ISLAMABAD: In a detailed verdict, the Supreme Court (SC) on Monday said no new evidence were provided in the review petition against Aasia Bibi’s acquittal, ARY News reported.
“Since there are no new evidence in the review petition, therefore it (the petition) is rejected,” read the verdict.The court ruling said the petitioner had requested to form a larger bench, however there was no such need for it.A three-member bench headed by Chief Justice of Pakistan (CJP) Asif Saeed Khan Khosa and comprising Justice Qazi Faez Isa and Justice Mazhar Alam Miankhel had rejected the appeal after hearing arguments from the appellant’s lawyer.
“The appellant failed to prove flaws in the announced judgment,” ruled the chief justice. “There were clear contradictions in evidences and depositions.”
Justice Khosa also noted that the witnesses were oblivious to the real facts of the incident and made misstatements in court.
Case history
Last year, on Oct 31, a SC bench headed by former chief justice Mian Saqib Nisar set aside the conviction of Asia Bibi, a Christian woman condemned to death for blasphemy. The 56-page verdict overturned the Lahore High Court (LHC) verdict and directed authorities to release her from prison.Following her acquittal, protests had erupted across the country which continued for three days before being brought to an end with an agreement between the government and demonstrators.
Aasia Bibi, a mother of five, had been on death row since 2010 after she was convicted on charges of committing blasphemy during an argument with three Muslim women in Sheikhupura.
Her case drew the attention of international rights groups and swiftly became the most high-profile in the country.
No new evidence was provided lol.... You rejected all the evidences on international pressure... Rejected all the testimonies on ridiculous grounds....
He was so afraid that he refused to make an independent and larger bench free from his corruption.
Moreover, he said that the issue wasn't about islam, lol..... This idiot doesn't even know the importance of the honor and dignity of Prophet Muhammad صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم in islam....
All of those who were involved in this decision will be humiliated like Nawaz sharef after Mumtaz Qadri case....
The problem of pakistan is the secular and liberal judiciary, they could have constitued a larger bench to satisfy the religious majority but they opted to constitute a similar bench and reject review petition.... Shameful.
All the humiliation of imran khan came after this verdict.... The intensity will increase as the time passes..... Our establishment and government think western powers are all mighty, they have to bow down against their orders and wishes.... Soon Allah will show both of them who is the real Almighty
The problem of pakistan is the secular and liberal judiciary, they could have constitued a larger bench to satisfy the religious majority but they opted to constitute a similar bench and reject review petition.... Shameful.
Nothing would have satisfy the idiots in our country. You can make a bench of the best Muslim scholars in the world and still some idiot will jump out and say that all of this is sazish, she should be hanged.
Our Mullahs are sore losers, since they haven't achieved anything and are unable to achieve, they want this bloodshed to somehow provide themselves with self satisfaction that Islam won.
Spot on! Western technology pe baith k west ko gaalian nikalnaye walay suur ki aulaadein!
Aik urdu mein likha huwa verdict parh k khud se analyze tou kar nai sakte aur chale hein duniya pe hakumat krne! Khotaye k bachaye! :LOL::LOL::LOL::LOL:
Nothing would have satisfy the idiots in our country. You can make a bench of the best Muslim scholars in the world and still some idiot will jump out and say that all of this is sazish, she should be hanged.
Our Mullahs are sore losers, since they haven't achieved anything and are unable to achieve, they want this bloodshed to somehow provide themselves with self satisfaction that Islam won.
I read the original verdict and I knew that it will be very difficult for the petitioner to prove otherwise..
Even if Asia said something objectionable, it was not proved in the highest court by stupid Muslims who couldn't stick to their testimonies, while the non-Muslim woman continued to have the same stance throughout the case from the lower courts to the highest court..
Islamic verdicts are based on witnesses and testimonies.. nothing else.. In a Zina case, if there are four witnesses who have seen zina happening and they give their statements, but two of them say that the zina he saw took place in room A, while the other two say that the zina took place in room B, both statements/ testimonies will be rejected.. and there is a chance of punishment of 80 lashes to be given to all the four witnesses..
This is how Islamic law is. People say that they are die hard supporters of Muhammad PBUH and Islam, but they can't act on the rulings of Islamic law. Shame
Nothing would have satisfy the idiots in our country. You can make a bench of the best Muslim scholars in the world and still some idiot will jump out and say that all of this is sazish, she should be hanged.
