Advertisement

Eidul Azha: In DHA, yaks, albino cows promise spectacular sacrifice for those who cant afford them

287907-CamelsPHOTOSNEFERSEHGALEXPRESS-1320435006-570-640x480.jpg


KARACHI: The 2.5-million-rupee black cow the size of a dumper truck is a star attraction at a businessmans marquee in DHA Phase V where they had to post a traffic policeman to manage the gridlock.

The long queues of families with excited children line up during the day and night outside the tent, which is a temporary home to nearly 70 imported beasts ahead of Eidul Azha. Everyone endures a body check by private guards before being herded past the walk-through gates. Inside, CCTV cameras monitor every little move whether on four legs or two.


To one side you will see the herd of yaks, the kind you find in the Himalayan region. Since Karachis heat is alien to them, the owner has installed air conditioners in this section. Meet the goats from Turkey and next door a set of their Afghan cousins.


Five camels, including a giraffe-sized one that the owner claims is the tallest in Pakistan, are having their fur shampooed. A special barber from rural Sindh had been summoned to create beautiful patterns all over their humps. Especially flown in from Islamabad was one cow, described as a cross between an Australian bull and a Pakistani cow. There were around 29 such breeds at the venue. But for the children the real attraction was the rare pair of albino cows. Traffic policeman Manzoor, who has been posted outside the tent, says that after 8pm, the spectator rush is insane and the small lane gets choked frequently.
The middle-aged owner of this spectacular bovine and camelidae display insists, however, that this was not an exhibition of his massive wealth. He specifies that he does not want to be named, as Islam doesnt allow showing off.


The jury may still be out on whether it is kosher to hold such open house invitations to exotica but in a city like Karachi this much is clear, not everyone has the money to sacrifice a yak. And while each Muslim manages according to their pocket, the DHA Phase V marquee does contrast starkly with the Eid preparations going on in other parts of the city.


Landhis plumber Abrar, for example, who supports his family of three on Rs20,000 a month, will not be able to make a sacrifice this year. Each year the prices keep going up, he said. People like me first shifted from buying goats to taking part in ijtimai qurbani [collective sacrifices], but the prices of that too have sky rocketed.


For his part, economist Dr Kaiser Bengali interprets the DHA case as a reflect[ion of] an obnoxious display of wealth and brazen insensitivity to the plight of millions. But, he argues that it is not new that thousands of people struggle to buy a goat for Rs7,000.


What is significant is that even the middle class is now afflicted with a kind of poverty, he said, citing the example of people who have jobs but are squeezed tight by the cost of making it there. The class divide and unequal distribution of wealth is supported by the numbers. For each rupee increase in the national income, the richest 10% of the people in the country gain 34 paisas, while the poorest 10% get 3 paisas only. Perhaps one advantage to the DHA tent full of international sacrificial animals is that many deserving people will get a taste of rich meat this Eid.

http://tribune.com.pk/story/287907/...lar-sacrifice-for-those-who-cant-afford-them/
 
Advertisement
i already knew this news would be from TRIBUNE.
well tribune should change its name to ZOOM
 
Eid ul Azha of Elite Class

[h=1]Eidul Azha: In DHA, yaks, albino cows promise spectacular sacrifice for those who cant afford them[/h]By Salman Siddiqui
Published: November 5, 2011



287907-CamelsPHOTOSNEFERSEHGALEXPRESS-1320435006-570-640x480.jpg
​
These camels at the DHA Phase V house respond to voice commands to sit down. The animals were constantly brushed to prevent flies from bothering them. PHOTO: NEFER SEHGAL/EXPRESS

287907-cowPHOTOSNEFERSEHGALEXPRESS-1320435032-305-640x480.jpg



The long queues of families with excited children line up during the day and night outside the tent, which is a temporary home to nearly 70 imported beasts ahead of Eidul Azha. Everyone endures a body check by private guards before being herded past the walk-through gates. Inside, CCTV cameras monitor every little move whether on four legs or two.




KARACHI:
The 2.5-million-rupee black cow the size of a dumper truck is a star attraction at a businessmans marquee in DHA Phase V where they had to post a traffic policeman to manage the gridlock.



