Advertisement

Kargil , operation was rejected by Leghari but in comparison alertness level of Nawaz and Imran is

People say that The kargil plan was not a brand new plan , it was first presented for approval from President Farooq Leghari. Leghari questioned the concerned quarters about foreign exchange reserves of Pakistan and he asked military about ammunition reserves , after finding them unsatisfactory , he forbade the operation because Leghari knew about repercussions . When at much later time period Nawaz Sharif was presented with some operational details ,they say they were of some other operation ,but as PM and that too a Kashmiri he should have known about the operation from other sources .

This reminds me of Imran khan who claims he did not know about Zarb e Azb , he is running province and he claims he did not know , the whole world says that Taliban relocated in advance and thus knew of operation . May be at least two three divisions were moved ,but there is no sensor of Imran sahib to detect it despite handpicked CM.

This does not augur well for Imran and makes him look like a less than alert person and his CM in KPK as charsi . An alert politician should know in advance , his duty was to anticipate IDP. If Imran thinks he can put blame of hungry IDP on Nawaz he is mistaken , his claimed non knowledge of operation and his lack of preparation makes him look like a fool .

Imran graph is going down but he still is the most favourite contender for PM slot in public . He has to be serious , you do not miss convocations if you are a chacellor of a british university , you cannot curse a PM or Army chief for starting operation in summer if militants are hitting planes in summer .

PM it seems will have to remove Irfan siddiqui and such like doves , as such high offices cannot be filled by such people if military secrecy is a consideration .

Already Army chief rejected the request of PM to remove ISI chief when ISI Geo issue strated and Ibrahim son of Mir Shakeel has to contend with only being a constant Raiwind guest to lick his wounds .
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Advertisement
ur saying as if imran knew few days ago it wouldve been fine.. thats not the case

of course when we know.. imran also knew

what imran khan is saying that the govt should have included them in the planning.. months ahead...because preparations for IDPs cannot be done in days .. it needs months...
 
[Qchief tz00007;2542376]ur saying as if imran knew few days ago it wouldve been fine.. thats not the case

of course when we know.. imran also knew

what imran khan is saying that the govt should have included them in the planning.. months ahead...because preparations for IDPs cannot be done in days .. it needs months...[/QUOTE]


A chief minister can know of abnormal troops movement at least three weeks in advance for an operation of such a scale , CM have funds in tens of crores to at least host the first wave of refugees by themselves . Imran like Nawaz cannot be forgiven for IDP issue bungling . The barbers of waristan were inundated with those wishing a haircut weeks before operation .
 
Advertisement
Vibes of impending operation have been going on for couple of years now BUT they were just vibes. The timing of the operation was worst possible (in summers during Ramazan). Things like these are properly planned and executed and all stake holders are taken into account, provincial or any other government don't act on insinuations. You draw parallels with Kargil operation, well the air & naval chiefs didn't know about it, will you call them stupid and idiots too.

What a dumb and pathetic post. You also seriously need to work on your English and being coherent. It is not required that you make every random thought into a thread.
 
[Qchief tz00007;2542376]ur saying as if imran knew few days ago it wouldve been fine.. thats not the case

of course when we know.. imran also knew

what imran khan is saying that the govt should have included them in the planning.. months ahead...because preparations for IDPs cannot be done in days .. it needs months...


A chief minister can know of abnormal troops movement at least three weeks in advance for an operation of such a scale , CM have funds in tens of crores to at least host the first wave of refugees by themselves . Imran like Nawaz cannot be forgiven for IDP issue bungling . The barbers of waristan were inundated with those wishing a haircut weeks before operation .[/QUOTE]
Sheikh sb build up was there long before talks started so its not unusual but this is ignorance nothing more that they exclude kpk govt before attacking
 
[QUOattacks ur.javed;2542607]Vibes of impending operation have been going on for couple of years now BUT they were just vibes. The timing of the operation was worst posIndian interferen(in summers during Ramazan). Things like these are properly planned and executed and all stake holders are taken into account, provincial or any other government don't act on insinuations. You draw parallels with Kargil operation, well the air & naval chiefs didn't know about it, will you call them stupid and idiots too.

What a dumb and pathetic post. You also seriously need to work on your English and being coherent. It is not required that you make every random thought into a thread.[/QUOTE]

The military operations are done to give surprise otherwise casualties of attaching side multiplies , Pak army generally plans diversionary operations near monsoon as indian interference becomes less likely owing to swollen rivers .Despite all this the opposite party knew and fled in advance . As we have no stakes for our professional advancement via PPP, PMLN or PTI so we are free to point the errors which vested interest do not want .

The attacks on airport in summer cannot have response in winter . What to talk of discomforts , the ancient empires slaughtered entire communities for supporting militancy much less than by TTP.

I suggest you read a few books on military history and befriend some experienced military men to explain things .
 
The military operations are done to give surprise otherwise casualties of attaching side multiplies , Pak army generally plans diversionary operations near monsoon as indian interference becomes less likely owing to swollen rivers .Despite all this the opposite party knew and fled in advance . As we have no stakes for our professional advancement via PPP, PMLN or PTI so we are free to point the errors which vested interest do not want .

The attacks on airport in summer cannot have response in winter . What to talk of discomforts , the ancient empires slaughtered entire communities for supporting militancy much less than by TTP.


I suggest you read a few books on military history and befriend some experienced military men to explain things .
Vibes of impending operation have been going on for couple of years now BUT they were just vibes. The timing of the operation was worst possible (in summers during Ramazan). Things like these are properly planned and executed and all stake holders are taken into account, provincial or any other government don't act on insinuations. You draw parallels with Kargil operation, well the air & naval chiefs didn't know about it, will you call them stupid and idiots too.

What a dumb and pathetic post. You also seriously need to work on your English and being coherent. It is not required that you make every random thought into a thread.
 
Advertisement
The military operations are done to give surprise otherwise casualties of attaching side multiplies , Pak army generally plans diversionary operations near monsoon as indian interference becomes less likely owing to swollen rivers .Despite all this the opposite party knew and fled in advance . As we have no stakes for our professional advancement via PPP, PMLN or PTI so we are free to point the errors which vested interest do not want .

The attacks on airport in summer cannot have response in winter . What to talk of discomforts , the ancient empires slaughtered entire communities for supporting militancy much less than by TTP.


I suggest you read a few books on military history and befriend some experienced military men to explain things .
I agree with u but what was wrong if they talk to CM kpk that get ready this about to happen
 
I agree with u but what was wrong if they talk to CM kpk that get ready this about to happen
There are some people in Islamabad who claim that kpk CM is an actual drug addict , may be this is one reason for not taking him into confidence , but then of course Hamayun and Jehangir were also opium addicts.So may be being smaller chars addiction can be forgiven for statehood along with incompetency . if there need not be medical examination including sanity or mental health assessment for judiciary ,there need not be urine testing for KPK CM , let all these assessments be reserved for the athletes who run from point A to B .
 
Last edited: