Advertisement

One sided Operation/Media Trial against MQM/Altaf Hussain is the Core REASON of Today's Result --- S

One Sided Operation and Media Trial against MQM/Altaf Hussain is the Core REASON of Today's Result -- Spartacus


One sided Operation/Media Trial against MQM/Altaf Hussain is the Core REASON of Today's Result.

The more the MEDIA Trial of MQM the better the RESULT for MQM.
The more One Sided Operation against MQM/Altaf Hussain , the better the RUSULT for MQM.

You can Cage MQM workers , BUT what to do with their voters ?



Any RIGGING in Karachi will follow by a REVOLUTION , STREET REVOLUTION.
 
Advertisement
ہماری قوم اتنی باشعور نہں ہوئی کہ خان جیسا اس کو لیڈ کر سکے۔
ابھی الطاف زرداری اور نواز جیسے ہی اس سے کھیلیں گیں
 
آپ کی بات سے یہ ثابت ہو رہا ہے کہ پاکستان میں موجود مہاجر عقل کے اندھے ہیں ان کو کچھ نظر نہیں آتا .یہ متحدہ قوامی موومنٹ کے غلام ہیں .الله نے ان کے دلوں میں مہریں لگا دی ہیں
 
sorry this gutka is a liar like most of his party.

the main reason for today's result i have already explained many times recently. people of karachi by and large were not interested in this election. did you see any lines on tv? if you went out today it was like strike - totally empty streets. i guess the turnout was around 25% since only the party activists were involved and public stayed at home. In this scenario mqm has a massive advantage since they have the biggest organization in karachi. They were also playing mohajir card and nothing else. However, despite this advantage and mohajir mqm failed to register 90% mandate that gutkas claim on TV. even if all mohajirs voted for mqm, it will not get more than 65% UC's. And if turnout increases or mohajir vote is divided then MQM can be defeated i karachi. This is what happened in 2013 until rigging took place.
 
جیسا کروگے ویسا بهروگے

ووٹ دیا هے تو رزلٹ بهی آئیگا...ان شا اللہ

قاتلوں اور بهتہ خوروں کو ووٹ دینے والے ہمیشہ سوگ میں رهینگے...صرف مقتول ہی کے گهر میں سوگ نہیں هوتا
 
It was a free for all.
full day news were like fake presiding officers
voters thrown out and god knows what was happening behind closed doors
anarchy and feuds by MQM workers which kept the voter turn out at minimum.

considering this MQM is a Mafia not a political party which has killers and extortionists amidst it.

And for those who are supporting these killers no sympathy for you and your likes in the hearts of majority of Pakistanis
 
Advertisement
یہ دلیل ہی تاقص ہیں کہ ایم کیو ایم اسلیے جیتی ہے کہ انکے خلاف آپریشن ہو رہا ہے۔

یہ 2013،2008،2007،2002،وغیرہ میں تو انکے خلاف کوئی آپریشن نہیں تھا پھر کیوں اتنی سیٹیں جیتی تھیں؟

آپریشن کے باوجود انکی غنڈہ تنظم ابھی تک وہی موجود ہے اور اپنے غنڈے ہر محکمے میں گھسائے ہوئیں ہیں جو پھر پریزائیڈنگ اور دوسرا الیکشن سٹاف بن جاتے ہیں۔ اب انہیں دو نمبر ملازمین کو کون نکال سکتا ہے؟ ایم کیو ایم نے ہر جگہ اپنی جڑیں بہت مضبوط گھسائے ہیں۔ انہیں کاٹنے یا کمزور ہونے میں بہت وقت لگے وہ بھی تب اگر سندھ میں کسی انسان کی حکومت بن جائے۔

 
Given Karachi's polarized and chaotic dynamics the votes are cast based on ethnic lines/divisions. Current operation or media coverage has nothing to do with the results.

