Advertisement

On Qaid E Azam's reason for two Nation Theory: Few Paras from the Book Jinnah to Zia

The two nation theory on which Mr. Jinnah founded his argument for Pakistan does not
require any explanation. Beverly Nichols who considered Mr. Jinnah as the most
important person in Asia says in his book "The Verdict on India" that in the course of an
interview with him, Mr. Jinnah had said that the Muslim case could be put in five
words "The Muslims are a nation", by reason of their history, their heroes, their art, their
architecture, their music, their laws and jurisprudence being different from those of the
Hindus. Questioned further whether he was thinking in terms of religion, his reply was
"Partly but by no means exclusively". On another occasion, he said "Islam is not only a
set of rituals, traditions and spiritual doctrines; Islam is a code for every Muslim, which
regulates his life and his conduct in all aspects, social, political, economic etc. It is based
on the highest principles of honor, integrity, fairplay and justice for all. One God,
equality and unity are the fundamental principles of Islam." (Fareed S. Jafri, "Pakistan's
Growth of Ideology"—VII, Pakistan Standard, January 30, 1955).
Thus two communities were face to face with fundamental differences between them.
As the authors of "Major Governments in Asia", Cornell University Press, remark at p. 377
of Chapter XLV of their book that "even though they lived together in one village and
might see each other every day of their lives, Hindus and Muslims were never part of
one community. They differed in religion, in morals, in diet, in dress, in education and
in family laws. They did not eat in one another's house and their children did not
intermarry. Under such circumstances, physical nearness bred suspicion, not
comradeship". The Hindu by his tradition, history, philosophy, law, deep rooted
prejudices, discrimination and intolerance stood quite apart from a Muslim. The great


traveler Alberuni, who spent several years in India, sat at the feet of the learned
Brahmahs to learn Sanskrit and Hindu beliefs and customs, and visited all the
important shrines to learn something more from them enumerates the differences
between the Hindus and the Muslims in their religious beliefs, modes of worship, social
behavior, customs, language and dress and comes to the conclusion that Hindus and
Muslims were two different peoples having nothing in common except that they lived
in the same country. On these differences was founded Quaid-i-Azam, M. A. Jinnah's

argument of two-nation theory.
It will be completely wrong to describe Mr. Jinnah as a
communalist. He had been a prominent member of the Congress since the start of his
career when he returned from England after completing his education and practicing
law for sometime there. That enchanting songstress of India, Sarojni Naidu, and many
others had described it as the harbinger, of Hindu-Muslim unity. In order to keep India
united in such a way as to save the Muslims from exploitation the Hindus he had
attended many Conferences, including Lord Wavel's Conference at Simla and the
Round Table Conference. Like many other persons he was a member of the Congress as
well as the Muslim League. And it was only when he found that the differences
between the Congress and the Muslim League were irreconcilable and the Muslims

were in real danger of losing their culture which meant their domination by the Hindu,
that he agreed to return from England in 1934 to lead the Muslim League in its struggle
with both the British Government and the Congress. His Lucknow Pact, 14-point
rejoinder to Nehru's Constitutional Reforms and his agreeing to discuss matters with
Gandhi, though nothing came out of this interview, all this shows that he was willing to
compromise if by so doing he could save the Muslim interests. The Lucknow Pact is
important in this that the Congress had agreed to separate electorates which amounted
to an admission that Muslims were a separate community and therefore the best course
for the British was to divide and quit.
When Indian Ministries were in office under the Government of India Act 1935 (1937-
1939), no Muslim was taken in the Ministry unless he abandoned the Muslim League
and joined the Congress. Dr. Ambedkar, spokesman of the untouchables, describes this
decision as "the political death of the Muslims as a free people." Having watched the
administration of these Congress ministries, the Quaid-i-Azam became more inflexible,
had the Lahore, Resolution passed by the Muslim League and in the subsequent critical
days he became so obdurate over the issue of Pakistan that the Congress and the
Viceroy, had to abandon all hopes of any change on his part. He was the President of
the Muslim League which was a virile and homogeneous body and the sole
representative of the Muslims. He was in a position to sway the Muslims in one way or
the other. Among the Hindus there were several capable leaders. "If Nehru diid there
was Rajgopalacharia or Patel to take his place. But if Jinnah goes there was no one to
replace him. And without him the League could completely run off the rails and charge

through India with fire and slaughter. But so long as Jinnah was there, nothing like that
would happen". (Beverly Nichols, "The Verdict on India").

