Advertisement

NEW strategy of TRUMP administration has no chance of success unless USA accepts Pakistan as paramou

Thread starter's comments : USA has resumed under TRUMP to play an aggressive Game with Pakistan and trying to force us to play Indo-west- Iranian game in afghanistan . Unfortunately our leadership is too busy in Umpires orchestrated games and India is gaining upper hand in diplomacy.

USA must understand that without Pakistani support his only bastion of support so far outside USA and UK and Eastern europe is Saudi -GCC -Islamic alliance of which Pakistan is an important part . All others within EU and USA are cursing him and disrespecting him all the time.

Second point is that Pakistan is an Islamic state and is a federation so Islamic nature and pashtoon interests in Afghanistan are important for Pakistan , we cannot allow afghanistan to be controlled by Northern alliance itself controlled by france , Iran , Western powers and Hindus.

USA needs to be told indian want water channels closed and nuclear war is imminent under Modi over water and kashmir .

USA under TRUMP is under delusion , they cannot satisfy warcontractors and bring more war in that poor country for no reason .Trump plan to use war contractors using Eastern European and Indian soldiers is of no interest to Pakistan.

Muslims of Pakistan are not unduly worried if Islamicists funded by our military , who happen to be pashtoons as well win and take over Kabul . Afghanistan as one nation has failed , pashtoon belt needs autonomy and pakistan be accepted its paramount military power to bring law and order .

USA can fund us , we can do the job and not let India and Iran enter Afghanistan . Double talk like Obama will not work , Carrot and stick is meant for others not likes of us .



Trump wants Pakistan’s ‘paradoxical’ policies to change: NSA




5986426367b4c.jpg


Gen H. R. McMaster defends the American president’s strategy on winning the war in Afghanistan by giving unrestricted powers to the US military based in the war-torn country.
WASHINGTON: US National Security Adviser Gen H.R. McMaster said on Saturday that President Donald Trump wants Pakistan to change its ‘paradoxical’ policy of supporting the militants who are causing the country great losses.


In an interview to a conservative radio host, Hugh Hewitt, Mr McMaster also defended President Trump’s strategy on winning the war in Afghanistan by giving unrestricted powers to the US military based in the war-torn country.
US officials have often accused Pakistan of helping the militants, a charge Islamabad vehemently denies, but this marks the first time that the allegation has been attributed to President Trump.


“The president has also made clear that we need to see a change in behaviour of those in the region, which includes those who are providing safe haven and support bases for the Taliban, Haqqani Network and others,” Mr McMaster said.


“This is Pakistan in particular that we want to really see a change in and a reduction of their support for these groups. I mean, this is of course, you know, a very paradoxical situation where Pakistan is taking great losses. They have fought very hard against these groups, but they’ve done so really only selectively,” he added.
Commenting on Mr Trump’s decision to win the Afghan war, Gen McMaster said: The president has said that, “He does not want to place restrictions on the military that undermine our ability to win battles in combat.”
“He has lifted those restrictions, and you’re beginning to see the payoff of that — as well.”


The US media reported earlier this week that in a July 19 meeting at the White House, President Trump berated his generals for not winning the war in Afghanistan and for allowing it to continue for more than 16 years.
He also criticised a team of national security consultants tasked with crafting a new winning strategy for Afghanistan for failing to do so.


At the same meeting, President Trump also “repeatedly suggested” to his senior military advisers that they should replace Gen John Nicholson, the commander of US and Nato forces in Afghanistan, with a new general who could win the war.


But Gen McMaster seems to disagree with this suggestion. Asked if he had confidence in Gen Nicholson, he said: “Of course. I’ve known him for many years. I can’t imagine a more capable commander on any mission.”
Although the White House has not announced a comprehensive strategy on Afghanistan yet, Mr McMaster said “the president’s already made some important decisions on Afghanistan”.


He said Mr Trump does not necessarily want to telegraph his intentions but “you’ve heard in pieces” the strategy that he wants to implement in Afghanistan. “What we’re endeavouring to do is pull this all together in a regional strategy that makes sense,” he said.


President Trump has authorised the Pentagon to take the lead on military decisions in Afghanistan, although he formed a separate team of experts to form the new Afghan policy.


Gen McMaster defended the campaign in Afghanistan, arguing they had seen “tremendous” success in the country.


