A very generic view (Superficial) and traditional contextual arguments raised in Utopian state.......This is not an ideal world particularly Pakistan is facing through a very multidimensional complex issues and needs an holistic approach however implemented and executed in a compartmentalised manner to keep the parrots and their masters poking their noses directly in our affairs. This time Army is following the right strategy behind the cover of DEMONCRASIES, who unanimously agreed for the formats of surgical operation against the coordinated mafias and dons. Democracy id intact, rule of law is intact, federal and provincial govts intact, while the governor Sind still functional, and media as usual crying over petty issues with 24/7 Breaking News. China-Russia, Afghanistan are brought onto a board, while America silently sidelined. Middle Eastern chaos having least impact on Pakistan as Pakistan remained isolated from the vicious circle of violence and war raged in the middle East. Altaf is scared of Imran Farooq murder case; Zardari by Ayan Ali, Zulfiqar Mirza, and Nawaz by making to defy NRO.......RECONCILIATION.......ETC.
اب جبکہ مقتدرحلقے کرپٹ افراد کے گرد حصار کھینچتے جا رہے ہیں اور وہ تحیہ کرچکے ہیں کہ بڑی مچھلیوں پر بھی ہاتھ ڈالیں گے ہمارے کرپٹ سیاستدانوں کی نیند یں حرام ہوتی جا رہی ہیں اور انہوں نے بدکنا شروع کر دیا ہے ، زرداری کی گیدڑ بھبھکیاں ایک ردِ عمل ہے جس میں وہ بالکل جھنجھلایا ہوا بلؔا نظر آیا اور جس کو اندرون سندھ بندہ بندہ گالیاں دے رہا ہے اور جس کی وجہ سے پیپلز پارٹی اپنا وجود تک کھوتی جا رھی ہے ، نے الطاف کلر کی زبان استعمال کی ۔ اس نے سیاسی حدود پار کر لی ہیں اب جس کو للکارا گیا ہے وہ آذاد ہے کہ اس لٹیرے سے جس طرح چاہے نمٹے ۔ بس تھوڑا ٹائم اور پھر سب کچھ اوور ۔ اس وقت افواج پاکستان مقبولیت میں ان سیاستدانوں اور بیوروکریٹ سے کہیں آگے ہے کم ازکم زرداری جس کو چاہنے والوں میں شیریں رحمن اور ایان علی کے سوا کوئی نہیں حتیٰ کہ اس کی اولاد بھی موقع کی تلاش میں ہے کہ اپنی ماں کے قاتل کو کب اور کہاں لٹکائیں ،کسی کھاتے میں نہیں
A very generic view (Superficial) and traditional contextual arguments raised in Utopian state.......This is not an ideal world particularly Pakistan is facing through a very multidimensional complex issues and needs an holistic approach however implemented and executed in a compartmentalised manner to keep the parrots and their masters poking their noses directly in our affairs. This time Army is following the right strategy behind the cover of DEMONCRASIES, who unanimously agreed for the formats of surgical operation against the coordinated mafias and dons. Democracy id intact, rule of law is intact, federal and provincial govts intact, while the governor Sind still functional, and media as usual crying over petty issues with 24/7 Breaking News. China-Russia, Afghanistan are brought onto a board, while America silently sidelined. Middle Eastern chaos having least impact on Pakistan as Pakistan remained isolated from the vicious circle of violence and war raged in the middle East. Altaf is scared of Imran Farooq murder case; Zardari by Ayan Ali, Zulfiqar Mirza, and Nawaz by making to defy NRO.......RECONCILIATION.......ETC.
Where is the integrity of people who are doing operation?
Apparently everything seems to be intact but integrity is not intact. One can't take direct actions in one province and leave others in the same situation. It's a direct attempt to divide a country and nothing else.
We have lost one part of Pakistan and we are repeating the same mistakes again.
We simply can't afford this non sense.
You have to have a " Moral Authority " to deal with such situations.
For God sake, empowered the Government departments and back them up.
Gen Zia attempted to destroy PPP but they are still here. It's another attempt to revive a dying parties on " Mazloom " ground.
Rather becoming DABANG KHAN, it's time to make institutions and it's not gonna happen since every institution is a MAFIA itself.
