Advertisement

Where did the money go? (40 billion USD given to Army for fighting terror...yet Malakand Levies stil

LAST week, a parliamentary resolution moved by the PML-N informed us that the Malakand Levies are still using antiquated Enfield Mark 4 rifles (referred to as Markhor in the vernacular) left behind by the British Raj administration.
Previously, the bullet-proof armoured personnel carriers provided to the Karachi police to fight militants were punctured by low-calibre bullets resulting in many police deaths. In the entire area of Fata, there are no established bomb disposal units and the ones in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa are understaffed and underpaid.


Pakistans security apparatus was incapable of stopping Mullah Fazlullah from fleeing to Afghanistans Kunar province during the Swat operation of 2009; the armed forces were self-avowedly inefficient in tracing Osama bin Laden in Abbottabad; and security forces were unable to target the top militant leadership. It took US drones to take out Pakistani militants Baitullah Mehsud, Ilyas Kashmiri, Nek Muhammad, Waliur Rehman Mehsud, Hakeemullah Mehsud, Al Qaedas Badruddin Haqqani, Yahya al-Libbi, Tahir Yaldashev and Mustafa al-Yazid among others.


Yet an incredible amount of resources have been spent on fighting terrorism. While the debate on whether this is our war ranges from the streets to parliament, the army owns the war and says we are fighting our own battle yet sends receipts for reimbursement to the US government. The US government concurs the reimbursements made through a budgetary heading of CSF (Coalition Support Funds) are declaredly not foreign assistance. As of June 2013, the amount disbursed to Pakistans army is close to $11 billion $10.7bn to be exact. And it was almost entirely for the army navy- and air force-related expenses total some 2pc of the claims.



This figure excludes the declared foreign aid given as military assistance to Pakistan by the US government. This includes project heads such as foreign military financing of over $2bn with which the army purchased the P-3 Orion aircrafts (which were destroyed by militants in the Mehran base attack in 2011), Cobra helicopters and military radio sets, and the expenses accrued to the Pakistan Counter Insurgency Capability Fund.



The year-by-year breakdown of the data, including the spreadsheets of appropriation and disbursements, has been made available by the Centre for Global Development through the Guardian newspapers data journalism project. It can also be cross checked against the publication of the US Congressional Research Service prepared by Susan Epstein and Alan Kronstadt.



The Pakistan Army claims that this war has not been financed entirely by the US, and that the armed forces have accrued heavy expenses. The army purchased the 18 F-16s and 100 anti-ship missiles entirely out of its own money. The CSF reimbursement is apparently only a quarter of what has been spent on the war against terrorism by Pakistans security forces, which signals a cost of $40bn for the fighting supplies and purchases aside.



Last year the defence budget was over $6bn, and $5bn in the year preceding that. Presumably, a significant chunk of the defence budget since 2001 has gone into fighting terrorism.


The war against Islamist militants must be fought and won, but it had to be fought even before 9/11 based on our own domestic imperatives, and the first battlefield should have been within the state itself. It is the state apparatus that has strengthened militants; hence the purging of the latter must first necessarily have been internal.


We know the social and economic costs involved almost 50,000 people have been killed, commerce and the economy have taken an immense hit, a generation has grown up with suicide bombings as a norm; journalists in Peshawar no longer flinch at the sight of scattered limbs.


But the question here is that if over $40bn later, we still cannot find the terrorist masterminds and imprison them, if militants are still able to conduct jailbreaks and free whoever has been captured, if we still dont have equipped and staffed bomb disposal units, if we still have weapons that date from the British era being used in flashpoint regions, where has all the money been spent?


It is the season of financial accountability for foreign assistance. While Geo struggles to explain funding for the Aman ki Asha programme, let us also use this opportunity to figure this one out. Let us also inspect the link between funding and agenda-setting by the Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf government in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. As declared in the official minutes of the joint midyear review of Annual Development Programme 2013-14 chaired by Chief Minister Pervez Khattak on Feb 19, 2014, the provincial government has received Rs35bn in foreign aid this year.