To one side you will see the herd of yaks, the kind you find in the Himalayan region. Since Karachis heat is alien to them, the owner has installed air conditioners in this section. Meet the goats from Turkey and next door a set of their Afghan cousins.
Five camels, including a giraffe-sized one that the owner claims is the tallest in Pakistan, are having their fur shampooed. A special barber from rural Sindh had been summoned to create beautiful patterns all over their humps. Especially flown in from Islamabad was one cow, described as a cross between an Australian bull and a Pakistani cow. There were around 29 such breeds at the venue. But for the children the real attraction was the rare pair of albino cows. Traffic policeman Manzoor, who has been posted outside the tent, says that after 8pm, the spectator rush is insane and the small lane gets choked frequently.
The middle-aged owner of this spectacular bovine and camelidae display insists, however, that this was not an exhibition of his massive wealth. He specifies that he does not want to be named, as Islam doesnt allow showing off.
The jury may still be out on whether it is kosher to hold such open house invitations to exotica but in a city like Karachi this much is clear, not everyone has the money to sacrifice a yak. And while each Muslim manages according to their pocket, the DHA Phase V marquee does contrast starkly with the Eid preparations going on in other parts of the city.
Landhis plumber Abrar, for example, who supports his family of three on Rs20,000 a month, will not be able to make a sacrifice this year. Each year the prices keep going up, he said. People like me first shifted from buying goats to taking part in ijtimai qurbani [collective sacrifices], but the prices of that too have sky rocketed.
For his part, economist Dr Kaiser Bengali interprets the DHA case as a reflect[ion of] an obnoxious display of wealth and brazen insensitivity to the plight of millions. But, he argues that it is not new that thousands of people struggle to buy a goat for Rs7,000.
What is significant is that even the middle class is now afflicted with a kind of poverty, he said, citing the example of people who have jobs but are squeezed tight by the cost of making it there. The class divide and unequal distribution of wealth is supported by the numbers. For each rupee increase in the national income, the richest 10% of the people in the country gain 34 paisas, while the poorest 10% get 3 paisas only. Perhaps one advantage to the DHA tent full of international sacrificial animals is that many deserving people will get a taste of rich meat this Eid.
Published in The Express Tribune, November 5[SUP]th[/SUP], 2011.


Source :
http://tribune.com.pk/story/287907/...lar-sacrifice-for-those-who-cant-afford-them/


 
Advertisement
Re: Eid ul Azha of Elite Class

Its up to Allah SWT to accept these people sacrifices. If they do these to boast in their elite circles, then surely they will be smashed on their faces on day of qyama.

If I have got that much wealth and considering current Pakistan circumstance, I would never 'wasted' that much money rather on those who committed suicides of hunger (1,600 figure of current year) or to build homes, provide shelters for flood victims.

Qurbani can still be done with 50,000 rupees but which comes first? An expensive qurbani or a fellow Muslim ? Which act would be more dearer to Allah SWT? We Muslims of Pakistan got some serious 'problem' and thus facing all these hardships.

---
brilTek
 
Re: Eid ul Azha of Elite Class

while i understand its a tradition to sacrifice pastoral animals during EID, i have a question. has anyone analyzed what the effect is of this sacrifice on the economy. i would assume in a rural agricultural economy, pastoral animals must be very important for things like milk, ploughing etc. Just asking of anyone has any good idea. google doesnt provide any decent reference.
 
Re: Eid ul Azha of Elite Class

I have an interesting finding to share. A few years ago when I was doing some research on Iran's Economy, I noticed that Iran's highest IMPORTS were
1. Womens' Bras
2. Civil Aircraft equipment
3. Bull semen from USA

The 3rd item stuck me by surprise. And then I found out that US breeds one of the strongest and large breeds of goats, cows and bulls. Their semen are then exported to across the globe for superior cattles.

Looking at pics over here just reminded me of that fact.

Kya Shaan hai Allah ki. Kesa nawaza hai Us zaat ne insaan ko. Chahe phir insaan us RAB ko maanay ya na maanay.

Pata nahi hamein Allah ne Ashraf-ul-Makhlukaat kyun kaha. Hum to na shukray fasaadi . Shayad Kalme aur Durood k sadke.. Wallahu Aalam.
 
Last edited:
Re: Eid ul Azha of Elite Class

while i understand its a tradition to sacrifice pastoral animals during EID, i have a question. has anyone analyzed what the effect is of this sacrifice on the economy. i would assume in a rural agricultural economy, pastoral animals must be very important for things like milk, ploughing etc. Just asking of anyone has any good idea. google doesnt provide any decent reference.

juju you just cracked me up. Mere bhai this is a religious ritual. And remember this in religion. Its connected via faith. And whats faith?
Faith is the opposite of reasoning. Its the belief in the unknown.

People fought wars and died because they believed in something - something they knew was greater than their existence. Ye to eak jaanwar hai jisse banaya bhi US ne, aur phir hum ko kaha k us ki jaan li jae Ussi ki ijazat se. Do u know the whole story behind it? Stuff's like thousands of years old.

