Advertisement

The culture of sycophancy beginning to engulf Pakistan Tehrik-i-Insaf ?

TANK: The culture of sycophancy that remains the hallmark of the Pakistani brand of politics is beginning to engulf Pakistan Tehrik-i-Insaf as well, perhaps a little too early.



A 48-hour journey along the PTIs SUV-infested caravan leaves you with the impression that the Khan is surrounded by sycophants as much as his counterparts.


Asif Zardari and Nawaz Sharif are both equal contenders as the most sought after people by this variety of people. To give credit to the President, Asif can smell a smooth talker from a distance and likes to scorn at them whereas Nawaz Sharif loves it. His usual fan club knows that a few pet themes like food, music, his immense popularity and good health can bring an instant glow on his cheeks.


Imran always had a middle class attitude and abhorrence for sycophancy. I remember him actually insulting a worker for overly buttering him in Washington. Not any longer. I suspect he is beginning to enjoy it now. Or so was my impression seeing the party culture from the sidelines in two days.


Of course, such being his demand that he is virtually harassed by a multitude of political wannabes. The electoral hopefuls will do anything to get his attention, and a party ticket if possible. I saw this great art of sweet talk in practice, particular the lethal I apologize for saying this Saraiki variety, never missing an opportunity to compliments him over, say, How Khan Sahib may have conquered the tribals; how Khan Sahibs may have vanquished his enemies.

The prospective candidate for DI Khan, Amin Gandapur, we were told, got 20 goats slaughtered for preparing the Rosh meat delicacy for over 2000 people. A black ox was sacrificed in the morning to save Khan Sahib from evil eyes. No wonder most of the foreigners left DI Khan seeing the blood cuddling bull. This was after suffering a terrible night not knowing how to use a Muslim toilet without paper rolls, besides the scare of Taliban attack and Dengue mosquitoes.

A finer spectacle of what Khan Sahib has to put up with was witnessed on the way back when the caravan stopped at the Dera of the Pir of Bilot Sharif Makhdoom Murtajad Shah, courtesy Ayla Malik. This lollapalooza of a person, the Pir had a turbaned Imran Khan on one side and an overly made-up Ayla Malik on the other. Before them on the table lay a roasted goat standing on all fours, its horns, eyes intact and a branch of leaves in its mouth. Half of the audience was the Pirs devotees and the rest police constables.

Pir Saheb first extolled a 4000-old glorious history of his family living on Indus. I asked one of his cousins that perhaps Pir sahib was exaggerating about a few millenniums as Islams history is not older than 1500 years and that as Syeds his family could not have been here before that.

Perhaps he was mixing up history about the ruins of Bilot. Pir Saheb went on to add that he was not the kind of Pir who take things from youaccusingly looking at Makhdoom Shah Mahmood but the Pir who gives you everything,this time looking at ever-smiling Ayla Malik for some reason. Imran matched his eloquence and in the process mentioned that he was a sinner (gunahgaar) Muslim but had managed to convert four people to Islam. This was after he had introduced former British Prime Minister Tony Blairs sister-in-law Lauren Booth as the one who had converted to Islam in the Tank public meeting. Nothing wrong about it. But this might encourage more sinners to purge themselves by forcing Hindus and Christians to convert as they are doing in Sindh and Balochistan. It is about wearing your religion on your sleeves.

This also begs a few questions about Imrans initiative about holding peace talk with Taliban. The argument that the Taliban are killing thousands of men, women and children just because they are being attacked by drones is too simplistic, if not frivolous. They have been at ittrying to impose their way of repressive, cruel livingmuch before the drones.

Assuming that we do that once the born-again Khan becomes the Prime Minister, what are the Taliban offering in return; what is the guarantee that they will abide by their commitment this time; who is he talking to; how can he forgive Taliban on behalf of those millions whose loved ones have perished. A lot of liberal Pakistanis who see him as the Messiah may have more such questionsmore so after the treatment meted out to the young Malala. Imran definitely needs to clarify his stance about these issues to fill up the gap in what he says and what he does.