اب جبکہ مقتدرحلقے کرپٹ افراد کے گرد حصار کھینچتے جا رہے ہیں اور وہ تحیہ کرچکے ہیں کہ بڑی مچھلیوں پر بھی ہاتھ ڈالیں گے ہمارے کرپٹ سیاستدانوں کی نیند یں حرام ہوتی جا رہی ہیں اور انہوں نے بدکنا شروع کر دیا ہے ، زرداری کی گیدڑ بھبھکیاں ایک ردِ عمل ہے جس میں وہ بالکل جھنجھلایا ہوا بلؔا نظر آیا اور جس کو اندرون سندھ بندہ بندہ گالیاں دے رہا ہے اور جس کی وجہ سے پیپلز پارٹی اپنا وجود تک کھوتی جا رھی ہے ، نے الطاف کلر کی زبان استعمال کی ۔ اس نے سیاسی حدود پار کر لی ہیں اب جس کو للکارا گیا ہے وہ آذاد ہے کہ اس لٹیرے سے جس طرح چاہے نمٹے ۔ بس تھوڑا ٹائم اور پھر سب کچھ اوور ۔ اس وقت افواج پاکستان مقبولیت میں ان سیاستدانوں اور بیوروکریٹ سے کہیں آگے ہے کم ازکم زرداری جس کو چاہنے والوں میں شیریں رحمن اور ایان علی کے سوا کوئی نہیں حتیٰ کہ اس کی اولاد بھی موقع کی تلاش میں ہے کہ اپنی ماں کے قاتل کو کب اور کہاں لٹکائیں ،کسی کھاتے میں نہیں
ایک کرپٹ دوسرے کرپٹ کو کیسے ہاتھ ڈالے گا ؟ ایک مافیا دوسرے مافیا کے ساتھ کیسے لڑے گا ؟
صرف ایک مثال ، جنرل مشرف نے الطاف بھائی کا پارٹی کو کھربوں روپے دے اور بھر پور سپورٹ کی تاکے انے والے وقت میں کوئی فائدہ اٹھاۓ اسیمشرف کی فوجکے نیچے یہ سارا نظام چلتا رہا ابجنرل شریف کی فوجشریفوں کو چھوڑ کر انہیں کے خلاف آپریشن کر رہی ھے مگر جنرل مشرف مزے سے گھر بیٹھے ہیں
یہ کیسا اور کہاں کا انصاف ہے ؟ پاکستان سے پیسا تو کب کا نکل کر دبئی کی ریل اسٹیٹ میں لگ چکا ہے سانپ نکل گیا ، یہ لوگ اب کیوں لکیر پیٹ تھیں ہیں ؟
عدلیہ میں جو ازدہے بٹھے ہیں ، انکے گریبان میں ہاتھ کون ڈالے گا ؟ میڈیا پر جو ازدہے بیٹھے ہیں ، ان پر ہاتھ کون ڈالے گا ؟ سوالات تو لاکھوں ہیں ، بنیادی سوال یہ کے
کیا یہ اپکا کام ہے ؟ نہیں تو کولے کی دلالی میں مونہ کالا کرنے کا کیا فائدہ ؟
جرنل مشرف نے ایک موہائیدہ کے تحت تمام کرپٹ سیاسدانوں کو پاکستان لاے اور اگلے دس سالوں کے لئے ملک انکے حوالے کر دیا یہ جنرل مشرف ہی تھے جنھوں نے الطاف بھائی پارٹی کی سرکاری سرپرستی کی
صرف اس ایک اقدام کی وجہ سے پاکستان ٥٠ سال مزید پیچھے چلا گیا اور ملک معاشی بدحالی کی جانب جنرل مشرف کی فوج نے یہسارے اقدامات صرف ذاتی مقصد کو پورا کرنے کے لئے کیے
اب جنرل راحیل کی فوج انکے پیچھے تو ہاتھ دھو کر پڑی مگر جرنل مشرف کے خلاف کوئی ایک لفظ نہیں بولتا جس نے بیج ڈال کر یہ تناور درخت پیدا کے ، اسکو اپ اپنی پناہ میں رکھ رہیں ہیں اور درخت کو کاٹنے کے چکر میں ہے
Where is the integrity of people who are doing operation?
