Advertisement

Majority Pakistanis slapped Desi Liberals : Overwhelming Majority wants Laws influenced by Quran

he is the creator of Muslims only, the rest of the Pakistanis dont consider him their creator, so laws should be influenced without religous interference

80 percent of the population of the rashidun caliphate was non muslim and did not recognise Allah as their Creator. so was it unjustified for the 4 rightly guided khalifas to impose sharia on them??? the majority population of madina was non muslim when the Prophet (SAW) was given the city, was it wrong for Him(SAW) to impose sharia on them????? Allah tells us to impose his Sharia on the earth, so why shouldn't laws be influenced as per sharia??????
 
Oh noo, you are so clever. You got me buddy. I mean a 20 year kid realizes, that I am gonna ask him a trick question, and viola he wouldn't be able to answer. The answer is: f@#k yes I am. It is better, it is common sense, and one day you will do it too.

hahahaha, i love how you claim that i will one day become more sensible and open my mind and gain common sense. i was an agnostic and was a staunch secularist, and 2 years later AlHamdulillah i am on the straight path. i gained nothing from being agnostic other than destroying my soul through various means. i thank Allah to have made me a muslim. and unlike what most people think. i actualy bothered to learn sharia and fiqh. May Allah give you Hidayah
 
80 percent of the population of the rashidun caliphate was non muslim and did not recognise Allah as their Creator. so was it unjustified for the 4 rightly guided khalifas to impose sharia on them??? the majority population of madina was non muslim when the Prophet (SAW) was given the city, was it wrong for Him(SAW) to impose sharia on them????? Allah tells us to impose his Sharia on the earth, so why shouldn't laws be influenced as per sharia??????
that was the 7th century
 
If you are serious and honest then read the my post keeping in mind the post i answered
there are a lot of things which are inaccurate in the Quran and some of the miracles were actually common knowledge in that time period
 
there are a lot of things which are inaccurate in the Quran and some of the miracles were actually common knowledge in that time period

well to discuss LOT things i have already started discussion with you .


but i asked you to read my post again with honesty and open mind


let me help you


A person post this.

""""""""""
I thought the number of Pakistanis wanting sharia would be much higher, like 90%. But it actually decreased from that. Now its down to 70%. Soon it will be 50. Pakistan is actually secularizing.

"""""""""""

So he was trying to say that people are getting away from Islam and they are turning secular..

now read the Hadith again.

It is narrated on the authority of Abu Huraira that the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) said: Islam initiated as something strange, and it would revert to its (old position) of being strange. so good tidings for the stranger. (Book #001, Hadith #0270)


Is int it exactly the same that is happening now ??
 
Advertisement
that was the 7th century

so? in the Quran, Allah says that whenever the Nabi of Allah used to tell the people of quraish stories of the previous people who rejected Allah's message, they were subjected to severe punishment. and in response to this the chiefs of quraish used to say" these are stories of an ancient people". tell me where in the Quran or Hadith does Allah or HIS Rasul say that the sharia is suppose to be followed only for a few years until our laws become archaic in the eyes of the kuffar and in order to please the kuffar, we have to remove the sharia of Allah and adopt the laws of the kuffar. please do give me your proof.
 
there are a lot of things which are inaccurate in the Quran and some of the miracles were actually common knowledge in that time period

you can deny anything you want, if you are blind. but how do u deny that story of the sahabi himself of what happened to him. Umayr ibn Wahb reported his story of how he became a muslim. he conspired with the help of safwan ibn ummaya to kill the Prophet. when he went to Madina to pay ransom for his son who was captured during the battle of badr, one of the sahaba told Umar ibn Khattab that the Prophet wants to see him alone in the masjid. when Umair sat down with the Prophet, the Nabi of Allah told him of how the Angel informed Umair of his plan to kill Him and that he had soked his sword in posison overnight. on hearing this, Umair immediately accepted Islam. how could the Prophet know that umair was conspiring on assassinating him while the Nabi lived in madina and the plan was made in makkah, and only safwan knew about the plan????? those who are arrogant and stubborn in disbelieve will never believe even fi you show them every sign.[h=3][/h]
 
