The only difference being that TTP don't hide behind the facade of a political party with a "mandate". TTP makes no qualms about their extra-constitutional modus operandi whereas MQM work in the same manner while trumpeting themselves as the champions of democracy and the constitution.
MQM gets air time on TV; they sit in legislative circles and promulgate laws; they have easy and open access to state machinery (police, infrastructure etc).
I agree. You are right, Taliban are not suffering from a personality disorder. They don't pretend to be the peace doves and make sure that we don't expect any warm fuzzies from their side. MQM on the other hand has a bad case of MPD, I guess its reflective of their leader's personality.
I am actually in the middle of mapping all of Karachi with MQM's sectors and different units under each sector. In the little work I have done so far I am SHOCKED to report that they have cast a very comprehensive web around the entire city! There are more units in any sector than police stations! Cleaning up Karachi will be a Herculean task, but the network of MQM in Karachi is DITTO mafia style.
I can now see how they are able to freeze the entire city on very short notice. To break this iron grip that they have, the Pakistani state needs:
1- The political will to counter them and disband all their units.
2- A very short (3-day max) and precise operation using police and state intelligence units.
3- My initial findings suggest that this will require at least 5,000 highly trained counter-terrorism policemen.
4- A very comprehensive program for the rehabilitation of unit workers who can't be kept in jail forever as it will have a negative political fall out.
5- Have at least 2 choppers available for each zone (there are 4 in Karachi + 6 cantonments*) for rapid action that will back up this force.
There is more, but to make all this effective police reforms is also very important for various reasons such as:
a- The current police structure actually has many loopholes. For example, local SHOs can easily tip off units in their circle who can escape. This has been happening all this while.
b- The police who carry out the above-mentioned clean up operation MUST consist of Urdu-speakers EXCLUSIVELY.
c- This special task force needs to be trained to deal with treating people under their custody humanely.
*There is not a SINGLE MQM Unit in any of the 6 cantonments in Karachi (Malir Cantt, Clifton Cantt, Korangi Creek Cantt, Faisal Cantt, Karachi Cantt, Manora Cantt). So you can see how the MQM operates. they are basically a shadow 'police'.
Thats great. You have provided a comprehensive and detailed tactical plan as only you could do :)
But I believe what we need is a strategic plan with a clear understanding of what are the goals and expectations.
If the true will is there then I strongly believe the menace of MQM could be easily handled if Altaf Hussain is neutralized. Once you take the head of the organization away (I think he is the biggest reason that MQM could never transform itself from the politics of violence and intimidation - he is pegging them back in the last century). Once you take him out of the equation then the rest will run around like chickens with their heads cut off. This is just the way things are with us. All these people who AH mentioned in his speech (who have used him as money making machine) are shallow, self serving people and will either fly overseas or will try to join other organization to provide them cover.
With these artificial and state created or sponsored organizations don't last long if you cut their funding and change the music sheet that they are supposed to sing from. They are standing not on their two feet rather need crutches of all sort to maintain their power and hegemony. You just kick those crutches away for a little bit and they will come crumbling down - faster than you think. No need for a big operation of loss of life.
Contrary to what some may say MQM did have a very large support base. They did hold huge public gathering in mid to late 80's but then started to drift away or rather stick to their real agenda.
The problem is that we have allowed AH to escape to a far away land where his paymasters have provided a safe haven to create mayhem at will in urband Sindh and then we wonder why can't we control the menace of MQM. The answer is simple - if you want peace in Karachi then you have to get AH out of the equation (I don't mean physically since we can't bear another shaheed).
I agree that if Altaf Hussain is neutralized, MQM will crumble within days and it will be fairly manageable to harness the splinter groups arising due to power vacuum.
Unfortunately, I don't see that happening as both civilian and military establishment lack the will to control this monster. The current rigging of elections in Karachi by MQM was done under the watchful eyes of military. When the city burns, rangers look the other way. Police is too impotent to do anything.
Actually the elite of Pakistani administration both with or without uniform share the same masters with Altaf Hussain. So hope for a chemotherapy for the cancer which infests the whole society and it will not come through ballot.
I agree. You are right, Taliban are not suffering from a personality disorder. They don't pretend to be the peace doves and make sure that we don't expect any warm fuzzies from their side. MQM on the other hand has a bad case of MPD, I guess its reflective of their leader's personality.
