Advertisement

تاریخ کا علم بھی ایک سائنس ہے مگر ہے خطرناک

????? ?? ????? ?? ???? ??? ??? ????? ?? ?? ???? ?????? ???? ??? ??? ??? ???

?? ??? ???? ????? ??? ??? ?? ??? ?? ???? ???? ??? ?? ?? ???? ?? ??? ???? ???? ????? ???? ?? ?? ?? ?? ????? ?? ???? ??? ??????? ??? ??? ?? ?? ?? ???? ??? ??? ?? ??? ??. ?? ???? ?? ????? ??? ??? ????? ??? ??? ?? ??? ???? ???? ???? ??? ?????? ?????? ???? ??????? ?? ?? ?? ?? ?? ???? ???? ?? ???? ??? ?

????? ??????? ?? ????? ?? ????? ?? ???? ???? ?? ???? ???? ?? ??? ?? ?????? ?? ??? ????? ???? ????? ?? ???? ??? ??? ????? ??? ?? ???? ????? ?

​
[video]http://tune.pk/video/4182884/truth-about-islam-beginning[/video]

 
Last edited:
Advertisement
Re: تاریخ کا علم بھی ایک سائنس ہے مگر ہے خطرنا&#1705

@Rustam SHah ... the name of this lair is Jay Smith..... watch his debate with Shabir ALLy

answer to all these question has been given ...
 
Re: تاریخ کا علم بھی ایک سائنس ہے مگر ہے خطرنا&#

@Rustam SHah ... the name of this lair is Jay Smith..... watch his debate with Shabir ALLy

answer to all these question has been given ...

پہلے ویڈیو دیکھ لو پھر کسی جو جھوٹا کہو

ویسے کونسی ڈیبیٹ اور لنک فراہم کر سکتے ہو ؟

​
 
Advertisement
Re: تاریخ کا علم بھی ایک سائنس ہے مگر ہے خطرنا&#1705

We have IMAN = belief= Muslim


Jews money talking now
 
Re: تاریخ کا علم بھی ایک سائنس ہے مگر ہے خطرنا&#1705

Good thing about them is they do loads of research where as we muslim we are lakeer key fakeer. We do not study and no research and this is the bitter truth.
 
Re: تاریخ کا علم بھی ایک سائنس ہے مگر ہے خطرنا&#


پہلے ویڈیو دیکھ لو پھر کسی جو جھوٹا کہو

ویسے کونسی ڈیبیٹ اور لنک فراہم کر سکتے ہو ؟

​
Thanks for sharing the video. I've a few things to say to you.



In my long experience of trying to understand the reality around us, I've discussed a lot of things with a lot of people. I never started with any pre-knowledge, I just had an itch of curiosity for truth and that made me read, watch and discuss many many things.



Going through that journey, I encountered two kinds of people. Either there were people who wanted to find the truth no matter what the consequence, or there were people who would favour practicality, culture, belief or brought-up over truth. This latter trait is not exclusive to Muslims, as I've found many Hindus, Christians and Jews to have such fixed thought process as well.



It took me five to six years to finally figure out that if a person has decided to find the truth, you can't stop him, and he will eventually develop an understanding of the reality about this whole religion thing. But at the same time, if someone wants to keep on marching to their fixed belief all their life (for whatever the reasons: practicality, culture, conformity, family pressure, strong brainwashing) - then they will never come to see the light no matter what evidence you provide to them.



At first I used to think that maybe, with enough persuasion and proof anyone can be made to see the light but after a long time banging my head with such conservative mentality, I learnt that how wrong it is to think this way. Conservatives are not 'in it' for the truth. They are 'in it' for practicality, culture, opposing change, calling out others as Kafirs, Bay-haya, Haram etc. and feel good that way about themselves, and no amount of evidence can convince them otherwise.



Let me give you an example: Someone very very close (just like my brother) in my family is a Consultant Doctor (that is highest level of training and education for a Doctor) in the UK. That person is trained and educated in the UK for 15 years with premium education after high school and has written numerous published papers in Medicine. There is no one else better than him as a candidate to confront with the truth about religion and belief. But whenever I talk to him about these issues, do you know what he says? He just says that he can't accept that men came from monkeys therefore Islam is the truth and scientists are wrong.