From Jinnah to Zia by Muhammad Munir Chief Justice Pakistan (Retd.), Page 26
and
(Beverly Nichols, "The Verdict on India").
 
Advertisement
All these arguments can be destroyed in just one line!

We Pakistanis love to flock to West and want to live there if given a chance. Are West and we one nation as per the arguments given by thread starter?
 
In subcontinent we enjoy on same Music, same poetry, we share languages, blood, culture, food, thoughts and dress!

Our all food is curry base, our Music is one. All musical raagas were discovered/invented in this same land we share. Our climate is same our birds are same and our rivers flow across borders!
 
Advertisement
ان تازہ خداؤں میں بڑا سب سے وطن ہے
جو پیراہن ہے اس کا مذہب کا کفن ہے
​

You are right. But loving your home your tribe your colour created by God for your identification is not a crime.

Sir no-one asking you to not follow your religion.

Iqbal ne Tarana e Mili bhi likha . But it does not mean that non Muslim have no place to live in this world as entire world in far Muslims. It means this world is given to all Muslims and Non Muslims and all should live in it peacefully as its inhabitants
 
All these arguments can be destroyed in just one line!

We Pakistanis love to flock to West and want to live there if given a chance. Are West and we one nation as per the arguments given by thread starter?
Every one knows on forum that you are a notrious indian on this forum
Your comments not needed
 
Advertisement
All these arguments can be destroyed in just one line!

We Pakistanis love to flock to West and want to live there if given a chance. Are West and we one nation as per the arguments given by thread starter?
Christians and Jews are our cousins and are People of the book , we can eat their food and can intermarry.
 
Christians and Jews are our cousins and are People of the book , we can eat their food and can intermarry.

Yeah you can eat their pig drink their Alcohol. Worship Jesus as God!

Hindu food is more cleaner than Christians as per Islamic law no issue of Halal Haram (they mostly avoid meat) no issue of contamination of Pig or Alcohol in kitchen.

Even Hindu food is cleaner than food available in Muslim countries no-one knows whether animal was properly slaughtered or it was dead or even it was a Halal animal lol

Jews Worship Yahweh you Worship Allah

If Yahweh and Allah are same then Ashwar and Allah are same too

If Muslims can call Allah by the name of Khudha a Parsi name for God then Muslims can also call God by the name of Bhagwan/Eshwar / Waahguru.

If Muslims can call Salaat as Namaz a Parsi word for prayer. Then we can also call Salaat as Pratna, Naman, Namo etc

America and Russia are Christian nations while Europe is mostly Agnostic /Deist like Hindus
 
Last edited:
All these arguments can be destroyed in just one line!

We Pakistanis love to flock to West and want to live there if given a chance. Are West and we one nation as per the arguments given by thread starter?

Most of the Western countries are monotheistic and follow Abrahamic traditions, a far cry from the oppressive casts system.

As one scholar has aptly pointed out,
In the East, we have muslims but not Islam; while in the West, they have Islam but no muslims!!!
 
Most of the Western countries are monotheistic and follow Abrahamic traditions, a far cry from the oppressive casts system.

As one scholar has aptly pointed out,
In the East, we have muslims but not Islam; while in the West, they have Islam but no muslims!!!

A number of Hindu sects in India are also Monotheistic . Hindus are both Monotheistic and polytheistic.