80 percent of the population of the rashidun caliphate was non muslim and did not recognise Allah as their Creator. so was it unjustified for the 4 rightly guided khalifas to impose sharia on them??? the majority population of madina was non muslim when the Prophet (SAW) was given the city, was it wrong for Him(SAW) to impose sharia on them????? Allah tells us to impose his Sharia on the earth, so why shouldn't laws be influenced as per sharia??????
But what if their God tells them something different? What then? How will you reconcile ? The time of the Khalifat has come and gone. The Prophets have come and gone. That time period is over. The world is a overcrowded sphere with the information age and people ascribe to all sorts of philosophies now. What once worked in a population, does not necessarily work now. The time for religious governance has passed. Humans are now far more in numbers. Systems of Law and Governance function only as the sum of their parts - And today those parts are too many more than what they were in the Rashidun time period. Yes I know the romanticized desire of having such a time (although none of us were alive then to witness it) But never the less, the fantasy and romanticized view exists; but the reality is far different today. You need to use that God given mind and adjudicate yourself, how can you do right by your fellow man. Do not transgress his rights. Remember, God forgives, man does not.

There are no more Kuffar. No more Muslims. No More Christians. There are only us Human Beings. You are NOT anything more or less than Human. A "Belief" doesn't change this.
 
Last edited:
Advertisement
Stonning for adultery
discuss this point

first of all tell me something, why is it barbaric in your opinion? is it because 2 people are making a decision to have sex? is it because you think that a married man has every right to cheat on his wife with another women, destroying the family in the process. you're the type of guys who thinks that having 2 wives is wrong but having multiple sexual partners and many times unknown sexual partners is A okay. tell me, in western societies, why is it okay for a man to walk in the streets without his shrit, bare naked from the top, but not okay for women, not just in a civil sense, but also legal manner? why is a women being denied the right to take off her top and walk without a bra???? it's called Hypocrisy my friend. adultery is an act through which societies are destroyed. i had 6 friends, all of whom were born out of wedlock, with the exception of one. non of them had any contact with their fathers, some had good step dads, some not so much. this is how societies are destroyed.
 
But what if their God tells them something different? What then? How will you reconcile ? The time of the Khalifat has come and gone. The Prophets have come and gone. That time period is over. The world is a overcrowded sphere with the information age and people ascribe to all sorts of philosophies now. What once worked in a population, does not necessarily work now. The time for religious governance has passed. Humans are now far more in numbers. Systems of Law and Governance function only as the sum of their parts - And today those parts are too many more than what they were in the Rashidun time period. Yes I know the romanticized desire of having such a time (although none of us were alive then to witness it) But never the less, the fantasy and romanticized view exists; but the reality is far different today. You need to use that God given mind and adjudicate yourself, how can you do right by your fellow man. Do not transgress his rights. Remember, God forgives, man does not.

There are no more Kuffar. No more Muslims. No More Christians. There are only us Human Beings. You are NOT anything more or less than Human. A "Belief" doesn't change this.

i want to ask you something. on the day of qiyamah, when Allah will ask me why i refused his sharia. can i quote you and say that mr lurker told me that their are no more muslim, no christians, just human beings.???? if you are a muslims, in the Quran, Allah says that whenever the Nabi of Allah used to tell the people of quraish stories of the previous people who rejected Allah's message, they were subjected to severe punishment. and in response to this the chiefs of quraish used to say" these are stories of an ancient people". tell me where in the Quran or Hadith does Allah or HIS Rasul say that the sharia is suppose to be followed only for a few years until our laws become archaic in the eyes of the kuffar and in order to please the kuffar, we have to remove the sharia of Allah and adopt the laws of the kuffar. please do give me your proof.
 
you can deny anything you want, if you are blind. but how do u deny that story of the sahabi himself of what happened to him. Umayr ibn Wahb reported his story of how he became a muslim. he conspired with the help of safwan ibn ummaya to kill the Prophet. when he went to Madina to pay ransom for his son who was captured during the battle of badr, one of the sahaba told Umar ibn Khattab that the Prophet wants to see him alone in the masjid. when Umair sat down with the Prophet, the Nabi of Allah told him of how the Angel informed Umair of his plan to kill Him and that he had soked his sword in posison overnight. on hearing this, Umair immediately accepted Islam. how could the Prophet know that umair was conspiring on assassinating him while the Nabi lived in madina and the plan was made in makkah, and only safwan knew about the plan????? those who are arrogant and stubborn in disbelieve will never believe even fi you show them every sign.

there's a word in the English language "Spy". look it up. they are very resourceful people
 
there's a word in the English language "Spy". look it up. they are very resourceful people

so their was a spy who was present with them when they were in their house planning this, even though he himself stated that only him and umair knew about this plan, not even the elders of quraish knew about it????.

