Advertisement

No one wants to change but everyone demands change|Major overhaul planned at FBR

Today in Dawn, there is a story of FBR officials threatening strike if structural reforms are applied.

They are now on par with doctors, businesses and many others.

Pakistanis are always cheeping about tabdili kahan per hai, while every section of society is fighting tooth and nail so things dont change


ISLAMABAD: In a major shakeup, the government has decided to restructure the entire tax machinery and introduce centralised collection of general sales tax (GST) on services and goods.

The proposed measures were already approved by PM Imran Khan on Oct 3 with a restructuring plan to convert the incumbent Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) into Pakistan Revenue Authority (PRA) with a deadline of June 2020.

But, the proposed timeline did not go as planned as the Inland Revenue Service (IRS) chief commissioners opposed the move in a meeting held on Monday.A source privy to the meeting told Dawn that IRS officers will hold another meeting on Tuesday with the FBR chairman to appraise him about their concerns. Both tax groups — IRS and customs – have also warned to go on a pen down strike in case government did not change the proposed plan.

Documents seen by Dawn showed that under the proposal, Ministry of Finance will prepare a comprehensive framework for PRA and centralised GST collection on services by the PRA. These reforms are part of the World Bank-funded ‘Pakistan Raises Revenue Project’.

Board to be replaced by Pakistan Revenue Authority; PM wants plan completed by June 2020

On the issue of centralised collection of GST on services, it has been decided to constitute a joint committee comprising representatives from Ministry of Finance, the FBR and provincial revenue authorities to finalise a proposal.The finance ministry will work out the mechanism for the transfer of tax proceeds of GST on services to provinces.

The decision to collect GST at the centralised level was taken on the plea that the collection potential is not fully realised owing to the jurisdiction issues between the FBR and provincial authorities. Cross-provincial jurisdictional and conflict of interest issues also stifle GST collection on services.

The move is likely to meet with stiff resistance from the provinces on the basis of it being against the Constitution. Currently, sales tax on services is collected by the provincial revenue authorities in the wake of the 18th amendment.

In the meantime, it has been decided to reorganise the FBR headquarters on functional lines segregating IRS and customs into north and south zones. Two deputy chairmen for each IRS and customs are expected to be appointed by Nov 30.

Under proposed functional hierarchy, FBR chairman will lead the tax body along with two deputy chairmen — IRS and customs. Moreover, a separate secretary for Revenue Division with four additional secretaries to deal with policy issues—customs policy, income tax policy, sales tax and federal excise duty and international conventions, finance action will also be appointed.

In addition, the PRA will also have 12 members including customs member operations south and north and two more members for transit trade and exports; legal and accounts.
In case of the IRS, the PRA will have IR operation members south and north, taxpayer audit; legal and account whereas four other members will be responsible for human resource management and administration, strategic planning, facilitation and taxpayer education and chief management information officer. There will be 18 DGs in BS-21 in the reformed PRA.

As per the proposed plan, six DGs will assist custom members operations while another six will extend support to IRS members operation. Moreover, additional six DGs will be responsible for administration, audit, automation, vigilance, alternate disputes and revenue coordination.

It has also been decided to restructure the regional tax offices (RTOs), large taxpayers units (LTUs) and customs collectorates and district tax facilitation measures. The deadline for these reforms has been set at Dec 31.

Each RTO/LTU will comprise tax units based on the number or category of taxpayers with tax assessment wings and legal wing. The legal wing will operates directly under the order of member legal based at the FBR.

At the same time, model customs collectorate will have collector customs in BS-21 and collector legal in BS-21. Currently, customs collectors are in BS-20.

It has also been decided to appoint chief information management officer until Nov 30 to automate income tax architecture on the lines of customs WeBOC-Glo to minimise human interface in tax administration and collection. It was also decided to appoint chief executive of the PRA to expedite the process of automation.

Published in Dawn, November 5th, 2019

 
Last edited:
Advertisement
Advertisement
Yes they trusted munafiq nawaz and his daughter because they were accomplice in corruption.

The article is about structural reforms in FBR which is a state institute. I know it somehow burns your heart but Niazi is head of the state
they dont trust Niazi so not paying taxes
 
Most of them are slip of tonque , happens to all politicians
Now this is slip of character then? ?

Tyrian-White-Khan-With-Her-Mom-Dad-&-Step-Mom-&-Step-Brothers63027763_2015618112341.jpg
 
Advertisement
He is answerable to Almighty for this not me or you. Is this all you got, attack him personally ?
ohh ho ho ho......
Tu najaiz bachi ka poochna personal baat hai? ?
well your youthia friend mentions Qatari to Maryum then whats that?
 
Today in Dawn, there is a story of FBR officials threatening strike if structural reforms are applied..............
Published in Dawn, November 5th, 2019
Lol... InshaAllah Niazi would be PM for next 10 years..better find some otger job...kab tak Ferari ki job karo "gay"..????????...
But they all trust haramkhor zar-shar & company....afterall, birds of a feather flock together
Everyone wants a change that doesn't affect them.
Mr patwari were tou ever paid any tax ya phir baas iis mulk ko loota hi loota hai tum logon ne



I think the Govt may have to come up with some sort of outside the box solution to tackle this menace of resistance from all these mafia groups.
Like it or not.... the 3 pillars of the state the PM, the CJP and the COAS in the best interest of Pakistan should sit down together to have a threadbare discussion of the challenges the state is facing and how to confront them within the ambit of law. The CJP may take the lead and show some direction to the other two to take xyz route for x number of years under the legal coverage of the supreme court...... giving the govt extraordinary powers to do the cleansing once and for all. Whosoever tries to come in the way of change should be considered a candidate for liquidation. No more ifs and buts and any mercy.

