Advertisement

Abu Dhabi mosque renamed ‘Mary, mother of Jesus’ in harmony bid

Re: UAE mosque renaming might generate opposition to legitimacy of Rulers and make their understanding of Islam suspect

All people here being outraged over this would be ecstatic if a Church or a Synagogue was being named after one of our religious figures - how hypocritical!
 
Re: UAE mosque renaming might generate opposition to legitimacy of Rulers and make their understanding of Islam suspect

another re-naming, possibly waiting in the wings "narinder modi mosque".

Quran demands same respect for Modi that it demands for Jesus? This is beyond absurd...
 
what's the harm in it? We believe Jesus was a Messiah and Mary was his mother... so why on earth is this offensive to anyone????

Firstly allow me to explain that theoretically there is nothing wrong with naming a mosque as Maryam mosque but the UAE ruler has done this as part of a policy of temples of other religions which bear idols , this is completely unacceptable as it undoes the work of Prophet of Islam and Caliphs as regarding Arabian peninsula and reintroduces idol worship in physical form in Arabian peninsula . The case of Arabian peninsula is different from other muslim lands .

Secondly , when was St paul's Cathedral named as Muhammad Cathedral .

Thirdly , we who live in pakistan have a different case from muslims living in christian lands , they mostly have chosen their life course themselves , we cannot for 4 million immigrants change our religion , our culture our rules for our 200 million or say 2 billion muslims , we are not obliged for that. Besides Christians are demanding that we change religion content as they being priest ridden have done . we have reached end of line on this issue .

Fourthly we cannot some media moguls to rewrite morality .

Pakistan is moving towards nudity and liberality and also islamic reaction at the same time . Times of PPP, PMLN, PTI , MQM and politics has ended and world changes are forcing us to withdraw provincial autonomy , media and political class and agree on central doctrines . Muslims have always done well under kings , dictatators and conquerers .
 
Firstly allow me to explain that theoretically there is nothing wrong with naming a mosque as Maryam mosque but the UAE ruler has done this as part of a policy of temples of other religions which bear idols , this is completely unacceptable as it undoes the work of Prophet of Islam and Caliphs as regarding Arabian peninsula and reintroduces idol worship in physical form in Arabian peninsula . The case of Arabian peninsula is different from other muslim lands .

Secondly , when was St paul's Cathedral named as Muhammad Cathedral .

Thirdly , we who live in pakistan have a different case from muslims living in christian lands , they mostly have chosen their life course themselves , we cannot for 4 million immigrants change our religion , our culture our rules for our 200 million or say 2 billion muslims , we are not obliged for that. Besides Christians are demanding that we change religion content as they being priest ridden have done . we have reached end of line on this issue .

Fourthly we cannot some media moguls to rewrite morality .

Pakistan is moving towards nudity and liberality and also islamic reaction at the same time . Times of PPP, PMLN, PTI , MQM and politics has ended and world changes are forcing us to withdraw provincial autonomy , media and political class and agree on central doctrines . Muslims have always done well under kings , dictatators and conquerers .

So what I am hearing you say is that we cannot name a mosque after the mother of our beloved Messiah because it will make Muslims want to wear less clothes and become more liberal?
 
So what I am hearing you say is that we cannot name a mosque after the mother of our beloved Messiah because it will make Muslims want to wear less clothes and become more liberal?

I do not know what logic system you are using these days , Canada can be quite cold .

But may be i should explain again .

There is another aspect to naming mosques , while there is nothing wrong if a mosque is named Issa , or Musa or Maryam , or Ibrahim or Dawood but muslims have mostly used names of prophet and his followers of his progeny for naming mosques.

The message of Musa , Issa , Muhammed was thought to be the same as per Islamic beliefs but zone of authority for Bani israel prophets if Bani Israel .

Jesus was Bani israel , have a look at this portion of bible which clearly states that Jesus was for Bani israel only as per himself .

quote :
[h=2]Matthew 15:21-28 (Bible )[/h]
Leaving that place, Jesus withdrew to the region of Tyre and Sidon. [SUP]22[/SUP] A Canaanite woman from that vicinity came to Him, crying out, “Lord, Son of David, have mercy on me! My daughter is suffering terribly from demon-possession.”

[SUP]23[/SUP] Jesus did not answer a word. So his disciples came to Him and urged Him, “Send her away, for she keeps crying out after us.” [SUP]24[/SUP] He answered, “I was only sent to the lost sheep of Israel.”