If we combine the population of Hindu Monotheistic sects and Buddhists, Jains , Sikhs, Muslims and Christians in India then India is also majority monotheistic nation.

Same caste system in Pakistan as in India. No difference!
 
Advertisement
Yeah you can eat their pig drink their Alcohol. Worship Jesus as God!

Hindu food is more cleaner than Christians as per Islamic law no issue of Halal Haram (they mostly avoid meat) no issue of contamination of Pig or Alcohol in kitchen.

Even Hindu food is cleaner than food available in Muslim countries no-one knows whether animal was properly slaughtered or it was dead or even it was a Halal animal lol

Jews Worship Yahweh you Worship Allah

If Yahweh and Allah are same then Ashwar and Allah are same too

If Muslims can call Allah by the name of Khudha a Parsi name for God then Muslims can also call God by the name of Bhagwan/Eshwar / Waahguru.

If Muslims can call Salaat as Namaz a Parsi word for prayer. Then we can also call Salaat as Pratna, Naman, Namo etc

America and Russia are Christian nations while Europe is mostly Agnostic /Deist like Hindus
AlCOHOL and eating pig is not allowed in Bible and Torah
and who ever has to drunk they drink anyways as 90% Pakistani politicans do drink .


HINDus do the following things which muslims , Christian and jews cannot do.
HINDUS drink cow urine as their religious thing.
HINDUS widows do satti to women as their religious thing
Hindus widows have to wear certain cloths
Hindu women when on menstural cycle should be separated .
HiNDU women worship man penius which no religion do

hINDUS Dasis girls are left in mandirs for their gurus for life which no religion does .
 
Yeah you can eat their pig drink their Alcohol. Worship Jesus as God!

Hindu food is more cleaner than Christians as per Islamic law no issue of Halal Haram (they mostly avoid meat) no issue of contamination of Pig or Alcohol in kitchen.

Even Hindu food is cleaner than food available in Muslim countries no-one knows whether animal was properly slaughtered or it was dead or even it was a Halal animal lol

Jews Worship Yahweh you Worship Allah

If Yahweh and Allah are same then Ashwar and Allah are same too

If Muslims can call Allah by the name of Khudha a Parsi name for God then Muslims can also call God by the name of Bhagwan/Eshwar / Waahguru.

If Muslims can call Salaat as Namaz a Parsi word for prayer. Then we can also call Salaat as Pratna, Naman, Namo etc

America and Russia are Christian nations while Europe is mostly Agnostic /Deist like Hindus
You've been watching too many bollywood films man. Ask the muslims who live in India what the reality is. I doubt you've ever even met one.
 
AlCOHOL and eating pig is not allowed in Bible and Torah
and who ever has to drunk they drink anyways as 90% Pakistani politicans do drink .


HINDus do the following things which muslims , Christian and jews cannot do.
HINDUS drink cow urine as their religioys religious thing.
HINDUS do satti to women as their religious thing
HiNDU women worship man penius which nl religion do

hINDUS dasis are left in mandirs for their gurus for life which no religion does .

Now you claimed you know more of Bible and Tohra than Christians and Jews. For your kind information Alcohol is a part of Jewish and Christian religious services and festivals

Jews donot eat Pig while Christian reject the law (Tohra )part of bible as per Gospel

Hindus donot drink cow urine as of something Holy. Just few Hindus use it as remedy as prescribed by Ayurveda for treatment of few diseases . Some Muslim also drink urine of Camel for same reasons.

Satti was a medieval cultural thing only practiced by few rich and feudal Hindus of some parts of India. Now Hindus have banned it.

Yes some sects of Hindus have Dasi tradition. Dasi means maidservants of God and Hindus also have Das/Sadhus now you can see equality! Christian also have same tradition of Naans and celebrate priests!