Thats great. You have provided a comprehensive and detailed tactical plan as only you could do :)
But I believe what we need is a strategic plan with a clear understanding of what are the goals and expectations.
If the true will is there then I strongly believe the menace of MQM could be easily handled if Altaf Hussain is neutralized. Once you take the head of the organization away (I think he is the biggest reason that MQM could never transform itself from the politics of violence and intimidation - he is pegging them back in the last century). Once you take him out of the equation then the rest will run around like chickens with their heads cut off. This is just the way things are with us. All these people who AH mentioned in his speech (who have used him as money making machine) are shallow, self serving people and will either fly overseas or will try to join other organization to provide them cover.
With these artificial and state created or sponsored organizations don't last long if you cut their funding and change the music sheet that they are supposed to sing from. They are standing not on their two feet rather need crutches of all sort to maintain their power and hegemony. You just kick those crutches away for a little bit and they will come crumbling down - faster than you think. No need for a big operation of loss of life.
Contrary to what some may say MQM did have a very large support base. They did hold huge public gathering in mid to late 80's but then started to drift away or rather stick to their real agenda.
The problem is that we have allowed AH to escape to a far away land where his paymasters have provided a safe haven to create mayhem at will in urband Sindh and then we wonder why can't we control the menace of MQM. The answer is simple - if you want peace in Karachi then you have to get AH out of the equation (I don't mean physically since we can't bear another shaheed).
There are two possible ways MQM may go in the future.
1- Back off from confrontation policy and take a back seat and a more chill approach to win back their support.
2- Or go hell for leather, in that case bloodbath in Karachi.
But either way, I don't think they would succeed. I do talk to lots of people in Karachi.
MQM game is up, even among people who were with them.
There are two possible ways MQM may go in the future.
1- Back off from confrontation policy and take a back seat and a more chill approach to win back their support.
2- Or go hell for leather, in that case bloodbath in Karachi.
But either way, I don't think they would succeed. I do talk to lots of people in Karachi. MQM game is up, even among people who were with them.
Such as ? Humans have two legs ? Sea seems Blue as does the sky. Night follows day, There is a God That sort of truth
Or that Altaf can perform Miracles and his name is written on the moon and he has never ever ever harmed anything anyone or willed evil and ill on anyone ?
Come on vagueness and bull sh it are the weapon of MQM say what you really mean
Bhai, in gunahgar ankhoon ne kod dekha log Altaf Pir ke hath choomte the, aur un ko Pir Sahab kahtte the.
Un ki tasveer patton me nazar anne ke claim walle calendar bhe deekhe appni ankhon se.(bigsmile)
There are two possible ways MQM may go in the future.
1- Back off from confrontation policy and take a back seat and a more chill approach to win back their support.
2- Or go hell for leather, in that case bloodbath in Karachi.
But either way, I don't think they would succeed. I do talk to lots of people in Karachi.
MQM game is up, even among people who were with them.
Jis 'janwar' kay moonh ko 'INSAANI KHOON' lag jaye woh 'kabhee sudhar nahin sakta'...*p*a*g*l* **k*u*tt*y* ka duniya mein koi ilaaj naih siway 'GOLee' kay.
True, but like I said, it could only back fired on them.
Everyone have to understand one thing, which MQM has understood that's why they are panicking.
Lots of people voted for PTI and they witnessed MQM mega rigging.
Now every steps MQM takes they could only infuriate those people, because they know what MQM did with their votes.
Going against PTI would erode their support further, trying to fool the people would erode their support as well. They have passed the point of return.
Why do you think Altaf has dissolved the "Intezami Committee" and not the "Rabita Committee"? Because he knows the iron grip has slipped.
Indeed, it has been a long time! I apologize that I can't divulge much over here about my findings, but I can tell you that MQM has 26 Sector offices across all the zones with around 225 Unit offices (and more springing up every day!) and the total number of people involved - directly and indirectly - is close to 10,000 personnel.
It is through these 10,000 people that this iron-grip is maintained and MQM implements its "writ" in Karachi. My analysis over here was simply to understand the tanzeem as it is now. Otherwise, the complete plan is not just to tackle them on the ground, but also take care of Altaf Hussain and the UK Secretariat. Neutralizing Altaf Hussain without tackling this web is actually very dangerous and will unleash massive chaos (as you might imagine).
