Advertisement

Was Gandhi gay? Letters found between Indian leader and bodybuilding friend

Was Gandhi gay? Letters between Indian leader and bodybuilding friend fuel speculation about true nature of relationship


  • Letters displayed in India's national archives reveal 'loving relationship'
  • National archives deny screening letters to reduce controversy
  • Gandhi signed off letters to bodybuilder with 'Sinly yours, Upper House'
  • Exhibition marks 65th anniversary of Gandhi's death

By Mail Foreign Service
PUBLISHED: 17:04, 30 January 2013 | UPDATED: 22:09, 30 January 2013

His enduring image is as the father of India, the loincloth-clad hero of his country’s struggle for independence.
But newly revealed letters have added to the speculation about a secret side to Mahatma Gandhi.
They detail his close friendship with a South African bodybuilder, Hermann Kallenbach, with some suggesting the pair may have had a physical relationship.

article-2172967-140B6D95000005DC-731_634x850.jpg

Lovers? Mahatma Gandhi (left) and Hermann Kallenbach (right) sit either side of a female companion.

A collection of letters between the two men have gone on display at India's National Archives

The letters, written by Gandhi, went on show in New Delhi yesterday, the 65th anniversary of his assassination.
One, handwritten to Kallenbach, is addressed to ‘My dear Lower House’ and signed ‘Sinly yours, Upper House’.
However scholars looking for clear evidence of the full extent of the men’s relationship, the subject of speculation for years, were left disappointed.
The archive of letters and photos belonging to Kallenbach was purchased by the Indian government last year, just before it was due to be auctioned by Sotheby’s in London. Curators acknowledge that they have put only a sample of the correspondence on display at the National Archives museum.

Mushirul Hasan, chief of the National Archives, denied that the collection had been screened and controversial letters left out because of Gandhi’s iconic status. ‘These are original letters and we have provided a sample of the correspondence between Gandhi and Kallenbach. There is a lot that is new and significant,’ he said.
‘Nothing controversial has been left out or necessarily included.

article-2172967-14003746000005DC-379_634x502.jpg

The documents previously belonged to relatives of Kallenbach, a German-born Jewish architect who met Gandhi in South Africa in 1904 and was impressed by his ideas.

article-2172967-140037FA000005DC-308_634x393.jpg

Gandhi and Kallenbach (middle row, centre) pose for a picture at Tolstoy Farm, South Africa in 1910. They became constant companions after they met in Johannesburg in 1904


‘They had a marvellous relationship and the archives reveal the intensity of that relationship.’

Gandhi moved to South Africa in 1893 after training as a lawyer. He already had a wife, Kasturba, as a result of an arranged marriage in 1883, according to local custom, when he was 13 and she was 14.
The couple had four sons: Harilal, born in 1888; Manilal, born in 1892; Ramdas, born in 1897; and Devdas, born in 1900. His wife joined him in South Africa in 1897 and they lived there until returning to India in 1914 to join the gathering political movement against British colonial rule.

article-2172967-03A17AE9000005DC-313_306x445.jpg

article-2172967-140B6B66000005DC-978_306x445.jpg


Gandhi (left) and Kallenbach lived together for two years in a house in South Africa. Joseph Lelyveld's controversial biography Great Soul: Mahatma Gandhi And His Struggle With India (right) was published in 2011



article-2270778-173F8445000005DC-917_634x374.jpg

The archive display coincides with the 65th anniversary of Gandhi's death. This picture shows Indian school children paying homage at a memorial statue in Bhubaneswar

Kallenbach, a German-born Jewish architect, lived with Gandhi in Johannesburg for about two years from 1907 – a year after Gandhi took a public vow of celibacy.

The relationship between Gandhi and the wealthy South African was chronicled in a book two years ago by Joseph Lelyveld, former editor of the New York Times.
In Great Soul: Mahatma Gandhi And His Struggle With India, Lelyveld quotes a letter from Gandhi to Kallenbach in which he wrote: ‘How completely you have taken possession of my body. This is slavery with a vengeance.’ Lelyveld defended his book against accusations that he had suggested Gandhi was bisexual. ‘The word “bisexual” nowhere appears in the book,’ he wrote afterwards.

article-2270778-173FD0C1000005DC-987_634x617.jpg

School children dressed as Mahatma Gandhi assemble to mark his anniversary in the southern Indian city of Chennai

Raj Bala Jain, part of the National Archives team that studied the Kallenbach collection in detail, said she was surprised how their relationship had been misconstrued.
‘I did not find even a single letter with sexual overtones,’ she said.
‘Friendship can be misinterpreted. I think Gandhi was very normal and above such things.’