Apparently everything seems to be intact but integrity is not intact. One can't take direct actions in one province and leave others in the same situation. It's a direct attempt to divide a country and nothing else.
We have lost one part of Pakistan and we are repeating the same mistakes again.
We simply can't afford this non sense.
You have to have a " Moral Authority " to deal with such situations.
For God sake, empowered the Government departments and back them up.
Gen Zia attempted to destroy PPP but they are still here. It's another attempt to revive a dying parties on " Mazloom " ground.
Rather becoming DABANG KHAN, it's time to make institutions and it's not gonna happen since every institution is a MAFIA itself.
Thanks for the arguments which seem rational at one level, however from my point of view
Integrity of the people doing operation is not only intact but enhanced............see the reaction from all sides....including the PM NS.
Integrity in intact as operation is carried out under the auspices of constitutional cover agreed and enforced by all political factors...
Institutional efficacy and strength will be reintroduced once the MOLES appointed at the top are removed....and scrutinised.
Moral authority is given to Rangers by those abusing moral authority............do you still believe MQM/PPP will fix the ISSUES in Karachi.....They are in power since last few decades not years and have become the part of problem than to eradicate criminal activities or killings.......when 90 and sectors incharges are responsible for murders and bhata what to talk about the sanctity of such so-called democrats...
No institution in the state is a position to tackle the issues, parliament has lost its efficacy to make rules/laws; bureaucracy is assumed as personal servants for vested interests, judiciary is fighting for its survival; so u think the Indian army or elite would come and solve the problems in Pakistan. The last institution in the country is sacrificing for the survival of the state........or the New World Order set by US hegemonic ambitions leased since 1980s would have torn apart Pakistan. Pakistan's seemingly apparent military and strategic blunders provided us safety from the globally unified foes and grabbers. Pakistan as a week party managed somehow its safety and survival. Politicians are vulnerable for such attempts as they care for their vested interests abroad.
Thanks for the arguments which seem rational at one level, however from my point of view
Integrity of the people doing operation is not only intact but enhanced............see the reaction from all sides....including the PM NS.
Integrity in intact as operation is carried out under the auspices of constitutional cover agreed and enforced by all political factors...
Institutional efficacy and strength will be reintroduced once the MOLES appointed at the top are removed....and scrutinised.
Moral authority is given to Rangers by those abusing moral authority............do you still believe MQM/PPP will fix the ISSUES in Karachi.....They are in power since last few decades not years and have become the part of problem than to eradicate criminal activities or killings.......when 90 and sectors incharges are responsible for murders and bhata what to talk about the sanctity of such so-called democrats...
No institution in the state is a position to tackle the issues, parliament has lost its efficacy to make rules/laws; bureaucracy is assumed as personal servants for vested interests, judiciary is fighting for its survival; so u think the Indian army or elite would come and solve the problems in Pakistan. The last institution in the country is sacrificing for the survival of the state........or the New World Order set by US hegemonic ambitions leased since 1980s would have torn apart Pakistan. Pakistan's seemingly apparent military and strategic blunders provided us safety from the globally unified foes and grabbers. Pakistan as a week party managed somehow its safety and survival. Politicians are vulnerable for such attempts as they care for their vested interests abroad.
I have raised a simple question in post No 49 Army of General Musharraf has invested heavily on MQM and brought back Nawaz & Zardari who created mess in Pakistan.
Pakistan Army remained silent. You got to understand a typical myth here .
In the name of discipline why would anyone remain silent when there country is at stake?
Now in the name of National Integrity, we are being told to say ,,,,,,Jai Ho Army of Raheel Sharif.
General Musharraf has created a big mess in Pakistan.
MY simple question is ........Why Army of General Raheel Sharif is not taking action against his predecessor who has created all this mess.
Moral authority and integrity of Pak Army will remain in question until they take action against own General who paved way for the proven criminals and become friend of those who are destabilizing Pakistan for so long.
Thieves are thieves, they will do what they are being trained for. What if custodians of a house starts patronizing them ?
If the custodian give them a key , show them the locker and also give them a free hand.
.........and if it becomes a known fact then you got to catch the custodian first and then catch the thieves later.