Meanwhile, with the assurance that 500 AK-47s will be given to the Malakand Levies, the parliamentary resolution was withdrawn.


http://www.dawn.com/news/1107806
 
Advertisement
I hope that the writer is aware of the fact that a major portion of the low-balled CSF fund has not been paid yet. And secondly, levies, FC and rangers, who are largely overseeing anti terror ops in the mainland, are civilian organizations and fall under the interior ministry. All funds allocated to them are directed (or not) through the int ministry. There are many stories of corruption. One major story that has already been broken is how KPK police was given substandard ammunition and equipment by the previous govt.....lots more to come.
 
awan4ever said:
But the question here is that if over $40bn later, we still cannot find the terrorist masterminds and imprison them
اعوان صاھب، جے اونہاں نو لبھ کے اندر کر دتا تے فیر ساری کھیڈ ئی مک جانی اے

Correction: "$40bn in aid " is false propanda. The total aid doesn't exceed $20bn during last 12 years (data given below in the end). The US aid given to military was misused to cover civilian deficits
:lol::lol:

Here are the correct statistics, please.


U.S. financial aid to Pakistan since the September 11, 2001 attacks[edit]

Between 2002-2010, US Congress approved $18 billion[SUP][7][/SUP] in military and economic aid from the United States. However the Pakistan Treasury only received $8.647 billion in direct financial payments.
Western officials have claimed nearly 70% (roughly $3.4 billion) of Military aid given to the military has been misspent in 2002-2007 and used to cover civilian deficit. However U.S-Pakistani relationship has been a transactional based and U.S military aid to Pakistan and aid conditions has been shrouded in secrecy for several years until recently .[SUP][8][/SUP][SUP][9][/SUP][SUP][9][/SUP][SUP][10][/SUP] Furthermore a significant proportion of U.S. economic aid for Pakistan has ended up in back in the U.S., as funds are channeled through large U.S. contractors. A U.S. lawmaker also said majority of U.S. economic aid has not left the U.S. as it spent on consulting fees and overhead cost.[SUP][11][/SUP][SUP][12][/SUP] Pakistan also states it has spent $80 billion on the War on Terror since 2001.[SUP][1][/SUP]


Military and economic aid[edit]


20021.361.233 for 2002 to 2004
20031.5001.233 for 2002 to 2004
20041.2001.233 for 2002 to 2004
20051.313.338
20061.260.539
20071.115.567
20081.435.507
20091.6891.366
20101.2321.409
20111.685unknown
Total11.740 billion[SUP][15][/SUP]6.08 billion[SUP][16][/SUP]

[TH="class: headerSort, bgcolor: #F2F2F2, align: center"]Year[/TH]
[TH="class: headerSort, bgcolor: #F2F2F2, align: center"]Military (USD in billions)[/TH]
[TH="class: headerSort, bgcolor: #F2F2F2, align: center"]Economic (USD in billions)[/TH]


P.S: Whether government received any aid or not, this is still unclear why government didn't armed the paramilitary forces with state-of-art weaponry and trained them at the best available facilities? Perhaps they want to get further few millions to cover up next budget deficits???
 
Last edited:
Advertisement
Thing you don't know does not mean do not exists
Stop talking against those who are protecting the lives and honor of your families
only those can raise the finger whose family honor could not be protected by these Army of ALLAH
the 40 billion or 400 billion whatever the money was it was used to save the soul of this country
one among those expenditures are your nuclear arsenals even enemies and world is acknowledging their safety and this could not be disclosed how they are protected but huge money was spent on that
 
Army funding audit is never made public. It should be made public so that everyone should know the haramkhori of some Generals which defame the whole Army. Their lifestyle isnt much less than an Arab prince.
 
Awan sahib what do you expect, its any body’s guess where the tranches of CSF have been spent since the so called War on Terror has been started after Sept 2001. No civilian government till this day has conjured up the courage even to do the physical audits of such accounts, records, invoices and expenditure of funds which are directed to the Armed forces from the central treasury and through the coffers of Pentagon and US Administration.

Aam banday kul rozgar naye hega, taleem naye, health service naye, social security naye aur transport di facility naye hegi par Army, Politicians, Bureaucrats tay high profile judges / lawyers nu aye aye naye pata kay o apnay paisay kithay aur kinj invest / kharch karan.
 
Advertisement
Only Army in the world that fight a full blown War with its local population.
 
اعوان صاھب، جے اونہاں نو لبھ کے اندر کر دتا تے فیر ساری کھیڈ ئی مک جانی اے

Correction: "$40bn in aid " is false propanda. The total aid doesn't exceed $15bn. The US aid given to military was misused to cover civilian deficits
:lol::lol:

Here are the correct statistics, please.





