ISLAMABAD: Punjab Chief Minister Mian Shahbaz Sharif has said that no US aid, no matter how huge it is, would be accepted by the province till the complete halt of the drone strikes by Washington.
We have been refusing to accept US aid of hundreds of millions of dollars for the last two and half year and would continue to do so to register our protest against Washingtons drone policy, Shahbaz Sharif said.
The Punjab chief minister said this in response to a question raised by this correspondent as part of a study over the strange dichotomy in the strategies adopted by the Federal, Punjab and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP) governments against the US drones. The similar confusions are reflected in the policies of the two parties-the PML-N and the PTI-ruling the Centre, Punjab and KP.
All the three governments are against the US drone strikes inside Pakistan. They also consider this policy of the US as a major cause of fuelling extremism and terrorism here. In their respective official statements, all three also shared the same view that the recent drone strike that had hit Hakimullah Mehsud, had actually hit the dialogue process as approved by the political leadership of the country in the last APC.
However, all the three governments still have their own strategies, different from one another.The federal government of Nawaz Sharif is lodging its protests over US drones and seeks from the US through diplomatic means to stop drones. The Punjab government of Shahbaz Sharif has refused to get the US aid as a sign of protest against the US drone strikes. The KP government is protesting against drones but is neither becoming part of the PTIs move to stop the Nato Supply Line nor refusing like Punjab to accept the US aid.When these strategies of the federal and two provincial governments are analysed in view of their respective political standings, both the PTI as well as the PML-N appear confused.
The KP coalition government is led by the PTI but still both the PTI and the PTI KP government are proceeding on different ways. The strange situation is that the PTI central leaders and its workers are on the roads of KP to get the Nato lines blocked but the KP government is completely aloof from this protest. The confusion is that the PTI as a party stops the lines but the PTI as a government in the province, which has the authority to do so, cannot officially do so. Instead as against the partys anti-US policy, the PTI provincial government continues to be the recipient of US aid.
In the case of the PML-N, the federal government led by Mian Nawaz Sharif though speaks against the US drone policy but neither is in favour of blocking drone strike nor is refusing the US aid. As against the PML-N government at Centre, the partys Punjab government led by Mian Shahbaz Sharif is refusing to accept the US aid as a sign of protest against US drones.
Though practically the PML-N government at the Centre is receiving the US aid, the PML-N government in Punjab is refusing the same. Even at the federal level, the PML-N government spokesman and information minister talks of pragmatism and oppose the stoppage of Nato supply lines. But the same government and the same partys key leader Chaudhry Nisar Ali Khan has taken a very harsh view against the US and has gone to the extent of stating that the US is deliberately fuelling terrorism within Pakistan owing to which the government would completely review its relations with Washington.As reported on Sunday by The News, the PML-N during its opposition days has been in support of stopping the Nato Supply Line but now it considers it against the interest of Pakistan. http://www.thenews.com.pk/Todays-News-13-26868-Shahbaz-again-rejects-US-aid-till-drones-stop
To kia yeh khula tazad nehin ?
kia yeh sab Noura kushtey hai ?
PTI and PMLN both have the same agenda !!!
They both want drown to stop, they both want to negotiate with Taliban
They both are taking us aid and want to stop it, yet they are against each other.
To kia yeh khula tazad nehin ?
kia yeh sab Noura kushtey hai ?
PTI and PMLN both have the same agenda !!!
They both want drown to stop, they both want to negotiate with Taliban
They both are taking us aid and want to stop it, yet they are against each other.
My question is that's this aid or is this borrowed money that has to be paid back with interest, I think it is borrowed money from world bank is paid back with interest.
So stop saying this is free money, this money is paid back with interest.
Punjab not taking usa aid but federal govt is .
IK saying no to usa aid but KPK is taking it.
PTI was going to block the nato supply ..did they do it ?? why not ?
My question is that's this aid or is this borrowed money that has to be paid back with interest, I think it is borrowed money from world bank is paid back with interest.
So stop saying this is free money, this money is paid back with interest.
If Pakistan stop taking aid, believe me it will make no difference to Pakistan.
Pakistan's budget is like 200 arab or billion $$$ or something and the aid is like 1 or 2 billion more
So if Pakistan can arrange 198 then they can arrange 200 too.
امریکہ سے مدد لے کر اسی کے خلاف احتجاج کرنے میں کیا خرابی ہے؟ اگر امریکہ کو اعتراض ہو گا تو امداد بند کر دے گا دوسرے کوئی مامے لگتے ہیں اعتراض کرنے والے، ان کو کیوں جلن ہو رہی ہے؟ یہ کیسی منطق ہے کہ، چونکہ آپ امداد وصول کر رہے ہیں اسلئے احتجاج نہیں کر سکتے؟ کیوں نہیں کر سکتے، کیا امداد ڈرون حملوں کے بدلے میں مل رہی ہے ؟
امریکہ سے مدد لے کر اسی کے خلاف احتجاج کرنے میں کیا خرابی ہے؟ اگر امریکہ کو اعتراض ہو گا تو امداد بند کر دے گا دوسرے کوئی مامے لگتے ہیں اعتراض کرنے والے، ان کو کیوں جلن ہو رہی ہے؟ یہ کیسی منطق ہے کہ، چونکہ آپ امداد وصول کر رہے ہیں اسلئے احتجاج نہیں کر سکتے؟ کیوں نہیں کر سکتے، کیا امداد ڈرون حملوں کے بدلے میں مل رہی ہے ؟
Very well put my friend. I have the exact same point-of-view but couldn't have articulated it any better. If in-fact PTI stops protesting against drones, then it would seem that aid is a bribe for them.
Pakistan ki 272 National Assembly seats may 128 National Seats sirf Punjab say hai.
PML-N came to majority only because of gaining punjab seats.
So it is safe to say that the Aid NS is taking is like Aid taken by Punjab, because the PM will ensure that he keep his grip firm over punjab in order to be PM again, and he has proved this behavior by taking SS with on on a couple of foreign tours(specially China) to make sure they keep a hold of Punjab.
Conclusion: Aid Taken by NS means Aid taken by Punjab[/b].
If Pakistan stop taking aid, believe me it will make no difference to Pakistan.
Pakistan's budget is like 200 arab or billion $$$ or something and the aid is like 1 or 2 billion more
So if Pakistan can arrange 198 then they can arrange 200 too.
Bhai mera apna opinion hai.
You think NS gives a shi't what i say. I am not his spokes person .... I hope He understands this ... The sooner the better.
Pakistan ki 272 National Assembly seats may 128 National Seats sirf Punjab say hai.
PML-N came to majority only because of gaining punjab seats.
So it is safe to say that the Aid NS is taking is like Aid taken by Punjab, because the PM will ensure that he keep his grip firm over punjab in order to be PM again, and he has proved this behavior by taking SS with on on a couple of foreign tours(specially China) to make sure they keep a hold of Punjab.
Conclusion: Aid Taken by NS means Aid taken by Punjab[/b].
chal bachay so ja raat ho gae hai, itna damag istamal na kar, thora imran khan ko day day ;)
himmat hai tu KPK govt ko bolo supply rokay, yeah dramay bazian khatam karo. :)