In terms of Ecomonics. Umm.. from a very technical point of view. The growth and consumption are very unstable because its once a year event so all the structures around the farming, cattle industry, get propped up during this time around the year and then get detangled till then end of the next year... Like in the USA, there are alot of retail jobs before Christmas but after that, those jobs vanish. So its in unsustainable event. Just my 2cent
 
Advertisement
Re: Eid ul Azha of Elite Class

If you got the money, its best to do it. At the end of the day, even if you spend 2 lakh on 1 cow, that money goes to a village in Sindh/Punjab where the money is spent on farming more land which in turn requires someone to work on that land, which creates employment in that village. So in the end, it does help.

Its up to Allah SWT to accept these people sacrifices. If they do these to boast in their elite circles, then surely they will be smashed on their faces on day of qyama.

If I have got that much wealth and considering current Pakistan circumstance, I would never 'wasted' that much money rather on those who committed suicides of hunger (1,600 figure of current year) or to build homes, provide shelters for flood victims.

Qurbani can still be done with 50,000 rupees but which comes first? An expensive qurbani or a fellow Muslim ? Which act would be more dearer to Allah SWT? We Muslims of Pakistan got some serious 'problem' and thus facing all these hardships.

---
brilTek
 
Re: Eid ul Azha of Elite Class

while i understand its a tradition to sacrifice pastoral animals during EID, i have a question. has anyone analyzed what the effect is of this sacrifice on the economy. i would assume in a rural agricultural economy, pastoral animals must be very important for things like milk, ploughing etc. Just asking of anyone has any good idea. google doesnt provide any decent reference.

Animals would have become extinct in Muslim countries as muslims are performing this ritual for more than 1400 years now.

We do this for Allah SWT, so he is making them in abundance and keeping the balance. BTW, on average, one goat gives 1-2 births every year, and we slaughter one each year, over years, we still got goats in surplus.

And BTW, understand the meaning of 'qurbani', to give some valuable thing for Allah's sake and is only compulsory for those who can afford it and not on poor people.



---
brilTek
 
Last edited:
Re: Eid ul Azha of Elite Class

If you got the money, its best to do it. At the end of the day, even if you spend 2 lakh on 1 cow, that money goes to a village in Sindh/Punjab where the money is spent on farming more land which in turn requires someone to work on that land, which creates employment in that village. So in the end, it does help.

That money will only go to one family.Now which is more important, saving some poor soul, feeding some hungry belly OR to spending unwisely on prodigal expenditures. As per my understanding, saving someone life is more important in Islam rather than any other act. It is in Quran ' whoever saves one human life, its alike he saved whole of human kind'


Whether you agree with me or not, but this expensive qurbani are done as status symbol.

---
brilTek
 
Re: Eid ul Azha of Elite Class

while i understand its a tradition to sacrifice pastoral animals during EID, i have a question. has anyone analyzed what the effect is of this sacrifice on the economy. i would assume in a rural agricultural economy, pastoral animals must be very important for things like milk, ploughing etc. Just asking of anyone has any good idea. google doesnt provide any decent reference.


It goes like this , u are a farmer , a poor one , have a lady goat :P , u use it as a source of milk , lady goat now gives birth to another lady goat and a Boy goat :P (i dont like using male female word).............. U feed them till they are healthy and old , U keep the lady goat and sell the boy goat for a handsome amount for EID. (bigsmile)


SO , its kind of a side business.
 
Advertisement
Re: Eid ul Azha of Elite Class

That money will only go to one family.Now which is more important, saving some poor soul, feeding some hungry belly OR to spending unwisely on prodigal expenditures. As per my understanding, saving someone life is more important in Islam rather than any other act. It is in Quran ' whoever saves one human life, its alike he saved whole of human kind'


Whether you agree with me or not, but this expensive qurbani are done as status symbol.

---
brilTek

dekho.. ho sakta hai you're right coz I am not as aware of social issues in Pakistan as you may be.
 
Re: Eid ul Azha of Elite Class

bro i'm all the way on the western border of US....it's full of farms...cows and horses and Guns(i'm serious).....me being a paindu, these things attract me alot....and i was talking to one of this farmer....he said he exports thousands of cows to middle eastern countries.....and import horses
I have an interesting finding to share. A few years ago when I was doing some research on Iran's Economy, I noticed that Iran's highest IMPORTS were
1. Womens' Bras
2. Civil Aircraft equipment
3. Bull semen from USA

The 3rd item stuck me by surprise. And then I found out that US breeds one of the most strong and large breeds of goats, cows and bulls. Their semen are then exported to across the globe for superior cattles.

Looking at pics over here just reminded me of that fact.

Kya Shaan hai Allah ki. Kesa nawaza hai Us zaat ne insaan ko. Chahe phir insaan us RAB ko maanay ya na maanay.