Here we are trying to catch the thieves and leaving the custodians. Obviously, thieves will cry for foul play.
Living in a society where moral integrity prevails on top of everything then .......
I am wondering, Why is this a rocket science for you ?
Oh,,,,Sorry..........I totally forgot, we were discussing Pakistan here..........My bad.........
I have raised a simple question in post No 49 Army of General Musharraf has invested heavily on MQM and brought back Nawaz & Zardari who created mess in Pakistan.
Pakistan Army remained silent. You got to understand a typical myth here .
In the name of discipline why would anyone remain silent when there country is at stake?
Now in the name of National Integrity, we are being told to say ,,,,,,Jai Ho Army of Raheel Sharif.
General Musharraf has created a big mess in Pakistan.
MY simple question is ........Why Army of General Raheel Sharif is not taking action against his predecessor who has created all this mess.
Moral authority and integrity of Pak Army will remain in question until they take action against own General who paved way for the proven criminals and become friend of those who are destabilizing Pakistan for so long.
Thieves are thieves, they will do what they are being trained for. What if custodians of a house starts patronizing them ?
If the custodian give them a key , show them the locker and also give them a free hand.
.........and if it becomes a known fact then you got to catch the custodian first and then catch the thieves later.
Here we are trying to catch the thieves and leaving the custodians. Obviously, thieves will cry for foul play.
Living in a society where moral integrity prevails on top of everything then .......
I am wondering, Why is this a rocket science for you ?
Oh,,,,Sorry..........I totally forgot, we were discussing Pakistan here..........My bad.........
Par excellence this thread of yours u have given words to how I feel!!!! until the first one is put behind the bar it is all spin doctoring by media to make portfolio for dabang General.
I have raised a simple question in post No 49 Army of General Musharraf has invested heavily on MQM and brought back Nawaz & Zardari who created mess in Pakistan.
Pakistan Army remained silent. You got to understand a typical myth here .
In the name of discipline why would anyone remain silent when there country is at stake?
Now in the name of National Integrity, we are being told to say ,,,,,,Jai Ho Army of Raheel Sharif.
General Musharraf has created a big mess in Pakistan.
MY simple question is ........Why Army of General Raheel Sharif is not taking action against his predecessor who has created all this mess.
Moral authority and integrity of Pak Army will remain in question until they take action against own General who paved way for the proven criminals and become friend of those who are destabilizing Pakistan for so long.
Thieves are thieves, they will do what they are being trained for. What if custodians of a house starts patronizing them ?
If the custodian give them a key , show them the locker and also give them a free hand.
.........and if it becomes a known fact then you got to catch the custodian first and then catch the thieves later.
Here we are trying to catch the thieves and leaving the custodians. Obviously, thieves will cry for foul play.
Living in a society where moral integrity prevails on top of everything then .......
I am wondering, Why is this a rocket science for you ?
Oh,,,,Sorry..........I totally forgot, we were discussing Pakistan here..........My bad.........
Wait and see all your concerns will be answered gradually...step by step.............however may I ask why the holy politicians remained scared of holy cow, as they were not sincere for the rule of law and promoted their vested interests................
They got refuge in SA and abroad, met with their masters. signed NRO's and helped to be the head of the state and govt. When country is waging a war and sper-powers at your door steps, a state like Pakistan loose much options. Survival tops integrity.......and what sort of integrity in the face of thousands killing only in Karachi, and so called HOLY politicians were directly involve in all sort of crimes.................so integrity is to give them save heaven......
Integrity was and is to bring the generals accountable with whom they signed NRO's. Simple issue is the security and integrity of the state, that is at stake provided all criminals groups took positions and just needed signal to act. Now MQM criminals seeking refuge abroad, while Gen Kyani's brothers are also put onto ECL list, included Gen Kyani himself...............let them work while the supposed responsibles are busy in investments abroad. Zardari cried when Gen Raheel is in Moscow for a new strategic alliance keeping US further away..........understand the myth of his cry...Ayan or Uziar.....or Qader Kaka, land grabbed, or BB murder.
Democracy in pakistan is a Joke , our democratic elected govt. can't even make their foreign policies ; heck we don't even have a foreign minister. Elections are the biggest scam in pakistan and the resulting parliament and its member only fill their pockets and some cosmetics to fool the foolish people of pakistan.
