Abu Dhabi mosque renamed ‘Mary, mother of Jesus’ in harmony bid
DUBAI: A mosque in the UAE’s capital Abu Dhabi has been renamed the “Mary, mother of Jesus” mosque in a bid to “consolidate bonds of humanity between followers of different religions.”
The mosque — “Mariam, Umm Eisa” in Arabic — was renamed by order of Sheikh Mohammad bin Zayed Al-Nahyan, Abu Dhabi crown prince and deputy supreme commander of the UAE Armed Forces, who made the comment on consolidating bonds between the followers of different faiths.
Minister of State for Tolerance Sheikha Lubna Al-Qasimi thanked the crown prince for his “wise directives in carrying out this initiative that set a shining example, and a beautiful image of the tolerance and coexistence enjoyed by the UAE”, according to a statement carried by WAM.
Reverend Canon Andrew Thompson of the nearby St Andrew’s Church told Gulf News that he was “delighted” with the news.
“We are delighted that we are celebrating something that we have in common between both our faiths,” he said.
“Mary, as the mother of Jesus, is of course a holy, special figure in our communities. She is a woman who symbolizes obedience to God. We look forward to growing in deeper understanding with our neighbors, and we celebrate with them the new name of the mosque.”
The mosque was previously called the Sheikh Mohammad bin Zayed Mosque.
Earlier this week, a church in the area of Al Ain opened its doors to Muslims for Maghrib prayers.
The event saw more than 200 Asian Muslim workers perform prayers in the church.
Although there is no Islamic objection to calling a mosque “Mariam, Umm Eisa” Mosque but changing the name of an existent mosque to it to try to create "harmony" is a semipolitical step.
The ruler shaikh Zayed bin Al Nahyan is getting too far in religious matters beyond his intellect and trying to pose as if Christianity and Islam are the same and deserve same level of patronage in Muslim lands. This cannot be so and will become cause of his ouster one day if he pushes this idea. Islam believes in fundamentals of teachings of Moses and Jesus but this is not the same as that modern day Christianity and Islam are the same. The concepts of "son of God' is very rigourously condemned in Quran .
Jesus was a jewish prophet and his objective was to reform jews . Muhammed PBUH was the last prophet and his mission was not merely to reform the whole universe .
Christianity as sanctioned religion to be distinct from Jewish faith itself was a later decision of his followers , thus sort of making Christianity a kind of "creation" as distinct from jewish faith which had direct sanction from almighty God.
While Islam for all times to come and jewish faith in their times had God's sanction , Jesus the son of Mary was a jewish prophet to reform jewish faith for Allah.
There is nothing wrong in name Issa mosque , or Miriam Mosque or Issa bin Marriam mosque but the sense in which UAE leader is doing it is creating suspicion , he allowed a Hindu temple recently in the country .
A Hindu temple on Arabian peninsula is in contravention of mission accomplished by prophet of islam and caliphs , a similar hindu temple in Pakistan is not the same thing as trying to re-introduce idol worship in Arabian peninsula.
The younger generation of Arabs are taking every thing granted , such acts can create opposition to their rulers for which no solution they might find except elimination .
A mission of a muslim is to spread Islam and rout idol worship from entire universe . How can a muslim ruler take such matters lightly and help idol worship in lands which were rendered idol free by prophet of Islam himself followed by Caliphs.
Is there a proper mosque in Dubai international airport or a room has sign of all faiths still ?
Re: UAE mosque renaming might generate opposition to legitimacy of Rulers and make their understanding of Islam suspect
I dont see any problem in it. Hazrat Eesa and Hazrat Maryam bas some place in Islam. Internet self proclaimed aalims will no dubt issue fatwaz without even looking into it
Re: UAE mosque renaming might generate opposition to legitimacy of Rulers and make their understanding of Islam suspect
what is wrong in the name Marium umm essa... means marium mother of eesa AS... do they not hold a place in Islam? isnt a surah in Quran named after her??????
idiots with no knowledge of Islam and only sectarian hatred would object...
It does not in anyway show the current version of christianity as similar.... Islam came since Prophet Adam AS and one message of tauheed has been brought.. Our Prophet SAW is the last and completes the message..this is what Islam says, so what is wrong in naming a mosque after mariyum AS????
if renaming a mosque to personalities that we believe in, can bring peace , then whats wrong in renaming it to them?? its not like its renamed to pop john paul...
Re: UAE mosque renaming might generate opposition to legitimacy of Rulers and make their understanding of Islam suspect
they could have instead put a plan how can we all Muslims come together and save syria or Yemen or Palestine or Kashmir no let's make a plan to create relations with countries who are destroying islameveryday
what is wrong in the name Marium umm essa... means marium mother of eesa AS... do they not hold a place in Islam? isnt a surah in Quran named after her??????
idiots with no knowledge of Islam and only sectarian hatred would object...
It does not in anyway show the current version of christianity as similar.... Islam came since Prophet Adam AS and one message of tauheed has been brought.. Our Prophet SAW is the last and completes the message..this is what Islam says, so what is wrong in naming a mosque after mariyum AS????
if renaming a mosque to personalities that we believe in, can bring peace , then whats wrong in renaming it to them?? its not like its renamed to pop john paul...
does it says in the quran by the way you can call prophet Issa mother Mary no it does not so it's obvious this was done to maktheirer gods in USA and other western countries happy
There is indeed no problem , but the plan of which this renaming of mosque is part of a larger state desire to even introduce church of idol worshippers in lands cleansed of this practice by Holy prophet and caliphs rashidoon .This is recipe for destruction of house of nahyan and disorder .