and tell me something mr logical mind, how did the Prophet knew that his sahabah will one day conquer the byzantine and sasanid empire one day, the 2 super power of the time ????? i bet your going to say that it was a calculative luck. May Allah Guide you
 
Advertisement
i want to ask you something. on the day of qiyamah, when Allah will ask me why i refused his sharia. can i quote you and say that mr lurker told me that their are no more muslim, no christians, just human beings.???? if you are a muslims, in the Quran, Allah says that whenever the Nabi of Allah used to tell the people of quraish stories of the previous people who rejected Allah's message, they were subjected to severe punishment. and in response to this the chiefs of quraish used to say" these are stories of an ancient people". tell me where in the Quran or Hadith does Allah or HIS Rasul say that the sharia is suppose to be followed only for a few years until our laws become archaic in the eyes of the kuffar and in order to please the kuffar, we have to remove the sharia of Allah and adopt the laws of the kuffar. please do give me your proof.
The Qayamah is your Belief. It is not necessarily your fellow man's. You asked me what shall I tell to Allah when He asks you? What if He doesn't ask you and commends you? What then? The possibility is there that perhaps you may be rewarded for using your facilities and preventing bloodshed. You would have saved many lives. Saving One Life is like saving the whole of humanity? Is it not? You fear Allah. And yet you do not fear that perhaps you can still be wrong in pushing Allah's words which may result in many deaths and atrocity? Think of the greater good. Alas, I cannot speak on Allah's behalf; He is the final Judge. I only offer possibilities and probabilities.
 
Sorry but let me barge into the discussion if you folks don't mind. First of all stoning is for adultery and not fornification, yes there us a difference. There is no certain or fixed punishment prescribed for fornification

Secondly the prescribed punishment is more of a deterrent than an actual punishment. There are certain terms that have to meant before it can be handed out. One being there have to be 4 sane witnesses of good character, unless you are having $ex in the middle of the street in broad daylight I think its pretty impossible for that condition to be met and remember not just 4 witnesses but 4 witnesses of good moral character. Or if the accused confess to the crime fully knowing the result. And these laws only come into effect in a proper Muslim khilafa type country. Just by having Islamic republic in your name does not make you one. As of today there are no proper Muslim countries or territories existing on this planet today.

Also I remember seeing beheading somewhere in one of your posts. Scientifically it is the most painless, most humane and quickest way to administer capital punishment. The accused does not suffer and its literally over in a split second. Now I'm talking of prescribed method of beheading, that is from the back of the neck with a sharp blade in one swift stroke, not the kind you see on gory online videos, that is more akin to slaughter and totally not allowed. Plus its also gory for the watcher and serves as a good deterrent for the public. Lethal Injection, Gas Chamber, Electricution have all show to cause sever and prolonged agony to the accused, specially if the execution gets botched and that happens more than you would think.

Wallahu alam
 
It proves that Islam is actually a true religion

why ??

bcz it is exactly the same what is being already mentioned by Rasool Allah SW


It is narrated on the authority of Abu Huraira that the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) said: Islam initiated as something strange, and it would revert to its (old position) of being strange. so good tidings for the stranger. (Book #001, Hadith #0270)

Ok so I consider myself a muslim. I am not an atheist or anything. However, I do have serious questions. Your above point that Islam has never changed. That isn't something to be proud of. Change is good. In fact you can't survive without changing.
 
well to discuss LOT things i have already started discussion with you .


but i asked you to read my post again with honesty and open mind


let me help you


A person post this.

""""""""""
I thought the number of Pakistanis wanting sharia would be much higher, like 90%. But it actually decreased from that. Now its down to 70%.Soon it will be 50. Pakistan is actually secularizing.

"""""""""""

So he was trying to say that people are getting away from Islam and they are turning secular..

now read the Hadith again.

It is narrated on the authority of Abu Huraira that the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) said: Islam initiated as something strange, and it would revert to its (old position) of being strange. so good tidings for the stranger. (Book #001, Hadith #0270)


Is int it exactly the same that is happening now ??

Every religion claims to make big bold predictions that this will happen or that will happen, and they point to events and say look "it is already mentioned in the wholly book." I won't talk about Islam, but 20 centuries ago christian believers knew that what we are preaching to people is complete and utter bullsh!t that humans after us will not buy. I believe I am smarter than the homo sapiens of 10th century.