What operation are you against btw? The one in the tribal areas or the one in sindh?
Democracy in pakistan is a Joke , our democratic elected govt. can't even make their foreign policies ; heck we don't even have a foreign minister. Elections are the biggest scam in pakistan and the resulting parliament and its member only fill their pockets and some cosmetics to fool the foolish people of pakistan.
What operation are you against btw? The one in the tribal areas or the one in sindh?
We are debating Mr. Zardari speech. He said that I have spent 5 years in jail while Gen Musharraf can't even spend couple of days. Mr. Zardadi has been trialed by our court but no one could convict him.
We have two key words here :- Gen Musharraf and Courts
Key word # 1
You are questioning about Pakistani political system but left alone Holy Cow, role of courts and bureaucracy. you are questioning about Politicians. Tell me who gave birth to PML-N, PML-Q and MQM ?
Forget about the past and lets examine recent event.
Gen Musharraf has nourished PML-Q and MQM and invested heavily through these parties. Pakistanis lost 50,000 in terrorism and thousands in Karachi. Gen Musharraf is directly / Indirectly responsible for loss of economy, law and order ، killings of innocent of Pakistani's
Goodwill of Pakistan Army has been damaged which is still not repaired
It's the loss of Army reputation that now Criminals are directly challenge them.
What is left with us ?
Imagine, no body is discussing on this angle. Eventually, they will.
Indirectly, Mr. Zardari has raised some questions.
It does not matter who is talking, see what he is talking
Key Word # 2
Pakistani Courts '- Suppose , If Pakistani Army catches criminals of Karachi.
Do you think that they have balls to convict them ?
Beside that, What damage Rangers has done to MQM in recent operation ? A complete failure since they could not even shake MQM.
Further, I have raised one question in my post # 2
Sir your desperate attempt to denunciate Pak Army shows your sympathies with MQM..........................which has been recently crushed by Army..................
Sir your desperate attempt to denunciate Pak Army shows your sympathies with MQM..........................which has been recently crushed by Army..................
That's right...........You did't understand me at all.
I have raised some questions. If you have some argument on the content of both the article, please share your thoughts. ایک لائن لکھ کر شہیدوں میں اپنا نام مت لکھوائیں I have wrote an article on MQM operation.
سیاست دن اور ایک سپہ سالار میں بہت فرق ہوتا ہے . اسلامی ریاست میں یہ بھی فرق نہیں کیونکے ہمارے رسول
بھی جنگوں میں شامل رھے ہیں مگر اصول اور ضوابط بنا کر حکومتیں کی ہیں .
لیڈر میں ایک ویژن ہوتا اور وہ کام کرتا ہے جس کے دور رس نتائج نکلیں. انے والی نسلیں اس سے فائدہ اٹھاتی ہیں مگر فوجی صرف آپریشن کرتا ہے اور انے والی نسلیں خمیازہ بھگتی ہیں .
اگر لوگ صرف اس بات کو ہی سمجھ لیں تو ساری بات سمجھ میں ا جے گی .
