"Maghribi Dunya" aur Bachoon ki tarbiyat. Ji haan, yahn Bache waldein ko Galli dete hein aur wo age se muskra dete hein, jahan respect nam ki kisi cheez ka wujood nahin Jahan waldein intezaar kerte hein ke kab bacha 18 saal ka ho aur jaan choote, Bahi Sahb ager aap 15 Saal se Ziada Magrib mein reh chukke hein to shayyed in k barre mein sahih likh sakein, ye do chaar saal ka tajzia nahin.
Thik he ke Bachhe ko khud mukhtar banaya jata he, lekin hamare Islami Tehzeb aur Maghrabi tehzeeb mein Zameen asman ka farq he. Waldein ki Khidmat aur respect kerne ka islam hamein hukum deta he.
i started writing in response to this, and after reaching almost a hundred lines, and still not bein able to convey what i wanted to say i thought better to scrap it.
i will just say. this writer is very factual. his observations are very accurate. and no i haven't spent just a couple of years in a western world cocooned in a DESI NETWORK (something our pakistanis are notorious by and large in the bigger western world in doing) of mostly other pakistanis and then trying to comment on westerners from inside that shell. this has always surprised me that some of the strongest opinions about western life usually come from pakistanis who actually observe this lifestyle from a distance, presuming and interpreting this way of life in consultation with other cocooned desis around them.
So, i have lived in pakistan till age 25, and the next 10 yrs in australia. i have very close friends in australia, both westerners and pakistanis. i interact with australian way of life very closely because of nature of my work and fact that i like networking to some extent across a wide range of demographic in australia. and my conclusion of that all is
no side is perfect. one has certain attributes that are better then the other. question is, which societal model is better TODAY. my answer to that is strongly in line with this writer. that is not to say that joint family system is bad. in fact if you look at it theoretically it is supposed to be the best system. but folks, THEORETICALLY !!!!!!! you don't see that in most places in pakistan and that's the reality. and that our elders are in much poorer shape and form both physically, psychologically and emotionally compared to western ones. please, this is a generalization and exceptions are a rule of thumb here. of course i find apathy in australian society towards elders as well, but man! its nowhere even close to the apathy our elders in pakistan experience.
they are so nice but still do not want allow same kind of justice n judiciary in Islamic Countries and it reflects how well they are being brought up ...
how many westerners do you befriend before you decide to judge their societal model, or whether they have respect for others or not.
is your source of this knowledge media, the newspapers and tv or actually other desis around you ? or you actually have observed EU family model first hand very closely being inside their house holds and seeing their day to day interactions among different generations.
You just point that one example of children abusing their parents in west. yes you are right that does happen, usually in the lower socio economic demographics, aka SLUMS. do you think whole of EU is represented by that? I don't think so. that's the same as painting a picture of some god forsaken part of pakistan and trying to depict that's what the whole of pakistan looks like.
I have spent more then 2 or 4 yrs in west, and i have interacted very closely with westerners. i have been invited to their houses, i have seen them dealing with their sorrows and happiness, and having had a background in psychiatry and general practice i have seen a very diverse cross section of western society, probably more then an average person. and with all of that experience i must say the writer is actually quite factual. i completely understand you may choose to disagree but that doesn't really change the facts.
besides, as to why you should really listen and at least consider my point. I decided to leave Pakistan not so much to earn dollars really, as Allah has been very grateful to me and i had no financial reasons to leave pakistan. It was more that inquisitiveness to know the bigger world, and which i have been doing ever since i have been abroad. I don't know whether you still reside in EU or because of your opinions you have actually called it quits and gone back to the land of pures that Pakistan is. But if you are still in EU, i will question that bigotry as well. i might expect the typical response that you are there for Euros or dollars (the reason for most pakistanis abroad). there is nothing wrong with that. just that, you never went out of pakistan to actually study other societies and you probably have been typically as conservative as an average desi pakistani who usually stay clumped in closely knit desi networks in fear that if they don't do that, western way of life will engulf their next generations. do you want me to start commenting on dynamics of those families! and no that's not coming from desi networks. that's coming from my interactions with them as a doctor and a mental health professional. and that's probably the information that your very desi friend decides NOT TO confide in you, so as not to disturb that smooth desi bubble we usually have. trust me i got a 1001 stories from that model as well, which are far from encouraging :)
"Maghribi Dunya" aur Bachoon ki tarbiyat. Ji haan, yahn Bache waldein ko Galli dete hein aur wo age se muskra dete hein, jahan respect nam ki kisi cheez ka wujood nahin Jahan waldein intezaar kerte hein ke kab bacha 18 saal ka ho aur jaan choote, Bahi Sahb ager aap 15 Saal se Ziada Magrib mein reh chukke hein to shayyed in k barre mein sahih likh sakein, ye do chaar saal ka tajzia nahin.