Indians fret about auctions of Gandhi’s belongings, saying they insult the memory of a man who rejected material wealth. ‘We are talking about Gandhi. Such emotions are justified,’ said Mr Hasan.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...ue-nature-relationship.html?printingPage=true
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Advertisement
Who gives a damn about his sexual preference. Would he being gay or not make the world a better place? Infact would it make Pakistan any better if he was gay?

We need to learn to respect others and their leaders. Mudslinging or making controversy is the work of lesser beings.
 
Advertisement
Who gives a damn about his sexual preference. Would he being gay or not make the world a better place? Infact would it make Pakistan any better if he was gay?

We need to learn to respect others and their leaders. Mudslinging or making controversy is the work of lesser beings.
^ What He said. (clap)
 
Lurker,, what a hypocritical stance ! [hilar][hilar] ...why not first start respecting Islamic Personalities and apply the same principles you hold others too.

It almost seems like your prejudice is towards your own kind and not others at all ! ...How lame is this ?? :lol::lol:

^ What He said. (clap)
 
Lurker,, what a hypocritical stance ! [hilar][hilar] ...why not first start respecting Islamic Personalities and apply the same principles you hold others too.

It almost seems like your prejudice is towards your own kind and not others at all ! ...How lame is this ?? :lol::lol:

who do you want me to respect?
 
I think Gandhi was bisexual which is why he claimed celibacy at such at early age. I don't see him as a great but a strange character who has some good traits.
 
Silly thread.

Mr. Gandhi was always in favor of greater Bharat/against creation of Pak. But we should also appreciate that he did stopped and tried to stop violence against Muslims.
 
Advertisement
Well kissi ki private life per behuda comments dena koi aala ikhlaq wali baat nahi hai.Gandhiji ko tau Nelson Mandela aur Martin Luther King bhi ek inspiration bolte thay for themselves tau ab hum unhein bhi Pakistan ka dushman kehne se rahe. Baqi Gandhiji ne offer ki thi Quaid-e-Azam ko key tum mulk ko tootne se bachalo aur PM bunjao lekin Nehru aur Sardar Patel Quaid ke sakht dushman thay aur Nehru ne Gandhi-Jinnah meetings ke bawajood bayaan diye thay key main Jinnah ko apni cabinet ka chapdasi bhi na rakhunga....self-respect kissi ki majrooh karo tau aap kya expect karoge?
Plus we can respect Gandhi due to his appreciation for Nabi Pakpbuh,Hazrat Issa Alayhis Salaam,Hazrat Abu Bakar Siddique Razi Allahu Andu,Hazrat Omar Farooq Razi Allahu Anhu and Hazrat Imam Hussain Razi Allahu Anhu too.He called the Islamic figures a source of inspiration among historical personalities that he like.Lekin in terms of politics,Gandhiji ki ek offensive baat thi aur woh yeh key bahir ke mulkoon mein woh racial equality ki baatein karte thay lekin India mein unhoon ne caste system ki ****** ko kabhi oppose na kiya and many Dalits and untouchables etc....criticize him due to his policies.
 
fair comment, except even if he were gay (which I believe he was not), what is the issue? its not a crime. people are born gay. does his contribution to our independence fall short just becuase he was gay? also his own grandsons have disagreed with the imputation that he was gay, but nevertheless said that same thing that even if he were gay, they find nothing objectionable in that.

Who gives a damn about his sexual preference. Would he being gay or not make the world a better place? Infact would it make Pakistan any better if he was gay?

We need to learn to respect others and their leaders. Mudslinging or making controversy is the work of lesser beings.
 
The whole world is researching his practices, thinking and principles and writing great books on them. Yahan kuch logon ko Gandhi Gay ya nahi ki charcha mein hain?

Gandhi Gay hone say Pakistan ko koi faida ha kya? Taliban bum botna chod thenge kya?
 
Advertisement
To be fair he was a great leader for the united India or Greater India. This is true that he never wanted and supported the creation of Pakistan. But he marched in support of muslims and also visited Karachi. At the end he was a human and had few short comings like he might be a gay or slept with underage girls. Whatever at the end he gave them a new country. He was not as poisionous as NEHRU
 
Everyone ...Be it an islamic or a non-islamic personality !..hold everyone to the same standards ..
If read again what I wrote in this thread, I was not disrespectful or respectful to Mr Gandhi. I was pointing out that this is a useless endeavor. You took that as respect.