Military and economic aid[edit]


20021.361.233 for 2002 to 2004
20031.5001.233 for 2002 to 2004
20041.2001.233 for 2002 to 2004
20051.313.338
20061.260.539
20071.115.567
20081.435.507
20091.6891.366
20101.2321.409
20111.685unknown
Total11.740 billion[SUP][15][/SUP]6.08 billion[SUP][16][/SUP]

[TH="class: headerSort, bgcolor: #F2F2F2, align: center"]Year[/TH]
[TH="class: headerSort, bgcolor: #F2F2F2, align: center"]Military (USD in billions)[/TH]
[TH="class: headerSort, bgcolor: #F2F2F2, align: center"]Economic (USD in billions)[/TH]


P.S: Whether government received any aid or not, this is still unclear why government didn't armed the paramilitary forces with state-of-art weaponry and trained them at the best available facilities? Perhaps they want to get further few millions to cover up next budget deficits???

This figure is more accurate.

Here is an interesting article:

[h=1]Pakistan received $68 billion in US assistance during 66 years
[/h]
October 23, 2013 - Updated 1011 PKT
From Web Edition



378 93 35 6

featured-USaidtoPakistan_10-23-2013_123489_l.jpg




KARACHI: Pakistan and the US have had a volatile relationship during the last sixty-six years, which saw the flow of US assistance periodically interrupted, yet US during the last 64 years (1948-2012) provided $68 billion in aid and assistance to Pakistan, which included $42 billion in economic aid, while the remaining $26 billion in military assistance.

Pakistan for the fist time in 1948 received a sum of $0.77 million in economic aid in tandem with the request to allow using Pakistan airbase for conducting intelligence in the Soviet Union, but the then prime minister Shaheed Liaquat Ali Khan refused to oblige them and, thereby, the US remained annoyed for some time.

Following the martyrdom of Liaquat Ali Khan in 1951, the US aid was resumed and by 1964 it increased to such an extent that Pakistan received as much as about $2.5 billion in economic and military aid.

This was an era of the military dictator General Ayub Khan, when Pakistan had given military airbase to the US for surveillance of the Soviet Union, but after 1965 war with India, the US assistance started dwindling and until 1971 i.e. at the time of fall of Dhaka it was reduced to such an extent that it amounted to $470 million only.

Later, US on the pretext of Pakistans nuclear programme had imposed a ban and by enacting a law in 1979 the door for the US aid to Pakistan was almost shutdown. But in December 1979 the situation once again took a turn in favour of Pakistan, when the Soviet Union had invaded Afghanistan and US badly needed Pakistans strategic support.

In this backdrop, US economic and military assistance to Pakistan again started in 1982 and during 1983-88 US aid to Pakistan surged to $1 billion annually. But with this increased flow of dollars, heroin and Kalashnikov cultures also took the roots in Pakistan.

Following Soviet Unions withdrawal from Afghanistan, US also lost interest in the region and once again an economic embargo was imposed on Pakistan under Pressler Amendment in 1990.

US started war against terror after 9/11 horrific incidents that again reminded US of Pakistan, the embargo was lifted and the flow of economic and military assistance continued uninterrupted, which saw Pakistan receiving over $25 billion during 2002-2012 constituting of $17 billion in military aid and $8 billion in economic assistance.

In spite of this, if the total loss of Pakistan in war on terror is estimated, then Pakistan as an US ally ended up losing a whopping amount of $100 billion i.e. Pakistan lost much more than what it got during the last 66 years.
 
Awan sahib what do you expect, its any body’s guess where the tranches of CSF have been spent since the so called War on Terror has been started after Sept 2001. No civilian government till this day has conjured up the courage even to do the physical audits of such accounts, records, invoices and expenditure of funds which are directed to the Armed forces from the central treasury and through the coffers of Pentagon and US Administration.

Your observation is correct but I am not sure the conclusion is.. Civilians did not have the courage .. why???? Because they are corrupt people and have big skeletons in their closets. Their main goal is to plunder people's money and not to govern. When you get a government that is for the people and really sincere with people, same Generals will be forced to be accountable to them. This is how it happened in turkey and else where, Corrupt stooges like Nawaz and Zardari can never raise their voices in front of Army, They can only conspire against the army with media and foreign powers because they got into power to accomplish only one task and that is to demoralize and cut to size the army so that when these powers invade pakistan then the damage to their forces is bearable for them..
 
Advertisement
Only Army in the world that fight a full blown War with its local population.

It has happened in lot of places in the world. South and Central America has a long list of insurgencies when the governments have been at war with indigenous groups. There are countries in East Asia and Africa that have seen conflicts where the government was targeting its own population.

