Advertisement

Remembering the lofty Islamic Mr.Jinnah's politics in anticipation of his upcoming "Birthday" on 2

Though some reputedbiographers dispute the date and year of birth of Mr.Muhammad Ali Jinnah , thefounder of separate Muslim dominated dominionof Pakistan, but for sake of rememberinghim on his “Birthday” the following is being submitted to establish his credentialsas official founding father of two nation theory , a rejector of western stylesecularism, a revolutionary within legal and moral bounds and a strategic planner who learnt from his earlier political mistakes for standing for nationalist cause .

Pakistan movement has beenmisread and deliberately distorted by the school historians of India andPakistan . Jinnahs struggle was to get legitimate proportional political share for33% Muslims of United India and hisagenda has at various times till 1946 excluded nothing to improve Muslim lotpolitically including all types of ideas such as of i) Three unit within United India , ii) Two Pakistans , iii) One Pakistanas it initially was till 1971 and so onand these have been well documented in relatively authoritative books asStanley Wolpert’s book on Jinnah . Jinnah’s emphasis on Political status ofIndian Muslims were offcourse based on idea of it being a separate communitydespite its being composed of many racesand languages and this in itself incorporates the two nation theory .

It must be remembered that Muslimleague’s funding and PakistanMovement engine was well greased byJinnahs personal friends made during legal carrier involving cases of Nawabsand by masses in Central India’s Muslim provinces. He never included any senior politicians in his leadership cadre who was a fence sitters thus giving him power unparalleled in theMovement . Muslim league later on became well organized mass movement in whatwas later to become Pakistan. To say that since Jinnah accepted Cabinet Missionplan does not mean he did not stand for two nation theory . Jinnah being leaderof all Muslims including those in central India had to give fair chance to allpolitical ideas which were beneficial to all the Muslims of India RememberJinnah was a Pan Islamicist not narrow Nationalist . Today , some criticizeas to why he did not trade Kashmir for Indian Hyderabad or Junagargh , he wasnot expected to , nor was it more an inidle insinuation , he wanted to give all chances to allied Muslims within remaining india . Cabinet plan includedconstitutional guarantees for Muslims for a proportional central representation and Muslimpolitical domination in peripheries of India in what later became Pakistan and was therefore a“Pakistan” plan in less explosive and less divisive manner and not a negation of Pakistan . Congress wasconfident in its economic and miscreant power and rejected it but could notprevail later .

Lately my view is that somecore congress politicians despite claim to contrary did want ethnic cleansingand did want to rule a muslim influence free remaining India .

Many secular writers try tomalign the Islamic clergy as enemies of creation Pakistan they also try to establish Mr.Jinnah’s credentials as a thoroughly secular person and attack theobjective resolution and its prime mover Shabbir Usmani alleging them to be diametrically opposed to idea of Jinnah about Pakistan. They even condemn the National assembly for declaring Ahmedis as non Muslims.Nothing could be far fromtruth , Jinnah wrote in his will that his funeral rites should be lead byShabbir Usmani and that it should be in a manner like that that of ordinaryMuslims . He did not approve his daughter marrying a Parsi and cut her off socially, though she was included in his hereditary will made earlier . ObviouslyJinnah was not a bigot or indecent or ethnic cleanser or a mobster , but yes he was opposed to population transfer assuch was never formal part of Pakistanmovement supported and voted by the masses of Muslims . Jinnah’s often quoted speech emphasizing non discrimination between Muslimsand non Muslims was made in the context of indecent and beastly sectarian carnage of 1947 and were therefore not only healing words butit emphasized what is fundamental to Islam that personal conduct was crucial in the hereafter and not mob conduct , it didnot mean he stood for a secular state but he did stand for a fair state takingcare of its citizens . The Zimmi empireof Islam , last being Ottoman empire , was a state meant to disseminatesuperior ideas and beliefs of Islamwhilst maintaining all rights of property , personal dignity and life for itsnon Muslim citizens .It would seem veryunrealistic and foolish to consider that Jinnah would name his party Muslimleague and stand for Non Muslim politics and secular objectives , that istantamount to distorting and rewriting history . Jinnah was offcourse no Mullah . Hisemphasis on Quranic Islam rather than Sunni or Shia Islam was basis of Pakistan.

