His stats may be better, but its beyond absurd to compare his captaincy skills to IK. IK groomed an entire generation of cricketers. Misbah cant claim to have mentored even one.
What is need for comparison any way? Both served the same country and both have done an excellent job under different circumstances. One has won us world cup and other has achieved top position in test ranking. Both are greats. You start comparing when you are jealous of one.
People who call Misbah a great captain have no clue about cricket. Winning only on the dead wickets of Abu dhabi and becoming no 1 team for few days does not make some one a great captain .