Saamnay kee baat hai keh mulk hai tou govt, army aur SC hein aur agar mulk he nahi to phir kaisi govt, kaisi army aur kaisi supreme court???

Let's enter into a civil debate on this all important issue facing the country. Serious members on the forum please pitch in with your suggestions beyond party affiliations and divisions.
Yeh mulk sub ka saanjha aur apna he tou hai naa.
 
Advertisement
ohh ho ho ho......
Tu najaiz bachi ka poochna personal baat hai? ?
well your youthia friend mentions Qatari to Maryum then whats that?
Did you ever see me doing any personal attacks ? I keep my distance from personal attacks.
The only time i got personal was people having sympathy for kalsoom nawaz. My father died in Pakistan, he was a tax payer and was victim of poor health care system of this country. While these morons enjoy health care facilities of abroad and let average Pakistani die in poorly maintained public hospitals.

I feel pitty for people whose tax these people loot and then enjoy treatment abroad. They governed the country for 30 years and built no hospital that can treat them.
 
I think the Govt may have to come up with some sort of outside the box solution to tackle this menace of resistance from all these mafia groups.
Like it or not.... the 3 pillars of the state the PM, the CJP and the COAS in the best interest of Pakistan should sit down together to have a threadbare discussion of the challenges the state is facing and how to confront them within the ambit of law. The CJP may take the lead and show some direction to the other two to take xyz route for x number of years under the legal coverage of the supreme court...... giving the govt extraordinary powers to do the cleansing once and for all. Whosoever tries to come in the way of change should be considered a candidate for liquidation. No more ifs and buts and any mercy.

Saamnay kee baat hai keh mulk hai tou govt, army aur SC hein aur agar mulk he nahi to phir kaisi govt, kaisi army aur kaisi supreme court???

Let's enter into a civil debate on this all important issue facing the country. Serious members on the forum please pitch in with your suggestions beyond party affiliations and divisions.
Yeh mulk sub ka saanjha aur apna he tou hai naa.
The biggest hurdles are courts. Any structural change is challenged in courts and then stay order is granted. It then get stuck in court for years, btw it gets approved, if ever , it is way too late for the change proposed.

SC judges almost never inquire their fellow judges, they are one of the holy cows of our system. Judiciary in itself needs reforms. The process through which judges are chosen is absurd.
 
I think the Govt may have to come up with some sort of outside the box solution to tackle this menace of resistance from all these mafia groups.
Like it or not.... the 3 pillars of the state the PM, the CJP and the COAS in the best interest of Pakistan should sit down together to have a threadbare discussion of the challenges the state is facing and how to confront them within the ambit of law. The CJP may take the lead and show some direction to the other two to take xyz route for x number of years under the legal coverage of the supreme court...... giving the govt extraordinary powers to do the cleansing once and for all. Whosoever tries to come in the way of change should be considered a candidate for liquidation. No more ifs and buts and any mercy.

Saamnay kee baat hai keh mulk hai tou govt, army aur SC hein aur agar mulk he nahi to phir kaisi govt, kaisi army aur kaisi supreme court???

Let's enter into a civil debate on this all important issue facing the country. Serious members on the forum please pitch in with your suggestions beyond party affiliations and divisions.
Yeh mulk sub ka saanjha aur apna he tou hai naa.
The biggest hurdles are courts. Any structural change is challenged in courts and then stay order is granted. It then get stuck in court for years, btw it gets approved, if ever , it is way too late for the change proposed.

SC judges almost never inquire their fellow judges, they are one of the holy cows of our system. Judiciary in itself needs reforms. The process through which judges are chosen is absurd.
 
Did you ever see me doing any personal attacks ? I keep my distance from personal attacks.
The only time i got personal was people having sympathy for kalsoom nawaz. My father died in Pakistan, he was a tax payer and was victim of poor health care system of this country. While these morons enjoy health care facilities of abroad and let average Pakistani die in poorly maintained public hospitals.

I feel pitty for people whose tax these people loot and then enjoy treatment abroad. They governed the country for 30 years and built no hospital that can treat them.
Can you atleast say that youthia who do the personal attack are
Did you ever see me doing any personal attacks ? I keep my distance from personal attacks.
The only time i got personal was people having sympathy for kalsoom nawaz. My father died in Pakistan, he was a tax payer and was victim of poor health care system of this country. While these morons enjoy health care facilities of abroad and let average Pakistani die in poorly maintained public hospitals.

I feel pitty for people whose tax these people loot and then enjoy treatment abroad. They governed the country for 30 years and built no hospital that can treat them.
sir jee I feel what you are saying but Niazi govt lost its mojo in initial year of failed ecomonics