan jaana parta hai unhein aik khas rakam bejhe jaati hai.

Jab makami jangjo kay hath Nato supplies lagta hai tou paanch hison mein aik hisa Taliban movement ko dena parta hai.

Is kai ilawa Tekaidar bhi apnay hifazat kay liye Taliban aik khas rakam dena parta hai.

Is pooray mali system ko chalanay kay "ground rules" Taliban apnay saalana jaari karda "Laaih" (Taliban ka Code of Conduct ka kitabcha) mein tayun kar deytay hai. Yeh "Laaih" har local Taliban commander kai pas hota hai. Oar is kay paband hotay hai.

Taliban ka central shura (Jisay Quetta Shura bhi kaha jata hai) saal mein aik ya do daafa Afghansitan kay har hisay mein apna "Inspection team" bejhti hai oar makami civilian rehnuma waghera sai pata karti hai kai aya us ilaqay kai Taliban apnay karawai Laaih kay mutabik kar rahi hai ya nahin. Agar Mali bezabtigi ka pata chal jaata hai tou us ilaqay kay Commander ko tabdeel kar diya jaat hai. Kuch salon sai aam shehri ko yehi inspection team aik contact number bhi se jati hai jis par un ko report kiya ja sakta hai.

Helmand kay ilaqay waadi Sangin may ISAF kay hath lagni 2010 ka Laih ka tarjuma :
www-tc.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/obamaswar/etc/mullahomar.pdf

Yad rakhain kay Amreka 2001 say Afghanistan par har Ghanta takreeban $10.45 million kharcha kar rahai hai.
Ithni bari rakam ko kharch kartay hoay "Leakages" hoti hai jis sai Taliban ka saalana $150 million budget Araam sai nikal aata hai. Report kai doosray hison mein yeh bhi likha hai kay Afghanistan mein kaafi ilaqon mein Afghansitan ki makami hakoomatein Taliban sai mil chuki hai. Mukhtalik kism kai jang bandi kay maudi kar chuki hai.
Kuch ilaqon mein hathyar oar jangi sazoo saman ko bhi inhein muahiday ki bina par Taliban kay hawaly kiya ja chuka hai,

وضاحت کا شکریہ، میں رپورٹ کھول نہیں سکا تھا
ملا عمر بہت عرصے سے منظر عام سے غائب ہیں شائد پکڑے جانے کے ڈر سے مگر سال نو میں جب امریکی اخراجات میں کمی آئے گی تو چوری ہونے والے سامان میں بھی کمی آئے گی اور نیٹو فوجوں کے انخلا کے باعث بیرون ملک میں مقیم افغانوں سے آنے والی امداد میں بھی کمی ہوگی تو کیا مختلف طالبان دھڑے ملا عمر کے خلاف کھڑے نہیں ہوجائیں گے ؟
 
وضاحت کا شکریہ، میں رپورٹ کھول نہیں سکا تھا
ملا عمر بہت عرصے سے منظر عام سے غائب ہیں شائد پکڑے جانے کے ڈر سے مگر سال نو میں جب امریکی اخراجات میں کمی آئے گی تو چوری ہونے والے سامان میں بھی کمی آئے گی اور نیٹو فوجوں کے انخلا کے باعث بیرون ملک میں مقیم افغانوں سے آنے والی امداد میں بھی کمی ہوگی تو کیا مختلف طالبان دھڑے ملا عمر کے خلاف کھڑے نہیں ہوجائیں گے ؟

Mein app kay tajziyay sai itefaq karta hoon.

Agar Nato forces ka inkhala ho tou Taliban kay support mein kadray kami asakti hai.
Afghan (Khasoosan janobi Afghanistan kai Pashtoon qabail) kai tarekh tou yehi hai kai jab koi bahir ki takat hamlawar ho tou ye ikhatay ho jaatay hai lekin bad mein apis mein lar partay hai.
 
Mein app kay tajziyay sai itefaq karta hoon.

Agar Nato forces ka inkhala ho tou Taliban kay support mein kadray kami asakti hai.
Afghan (Khasoosan janobi Afghanistan kai Pashtoon qabail) kai tarekh tou yehi hai kai jab koi bahir ki takat hamlawar ho tou ye ikhatay ho jaatay hai lekin bad mein apis mein lar partay hai.

Pakistan will remain the bastion of terrorism, even after pullout Afghanistan will remain destabilized for coming generation, which is good news or bad how one takes but Talibanization of KPK is something which everybody should be worried abt. PMLn if prudent shud work with PTI in bringing KPK to become a economically prosperous province to discourage militancy