This is said by someone whose studied Human Biology for 15 years and practiced it as a Doctor for 10 of those years and still doesn't accept the scientific truth of 'common ancestor' when presented to him with evidence.



So, my friend, no matter what you say, you can't convince these people. And no matter how much you hide the facts, those who seek the truth eventually will in-spite of that.
 
Re: تاریخ کا علم بھی ایک سائنس ہے مگر ہے خطرنا&#

there is A Allah SWAT accepted by every and have one no problem

Adam and Eva accepted by every one and have no problem

when its come to make human life a free born to makes a choice between wrong and correct through our beloved Prophet Muhammadpbuh learning that do not take or give interest on money then all problem started because all westerns societies are going to be distorted by theirs own interest system and other sector is man made law which distorted whole human as you seen at today TVs are killing and only killing and no mercy that our beloved pbuh has full of mercy in his education
and every one get it just used in their practical life to live easily for self and all around them.
 
Advertisement
Re: تاریخ کا علم بھی ایک سائنس ہے مگر ہے خطرنا&#1705

Anyone can share the video which answers this video and claims of mr. Smith
 
Re: تاریخ کا علم بھی ایک سائنس ہے مگر ہے خطرنا&#

So, my friend, no matter what you say, you can't convince these people. And no matter how much you hide the facts, those who seek the truth eventually will in-spite of that.

Some how I came to the same conclusion earlier, like you I was also passionate to think that if you tell some one so obvious like a day light, of course, everybody will accept it, though later I discovered to much of shock that much of humanity is literally "blind". I wanted to know why, and some how I think it has to do with fear we all have in our genes.

You see when we as humans were going throw evolutionary stages, there were only two main problems our ancestors faced, survival and reproduction. These two problems were so massive and huge that hundreds of generations lived facing only these two problems in their whole life. I can imagine our ancestors liking Sun light more then nights as evil where in day time they could see much better and face dangers better so obviously the object of interest much high, very bright, one and only and powerful was our first god, where night brought miseries and danger and it was dark and evil...

These religious teachings create the fear of unknown and like all fear we always wanted to avoid some how this fear of unknown plays with minds and stop opening it, I don't know Muslims specially love Allah because He is God or because He could throw them in Hell ?

Any way, I have a similar story to tell, where a very good friend of mine and really wonderful and bright student, gold medalist and physics and knowledge, but you ask him about few difficult things, the answer was always, oh well we humans will never understand how Allah works and when he said something in Koran then what ever science says is is wrong and null and voided due to Quranic commands. Of course then you do not have much to discuss.
 
Last edited:
Re: تاریخ کا علم بھی ایک سائنس ہے مگر ہے خطرنا&#

We have IMAN = belief= Muslim


Jews money talking now

Meaning you were born "Jahil" and you will remain like one the whole life without learning anything ? Please go on and have such life.
 
Re: تاریخ کا علم بھی ایک سائنس ہے مگر ہے خطرنا&#

Some how I came to the same conclusion earlier, like you I was also passionate to think that if you tell some one so obvious like a day light, of course, everybody will accept it, though later I discovered to much of shock that much of humanity is literally "blind". I wanted to know why, and some how I think it has to do with fear we all have in our genes.

You see when we as humans were going throw evolutionary stages, there were only two main problems our ancestors faced, survival and reproduction. These two problems were so massive and huge that hundreds of generations lived facing only these two problems in their whole life. I can imagine our ancestors liking Sun light more then nights as evil where in day time they could see much better and face dangers better so obviously the object of interest much high, very bright, one and only and powerful was our first god, where night brought miseries and danger and it was dark and evil...

These religious teachings create the fear of unknown and like all fear we always wanted to avoid some how this fear of unknown plays with minds and stop opening it, I don't know Muslims specially love Allah because He is God or because He could throw them in Hell ?