PTI and JI live in fantasy land otherwise they have not done anything on the ground to have claimed that they will get a positive result. Rallies and jalsas a few days before the elections
dont get you votes. You have to be present and visible to get votes.
 
یہ دلیل ہی تاقص ہیں کہ ایم کیو ایم اسلیے جیتی ہے کہ انکے خلاف آپریشن ہو رہا ہے۔

یہ 2013،2008،2007،2002،وغیرہ میں تو انکے خلاف کوئی آپریشن نہیں تھا پھر کیوں اتنی سیٹیں جیتی تھیں؟


This part of argument is valid.

آپریشن کے باوجود انکی غنڈہ تنظم ابھی تک وہی موجود ہے اور اپنے غنڈے ہر محکمے میں گھسائے ہوئیں ہیں جو پھر پریزائیڈنگ اور دوسرا الیکشن سٹاف بن جاتے ہیں۔ اب انہیں دو نمبر ملازمین کو کون نکال سکتا ہے؟ ایم کیو ایم نے ہر جگہ اپنی جڑیں بہت مضبوط گھسائے ہیں۔ انہیں کاٹنے یا کمزور ہونے میں بہت وقت لگے وہ بھی تب اگر سندھ میں کسی انسان کی حکومت بن جائے۔

You have to understand that urdu speaking do support MQM without giving much consideration to the violent tactics or "ghunda gardi." In fact most see this as a plus point and as a safeguard for their community. MQM doesn't just have 'ghundas' but they also have common people who live and work among the people. They don't always get votes by force or compulsion. People do vote for them willingly in large numbers - yes, sometime they do force people to vote but the proportion of that is small. They don't really need that force or ghunda gardi to do some rigging but i think that they do just because they can but that doesn't have a big impact on the end result.

Once people do understand that MQM does get legitimate votes and try to understand the reasons behind it only then they will be able to counter their strategy. But if their rivals keep blaming all of MQM's electoral victories on rigging alone then there is no hope for their rivals like PTI which is a seasonal party in Karachi.
 
Last edited:
Given Karachi's polarized and chaotic dynamics the votes are cast based on ethnic lines/divisions. Current operation or media coverage has nothing to do with the results.

PTI and JI live in fantasy land otherwise they have not done anything on the ground to have claimed that they will get a positive result. Rallies and jalsas a few days before the elections
dont get you votes. You have to be present and visible to get votes.

you are contradicting your own point.

mqm ha done nothing on ground either for last 7 years. In fact if you take out mushi from the equation, mqm has not done anything for karachi in 30 years. PPP did nothing in sindh for the last 40 years and still won by biggest margin of all 70%. pmln has done nothing in punjab in last 35 years apart from 2 metro projects and 1 motorway but still won 45%.

People in pakistan do not vote based on performance except for pashtun. another advantage that pashtun have is that they cannot be forced to vote. a pathan would rather die than vote against his will so it is it is very difficult to rig an election in pashtun area through money or force. these 2 factors mean that KP has given a new party a chance irrespective of religion/ideology/ethnicity and if democracy continues in pakistan for another 25-30 years, KP will be the most developed province in pakistan.
 
Advertisement
[/SIZE][/COLOR]This part of argument is valid.



You have to understand that urdu speaking do support MQM without giving much consideration to the violent tactics or "ghunda gardi." In fact most see this as a plus point and as a safeguard for their community. MQM doesn't just have a 'ghundas' they have common people who live and work among the people. They don't always get votes by force or compulsion. People do vote for them willingly in large numbers - yes, sometime they do force people to vote but the proportion of that is small. They don't really need that force or ghunda gardi to do some rigging but i think that they do just because they can but that doesn't have a big impact on the end result.

Once people do understand that MQM does get legitimate votes and the reasons behind it only then they will be able to counter their strategy. But if they keep blaming all of MQM's electoral victories on rigging alone then there is no hope for their rivals like PTI which is a seasonal party in Karachi.