Offcourse congress wanted to label him a Shia minority via Mullahs of other sects but that did not work as heowned no sect .Some secular modern writers take declaration RegardingAhmedis being declared Non – Muslims as contrary to jinnah’s ideals , but this has nothing to do with Jinnahs ideals. Ahmediat and its teachings were not clear till very late andwhen in National assembly Ahmedi leaders stated that they do not consider thosepeople as Muslims who deny their“Prophet” i.e 1880’s personality, it wasclear that it was a new religion and were declared Not to be Muslims . Their making separate prayer places from the beginningmeant they were separate in their own mind much earlier . This is irrelevant to Jinnah as a person and a leader.


Had Jinnah been a secularleader he would not will Shabir Usmani to lead his funeral prayer , he wouldhave renamed Muslim league , he would not have disowned his daughter for marrying a Parsi , he wouldhave remained in Congress , he would not have asked for Pakistan and he wouldnot have approved the flag of crescent of Pakistan which was a symbol of Muslim power of theboth the Ottomans and even the Mughals .To say that Jinnah was secularin later life is therefore incorrect and to say that he was a mad religiousfanatic and ethnic cleanser as projectedin Indiais also wrong . Jaswant Singh’s book although meant not to reinstate Jinnah but to insinuate Congress complicity in division of India is also a form of partial correction of History in Bharat and Jaswant isback in BJP .

Neither Jinnah not evenGandhi was an ethnic cleanser , Jinnah’s speech to constituent assembly andGandhi recitations in 1947 were in an atmosphere of raging inter religious violence and were meant to be soothers toMuslims and Hindus respectively and a call to decent citizenry , they were no repudiation of their life long stands . i.e Jinnah of Islamic Pan –Islamism and Gandhi of IndianNationalism . Stanley Wolpert book clearlyquotes proceedings of Muslim league before partition and its last day wasalways reserved for Pan – Islamic issues and Muslim league via its resolutionopposed creation of state of Israel .Jinnah was a modernpolitician , Muslims were so educationally weak that there was no option exceptto retain British Civil servants , the Muslim was so economically weak that Jinnah was not happy with total exodus of business man class which was exclusively of Hindus and infact expected some refugees to return in the opinion of Indian writer KhushwantSingh before India occupied Kashmir forcibly

People like Hindu Mandal who later quit Pakistan in socalled disgust but were earlier alignedwith Jinnah were expecting the Indian politics to take different turns .Mandal’s interest in league was if jinnah did not succeed in making separatePakistan Mandal would still have theoption of aligning lowcaste Hindus with Muslim Vote beginning a new type ofpolitics within Unified India against Congress of Hingh cases mainly , and if he did succeed which Mandal admitted he thoughtJinnah would probably not , the residual20% minority in Pakistan would still need political leadership like Mandal.Both events did not happen and this was unexpected and unforeseen . Jinnah had a third headache,large sections of ruling British werenot interested in separate Muslim state so a strategic way to convince them wasto be found and not ally with Hindus Militarily . So liberal stance of Jinnahis wrongly construed now by later day experts as of secularism. There are someindications of strategic long term written or unwritten understanding withBritain but so far I have not been able to find some solid evidence of that.Those charging Jinnah to besecular should retract their standforthwith but yes on one issue moreagreement is needed now than before , we all need some humanity and enlargingour scope of thought .


We follow Islam , we propagate and preserve our Islamicvalues as we think it is superior to others . We cannot rate a superior and inferior thingequally and if we do it we shall be unfair with ourselves and civilization,this is why some portions of our currentconstitution does not reflect fully the superiority of Islam and need reviewand possibly a new constitution.Finally , A ruling high caste Hindu of 50 years back will not eatalong a Muslim fearful of being contaminated and a English would gladly writeon England’s street ends , “Dogs andcoloured not allowed” . What secularism would Jinnahstand for in that context one may ask ,He actually did not !Finally , it seems to me thatsome of the fundamental stand of Mr.jinnah which are hallmarks of his politicswere learnt from others like idea of word Pakistan from Chaudhary Rahmat aliand the idea not to seek independence per se without settling for Muslim futurewith British and congress first from Nawab sahib .

Let Mr.Jinnah’s soul, aMussalman’s soul remain in peace .Let seculars find some other personality from history to trytheir luck to convert Pakistan to secularism.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Advertisement
Advertisement
who care of that Kind of morons .like These anti pak Mullah .

Dude before you post comments it is always better to hear what you are comenting about. From your comments I regard you as the highest rated moron of this thread. You should be glad being an Australian and should celebrate.