Any way, I have a similar story to tell, where a very good friend of mine and really wonderful and bright student, gold medalist and physics and knowledge, but you ask him about few difficult things, the answer was always, oh well we humans will never understand how Allah works and when he said something in Koran then what ever science says is is wrong and null and voided due to Quranic commands. Of course then you do not have much to discuss.
Your evolutionary explanation of the fear is correct. Given survival at stake, humans tend to think on instinct of fear and worry rather than testing uncharted waters. But there is another thing in addition to that. I've talked to people in the UK and US who are absolutely guaranteed a basic life of (roti, kapra, makan from the state) and who get free education as much as they want and other facilities and yet they gravitate towards ultra conservative rhetoric. In fact there are a few people on this forum who I've confronted for being in this situation. And that leads me to believe that in addition to biological explanation of fear there is another reason too: i.e. the disease of being a conservative.

Just like there is energetic people and lazy people, just like the optimists and pessimists, or empathics and sociopaths, there are free thinkers and conservative people. You can provide a person with every kind of security and resources but if he is a conservative, nothing can change him from being one.
 
Advertisement
Re: تاریخ کا علم بھی ایک سائنس ہے مگر ہے خطرنا&#

Your evolutionary explanation of the fear is correct. Given survival at stake, humans tend to think on instinct of fear and worry rather than testing uncharted waters. But there is another thing in addition to that. I've talked to people in the UK and US who are absolutely guaranteed a basic life of (roti, kapra, makan from the state) and who get free education as much as they want and other facilities and yet they gravitate towards ultra conservative rhetoric. In fact there are a few people on this forum who I've confronted for being in this situation. And that leads me to believe that in addition to biological explanation of fear there is another reason too: i.e. the disease of being a conservative.

Just like there is energetic people and lazy people, just like the optimists and pessimists, or empathics and sociopaths, there are free thinkers and conservative people. You can provide a person with every kind of security and resources but if he is a conservative, nothing can change him from being one.

Exactly ! However, there is one more thing to consider, you and as a matter of fact myself, once were same believers, we changed, we are not special, but something changed in our selves, I don't know about you but I considered myself a good believing person and today when I look back, I found it quite interesting the development over time, don't know how :-)

Also on the subject of this video, I had few responses earlier, and they were typical, we just believe what we believe and its enough, this guy is liar and bla bla bla totally ignoring all the facts mentioned in his presentation. Now one thing is sure, Could majority in Muslim world actually believing a fairy tale which was written much later ? and had nothing to do with reality ?
 
Re: تاریخ کا علم بھی ایک سائنس ہے مگر ہے خطرنا&#

Exactly ! However, there is one more thing to consider, you and as a matter of fact myself, once were same believers, we changed, we are not special, but something changed in our selves, I don't know about you but I considered myself a good believing person and today when I look back, I found it quite interesting the development over time, don't know how :-)

Also on the subject of this video, I had few responses earlier, and they were typical, we just believe what we believe and its enough, this guy is liar and bla bla bla totally ignoring all the facts mentioned in his presentation. Now one thing is sure, Could majority in Muslim world actually believing a fairy tale which was written much later ? and had nothing to do with reality ?
I know about you a little because you told me earlier about your background. I think I told you about my perfect Islamic upbringing as well.

Like I said, there are few people who can be born in utter darkness but can find their way to light no matter what. Nothing can stop that itch that keeps bothering you to find the truth as opposed to religious brainwashing which doesn't satisfy a rational mind at all.

I know you're that type. I really appreciate that in you. I've seen this quality in few other people as well.
 
Re: تاریخ کا علم بھی ایک سائنس ہے مگر ہے خطرنا&#1705

So far listen 8 min

and few points which shows the correctness of knowledge of the speaker

Quran was "Compiled" on request of Abu Bakar RA not Usman RA as the speaker mention
Abu Bakar RA order Zaid Bin Sabit RA to Compile it not Usman RA.

Reference Sahi Bukhari (Book #60, Hadith #201)

and Suna is what Rasool Allah did what he Say is called Hadith not suna. i think speaker mixed the both by calling it "Suna"
 
Re: تاریخ کا علم بھی ایک سائنس ہے مگر ہے خطرنا&#1705

All of the questions have answered if somebody is willing to get answers in details. But for those who need tangible proofs then watch these videos.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k7n6gyzmYDw
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WDEbLPsjEvg

The Qur'an was compiled after the death of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) doesn't mean Qur'an was rewritten. Qur'an was compiled based on the original text written down at the time of prophet Muhammad (PBUH). So the claim that Qur'an was written after the death of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) is wrong.