سر جی آپکی بات جزوی طور پہ ٹھیک ہے لیکن پوری نہیں کیونکہ اگر ایم کیو ایم واقعی 100٪ ٹھیک طریقے سے جیتی تو:۔

یہ لوگ دو نمبر پریزایڈنگ افسر اور الیکشن سٹاف نہ لگواتے۔

یہ حلقہ بندی میں دو نمبری نہ کرتے

یہ ایک ایک گھر پہ 1200 وؤٹ درج نہ کراتے۔

یہ الیکشن کے دن اتنی غنڈہ گردی نہ کرے۔

یہ لوگوں کو ڈراتے دھماتے نہ۔

کے پی میں بھی جنرل الیکشنز بھی ہوئیں اور بلدیاتی بھی۔ بلدیات میں کچھ وجوہات کے بنا پہ بد انتظامی ہوئی لیکن کسی نے کسی سے زبردستی وؤٹ نہیں لیے، کسی نے حلقہ بندی پہ کچھ نہیں کہا، کسی نے وؤٹر لسٹ میں گڑبڑ کی شکایت نہیں کی وغیرہ وغیرہ۔

یہ سارے دو نمبری کے کام کراچی میں ہی کیوں ہوتے ہیں؟ یہ ایم کیو ایم ہی کیوں وؤٹرز لسٹس کے سروے اور حلقہ بندی پہ اتنا آسمان سر پہ اُٹھاتی ہے۔

یہ تو کہتے ہیں نا کہ انکے وؤٹر سب سے زیادہ تعلیم یافتہ ہے لیکن جب بائیو میٹرک کی بات آتی ہے سب سے زیادہ یہ چیختیں ہیں اور یہ دلیل دیتے ہیں کہ لوگوں ابھی تک اتنے تعلیم یافتہ نہیں ہوئے۔

اب پھر نتائج آنا بند ہوگئے۔ کیا کبھی آپ نے کے پی کے نتائج بند ہوتے دیکھے ہیں تو بتائے مجھے؟

میرے خیال میں اگر یہ سب کام ٹھیک ہوجائے اور یہ لوگوں کو ڈرائے دھمکائے نہ تو یہ ساری کراچی سے 50-45 فیصد سے زیادہ سیٹیں نہیں جیت سکتے۔ یہ لکھ لیں۔ یہ الیکشن دن کا معامہ صرف نہیں، آدھی سے زیادہ دھاندلی یہ وؤٹر لسٹس، حلقہ بندیوں وغیرہ میں دو نمبری کے ذریعے الیکشن دن سے پہلے ہی کر لیتے ہیں۔

 


This part of argument is valid.



You have to understand that urdu speaking do support MQM without giving much consideration to the violent tactics or "ghunda gardi." In fact most see this as a plus point and as a safeguard for their community. MQM doesn't just have 'ghundas' but they also have common people who live and work among the people. They don't always get votes by force or compulsion. People do vote for them willingly in large numbers - yes, sometime they do force people to vote but the proportion of that is small. They don't really need that force or ghunda gardi to do some rigging but i think that they do just because they can but that doesn't have a big impact on the end result.

Once people do understand that MQM does get legitimate votes and try to understand the reasons behind it only then they will be able to counter their strategy. But if their rivals keep blaming all of MQM's electoral victories on rigging alone then there is no hope for their rivals like PTI which is a seasonal party in Karachi.
For the last few days in every TV show people were saying that MQM will win based on three reasons:
1- Muhajir Card
2- Karachi Sooba tehreek
3- Mazloomiyat due to operation.

I say all of these three points have a parent reason and that is:

The real grievances of people of Karachi. Until and unless these issues are not addressed and resolved, people will keep voting MQM.

And what are those grievances? You know better. No need to mention you at least. Thanks
 
you are contradicting your own point.

mqm ha done nothing on ground either for last 7 years. In fact if you take out mushi from the equation, mqm has not done anything for karachi in 30 years. PPP did nothing in sindh for the last 40 years and still won by biggest margin of all 70%. pmln has done nothing in punjab in last 35 years apart from 2 metro projects and 1 motorway but still won 45%.