You call it Penis while Hindus call it Lingam (Evidence of creation)

A lingam (Sanskrit: लिङ्गम्, IAST: liGga, lit. "sign, symbol or mark"), sometimes referred to as linga or Shiva linga, is an abstract or aniconic representation of the Hindu deity Shiva in Shaivism.[1] It is a votary symbol revered in temples, smaller shrines, or as self-manifested natural objects.[2][3] The lingam, which itself is phallic, is often represented within a lipped, disc-shaped platform called a yoni that symbolizes the goddess Shakti.[1][4]Lingayats wear a lingam inside a necklace, called Ishtalinga.[5][6]
Lingam is additionally found in ancient Sanskrit texts with the meaning of "evidence, proof",[7]

Reality is you too came in this world by the performance of lingam and Yoni. Do you deny this fact?
 
Advertisement
Now you claimed you know more of Bible and Tohra than Christians and Jews. For your kind information Alcohol is a part of Jewish and Christian religious services and festivals

Jews donot eat Pig while Christian reject the law (Tohra )part of bible as per Gospel

Hindus donot drink cow urine as of something Holy. Just few Hindus use it as remedy as prescribed by Ayurveda for treatment of few diseases . Some Muslim also drink urine of Camel for same reasons.

Satti was a medieval cultural thing only practiced by few rich and feudal Hindus of some parts of India. Now Hindus have banned it.

Yes some sects of Hindus have Dasi tradition. Dasi means maidservants of God and Hindus also have Das/Sadhus now you can see equality! Christian also have same tradition of Naans and celebrate priests!

You call it Penis while Hindus call it Lingam (Evidence of creation)

A lingam (Sanskrit: लिङ्गम्, IAST: liGga, lit. "sign, symbol or mark"), sometimes referred to as linga or Shiva linga, is an abstract or aniconic representation of the Hindu deity Shiva in Shaivism.[1] It is a votary symbol revered in temples, smaller shrines, or as self-manifested natural objects.[2][3] The lingam, which itself is phallic, is often represented within a lipped, disc-shaped platform called a yoni that symbolizes the goddess Shakti.[1][4]Lingayats wear a lingam inside a necklace, called Ishtalinga.[5][6]
Lingam is additionally found in ancient Sanskrit texts with the meaning of "evidence, proof",[7]

Reality is you too came in this world by the performance of lingam and Yoni. Do you deny this fact?
YOU Hindu always lie :)
 
You've been watching too many bollywood films man. Ask the muslims who live in India what the reality is. I doubt you've ever even met one.

I know life of Muslims in India is difficult especially after the rise of Bhagats but not as you think.

Now tell me how many Indian Muslims are migrating to Pakistan or Bangladesh?
 
I know life of Muslims in India is difficult especially of the rise of Bhagats but not as you think.

Now tell me how many Indian Muslims are migrating to Pakistan or Bangladesh?
Personally I know of one ! LOL Maybe if we had a open border for Indian muslims instead of treacherous Afghanis. Right now its easier to migrate to the west than it is for Indians to get a Pakistani visa.

But thats not the point and your whole argument is a strawman.
 
You are right. But loving your home your tribe your colour created by God for your identification is not a crime.

Sir no-one asking you to not follow your religion.

Iqbal ne Tarana e Mili bhi likha . But it does not mean that non Muslim have no place to live in this world as entire world in far Muslims. It means this world is given to all Muslims and Non Muslims and all should live in it peacefully as its inhabitants
جی بلکل، وطن، قوم، نسل، قبیلے کی محبت مذہب کی محبت کے تابع رہنی چاہے. سنت رسول صللھ علیہ وسلم اور اصحاب بھی یہی تعلیم دیتی ہے​
 
Personally I know of one ! LOL Maybe if we had a open border for Indian muslims instead of treacherous Afghanis. Right now its easier to migrate to the west than it is for Indians to get a Pakistani visa.

But thats not the point and your whole argument is a strawman.

But border with Bangladesh is porous one. How many of them are migrating there?

How many Indian Muslims are taking refuge in Arab kingdoms and Europe by claiming not being safe in India?

If Rohingia can reach Karachi then why not Indian Muslims?