For sake of argument, if non Muslims not willing to accept the fact that Qur'an was written in the life of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) then at most they could question the accuracy of Qur'an rather than denying it. Because they never know what happened back then.

So, it is Qur'an only that could certify or reject any claim. If Qur'an is the word of just Human then it cannot be perfect. But if Qur'an is perfect, it is the word of God with no question of what time it was compiled.

The critics, at least, accept that Qur'an was written 1200 year ago if not 1400 years ago. Still, how could it be possible for somebody to write a book that contains scientific facts that couldn't be discovered without scientific knowledge and equipment.

The discussion could be dragged more and more but the final answer is always gonna be Qur'an by itself.
 
Advertisement
Re: تاریخ کا علم بھی ایک سائنس ہے مگر ہے خطرنا&#1705

I listened to his whole fact twisting rant from start to end. I have to admit he did get me, especially on the authenticity of Quran. It was pretty disturbing. If some one feels the same way read this article on exactly how Quran was compiled. It will clear everything this guy tried to put behind smoke screens.

http://sunnahonline.com/library/the-majestic-quran/272-holy-quran-its-historical-authenticity-the

Other than that he negated his own comments so many times. He was just twisting words. He is proud the oldest manuscript for Christianity is 200 years before Islam and "according to him' oldest Quran is after 200 years Islam's birth. In his Joshe-Khatabit he forgot to mention 200 years before Islam means oldest manuscript for Christianity is found after almost 400 years of Jesus.
This guy is nothing but putting his on spin on cherry picked history.
He is discrediting the whole notion that Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) was prophet or he ever existed. I mean seriously ? All those thousands of sahaba, All those wars. wives and friends , relatives. whole blood line of prophet , his grand kids. how can one neglect so much proof of not only his existence but most respected human being in history by Muslims, non-Muslims and atheists together. one can reject His message but no one cant dispute His existence and intellgence.
 
Re: تاریخ کا علم بھی ایک سائنس ہے مگر ہے خطرنا&#1705

EK musalman ki hesiat se is video ko post kerne se pehle aap ko khud kisi ilm wale se sawal kerna chahye tha us k baad jawab k sath yeh video post kerni thi ta k logon k concept clear hon na k hum jaise kul ilmon mein yeh video phelani thi ta k log gumrah hon. App ne wohi kia jo yeh aadmi chahta tha.
Mera ilm itna nhi k mein is video ka jawab don lekin itna janta hon k Allah SWT ki mojodgi Quran aur Rasool ki mohtaaj nhi. Woh her waqt her zamane mein apni nishanion k sath mojood rha hey aur logon ne bagher kisi Rasool aur kalaam k usey mana hey. Jab aap Allah SWT ko us ki nishanion se aur aqal se pehchan lete hein tu phir next step us k kalam aur Rasool ka hota hey. Allah SWT ko is lye nhi mante hum k Quran mein aise likha hey, balk Allah ko pehle mante hein us k baad Quran ko us ka kalam aur Muhammad SAW ko us ka aakhri rasool maante hein.
Teesri baat yeh k is ki baat mein tab sunon ga jab yeh bible ko such sabit kre. Ager is ka apna yaqeen jhoot per hey tu is k jhoot k lye mein kion apna aqeeda khrab kron.
Hazrat Ali ka ek yahoodi ko jwab bhi ek yahoodi ya mushrik ko jawab is zimn mein kafi hona chaye k jab us ne poocha Hazrat Ali se k ager qyamat nhi aai tu tumhari is mehnat ka kia ho ga tu unhon ne jo jawab dia us ka matlab tha qayamt nhi aai tu death tu aani hee hey, mein tu kuch ache kaam ker k chala jaon ga lekin ager qyamat aa gai tu tumhara kia ho ga. Its better to believe rather than be a non-believer.
 