“There’s a tremendously successful campaign going on with Afghan forces in the lead. It’s an unreported campaign in Nangarhar Province of Afghanistan,” Mr McMaster said.


He said Mr Trump disagrees with the Obama administration’s strategy of announcing everything, from US deaths in Afghanistan to the deadlines for sending in or pulling out American troops from there.


“And so the president has said, ‘that is not the way to fight a war. It never has been’. This is an invention of recent years,” Mr McMaster said.


Published in Dawn, August 6th, 2017
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Advertisement
Re: NEW strategy of TRUMP administration has no chance of success unless USA accepts Pakistan as paramount power with funds given to correct things in Pashtoon areas of Afghanistan and autonomy be granted to pashtoons in afghanistan context .

Yaa Pandit ul Shivalingham..

Your insane gibberish will be flushed down a clogged up TOILET of urine drinkers of Hindustan.

American Jew controlled dying empire can go and F itself.

No one gives a rats A##s you sectarian maggot.

We know who ju are ....
 
if policies of those trying to reign in Afghanistan were clear and honest there can be no paradox in the results. Confused results are a reflection of the confused ill planned efforts. By simple reverse analysis of events the big saviors are the main problems.
 
Advertisement
Americans are trapped in afghanistan like a greedy monkey for last 16 years, and still are dreaming of estimated 3 trillion dollars worth of precious metals & minerals, and oil pipe line from central asia through afghanistan.
In 16 years times are changed, china is the biggest stake holder in afghan resources, russia stands with china, pakistan is the center
of gravity. Destiny awaits indian army very patiently, they will have to bring their body bags with them as an essential part of their fatigue.
 
Now let's glance from average American perspective :

Cutting losses 2014-2015 coalition's forces abandoning Afghanistan and running back home without a clear victory didn't say much for superpower !

Changing Army General here or there won't eradicate threat !

What Americans need is truth from Kabul govt, not some Donkeys sitting on pay check to pay check that all of Afghans is under their coalition's control !

What Americans require is full fledged military engagement of all its forces to invade, eradicate & overthrow the rogue forces as known as ISIS or whatever Western media calls them, who is mind you the locals general populations !

Than have considerable force and supply for next 30+ years to fight one mountain at a time, maybe half hearted the coalition might get rid of 10% of problem !

You see the problems for Trump, sitting half a world away, and calling make believe shots on the Afghans soil is one thing, but a rhetorical bad attitude towards his own argument says a lot about himself !

It's the average poor Afghans who suffer the most !

Yeman is now certainly dissolved, what he wants Iran & Saudi conflict?
 
Last edited:
Americans are trapped in afghanistan like a greedy monkey for last 16 years, and still are dreaming of estimated 3 trillion dollars worth of precious metals & minerals, and oil pipe line from central asia through afghanistan.
In 16 years times are changed, china is the biggest stake holder in afghan resources, russia stands with china, pakistan is the center
of gravity. Destiny awaits indian army very patiently, they will have to bring their body bags with them as an essential part of their fatigue.

Absolutely correct and well summarized ground situation .
 
Now let's glance from average American perspective :

Cutting losses 2014-2015 coalition's forces abandoning Afghanistan and running back home without a clear victory didn't say much for superpower !

Changing Army General here or there won't eradicate threat !

What Americans need is truth from Kabul govt, not some Donkeys sitting on pay check to pay check that all of Afghans is under their coalition's control !

What Americans require is full fledged military engagement of all its forces to invade, eradicate & overthrow the rogue forces as known as ISIS or whatever Western media calls them, who is mind you the locals general populations !

Than have considerable force and supply for next 30+ years to fight one mountain at a time, maybe half hearted the coalition might get rid of 10% of problem !

You see the problems for Trump, sitting half a world away, and calling make believe shots on the Afghans soil is one thing, but a rhetorical bad attitude towards his own argument says a lot about himself !

It's the average poor Afghans who suffer the most !

Yeman is now certainly dissolved, what he wants Iran & Saudi conflict?

American policy formation had started with 9/11 times , Russia was weak , china on margins , we not having had casualties and Taliban intried as adversary by USA . TRUMP better leave Afghanistan to us and Saudi arabia and wait what we do in its pashtoon belt of method of our choosing using diplomacy , aid and strength . If it has a plan still for afghanistan it should limit itself to non pashtoon afghanistan and there USA emerging as major superpower is remote as they spent their money and energy in Iraq before .