Altaf can be neutralized in non-violent ways, but it requires political will. For example, how hard is it to pass legislation in the NA in the form of a constitutional amendment that: (a) a dual national cannot be leader of a political party; (b) if a political leader stays outside of the country for a protracted period (say 6+ years) then he will automatically be disqualified from taking part in politics; (c) foreign and local assets will be frozen if the political party doesn't comply.
With the numbers that PML-N has today in the assembly, I hope this happens. The above non-violent way of removing Altaf (and other idiots) from the scene will also ensure that the very many units in Karachi don't go bonkers which will result in an all-out gang war.
You might be interested to know that MQM units have enmities between themselves and you often see them at each other's throats (due to conflicting interests). So much so, that every Unit office that I have researched up till now (I have done at least 65 of them) there is a LIST of "shuhada" in every office!! haha :P
I agree. You are right, Taliban are not suffering from a personality disorder. They don't pretend to be the peace doves and make sure that we don't expect any warm fuzzies from their side. MQM on the other hand has a bad case of MPD, I guess its reflective of their leader's personality.
Thats great. You have provided a comprehensive and detailed tactical plan as only you could do :)
But I believe what we need is a strategic plan with a clear understanding of what are the goals and expectations.
If the true will is there then I strongly believe the menace of MQM could be easily handled if Altaf Hussain is neutralized. Once you take the head of the organization away (I think he is the biggest reason that MQM could never transform itself from the politics of violence and intimidation - he is pegging them back in the last century). Once you take him out of the equation then the rest will run around like chickens with their heads cut off. This is just the way things are with us. All these people who AH mentioned in his speech (who have used him as money making machine) are shallow, self serving people and will either fly overseas or will try to join other organization to provide them cover.
With these artificial and state created or sponsored organizations don't last long if you cut their funding and change the music sheet that they are supposed to sing from. They are standing not on their two feet rather need crutches of all sort to maintain their power and hegemony. You just kick those crutches away for a little bit and they will come crumbling down - faster than you think. No need for a big operation of loss of life.
Contrary to what some may say MQM did have a very large support base. They did hold huge public gathering in mid to late 80's but then started to drift away or rather stick to their real agenda.
The problem is that we have allowed AH to escape to a far away land where his paymasters have provided a safe haven to create mayhem at will in urband Sindh and then we wonder why can't we control the menace of MQM. The answer is simple - if you want peace in Karachi then you have to get AH out of the equation (I don't mean physically since we can't bear another shaheed).
Bhai, in gunahgar ankhoon ne kod dekha log Altaf Pir ke hath choomte the, aur un ko Pir Sahab kahtte the.
Un ki tasveer patton me nazar anne ke claim walle calendar bhe deekhe appni ankhon se.(bigsmile)
next people will see him walk across the Thames
and fly into Heathrow terminals 1 and 5 Gatwick
and Karachi airports at the same time unaided wingless and without fuel......
MQM is killer pary and altaf is psychopath. no leader with right mind behaves like he does. guy is a mess, he barks like a dog then he cries, the he screams, gives galian etc etc people who vote him are mental as well. TTP no way can compare the that killer party. TTP is fighting US forces and only reason they attack pak is coz of our stupid and corrupt leaders. who do everything wrong, people who say mqm and ttp are same are dead wrong. ur nr enemy is mqm and if given chance MQM will seprate karahi from pak, altaf always says that and takes back but its something he really believes in. altaf sees karachi as his and thats why he is barking since PTI got so many votes. karachi us ko apni baap ki jageer lagta hai. people of pak should awake up and see the ligth b4 its too late
next people will see him walk across the Thames
and fly into Heathrow terminals 1 and 5 Gatwick
and Karachi airports at the same time unaided wingless and without fuel......
In those days "Bhai" were adopting another habit he was ordering young girls to do a bit of entertainment for him. I know few families who left the Pir after watching those events.
Oh yeah, Pir Sahib were always under the influence of drink of the "Paradise".(bigsmile)
MQM is a regional terrorist organization according to world's leading agencies including Amnesty International, UNO, Human Rights Watch and US State Department::
It Takes a Terrorist to Kill a Terrorist, That's what it boils down to in Karachi...Our Intelligence agencies are a failure....our leadership is just protecting its own turf...Army is too busy to hunt down extremists...We as common Pakistanis are left fending for ourselves...so let Taliban take care of these MQM terrorists....