Our Mullahs are sore losers, since they haven't achieved anything and are unable to achieve, they want this bloodshed to somehow provide themselves with self satisfaction that Islam won.
The problem with liberals is that they don't have matured brains to do the right analysis of the situation
Liberals are the real losers in pakistan, they are the ones getting science, commerce, economics, botany, medicine etc education even then they have achieved nothing.
They demand Molvis to take them to moon where they are the ones getting modern education...
Liberals are only good at criticizing molvis, cuz they have been programmed in this manner in elite schools.
Till the high court decision the narrative of enitre liberal swines was that she should be forgiven as she has apologized ...... The case against aasiya was so strong that salman taseer asked for presidential pardon, he didn't opt to fight it in the Supreme court.
It was a fabricated judgement, we all know saqib nisar was a puppet cheif justice. He himself appointed the lawyer of aasiya maloon....
I read the original verdict and I knew that it will be very difficult for the petitioner to prove otherwise..
Even if Asia said something objectionable, it was not proved in the highest court by stupid Muslims who couldn't stick to their testimonies, while the non-Muslim woman continued to have the same stance throughout the case from the lower courts to the highest court..
Islamic verdicts are based on witnesses and testimonies.. nothing else.. In a Zina case, if there are four witnesses who have seen zina happening and they give their statements, but two of them say that the zina he saw took place in room A, while the other two say that the zina took place in room B, both statements/ testimonies will be rejected.. and there is a chance of punishment of 80 lashes to be given to all the four witnesses..
This is how Islamic law is. People say that they are die hard supporters of Muhammad PBUH and Islam, but they can't act on the rulings of Islamic law. Shame
Spot on! Western technology pe baith k west ko gaalian nikalnaye walay suur ki aulaadein!
Aik urdu mein likha huwa verdict parh k khud se analyze tou kar nai sakte aur chale hein duniya pe hakumat krne! Khotaye k bachaye! :LOL::LOL::LOL::LOL:
Liberal suwar modern education hasil kar key bhe kuch nahe kar paey..... Na koe dhang ki university bana paey, na research main nam bana paey , na koe chez ijad kar paey....
Siwaey ulma peh bhook nay k in banj logoun k pass kuch nahe.....
Pechlay 20 saal say mulk main liberaloun ki hukmarani hai, mulk ka kya haal kardiya.... Jootay chat chat k angrezoun ki in ki zabanain ghis gae phr bhe kuch hasil nahe howa
You can't change the rules because of what you think is correct.. Everyone will start asking for a larger bench.. Courts must have been provided with the appropriate supports to make the application of larger court successful..
Pechlay 20 saal say mulk main liberaloun ki hukmarani hai, mulk ka kya haal kardiya.... Jootay chat chat k angrezoun ki in ki zabanain ghis gae phr bhe kuch hasil nahe howa
She was contesting it from the beginning.. The thing is, when her lawyer cross questioned the witnesses, they lost the plot seriously.. they couldn't give similar statements. Now you should blame judges and Asia on their departure from the truth (I don't want to use the word that they were liars, but what else I should call two people, one of whom says that the meeting happened under a tree and the other one said the meeting was organized in a home of flaan flaan..
You can't change the rules because of what you think is correct.. Everyone will start asking for a larger bench.. Courts must have been provided with the appropriate supports to make the application of larger court successful..
Lol this was a sensitive case, whole country was jammed for 2 days, they did not even consider the petition.... Let alone setting up a neutral bench...
You are calling it a justice cuz it satisfies you , up until th e high court the decision was cruel..... Lol..
Do you really think he is talking based on facts or emotion?
He just now called CJP's of Paksitan puppet of international forces, because he personally didn't like the decision.
He has no clue what the Islam or the law says about it, just wanted to see some bloodshed and go out on streets and chant Allah u Akbar. As if it was a victory of some sort.
Then according to Islamic law, the testimony can't be used to give capital punishment.. it's very simple my dear friend.. This is such an important matter and a matter of life and death for someone and the people couldn't remember where the meeting took place.. or how many people were there or how the accused was brought to the meeting place.. come on man.. don't make mockery of the Islamic law.. We have the best system of accepting and rejecting witnesses.. and you are saying that since the crowd couldn't recall the words, or the meeting place, still the accused should be given the capital punishment? You are seriously giving a bad name to Islamic justice system.