Not that I am endorsing it rather stating the facts.
 
I hope that the writer is aware of the fact that a major portion of the low-balled CSF fund has not been paid yet. And secondly, levies, FC and rangers, who are largely overseeing anti terror ops in the mainland, are civilian organizations and fall under the interior ministry. All funds allocated to them are directed (or not) through the int ministry. There are many stories of corruption. One major story that has already been broken is how KPK police was given substandard ammunition and equipment by the previous govt.....lots more to come.

ڈان کی،خبر،آرٹیکلز،تصویر وغیرہ کی تحقیق کرلیا کریں، یہ جنگ /جیو سے بھی آگے ہے
 
Where did the money go?

Where did the money go?

Nazish Brohi


LAST week, a parliamentary resolution moved by the PML-N informed us that the Malakand Levies are still using antiquated Enfield Mark 4 rifles (referred to as Markhor in the vernacular) left behind by the British Raj administration.

Previously, the bullet-proof armoured personnel carriers provided to the Karachi police to fight militants were punctured by low-calibre bullets resulting in many police deaths. In the entire area of Fata, there are no established bomb disposal units and the ones in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa are understaffed and underpaid.

Pakistan’s security apparatus was incapable of stopping Mullah Fazlullah from fleeing to Afghanistan’s Kunar province during the Swat operation of 2009; the armed forces were self-avowedly ‘inefficient’ in tracing Osama bin Laden in Abbottabad; and security forces were unable to target the top militant leadership. It took US drones to take out Pakistani militants Baitullah Mehsud, Ilyas Kashmiri, Nek Muhammad, Waliur Rehman Mehsud, Hakeemullah Mehsud, Al Qaeda’s Badruddin Haqqani, Yahya al-Libbi, Tahir Yaldashev and Mustafa al-Yazid among others.

Yet an incredible amount of resources have been spent on fighting terrorism. While the debate on whether this is our war ranges from the streets to parliament, the army owns the war and says we are fighting our own battle — yet sends receipts for reimbursement to the US government. The US government concurs — the reimbursements made through a budgetary heading of CSF (Coalition Support Funds) are declaredly not foreign assistance. As of June 2013, the amount disbursed to Pakistan’s army is close to $11 billion — $10.7bn to be exact. And it was almost entirely for the army — navy- and air force-related expenses total some 2pc of the claims.

Some answers are needed about the handling of foreign aid.


This figure excludes the declared foreign aid given as military assistance to Pakistan by the US government. This includes project heads such as foreign military financing of over $2bn with which the army purchased the P-3 Orion aircrafts (which were destroyed by militants in the Mehran base attack in 2011), Cobra helicopters and military radio sets, and the expenses accrued to the Pakistan Counter Insurgency Capability Fund.

The year-by-year breakdown of the data, including the spreadsheets of appropriation and disbursements, has been made available by the Centre for Global Development through the Guardian newspaper’s data journalism project. It can also be cross checked against the publication of the US Congressional Research Service prepared by Susan Epstein and Alan Kronstadt.
The Pakistan Army claims that this war has not been financed entirely by the US, and that the armed forces have accrued heavy expenses. The army purchased the 18 F-16s and 100 anti-ship missiles entirely out of its own money. The CSF reimbursement is apparently only a quarter of what has been spent on the war against terrorism by Pakistan’s security forces, which signals a cost of $40bn for the fighting — supplies and purchases aside.

Last year the defence budget was over $6bn, and $5bn in the year preceding that. Presumably, a significant chunk of the defence budget since 2001 has gone into fighting terrorism.

The war against Islamist militants must be fought and won, but it had to be fought even before 9/11 based on our own domestic imperatives, and the first battlefield should have been within the state itself. It is the state apparatus that has strengthened militants; hence the purging of the latter must first necessarily have been internal.

We know the social and economic costs involved — almost 50,000 people have been killed, commerce and the economy have taken an immense hit, a generation has grown up with suicide bombings as a norm; journalists in Peshawar no longer flinch at the sight of scattered limbs.

But the question here is that if over $40bn later, we still cannot find the terrorist masterminds and imprison them, if militants are still able to conduct jailbreaks and free whoever has been captured, if we still don’t have equipped and staffed bomb disposal units, if we still have weapons that date from the British era being used in flashpoint regions, where has all the money been spent?


[email protected]
Published in Dawn, May 22nd, 2014
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Advertisement
Re: Where did the money go?