Pata nahi hamein Allah ne Ashraf-ul-Makhlukaat kyun kaha. Hum to na shukray fasaadi . Shayad Kalme aur Durood k sadke.. Wallahu Aalam.
 
Re: Eid ul Azha of Elite Class

cefspan its not like that unfortunately. remember from the perspective of the overall economy, a productive member of the economy (who gives milk etc.) is replaced by an unproductive (dead) animal. i think it should have a negative effect. unlike chicken which are reared only for meat and are otherwise unproductive.

lets convert all arguments to the cow.
so for e.g. suppose all of pakistan on eid -1 day had 10 lakh cows each on an average giving 10 litres milk. so milk production of pakistan is 100 lank litres. next day on eid suppose 1 lakh are killed. the next milk productivity of pakistan goes down by 10% to 900 lakh litres.

to everyone else it is an intellectual exercise. I am not challenging your traditions please. so no offence intended. i understand your deep conviction and respect it.

BUT cefspan i see your point that the male members of all these species (except maybe sheep and draught cattle) are unproductive.


It goes like this , u are a farmer , a poor one , have a lady goat :P , u use it as a source of milk , lady goat now gives birth to another lady goat and a Boy goat :P (i dont like using male female word).............. U feed them till they are healthy and old , U keep the lady goat and sell the boy goat for a handsome amount for EID. (bigsmile)


SO , its kind of a side business.
 
Last edited:
Re: Eid ul Azha of Elite Class

bro i'm all the way on the western border of US....it's full of farms...cows and horses and Guns(i'm serious).....me being a paindu, these things attract me alot....and i was talking to one of this farmer....he said he exports thousands of cows to middle eastern countries.....and import horses

Yaar I just love the milk here! What state? WA or OR? or is it CA? You gotta have a gun man.. U gotta have a GUN. 2nd Amendment baby! Look, the difference b/w a free man and a slave is a GUN.
 
Advertisement
Re: Eid ul Azha of Elite Class

cefspan its not like that unfortunately. remember from the perspective of the overall economy, a productive member of the economy (who gives milk etc.) is replaced by an unproductive (dead) animal. i think it should have a negative effect. unlike chicken which are reared only for meat and are otherwise unproductive.

lets convert all arguments to the cow.
so for e.g. suppose all of pakistan on eid -1 day had 10 lakh cows each on an average giving 10 litres milk. so milk production of pakistan is 100 lank litres. next day on eid suppose 1 lakh are killed. the next milk productivity of pakistan goes down by 10% to 900 lakh litres.

to everyone else it is an intellectual exercise. I am not challenging your traditions please. so no offence intended. i understand your deep conviction and respect it.

BUT cefspan i see your point that the male members of all these species (except maybe sheep and draught cattle) are unproductive.

Nope , I understand what u are saying.

Usually , what I see around , people prefer Male goats , bulls and all that..............

Aur sunaen! JUJU sb!

Are u on facebook?
 
Re: Eid ul Azha of Elite Class

to everyone else it is an intellectual exercise. I am not challenging your traditions please. so no offence intended. i understand your deep conviction and respect it.

juju.. I have consistently noticed, even here in the US that Indians are very considerate in matters of religious affairs. And its always appreciated. Mutual Respect and Individualism, if these 2 things were known by ppl, there would never be a war on this planet. I sincerely believe that.

cefspan its not like that unfortunately. remember from the perspective of the overall economy, a productive member of the economy (who gives milk etc.) is replaced by an unproductive (dead) animal. i think it should have a negative effect. unlike chicken which are reared only for meat and are otherwise unproductive.

lets convert all arguments to the cow.
so for e.g. suppose all of pakistan on eid -1 day had 10 lakh cows each on an average giving 10 litres milk. so milk production of pakistan is 100 lank litres. next day on eid suppose 1 lakh are killed. the next milk productivity of pakistan goes down by 10% to 900 lakh litres.

to everyone else it is an intellectual exercise. I am not challenging your traditions please. so no offence intended. i understand your deep conviction and respect it.

BUT cefspan i see your point that the male members of all these species (except maybe sheep and draught cattle) are unproductive.
 
Re: Eid ul Azha of Elite Class

[MENTION=19074]jujuju[/MENTION]

Forgot to write about your main question. I believe milk-giving cows are the not prefered choice because there is a difference in the quality of meat.
 
Re: Eid ul Azha of Elite Class

NAH ONLY YOUTUBE.
http://www.youtube.com/user/shankyxyz
only thing i do online is listen classical music and argue on this forum (lol) though i originally came here only to work on my urdu. so no facebook, or twitter or myspace (dont know if anyone is on myspace)?

Nope , I understand what u are saying.

Usually , what I see around , people prefer Male goats , bulls and all that..............

Aur sunaen! JUJU sb!

Are u on facebook?