For a start, a little protest against drones outside GHQ may not be out of place. Now that it is established through deliberate leaks in the US media that the Pakistan government, read Army, is informed about drone attacks, which means they have a tacit understanding on the issue. Do it, Khan Sahib.

Source
 
Advertisement
الله کرے کہ یہ صرف اس بندے کا خیال ہو - لیکن پھر بھی خان صاحب کو خوشامدی اور چاپلوس لوگوں سے احتیاط کرنے کی ضرورت ہے - کیوں کہ یہ لوگ اچھے خاصے انسان کو کہیں کا نہیں چھوڑتے ​
 
IK is great leader and has seen all ups and down's...not the first time for him. I have no doubt that IK will fight for middle class like they way he worked hard to establish Shaukat Khanum Cancer hospital and then Nimal college.
 
Advertisement
IK is not new to fame, he has seen more fame and glory than any Pakistani leader of today.
So don't worry about him, take care for yourself.
 
********. why always try to point fingers based on someones may or may not i..e assumptions. idiots. did anyone see people spreading their assumptions as truth. check this one
 
Article is written by AMIR MATEEN . .very good friend of IK and he also wrote Waziristan March form the inside. . .

I think the points that he has risen , shows that he is a real friend of IK . .

I think that it shall be responded .but one thing is that the PIR of Aila Malik is THURKI . .
 
Advertisement
********. why always try to point fingers based on someones may or may not i..e assumptions. idiots. did anyone see people spreading their assumptions as truth. check this one

@ Mansoor.... If you readcarefully what Geek is saying in his post he is mentioning here about his observation. There is nothing wrong with what person observes and writes about it. This is a forum, if you don't agree then it's fine but calling someone's observation as idiotic & ******** is not right. We all hope IK doesn't fall for this sycophancy and proves this theory wrong. But at the same token we should listen to what the other person with opposing views is saying and analyze it giving the ground realities and looking at Pro's and Con's.

Problem is we as a nation are very emotional people. If we follow someone we follow him off the cliff without any questions asked. We have to think who we follow is a human being just like us and humans are prone to make mistakes. Sorry for the lecture didn't intentioned it that way.......Regards....
 
Everybody wants Imran to take Army head on , this article is an attempt to coax him to do that, he was in perfect political academy when he was in cricket team so for him to be sorrounded by chamchas is nothing new, although he advocates the rights of common man, it is a fact that he was born in an elitist family but Allah has given him the character to criticize the same elite to which he belongs. No worries about Imran as suleman Khan says Aik daffa jab main commitment kar laita hoon to apni bhi nahi sunta
 
I dont know about the rest of the stuff but this is utter nonsense:
This also begs a few questions about Imrans initiative about holding peace talk with Taliban. The argument that the Taliban are killing thousands of men, women and children just because they are being attacked by drones is too simplistic, if not frivolous. They have been at ittrying to impose their way of repressive, cruel livingmuch before the drones.

Assuming that we do that once the born-again Khan becomes the Prime Minister, what are the Taliban offering in return; what is the guarantee that they will abide by their commitment this time; who is he talking to; how can he forgive Taliban on behalf of those millions whose loved ones have perished. A lot of liberal Pakistanis who see him as the Messiah may have more such questionsmore so after the treatment meted out to the young Malala. Imran definitely needs to clarify his stance about these issues to fill up the gap in what he says and what he does.

I think the writer maybe the typucal burnt nazriati variety.
These political heeavyweights have their own idiosynchorices you have to put with.
What is IK to do lecture them on ethics at every stop.

In the bold parts he on purpose is distorting IK position. Listen to any of his countless interviews and you see this person is just scaremongering. He has explained already that Taliban is a blanket term for 20 or so groups.
Many are till now actually supporting Army. The Anti Pakistan faction is a small part TTP (Hakimullah group) and other proxies to north or Fazlullah group etc. Of these the motivation to fight arent the same.Some are outside proxies. Other are ciminals. Some are radiclised from collateral damage, soem are former Jihadi groups from Punjab and AJK. A tiny part of the whole are ideological who believe the Pakistnai state isnt legitimate anymore and its army is just a mercernary force for America and has to be destroyed.

