Advertisement

Manhaj Ul Quran a new Lal Masjid? Stop this non sense of INQILLAAB!!

Just wanted to follow up with you on this matter:

Now that Rana Sanaullah has been sacked, we can safely assume that the top leadership is not satisfied at what has transpired. In fact, I think Rana Sanaullah would have also been dismayed at all this, but the axe had to fall to control the damage.

Note, though, that slowly but surely PML-N is falling apart. The establishment is playing a damn good game here. I am expecting Chaudhry Nisar and a few others to abandon ship very soon.

I guess as in true Pakistani fashion we will never know the truth. We will all be speculating as did our parents about major events in our history. We are never able to ascertain who was responsible for major debacles or failures in our history.

I think you are right that any one of the scenarios you listed below are a possibility. Though I would think that it could be a mix of scenario 1 and 3.

Given the way things work and the mindless rhetoric coming out of the PMLn camp it seems to me that it surely is scenario 1 with some support of PMLn's top tier leadership's involvement.

It seems to me that everyone in Pakistan is trigger happy - literally. From media to judiciary to politicians to military, all seem to overreact.

We heard a lot about how PMLn has matured and have learned its lessons and its leadership is more mature or has more self-belief and self-confident and how they have come to realize the value of true democracy. As most people have come to realize it seems that it was a just a charade. They are still the good ole PMLn. They have not learned a thing. You could blame Zardari for being Zardari as he had no history of being in the government and politics but Sharifs have been around and should have learned their lessons.

I agree with your observation about the military dictating the policy especially with whats on the horizon for Afghanistan. The question is when have they not dictated the foreign policy in Pakistan. They have always had the veto power when it came to anything on our eastern or western fronts. I am a very strong critic of the diproportionate role of the military in Pakistan - both on foreign and domestic fronts - but I believe that it will take time and some hard work by the politicians to check that influence. They could only do it by strengthening the civilian institutions and strengthening democracy and avoid events like the one in Lahore yesterday.

I have to confess that I was one of those who earnestly believed that PMLn would be better this time around but as it has been proven in Pakistan before you can't ever trust what these politicians tell you. Especially the politicians who have vested interests. Just look at the way the 'principled' politician like Achakzai has changed his tune recently. There seems to be a price for every politician in this country and this is a sad reflection on our state of affairs.

Almost all of our leaders are demagogues.
 
Just wanted to follow up with you on this matter:

Now that Rana Sanaullah has been sacked, we can safely assume that the top leadership is not satisfied at what has transpired. In fact, I think Rana Sanaullah would have also been dismayed at all this, but the axe had to fall to control the damage.

Note, though, that slowly but surely PML-N is falling apart. The establishment is playing a damn good game here. I am expecting Chaudhry Nisar and a few others to abandon ship very soon.

I think you are right. It seems that all is not well inside PMLn camp at the moment.

Sanaullah's resignation is a sign that we may have turned the corner or it may just turn out to be a one-off. This has not happened in Pakistan recently - someone is being held accountable for their actions. I only listened to SS' press conference briefly and with all his antics to come across as contrite he also had a defiant tone. Seems that this resignation may have been forced upon PMLn.

The establishment may be playing their games here but seems that PMLn is responsible for shooting itself in the foot.

I am just thinking about how the Murtaza Bhutto killing would have played out if we had all this wall-to-wall coverage back in the day.