First step to prove in the judgement would have been to substantiate that the petitioners had a prima facie evidence that an offence has been committed. Mr. khosa's remarks does not
mention or avoids to mention anything like that. Mr. Khosa depended on all what was being said in the media and did not base on matters of fact or trustworthy evidence. To give a dissenting judgement, he must have analysed the documentary evidence which was produced by the respondents which he did not. Should he was to derive inference to the contrary, he must straight away have gone for an independent commission or given benefit of doubt to the respondents. His reference to a noval quotation shows he has tried to give a moral rather than a legal judgement. He looks like Nazir Naji, Mobashar Luqman, an ARY analyst, an abuser of siasat.pk, or an editor of a biased news paper rather than a Supreme Court judge. In fact, he has attempted to further destabilize the politics in the country.To my opinion he was biased to the respondents in the entirety of his minority remarks. He has misused his position as a judge of the Supreme Court and a reference must be filed against him in the supreme Judicial Council.
First step to prove in the judgement would have been to substantiate that the petitioners had a prima facie evidence that an offence has been committed. Mr. khosa's remarks does not
mention or avoids to mention anything like that. Mr. Khosa depended on all what was being said in the media and did not base on matters of fact or trustworthy evidence. To give a dissenting judgement, he must have analysed the documentary evidence which was produced by the respondents which he did not. Should he was to derive inference to the contrary, he must straight away have gone for an independent commission or given benefit of doubt to the respondents. His reference to a naval quotation shows he has tried to give a moral rather than a legal judgement. He looks like Nazir Naji, Mobashar Luqman, an ARY analyst, an abuser of siasat.pk, or an editor of a biased news paper rather a Supreme Court judge. In fact, he has attempted to further destabilize the politics in the country.To my opinion he was biased to the respondents in the entirety of his minority remarks. He has misused his position as a judge of the Supreme Court and a reference must be filed against him in the supreme Judicial Council.
Justice khosa didn't base his judgement based on Media, but based on speeches in Parliament and to the nation(let alone the stance he had in public all these month/years regarding the flats) which are and should be considered as official statement from a Person On such a High Position. Now I am not sure about you, but I don't want my PM to lie about things in Parliament or in his Official speech to the nation. A person was asked about flats of Children. And the official replies(in Parliament and in the speech from the nation) were against the replies submitted in court(Qatari letter). And so based on this he was considered as dishonest and rightly so..
@miafridi A statement or a document becomes legally actionable when the maker is given a right of defence in the court. The deposer repeats it before the court and clarifies it in response to court questions or cross examination by the opposite party. Further statements in the parliament are not challengeable at any legal forum. The PM has not been allowed any such rights. Mr. Khosa has violated the Evidence Law and interpreted the statement unilaterally and what-ever the way he wanted to do it.
I think this judgement was not written by the judges themselves but a rival of a the PM and the judges have just signed it.