IK strategy is to deal with tribal population and deny these groups a sympathetic population from where they can operate.
Thats the only strategy that works. For e.g the Wazir Areas of SWA agency expelled the Uzbek IMU after they became increasingly violent. Its only due to these Wazir groups that PA can even operate in SWA.

On dornes IK has said many times yes they are more precise then Army artillery fire or bombings. But at same time their presence gives legitimacy to groups who claim they are fighting Jihad (In actual very little part of what we call TTP fights in Afghansitan i.e Haqqani Network.They have never attacked Pakistani forces.) The militants use the paranoa and fear to establish their grip on the local population. It labels opponenets CIA spies and kills them, and point to their "Martyrs" to justify them selves. The Psychological impact of death looming over you can make you supportive of people who show them selves to be fighting against this threath. Its called Stolkhom Syndrome.

And no Taliban havent killed millions. The idea is ridiculous oF the 29,000 or so killed in WOT. 7000 are the deaths attributable to Taliban rest is collateral damage due to Army operation against the Militants and smaller part are Drone victims (around 3000).
This isnt that surprising as the Army has far more firepower Artillary, Bombs) which mostly is very imprecise, its not unusal it has caused the biggest chunk of deaht and destruction.

And why should IK who is not in power, hold no post, isnt responsible for Malal security nor ever put her in harms way answer for Malala. Why doesnt he asks ANP these questions. Infact I am getting sick of these repetitive nonsense.

If this utter moron does not even understand such a basic thing why did he even go to the peace march.

I think he is another Asteen ka Samp, of which PTI has no shortage it seems. IK should be careful of those around him. They are small minded territorial rats who are quick to bite the hand that feeds them on imagined insults.
 
Last edited:
@ Mansoor.... If you readcarefully what Geek is saying in his post he is mentioning here about his observation. There is nothing wrong with what person observes and writes about it. This is a forum, if you don't agree then it's fine but calling someone's observation as idiotic & ******** is not right. We all hope IK doesn't fall for this sycophancy and proves this theory wrong. But at the same token we should listen to what the other person with opposing views is saying and analyze it giving the ground realities and looking at Pro's and Con's.

Problem is we as a nation are very emotional people. If we follow someone we follow him off the cliff without any questions asked. We have to think who we follow is a human being just like us and humans are prone to make mistakes. Sorry for the lecture didn't intentioned it that way.......Regards....

sorry big brother actually my mistake i didnt read it fully. I thought it was also something like other stuff which we see all around and you know reading that articles is real waste of time. so i thought this was also like others. sorry for my mistake again and apologies to others if i ve hurt them. just got a bit careless otherwise m not that emotional
 
Advertisement
مضمون نگار نے عمران خان سے مطلق اپنی قیاس آریوں سے مضمون بھر دیا ہے .... اب وہ لوگ بھی جنھوں نے عمران کی کبھی ایک ادھ جھلک ہی دیکھی ہو ، وہ بھی اس پر مضمون لکھنے لگے ،،،،
تجزیہ میں کوئی جان ہی نہیں ہے .... نہ عمران کی شخصیت کا کوئی پہلو اجاگر ہو رہا ہے .


اچھی پراکتیس ہے کسی اور پر شائد کامیاب ہوجا یے
 
IK has seen too much to fall into the trap of sycophancy. His life tells us he's quite brutal about merit, even during his cricketing days when he had to drop Majid Khan from the team. These things are not "unlearned" at this age, as Amir Mateen suggests.

Sycophants will keep doing their job, and IK will keep doing his on merit. In any case, they haven't even been able to get anything from him as yet, no tickets, no party positions even (as now party elections are being held). None of them have been able to butter him into changing any of his core policies, nor to convince him to abandon party elections. So where is the evidence sycophancy is working on IK (except for an impression of "enjoying" it)...?

It's weird though the article goes from sycophancy to the war on terror and also makes a stop at religion. And it's apparently a VERY bad thing to do to talk about religion or "wear it on your sleeves" especially when you are among fellow Muslims. :(

Does not leave a very good impression of the otherwise quite balanced Amir Mateen...