This was already posted here today and the amount mentioned in either a huge blunder on the writer's side or it is yet another propaganda...
 
Re: Where did the money go?

Don't question the holy cows! Its pretty clear there is an ethnic cleansing going on of pashthoons. Not to worry though, they'll become the freedom fighters soon, if modi lives up to his reputation.
 
Re: Where did the money go?

۔ پچھلے چودہ سال کی صورت حال ہماری اگلی نسلوں کیلیے عبرت کا پیغام ہے کہ آرمی اور سی-آئ-اے کے ٹاؤٹوں کا بلآخر کیسا بھیانک انجام ہوتا ہے. گندم کے ساتھ گیہوں کا سنا تھا، مگر اس خدائی عذاب میں تو ٹاؤٹوں کے ساتھ سارا معصوم معاشرہ برباد ہوا ہے. برزنسکی کا لنڈی کوتل میں لگایا گیا نعرہ تکبیر اور نعرہ جہاد آج بھی یو-ٹیوب پر موجود ہے
 
Re: Where did the money go?


The war against Islamist militants must be fought and won, but it had to be fought even before 9/11 based on our own domestic imperatives, and the first battlefield should have been within the state itself. It is the state apparatus that has strengthened militants; hence the purging of the latter must first necessarily have been internal.

۔راقم شاید کل پیدا ہوا ہے وگرنہ سب کو پتہ ہے کہ آرمی سے زیادہ ان کے ٹاؤٹوں کو دنیا فتح کرنے کی' چُل 'پڑی ہوئی تھی. جو بھی سمجھاتا تھا وہ انہی [FONT=Jameel Noori Nastaleeq][COLOR=#000000][FONT=Jameel Noori Nastaleeq][FONT=jameel noori nastaleeq][SIZE=5][COLOR=#000000][FONT=Jameel Noori Nastaleeq][COLOR=#000000][FONT=Jameel Noori Nastaleeq][FONT=jameel noori nastaleeq] ٹاؤٹوں کے ہاتھوں منکر جہاد، مرتد ،کافر اور غدار قرار پاتا تھا. آج نشانے پر ہیں تو ہزار شکوے ہیں، کل کو پھر سب 'ہنکی- ڈوری' ہو گا. زمانہ 'وہ 'نہیں رہا تو' یہ' بھی نہیں رہے گا. وقت 'وہ 'گزر گیا تو' یہ' بھی گزر ہی جائیگا. اسلیے ٹینشن ناٹ [/FONT][/FONT][/FONT][/COLOR] [/FONT][/FONT][/COLOR][/FONT][/COLOR][/SIZE]
 
Re: Where did the money go?

۔راقم شاید کل پیدا ہوا ہے وگرنہ سب کو پتہ ہے کہ آرمی سے زیادہ ان کے ٹاؤٹوں کو دنیا فتح کرنے کی' چُل 'پڑی ہوئی تھی. جو بھی سمجھاتا تھا وہ انہی [COLOR=#000000][FONT=Jameel Noori Nastaleeq][COLOR=#000000][FONT=Jameel Noori Nastaleeq][FONT=jameel noori nastaleeq][SIZE=5][COLOR=#000000][FONT=Jameel Noori Nastaleeq][COLOR=#000000][FONT=Jameel Noori Nastaleeq][FONT=jameel noori nastaleeq] ٹاؤٹوں کے ہاتھوں [/FONT][/FONT][/COLOR][/FONT][/COLOR][/FONT][/FONT][/COLOR][/FONT][/COLOR][/SIZE] منکر جہاد، مرتد ،کافر اور غدار قرار پاتا تھا. آج نشانے پر ہیں تو ہزار شکوے ہیں، کل کو پھر سب 'ہنکی- ڈوری' ہو گا. زمانہ 'وہ 'نہیں رہا تو' یہ' بھی نہیں رہے گا. وقت 'وہ 'گزر گیا تو' یہ' بھی گزر ہی جائیگا. اسلیے ٹینشن ناٹ

زمانہ بدل چکا ہے، ٹاوٹ اور چُل بھی. جو سمجھائے وہ خارجی، دہشت گرد اور طالبان قرار دیا جاتا ہے. دنیا فتح کی چُل پاکستان فتح کرنے تک محدود ہو چکی ہے. ٹینش تو ہو گی ہماری جنگ کے سپاہی آپس ہی میں دست و گریبان نظر آ رہے ہیں
​