Advertisement

Jinnah made a mistake and I am ashamed of being Pakistani! By Mahwash Badar Published: May 12, 2014

Note: I do not endorse this view but was so appalled that I felt I had to share even though I was advised to the contrary.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Anyone who has ever travelled abroad will tell you that no matter where you go, no matter how developed the country it is that you’re travelling to – if you’re a British national or a Caucasian American, the doors become friendlier. The security becomes less pressurising. Visa queues are shorter. Procedures are simpler.

If you’re a brown Pakistani man (or even woman) who is travelling to another country – that’s a whole other story. You’re working in the Middle East, chances are your salary is just a little bit above the basic working wage – or anything that will get you a bed-space with seven other human beings. Respect is minimal. You’re not supposed to ruffle any feathers. Or demand for rights. Your children are thousands of miles away studying (because you can’t afford education for them here), your wife probably has another job to help make ends meet and your job squeezes every drop of your blood into a tiny container that helps build the skyscrapers and that little container is thrown away quicker than you can say ‘burj’, as soon as your company decides to say bye bye.


Pretty much the equivalent of… well, I don’t know. What is that the equivalent of? What analogy do I draw to represent the utter misery that is being a Pakistani in this super-power dominated world?


As if the current state of the country, what with its years of dictatorship and lack of infrastructure, hasn’t driven us insane enough, there is the added bonus of inviting religious extremists and letting them destroy everything we hold near and dear. Sure, apologists will reason it saying “this is not true Islam” and whatnot. But my question is when – seriously – when do we set aside the debate of what is true Islam and what isn’t?


Let the clerics and the religious scholars sit in their mosques and minibars – oh I meant minbars. But once and for all, eliminate and annihilate the savage, beastly, cowardly, immoral men who buy the bodies of fragile, poverty-stricken, desperate men, strap them with explosives and send them into markets with innocent women and children. Finish these abhorrent elements in the society that attempt to throw us back to the Stone Age.


A recent article in the New York Times reported on the World Health Organisation (WHO) declaration of the polio emergency in Pakistan.


Last year, a polio worker was killed in Peshawar, as well as another who was shot dead in Khyber Agency. Several were kidnapped in Bara. In January this year, gunmen killed three health workers taking part in a polio vaccination drive in Karachi. Not Kabul. Not Sierra Leone. Not Riyadh. Karachi. My heart boils and burns as more devastating news and reports flood the channels. The New York Times article further stated that according to a report, the highest refusal rates for polio vaccination were recorded in wealthy neighbourhoods of Karachi because they had “little faith in public health care”. In North Waziristan, the Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) have forbidden vaccinations since years. Pakistan thus has 59 polio cases to report, the most of any in the world.


Being a mother, it scares me. It keeps me awake at night. It reminds me that even if I run far far away from the borders of my own land, its demons will continue to haunt me and my future generations. I Google ‘Pakistan’ on the news and everything that is reported is about death, destruction, squabbling politicians, ailing children, extremists blowing up things and a struggling economy.


I raise my eyes to our neighbouring country and see what could have happened if we were still a United India. Maybe we would have been polio free too. We would have been a unified part of a process of being the world’s next big force to reckon with. Of being a part of the next blazing economy.


I find myself deeply wishing that Jinnah hadn’t made this mistake – that he had thought about the future of Pakistan. He didn’t think of the obscurantist mindset that he had propelled forward, the countless millions that died at the hand of this vague agenda that fails to unite us as a nation. I look at the years of struggles that Pakistan faces, the fall of Dhaka, the provincial wars, the stark separatist mindsets and I wonder what Mr Jinnah was thinking when he decided to leave the Indian National Congress (INC).


We share more with our Indian brothers than our ancestral DNA. Our food, language, clothes, lifestyles are more like them than the Arabs we so badly want to mimic and ape. I stare at the green passport with the same self-loathing as the fat 16-year-old girl with pimples on her face who is told that she cannot get married because she will always be blind, diseased and fat and her elder, stronger, prettier, better-educated sister will snag all the good catches because she ended up with the better caretaker after the divorce of their parents.


I am ashamed of being a Pakistani today. I am ashamed that I belong to a country that kills human rights lawyers and sitting governors, and issues death threats to university professors. I am ashamed that we believe in spaghetti monster theories and pie in the sky conspiracies and risk the future of our children. I am ashamed that we have rejected our scientists just because they believe in a different dogma. I am ashamed that we cannot protect our women, we cannot protect our children and we cannot protect our men from the evil that is extremism, fundamentalism and the foolhardy idea that Pakistan is a great nation.


Pakistan is a fledgling, flailing state. And those 59 children, whose legs can never work anymore, the family of Raza Rumi’s driver, those who shed tears for Salman Taseer, for Perveen Rehman, for Rashid Rehman, for Dr Murtaza Haider and his 12-year-old son – every single person who went out to have a normal day and never made it home alive – are all paying the price of the empathy, respect and awe YOU show cowards like Mumtaz Qadri.