What contradiction do you see?

I don't think I said that MQM gets votes based on their performance. If you read my post I had said that its the ethnic affiliation and the perception on the part of the Urdu speaking community that MQM will safeguard their interests. In fact I am making the point that nothing else matters - MQM's use of violence and intimidation doesn't affect the loyalty that their hard core voters and supporters feel for MQM. The thread starter is making the point that the recent operation and negative media attention, which had exposed some of the bad acts of MQM, has resulted in this win for MQM and I am arguing that its not the case. MQM will keep getting the votes in localities predominantly inhabited by Urdu speaking community. And, this happens because people do see MQM on the ground. They are not like JI or PTI which are seasonal parties in Karachi and you see them around mostly during election cycles.

People in pakistan do not vote based on performance except for pashtun. another advantage that pashtun have is that they cannot be forced to vote. a pathan would rather die than vote against his will so it is it is very difficult to rig an election in pashtun area through money or force. these 2 factors mean that KP has given a new party a chance irrespective of religion/ideology/ethnicity and if democracy continues in pakistan for another 25-30 years, KP will be the most developed province in pakistan.

I pretty much agree with what you said about the political awareness of the Pushtuns in KPK.
 
:lol:
ون سایڈ ڈ آپریشن کیا ہوتا ہے ؟؟ اور ٹو سایڈ ڈ آپریشن کیا ہوتا ہے ؟؟
جب مجرم جرم کرتا تو پولیس کروائی کو کتنے سایڈ ڈ کروائی کہتے ہیں ؟؟؟

تمہارے لیڈر پر تو برطانیہ میں بھی مقدمے بنے ہوے ہیں ، وہ کتنے سایڈ ڈ ہیں ؟؟

کرنے جرم اور قتل اور پھر سینہ زوری کہ ہم سیاست دان ہیں ہم مہاجر ہیں

 
Advertisement

سر جی آپکی بات جزوی طور پہ ٹھیک ہے لیکن پوری نہیں کیونکہ اگر ایم کیو ایم واقعی 100٪ ٹھیک طریقے سے جیتی تو:۔

یہ لوگ دو نمبر پریزایڈنگ افسر اور الیکشن سٹاف نہ لگواتے۔

یہ حلقہ بندی میں دو نمبری نہ کرتے

یہ ایک ایک گھر پہ 1200 وؤٹ درج نہ کراتے۔

یہ الیکشن کے دن اتنی غنڈہ گردی نہ کرے۔

یہ لوگوں کو ڈراتے دھماتے نہ۔

کے پی میں بھی جنرل الیکشنز بھی ہوئیں اور بلدیاتی بھی۔ بلدیات میں کچھ وجوہات کے بنا پہ بد انتظامی ہوئی لیکن کسی نے کسی سے زبردستی وؤٹ نہیں لیے، کسی نے حلقہ بندی پہ کچھ نہیں کہا، کسی نے وؤٹر لسٹ میں گڑبڑ کی شکایت نہیں کی وغیرہ وغیرہ۔

یہ سارے دو نمبری کے کام کراچی میں ہی کیوں ہوتے ہیں؟ یہ ایم کیو ایم ہی کیوں وؤٹرز لسٹس کے سروے اور حلقہ بندی پہ اتنا آسمان سر پہ اُٹھاتی ہے۔

یہ تو کہتے ہیں نا کہ انکے وؤٹر سب سے زیادہ تعلیم یافتہ ہے لیکن جب بائیو میٹرک کی بات آتی ہے سب سے زیادہ یہ چیختیں ہیں اور یہ دلیل دیتے ہیں کہ لوگوں ابھی تک اتنے تعلیم یافتہ نہیں ہوئے۔