There is indeed no problem , but the plan of which this renaming of mosque is part of a larger state desire to even introduce church of idol worshippers in lands cleansed of this practice by Holy prophet and caliphs rashidoon .This is recipe for destruction of house of nahyan and disorder .
How can that be so , Islam's first target was to destroy idol worship . Ridding Arabian peninsula of idol was a great ask of Muhammed and Rashidoon caliphs , another was end to female slaughter on birth . The Hindi temples allowed will bring those idols again on holy land . What is UAE doing ? .
Regarding renaming a mosque , there is nothing wrong with it , but it is part of an impression to belittle the distinctness , superiority of Islam over all religions of the world.
There is big difference in having a idol temple in pakistan and having a idol temple in Arabian peninsula the centre of islam. Allowing idols to return to holy lands is direct challenge to ways of prophet and his caliphs.
Re: UAE mosque renaming might generate opposition to legitimacy of Rulers and make their understanding of Islam suspect
WTH are u saying??? Maryam umme Essa is the name of mosque..its an arabic name.. yes from Quran, surah maryam, have u ever bothered to read??? u can translate it to any language but thats the original.....Nafrat me tum logo ki aqal ghaas khaney chali jati hay.. western countries are not sitting waiting for u to change names of ur mosques and they will jump from happiness.. they dont even care.. they just want ur immigrants away from their countries...
does it says in the quran by the way you can call prophet Issa mother Mary no it does not so it's obvious this was done to maktheirer gods in USA and other western countries happy
Re: UAE mosque renaming might generate opposition to legitimacy of Rulers and make their understanding of Islam suspect
you are an idiot... Islam target was to destroy the 'RULE of idol worshippers".. and that it did.. Islam never allowed to destroy other religious places or discredit them.. Islam allows minorities to follow their faith.. Only in the area of hijaz, non muslims and non muslim places are not allowed... beyond that, minorities can have their places of worship... there are hundreds of thousands of indian hindu workers in UAE, what wrong in giving them their place of worship??? Islam totally allows that, infact its a good thing..
Renaming a mosque to "maryam umme Essa" is belittling??? where is ur brain??? have you not read Surah Maryam????? If a surah of Quran can have the name, why cant a mosque have the name???? in no way the mosque name represents christanity or any other religion.. It in fact asserts the superiority of Islam, Essa AS is our prophet too and anyone who doesnt belive in Him cannot be a muslim... what kind of stupid mentality u ppl have... dont let ur pea sized brain think too much...
How can that be so , Islam's first target was to destroy idol worship . Ridding Arabian peninsula of idol was a great ask of Muhammed and Rashidoon caliphs , another was end to female slaughter on birth . The Hindi temples allowed will bring those idols again on holy land . What is UAE doing ? .
Regarding renaming a mosque , there is nothing wrong with it , but it is part of an impression to belittle the distinctness , superiority of Islam over all religions of the world.
There is big difference in having a idol temple in pakistan and having a idol temple in Arabian peninsula the centre of islam. Allowing idols to return to holy lands is direct challenge to ways of prophet and his caliphs.
yout are an idiot... Islam target was to destroy the 'RULE of idol worshippers".. and that it did.. Islam never allowed to destroy other religious places or discredit them.. Islam allows minorities to follow their faith.. Only in the area of hijaz, non muslims and non muslim places are not allowed... beyond that, minorities can have their places of worship... there are hundreds of thousands of indian hindu workers in UAE, what wrong in giving them their place of worship??? Islam totally allows that, infact its a good thing.. Renaming a mosque to "maryam umme Essa" is belittling??? where is ur brain??? have you not read Surah Maryam????? If a surah of Quran can have the name, why cant a mosque have the name???? in no way the mosque name represents christanity or any other religion.. It in fact asserts the superiority of Islam, Essa AS is our prophet too and anyone who doesnt belive in Him cannot be a muslim... what kind of stupid mentality u ppl have... dont let ur pea sized brain think too much...
You really need to read quran a few times with translation and tafsir ,along with hadith to understand the spirit of Islam . Good websites for that include WWW.alim.org and WWW.urdu-quran.org and so on and videos on you tube like those of Dr.Israr Ahmed There is no objection to naming any mosque as marriam mosque or issa mosque and there are historical mosques with ottoman women name but Muslims have preferred to give them neutral names or names of persons who helped prophet , like abubakr siddiq or umar or Usman and so on. Issue here is that UAE and gulf Emirates are reestablishing non Muslim culture in Arabian peninsula and there are some indications and assumptions that prophet of Islam had some special instructions on Arabian peninsula to rid Arabian peninsula of idol worship , why do you not quote those . ( You stated above "Islam target was to destroy the 'RULE of idol worshippers".. and that it did ) is factually wrong , idol worship is still rife , even in muslim dominated lands . If we assume that islam was just about destroying rule of idol worshippers then it is completely wrong , it is about thanking and obeying the creator God (Allah) and discouraging idol worshiping of false gods and other forms of cults like human worship , ancestor worship , spirit worship. The non muslims continue their ways by way of either submitting jizya which is a form of submission to Islamic state and even can be construed as getting in the category of "citizen" of Muslim ruled state . These days we go further as impose more taxes not just jizya. The case of arabian peninsula is different from case of other muslim countries in this respect .