Re: تاریخ کا علم بھی ایک سائنس ہے مگر ہے خطرنا&#

I listened to his whole fact twisting rant from start to end. I have to admit he did get me, especially on the authenticity of Quran. It was pretty disturbing. If some one feels the same way read this article on exactly how Quran was compiled. It will clear everything this guy tried to put behind smoke screens.

http://sunnahonline.com/library/the-majestic-quran/272-holy-quran-its-historical-authenticity-the

Other than that he negated his own comments so many times. He was just twisting words. He is proud the oldest manuscript for Christianity is 200 years before Islam and "according to him' oldest Quran is after 200 years Islam's birth. In his Joshe-Khatabit he forgot to mention 200 years before Islam means oldest manuscript for Christianity is found after almost 400 years of Jesus.
This guy is nothing but putting his on spin on cherry picked history.
He is discrediting the whole notion that Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) was prophet or he ever existed. I mean seriously ? All those thousands of sahaba, All those wars. wives and friends , relatives. whole blood line of prophet , his grand kids. how can one neglect so much proof of not only his existence but most respected human being in history by Muslims, non-Muslims and atheists together. one can reject His message but no one cant dispute His existence and intellgence.

If you have listened the whole presentation then you must also know that all the information he presented from the History is what Muslim accepted so far, its fact that Third Khalifa Uthman burnt the copies of Quran after compiling one standard one, why would he burnt the other M Scripts ? Of course there is only one reason is and its if they do not mach with his version !

Its also fact that first history of Prophet was written much much later and saying its some how disturbing then well my dear friend, its a fact, either you like it or not, it won't change the reality.
 
Re: تاریخ کا علم بھی ایک سائنس ہے مگر ہے خطرنا&#

If you have listened the whole presentation then you must also know that all the information he presented from the History is what Muslim accepted so far, its fact that Third Khalifa Uthman burnt the copies of Quran after compiling one standard one, why would he burnt the other M Scripts ? Of course there is only one reason is and its if they do not mach with his version !

Its also fact that first history of Prophet was written much much later and saying its some how disturbing then well my dear friend, its a fact, either you like it or not, it won't change the reality.
Third khalifa burnt the copies after completing one standard one. Now your reasoning is totally speculative as to why he did it. my reasoning is he did it to stop any confusion of the order of the quran and future counterfeits emerging.
I didn't care about Prophet Munahmmad (pbuh) history written much much later because he was again twisting the history . There are more than 2000 ahadith from hazarat ayesha about prophet muhammad ( pbuh). I mean this guy is pounding his chest about bible and jesus history being more legit while conveniently ignoring the fact that prophet muhammad's (pbuh) own wife is one of narrators of HIS biography .
Dude i know you have made up your mind. If you are going to listen and not do cross examination of these claims like you have done about islamic or any other relgions claim then you are not being fair to your own self.
 
Re: تاریخ کا علم بھی ایک سائنس ہے مگر ہے خطرنا&#

Third khalifa burnt the copies after completing one standard one. Now your reasoning is totally speculative as to why he did it. my reasoning is he did it to stop any confusion of the order of the quran and future counterfeits emerging.

There is no reason to burn any copy which does not contradicts the standard one, if you read the history it was the case that there were many different version of Quran in circulation and if you don't like it then my dear friend its your own problem.
I didn't care about Prophet Munahmmad (pbuh) history written much much later because he was again twisting the history . There are more than 2000 ahadith from hazarat ayesha about prophet muhammad ( pbuh). I mean this guy is pounding his chest about bible and jesus history being more legit while conveniently ignoring the fact that prophet muhammad's (pbuh) own wife is one of narrators of HIS biography .
Dude i know you have made up your mind. If you are going to listen and not do cross examination of these claims like you have done about islamic or any other relgions claim then you are not being fair to your own self.

You can believe these fairy tales mentioned in Hadith Books, these stories written 200 plus years later and none of them were eye witnesses, I usually heard a joke about the authenticity of these stories that there is a whole science of chain of narrations, Lol.. really, if some one can fake a long Hadith then he or she can also fake a chain of narration !