اب پھر نتائج آنا بند ہوگئے۔ کیا کبھی آپ نے کے پی کے نتائج بند ہوتے دیکھے ہیں تو بتائے مجھے؟

میرے خیال میں اگر یہ سب کام ٹھیک ہوجائے اور یہ لوگوں کو ڈرائے دھمکائے نہ تو یہ ساری کراچی سے 50-45 فیصد سے زیادہ سیٹیں نہیں جیت سکتے۔ یہ لکھ لیں۔ یہ الیکشن دن کا معامہ صرف نہیں، آدھی سے زیادہ دھاندلی یہ وؤٹر لسٹس، حلقہ بندیوں وغیرہ میں دو نمبری کے ذریعے الیکشن دن سے پہلے ہی کر لیتے ہیں۔


That is exactly the point I was making that this insistence on part of supporters of JI and PTI that MQM can't win if the elections are fair and square.

Its been proven that MQM beats everyone handily when by all accounts the elections are free and fair. We saw that in NA 246 and then again in the LB elections.

I agree that MQM does indulge in vote rigging practices and that is part of their intimidation tactics. They want to be the only party in town and this way its helps them achieve that goal. In Pakistan lot of people do things just because they can get away with it. There are people who have gazillions but they still want to make more money using corrupt practices just because they can.

I am not sure what you are basing your analysis on that MQM will only win on 45-50% seats if the elections are completely free and fair. Unless you have some statistics to prove this its very hard to know what that figure will be. But by all accounts the elections overall are free and fair. Remember that PTI or JI didn't raise any issues with the election in NA 246.

people have to realize that JI has been rejected once and for all by the Karachiites. They will be there but they will never be the force that they claim to be. As for PTI there is nothing much that PTI has done to gain support of the people. As I said before holding rallies and jalsas just before elections can't get you elected.

I am not defending anything that MQM does or doesn't do that it should. I am not an MQM supporter but I know the reality on the ground and the sooner the PTI supporters see, realize and understand the reasons of their defeats in elections the better it will be for them. IK always realizes his mistakes after the fact. He admits to mistakes which make his party lose after the fact. But when it matters he is adamant that everything he is doing is great and no one knows better than him even when sane people are pointing out the obvious mistakes that he and his party makes.

All politics is local and unless you have a good ground game and show your presence in the localities then just hoping that IK's presence in Jalsas and rallies just before the elections will definitely not get you much votes.
 
For the last few days in every TV show people were saying that MQM will win based on three reasons:
1- Muhajir Card
2- Karachi Sooba tehreek
3- Mazloomiyat due to operation.

I say all of these three points have a parent reason and that is:

The real grievances of people of Karachi. Until and unless these issues are not addressed and resolved, people will keep voting MQM.

And what are those grievances? You know better. No need to mention you at least. Thanks

No one should kid around. The only reason for overwhelming support for MQM among urdu speaking community is that they feel that its the party that will somehow safeguard their interests given the tense and chaotic situation in Karachi. It wouldn't matter if the people see them killing their rivals or stuffing the ballot boxes - as long as they somehow perceive that MQM is representing them as a community.

Unless the demographic of the city change dramatically and unless somehow the ethnic tensions, divisions, mistrust, etc along with the feeling of discrimination and deprivation persists then MQM will keep wining.

Let me give an example - if in West Bank the tension and violence between the Palestinians and Jews continue then the Palestinians will keep supporting the Palestinian cause even if the Israelis build the best road system and other infrastructure facilities. People think that
 
O ghudoo ye mqm thuppa mafia ha inhoon ne kal jitni dhaandli ki ha tum punjaab walon ne wo khoab main bhi nai dekhi hogi. I m from karachi and know each and every technique of mqm thupp mafiya.
 
Look everyone huddles together for warmth and protection. but in mqm's case it has protection from the center government as all crooks are in line hence all are now huddling together for warmth. One sided, two sided, tri sided, quad sided and so forth. if center falls then where do you stand?