Advertisement

Primary schools ban Muslim pupils from fasting during Ramadan with one saying it is a health risk fo

Source : http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...an-one-saying-health-risk-young-children.html

Barclay Primary School in Leyton, east London, issued the letter yesterday
It said it would not allow pupils fasting to attend school during Ramadan
Acting head said pupils would not be able to fast without meeting him first
Muslim Association of Britain slammed 'blanket enforcement' of rule


A primary school trust has banned Muslim pupils from fasting during Ramadan, claiming the tradition can be harmful to the health of young children.

Barclay Primary School in Leyton, east London, issued a letter to parents informing them that it would not allow children attending school to fast in order to 'safeguard the health and education of the child'.
In the letter, the acting head said children would not be able to fast without meeting with him first.
The move has been slammed by members of the Muslim community who said schools should seek to support parents instead of 'blanket enforce' their own rules when it comes to religion.


298B82E800000578-3120407-image-m-2_1434046924725.jpg


In the letter issued yesterday, the school claimed to have 'sought guidance' before implementing the ban.
'We are reliably informed that in Islamic Law, children are not required to fast during Ramadan, only being required to do so when they become adults,' it said.


It continued to describe how children 'fainted' and 'became ill' during last year's festival after going without food or water for '18 hours, a significant amount of time for a child.'
Alongside Barclay Primary School the ban will be implemented across three other schools which belong to the trust. They are Sybourn Primary School and Thomas Gamuel Primary School in Waltham Forest and Brook House Primary School in Haringey.

The letter, posted on 5pillars, a British Muslim publication, was today criticised by members of the Muslim community which said deciding whether a child should fast or not is the prerogative of their parent.

298B837C00000578-3120407-image-a-3_1434046966856.jpg


298B837800000578-3120407-image-a-4_1434047000431.jpg


The Muslim Association of Britain said there were enough rules in place to protect the vulnerable from fasting without school's interference.
'We believe that there are sufficient and stringent rules within Islam which allow those who are unable to fast, to break fast,' a spokesman told Mail Online.

'These rules include those who are medically ill or compromised; or too young or too old to fast.
'However, we believe that this determination should be decided by parents with their children; who can together reach a collective decision whether or not the child can fast.

'MAB ascertains that the final choice of whether or not to fast should be the right of the parents, who should in turn encourage their children to fast without forcing them to do so.'
Dr Omer El-Hamdoon, the President of MAB added parents ought to have the ultimate say in whether their child participates in the fast.
'Schools should play a supporting role to parents; and issues like this should be discussed, not blanket enforced,' he said.
Neither Barclay Primary School nor the Lion Academy Trust responded to Mail Online's requests for comment this afternoon.


298B837400000578-3120407-image-a-5_1434047100432.jpg




 
Last edited by a moderator:
Advertisement
Primary school is usually for kids from age 5-11. Parents should understand their kids and not make them fast if they are fainting. Every kid is different and fasting is not obligatory until a child is able to fast. The best person to know that is the parents. When parents are stupid that is when the problem arises. Parents need to give proper education themselves about islam and also transfered to the kids. If they are fasting and dont feel good. they can always break their fast. It is allowed for Elder people then what about kids. Kids should start fasting at home on weekends so that they are not exhausted. Fasting time in UK are very long so parents needed to be considerate and still need to be considerate of their little kids and not burden them.
Thanks for Sharing Mohan to highlight so that Muslim parents can learn to teach islam to their kids in the best way and not so that it becomes hard for them. Islam has concession for kids who find it really hard to fast as most kids at age 10 or 11 have not crossed puberty and are too young. Most scholars of Islam has set the age as 10 to start introducing fasting but that to with the condition if the kid is able to do so..Problem is when people start taking things BLACK AND WHITE. But i do feel most muslim parents dont burden their kids and our understanding. SOme need to learn
I don't agree with the school on BANNING the fasting but i do agree that younger kids aged 10 or less should not be fasting at school and should fast on weekends if they are able to..
 
Advertisement
What a respectful language, and what a wise approach, I being a practicing muslim would definitely support the cause had I been living in the west.
 
Advertisement
Islam is very flexible, it allows to make up the fast on other days for students that wish to fast and they will get the same rewards.

Allah in his wisdom has planned for every contingency.
 
سیکولر ریاست فتووں پر کب سے عمل کرنے لگی

they know our religion better than us............ :)
waisay main nay yeh baat Secular riasat kay liay nahi.....apnay Musalaman Parents kay liay kahee thee.... (in case if they are feeling offended) :jazak:
 
they know our religion better than us............ :)
waisay main nay yeh baat Secular riasat kay liay nahi.....apnay Musalaman Parents kay liay kahee thee.... (in case if they are feeling offended) :jazak:
پھر انھے یہ بھی پتہ ہو گا کے روزہ صحت مند بالغ افراد پر فرض ہے، پھر بھی اگر کسی وجہ سے قبل از وقت ختم کرنا پڑے تو کیا جا سکتا ہے
 
اتنے چھوٹے بچوں پر روزہ فرض ہی نہیں ہے اسلئے تھریڈ سٹارٹر کو پہلے خود اسلام کا مطالعہ کرنا ضروری ہے
 
Advertisement
My son going to school here in the UK... got one letter about Ramadan today; they are facilitating them rather than stopping.... no such thing I observed like what is mentioned by thread starter.
 
Some stupid parents force fasting on children, schools are right.