Advertisement

Ex-CJ of Shariat Court to repay millions taken as illegal pension

یہ چھوٹے فرعون لوگوں پر شریعت نافظ کرتے تھے
​

ISLAMABAD: After playing flip-flop on the issue of the illegal pension of recently retired Chief Justice Federal Shariat Court Justice Agha Rafiq Ahmad Khan when he was in service, the Law Ministry has now allowed the AGPR to deduct from Khans commutation all the amount that he has been drawing as pension since June 2011.


The AGPR sources confirmed to The News that the Law Ministry has finally responded after Agha Rafiqs retirement and has allowed the AGPR to deduct from the retired CJFSCs commutation millions of rupees that he was paid during the last three years as pension of retired CJFSC.

The AGPR and the Law Ministry were interacting for the last several months on the issue whether under the law it was possible for Agha Rafiq Ahmad Khan to draw both pension and salary of the office of the FSC CJ at the same time.

Justice Aghas pension payment order, issued to him in June 2011, showed him retiring as the FSC Chief Justice on June 4, 2011, when he had actually completed his two-year tenure, which was extended for another three years, ended in June this year. However, he never took a fresh oath.

Following The News report on this strange anomaly, the AGPR took up the issue with the Law Ministry which initially said that no FSC judge could be allowed a pension.

The Law Ministry had referred to the clause (4) of Article 230C of the Constitution which says that the chief justice and a judge shall hold office for a period not exceeding three years, but may be appointed for such further term or terms as the president may determine.

This provision abundantly manifests that the appointment of the chief justice and a judge of Federal Shariat Court is of contractual nature and is not regular appointment leading to retirement because in case of judges of the apex court Article 179 of the Constitution and in respect of judge of high court Article 195 of the Constitution provide for retirement of judges but no such provision exists in the Constitution regarding the retirement of the chief justice and the judge of the Federal Shariat Court, the Law Ministrys advice had conveyed to the AGPR.

However, after sometime the Law Ministry revised its advice and took a complete somersault and informed the AGPR that these judges were entitled to pension if they had a minimum of five years of service.

However, even in its revised advice the Law Ministry did not respond to the original query of the AGPR whether the then chief justice of the FSC Justice Agha Rafiq Ahmad Khan was entitled to draw the salary as well as the pension of the office of CJ FSC simultaneously.

On this the AGPR again referred the issue to the Law Ministry to get the clarification if the then CJ FSC was entitled to draw the salary as well as pension. The Law Ministry did not respond to the AGPRs last reference till the retirement of Afgha Rafiq. However, after his retirement an unambiguous and straight reply has been given to the AGPR, which has now moved to get the money back.
 
Advertisement