پاکستان آرمی کے جرنل ضیاالحق نے موہاجر قومی موومنٹ بنائی پھر جنرل مشرف نے توانا کیا اور اب جنرل راحیل طاقت کے زور پر ختم کرنا چاہتے ہیں . کیا اسطرح نیٹو والوں کے کنٹینر برآمد ہو جائیں گے ؟ کیا پتا وہ کنٹینر طالبان لے اڑے ہوں ؟ ہمارے دنیا کے بہترین جاسوس بھی آج تک پتا نہیں چلا سکے کے ٢٨٠٠٠ ناٹو کنٹینر کدھر گئے ؟ مگر وطن کی موہبت کا تقاضا ہے انکو بہترین مانا جاۓ . اس آپریشن میں بدنامی کے ساتھ رینجر کو آخر ملا کیا ؟ چند ہتھیار اور چند لوگ فوج کے آپریشن تو خفیہ ہوتے ہیں مگر ادھر تو پورا پلان ٹیلی ویژن کے اینکرز نے عوام کو بتا دیا . پیسہ نکالنے والے نکال کر لے گئے اب کرنے کو کیا رہ گیا ہے ؟
جنرل راحیل شریف نواز شریف میں کم از کم ایک قدر مشترک ہے کے دونو گونگے ہیں اور عوام کو اعتماد میں نہیں لیتے . کام سب امریکا والوں کے کرتے ہیں اور پھر عوامی خدمات کے بھی دعوے کرتے ہیں
جرنل راحیل شریف نے جتنا مایوس کیا ہے اتنا شائد کسی نے نہیں کیا ہو گا . میرے خیال سے اتنا نالائق جرنل پاکستان کی آرمی نے کبھی نہیں دیا ہو گا . راحیل شریف نے ایک آپریشن شروع کیا ہوا ہے وہ بھی امریکا کا افغانستان والا آپریشن ثابت ہو رہا ہے . ریاست جس کے پاس پہلے ہی وسائل نہیں ہیں اس کا اور بیڑا غرق کیا ہے . امریکا کی جنگ کا ہرجانہ بھی ہم وصول نہیں کر رھے ہیں . کوئی پوچھنے والا نہیں کے بھی صاحب آپریشن کا دی اینڈ کب ہو گا ؟ لاکھوں لوگ کب اپنے گھروں کو لوٹیں گے ؟ کیا سوچ کر یہ آپریشن کیا تھا ؟ کیا نتائج اب تک حاصل کے ہیں ؟
فوج کے سپہ سالار اگر کچھ کرنا چاہتے ہیں توفوج کے سسٹم کو ٹھیک کریں . فوج کو کاروبارسے علیحدہ کریں . صرف یہ دعوے کرنا کا پاکستان کی آرمی دنیا کی بہترین آرمی ہے اور یہ دعوے کرنا کے ہمارے جاسوس دنیا کے بہترین جاسوس ہیں ، ٹھیک نہ ہو گا . کب تک وطن کی موہبت میں یہ مانتے رہیں گے آپکی لوگوں کی میٹنگ کی سکریٹ تک پاکستان کی میڈیا میں پڑھے جا رہیں ہیں کیا خاک آپلوگ پروفیشنل ہیں ؟
یہ ٹارگتٹڈ آپریشنز نہ صرف لسانیت کو بڑھاوا دیں گے بلکے پاکستان کو بھی نقصان دیں گے . کیا ہی اچھا ہوتا اگر حکومت پاکستان ، برطانیہ کی حکومت سے بات کرتی اور اسکے بعد ریاست میں اگر کوئی سسٹم ہوتا تو وہ خود بخود حرکت میں آجاتا . کیا ہی اچھا ہوتا اگر قادری صاحب کو انکے مریدوں کی نیاز دی گئی تھی انکو کیفر کردار تک پونھچایا جاتا کیا ہی اچھا ہوتا پاکستانی میں جو مذہبی جماعتیں ہیں اور مذہب کی بنیاد پر قتل و غارت کرتی ہیں انکا قلا قمع کیا جاتا جرنل راحیل جسطرح سے سیاست دانوں کو ٹیکل کر رہیں ہیں وہ بہت نقصان دہ ھے . پہلے ڈائریکٹ کروائی ہوتی تھی اب بلواسطہ بھائی جی ڈنڈا رکھ کر منوانا کوئی کام نہیں ڈنڈا دینا اصل کام ہے مگر اسکلیے تو واشنگٹن سے اجازت لینی پڑے گی . لوٹ کھسوٹ پر کوئی ایکشن نہیں مگر ....... ..اسطرح وقت تو گزر جاتے گا مگر اسکا تاوان ایک دفع پھر عوام ور اسکی نسلیں بھریں گی کھیلنا ہے توجیسے یہ کھیل دہرایا جاتا رہا ہے ویسے دہرائیں ، بونگیاں نہ ماریں . نہیں کھیلنا تو سسٹم کو آزمانے دیں شائد کوئی لیڈر پاکستان سے نکل اے . جو آپریشن کے سوا سب کچھ کرے
یہ گونگلوں سے مٹی ہٹا کر جنرل راحیل ، جسٹس افتخار چودھری کے راستے پر چل رہیں انجام دیوار پر لکھا ہے