Advertisement

Ahmad Deedat - How Salman Rushie fooled the west and fu**ed the English language (A Must See)

2rwmjko.png
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Advertisement
I don't know how he fooled the west. His book was a Satirical look at religion. There are satirical books on every religion the writers don't create them the punch lines are already there.
 
I don't know how he fooled the west. His book was a Satirical look at religion. There are satirical books on every religion the writers don't create them the punch lines are already there.
Its a terrible almost unreadable book. The reason for its fame is that it pisses of Muslims.
Thre is saying in literary circles about Satanic verses, its the "Least read best seller".
If Khomeni had not chosen to use it as a propaganda tool it would be largely unknown.
The prizes Rushdie milked from this are a scandal .

As for satire and religion. Can you tell us why India's Piccaso,
MF Hussain had to die outside incredible secular Endia.
For the crime of making paintings similar to hundreds of mosaics and sculptures present in thousands of temples through out india.
Or was his mistake being born a Muslim??


Here is a non Youtube link to Deedat talk:
[video]http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=bad_1351127840[/video]
 
Last edited:
Advertisement
Its a terrible almost unreadable book. The reason for its fame is that it pisses of Muslims.
Thre is saying in literary circles about Satanic verses, its the "Least read best seller".
If Khomeni had not chosen to use it as a propaganda tool it would be largely unknown.
The prizes Rushdie milked from this are a scandal .

As for satire and religion. Can you tell us why India's Piccaso,
MF Hussain had to die outside incredible secular Endia.
For the crime of making paintings similar to hundreds of mosaics and sculptures present in thousands of temples through out india.
Or was his mistake being born a Muslim??

When I read the book it was horrible. The reason was that I had no idea about the religion. It was a much better read with familiarity of religion. You are absolutely correct it was Khomeni who promoted the book otherwise no one would have read it.

MF Hussein was one of the greatest painters of the sub continent. He did not even satirize the religion. He faced death threats from religious Hindu nuts. I hope you guys can understand that India as a state is secular because its constitution is secular. State of India does not force, and nor it should, its citizens to be secular, each individual has to make that choice. Being a secular country does not mean that people can't hate each other based on religions.At the same token there is more satire in Hindu scriptures than many of the other scriptures I have read but people who follow don't see them as funny but I do.
 
When I read the book it was horrible. The reason was that[HI] I had no idea about the religion. It was a much better read with familiarity of religion.[/HI] You are absolutely correct it was Khomeni who promoted the book otherwise no one would have read it.

MF Hussein was one of the greatest painters of the sub continent. [HI]He did not even satirize the religion.[/HI] He faced death threats from religious Hindu nuts. I hope you guys can understand that India as a state is secular because its constitution is secular. State of India does not force, and nor it should, its citizens to be secular, each individual has to make that choice. [HI]Being a secular country does not mean that people can't hate each other based on religions.[/HI]At the same token there is more satire in Hindu scriptures than many of the other scriptures I have read but people who follow don't see them as funny but I do.

MF Hussain could not live in India because India is a militant Hindu state. As you pointed out his paintings were no even Satire they were a homage to the Hindu gods. However his crime was being a MUslim the same crime that can can means you cant live in the better parts of Bombay.The same crime by which an innocuous act like doing a sacrifice in Eid can cause a riot. There is a good reason why Sachar Report commissioned by the Lokh Saba concludes that Muslims are now the most deprived class in Shining India. Thank God for Jinnah, History proved him right. This isnt what secular means.

As for familiarity of religion and Satanic verses. The book is inflammatory it meant to hurt sentiments of Muslims otherwise its unreadable. Thats Deedat point. The book is similar to Protocols of Elder of Zions or the Julius Striecher "Poisonous Toadstool". or his work on the Talmud.

Streicher went to the gallows after Nuremberg for his hate speech, unrepentant till the end.
Your secular Indian Hero Rushdie on Christmas Eve 1990 issued a statement bearing witness that "there is no God but Allah, and Muhammad is his last prophet". Claiming to have renewed his faith in Islam, he said he did not agree with any character in The Satanic Verses who "casts aspersions... upon the authenticity of the holy Qur'an, or who rejects the divinity of Allah". He also said he would not release a paperback of the book.
A truly pathetic man in every respect.


But you take lecherous glee at such hate speech because you are just another "Hindu nut job" trolling Pakistani forums, trying to get a reaction for self affirmation.

The same nutjobs that make the comment section of any Pakistani Newspaper article or any article about Pakistan unreadable with their predictable hate and two facedness.

As for Hindu scripture having read parts of the Mahabharta,Bhagvadgita and Rigvedas with a lot of effort, I wont comment as we are taught not to make fun of other peoples belief.
 
Last edited:
When I read the book it was horrible. The reason was that I had no idea about the religion. It was a much better read with familiarity of religion. You are absolutely correct it was Khomeni who promoted the book otherwise no one would have read it.

MF Hussein was one of the greatest painters of the sub continent. He did not even satirize the religion. He faced death threats from religious Hindu nuts. I hope you guys can understand that India as a state is secular because its constitution is secular. State of India does not force, and nor it should, its citizens to be secular, each individual has to make that choice. Being a secular country does not mean that people can't hate each other based on religions.At the same token there is more satire in Hindu scriptures than many of the other scriptures I have read but people who follow don't see them as funny but I do.

I am surprised that you have so conveniently dismissed that there is hate in india against some people but what happened to the state security which should have protected it's esteemed citizen?
If there is hate in india and you have accepted it as a normal process then it is sad. Given this acceptance then india looses the right to criticize any such act any where in the world.
Now in my opinion hate is a deplorable thing just as much as is the satire of any religion or faith.
There can not be any and should not be any EXPLANATION for such an act. You can not explain it away.
Thank God for Jinnah and Thank God for Pakistan.
Aap ko india mubarik.
By the way Rushdie was an indian citizen, is he still an indian also?