[SUP]25 [/SUP]The woman came and knelt before Him. “Lord, help me!” she said. [SUP]26[/SUP] He replied, “It is not right to take the children’s bread and toss it to their dogs.” [SUP]27[/SUP] “Yes, Lord,” she said, “but even the dogs eat the crumbs that fall from their master’s table.”


[SUP]27[/SUP] Then Jesus answered, “Woman, you have great faith! Your request is granted.” And her daughter was healed from that very hour.


So while Muslims believe that Issa and Musa were prophets with same message but their jurisdiction area was limited to Bani Israel . It is therefore not unnatural that Muslims name mosques after muhammed and his followers .

Regarding nudity and obscenity , it is tragedy that women in christian world in ample percentage use their religion only to get alimony in divorce and follow none of the injunctions of Mosaic law and are very aggressive in promoting their promiscuous culture in islamic societies.

Islam and Christianity are different , infact Christanity is perhaps not really a religion , it is later day adaptation of reformatory (but rejected by jews high priests ) teaching of jesus reported in unreliable and erroneous way to posterity . Moses did help advance and promulgate religion and that is a religion because in Islam we need a massenger and a message.
 
Re: UAE mosque renaming might generate opposition to legitimacy of Rulers and make their understanding of Islam suspect

lolz how many times have u translated and done tafsir of Quran??? I dont think u have even read it once.... or else u would know about the spirit of Islam... First u said renaming the mosque "BELITTLES" Islam.... that was ur BS... and now u took a uturn since everyone here saw ur an idiot... so first appologise that u were wrong about the mosque name and belittling Islam comment...

2ndly, If Islam wanted to finish every Idot, then Allah would have asked us to destroy every place of Idol... that is not the case... Islam orders to protect minorities and their places of worship.. yes discourage idol worshiping but not by force... but my Ilam and logic..

Arabian peninsula was cleared of all idols long ago...but now that hindu workers work, they have all the right to have a mandir of their own... Muslims rule these lands and there is no restriction in allowing minorities to have their place of worship... go do some study and learn something... u were wrong about the mosque name issue.. and now ur wrong about this too..



You really need to read quran a few times with translation and tafsir ,along with hadith to understand the spirit of Islam . Good websites for that include WWW.alim.org and WWW.urdu-quran.org and so on and videos on you tube like those of Dr.Israr Ahmed There is no objection to naming any mosque as marriam mosque or issa mosque and there are historical mosques with ottoman women name but Muslims have preferred to give them neutral names or names of persons who helped prophet , like abubakr siddiq or umar or Usman and so on. Issue here is that UAE and gulf Emirates are reestablishing non Muslim culture in Arabian peninsula and there are some indications and assumptions that prophet of Islam had some special instructions on Arabian peninsula to rid Arabian peninsula of idol worship , why do you not quote those . ( You stated above "Islam target was to destroy the 'RULE of idol worshippers".. and that it did ) is factually wrong , idol worship is still rife , even in muslim dominated lands . If we assume that islam was just about destroying rule of idol worshippers then it is completely wrong , it is about thanking and obeying the creator God (Allah) and discouraging idol worshiping of false gods and other forms of cults like human worship , ancestor worship , spirit worship. The non muslims continue their ways by way of either submitting jizya which is a form of submission to Islamic state and even can be construed as getting in the category of "citizen" of Muslim ruled state . These days we go further as impose more taxes not just jizya. The case of arabian peninsula is different from case of other muslim countries in this respect .
 
Re: UAE mosque renaming might generate opposition to legitimacy of Rulers and make their understanding of Islam suspect

lolz how many times have u translated andbellitlsir of Quran??? I dont think u have even read it once.... or else u would know about the spirit of Islam... First u said renaming the mosque "BELITTLES" Islam.... that was ur BS... and now u took a uturn since everyone here saw ur an idiot... so first appologise that u were wrong about the mosque name and belittling Islam comment...

2ndly, If Islam wanted to finish every Idot, then Allah would have asked us to destroy every place of Idol... that is not the case... Islam orders to protect minorities and their places of worship.. yes discourage idol worshiping but not by force... but my Ilam and logic..

Arabian peninsula was cleared of all idols long ago...but now that hindu workers work, they have all the right to have a mandir of their own... Muslims rule these lands and there is no restriction in allowing minorities to have their place of worship... go do some study and learn something... u were wrong about the mosque name issue.. and now ur wrong about this too..

I have no need to apologize ,such intentioned renaming of mosque tends to belittle the distinctness of Islam , we are under no obligation to reintroduce idol based worship in Arabian peninsula , The case of Arabian peninsula is different from that of rest of Muslim dominated lands . They kill Muslims for eating cow or in west Muslim girls cannot now safely wear even hijab .