Thik he ke Bachhe ko khud mukhtar banaya jata he, lekin hamare Islami Tehzeb aur Maghrabi tehzeeb mein Zameen asman ka farq he. Waldein ki Khidmat aur respect kerne ka islam hamein hukum deta he.
بھائی ماں لیں کہ ہم بہت پیچھے ہیں مغرب سے . ایک زمانہ تھا جب مسلم تہذیب دنیا کی ترقی یافتہ تہذیب تھی لیکن اب وہ زمانے نہیں رہے . بجاے اس کے کہ ہم مغربی تہذیب کی برائیاں کریں، کیوں نہ یہی ٹائم اپنی خامیاں تلاش کر کے ان کا مداوا کرنے پر خرچ کر دیں . جو لوگ ١٩٩٥ کے بعد پیدا ہووے ہیں ، ان کی دنیا اور ہے . وہ انٹرنیٹ کے ساتھ اور مغربی آئیڈیاز کے حصار میں بڑے ہو رہے ہیں . اس سے پہلے کہ انہیں اپنے معاشرے کی منافقت اور دوغلے پن سے نفرت ہو جاے ، ، ہمیں آگے بڑھ کر انہیں بچانا ہوگا . نئی نسل کو اپنی اصل تہذیب سے آگاہ کر کے ہی ہم اپنے معاشرے کو بچا سکتے ہیں .
Chal ****** na hoove kisses than da, tenu l-n sur da pata ve pata Nahin kit hoon sahafi ban jandey nein, chal feet das Eddie changgey tarbiat hey TE eh Saray addict kit hoon awandey nein, door de dhool suhanay bhai
Pakistani Family system is good if Pakistani people have to live poor, for next of the 100 years. If we want to get developed and rich than we have to opt Western family system.
In Pak Yousaf Raza Gallani Did lot of corruption to make his children happy by having good cars and home and property and jobs. by that He did secure his children future. Same way Nawaz Sharif doing corruption and prompting his Children and relative at all government level you see all of his family is on key positions in Govt to take decisions. Nawaz Sharif did all that corruption by having properties business in UK for his children.. These are just example trust me every parents in Pak think like yousaf Raza and Nawaz Sharif for children, which simply prompt corruption. Those Parents not do corruption in PAk bcz they have no opportunity to do corruption.
Paki Parents do corruption for there children bcz they think when they turn old our Children will provide us with better facilities.
I completely agree with the writer. That's a real fact no matter how much you deny. We are leading towards a hyppcritic society as a whole nation. instead we should figure out our social hypocricies and overcome these drawbacks in a positive manner. we criticise western society for all their social norms & act like none is superior than us. On the other hand, it is also true We have got so many good things in our culture but the way how we are dealing with them is just hypocritic and based on our so called ego and to earn a fake respect in the society.
بات تو ٪١٠٠سچ ہے.. مگر بات ہے ٪١٠٠ فیصد رسوائ کی.. اس تحریر کو پڑھنے کے بعد ہم میں سے اکثر کی راۓ یہی ہو گی کہ جس نے یہ کالم لکھا ہے وە زہنی طور پہ مغرب کا غلام ہو چکا ہے۔ بجاۓ اس کے کہ ہم اپنے گریبان میں جانک کراپنی کوتاہیوں کو دور کرنے کی کوشش کریں، ہم دوسروں پہ تنقید کر کے اپنے آپ کو اعلٰی وبرتر ثابت کرنے کی کوشش کرتے ہیں۔