So, to every single person who defends their patriotism blindly and their religion with a bullet, I hope you know exactly whose side you are on. I hope you sleep well at night knowing that you are on the side of the murderers.

http://blogs.tribune.com.pk/story/22231/jinnah-made-a-mistake-and-i-am-ashamed-of-being-pakistani/
 
Last edited:
Advertisement
aapka kia hy kal keh do gay k naaozobillah ALLAH made a mistake to create humans, they are killing eachother
therbaby borne tomorrow after 20 years he will going to call his father that you made mistake why did you marry my mum she is not good mother
 
Advertisement
Mahwash Badar, Your parents are also ashamed on the SiN of giving birth to you.

By the way, I think , your only shame is that you are brown. And those who are ashamed on themselves, don't belong anywhere, except in pile of dung.

We aren't ashamed of anything what so ever. We do feel sorry. But this is how things work.

Since your are too ashamed to be a brown and i am damn sure, very proud of being out of Pakistan, can you please do us a favor, and give us a lecture on the following topics of west;

Alarming Rate of Pedophile
Underage Prostitution
Deteriorating Govt Education System
Different law for Rice & Poor
Teenage Deaths due to Narcotics
Alarming Rise in ******* Childs
Forced Labor of Kids (they call it dignity of work, if a kid is selling newspaper in Europe, after school, but same is child labor in Pakistan)
And the list goes on.
 
Its not Jinnah who made mistake ,its our corrupt and selfish leaders who brought us to this situation.It doesnt matter if u Indian ,Pakistani or Bangladeshi world consider us same,Pakistanis is just under microscope because of 9/11 and afghan war.Nation like british ,german ,french ,American all have long history they all went through more worst time and finally became proper nations.Their are other countries who are not Muslims their situation is not different than Pakistan we should also compare them.
 
What a horrible reasoning. Blame Pakistan and it's Founder Jinnah, because of our own short comings. Amazingly childish explanation. Finding escape goat is easy and better to put fault on someone else rather then taking the charge.

We ourselves are responsible for the degradation of our Society. We have Mir Jaffer's among our selves. We as an Individual have to take responsibility with what goes around in our community.

I want to write more, but my blood is boiling after reading the reasoning given so I have to put my pen down.
 
Tis guy or gal they are indian taots and they pretend to be pakistani and bringing up things that touches the heart and by doing this even if it effects only one person they got their objective because that person will start spreading their words and starts to effect other peopl. So I request admin please block these type of people I think thia will not effect freedom of speech. As these people are spreading haterate against the country.
 
Advertisement
So what?
Is this extremism only our eggs? Let the incumbent terrorist rest in uk hell, what do you say about propaganda generated against Pak Atomic facilities and advocating the cause of taliban and enabling them to fight Russia? It was USA who flooded Pak with guns (mischieveously given to taliban).
These pro-women rights state and liberal are helping these terrorist who blew our people and helping those terrorist who blew Syrian people. Emotional words can make you a good writer of women digests but not a leader visionary.
We are fighting against these things. we are working to eliminate this status qou. we are generating another party to manufacture a newer Pakistan better and stable.
 
"I am ashamed of being a Pakistani today. I am ashamed that I belong to a country that kills human rights lawyers and sitting governors, and issues death threats to university professors."


NO need to be F88ken smart A88. If you are ashamed of you nationality go F your self and take this F88iken ***** RONA some where else. Better move to INDIA where your DNA is. A**hole.

I'm in these countries for the last 30 years and never felt ashamed of my Heritage.
 
What a horrible reasoning. Blame Pakistan and it's Founder Jinnah, because of our own short comings. Amazingly childish explanation. Finding escape goat is easy and better to put fault on someone else rather then taking the charge.

We ourselves are responsible for the degradation of our Society. We have Mir Jaffer's among our selves. We as an Individual have to take responsibility with what goes around in our community.

I want to write more, but my blood is boiling after reading the reasoning given so I have to put my pen down.
The intention of posting this here was to sow how some of us think. It doe not reflect my opinion................. It seem sI had to clarify that going by the dislikes this post received.
So, dont shoot the messenger. I actually came to know of this today as it was posted by a zionist troll on a blog else where and promoted by our neighbors.
What i dotn get is what the heck are pakistanis doing in pakistan? too busy watching TV and not taking these self haters to task?
 
Tis guy or gal they are indian taots and they pretend to be pakistani and bringing up things that touches the heart and by doing this even if it effects only one person they got their objective because that person will start spreading their words and starts to effect other peopl. So I request admin please block these type of people I think thia will not effect freedom of speech. As these people are spreading haterate against the country.
Every one have right to his views what ever he think and feel and same way we cannot paint every one as indian tout .I met lot of pakistanis both in Pakistan and abroad who think same some are not happy because they had to migrated from their homelands and sacrificed too many lives ,brothers ,sisters, mother and father slaughtered and raped in front of them and when they arrived here it was like fire to fry pan.But same time we forget as a nation we never thought we are pakistani we are divided sindhi,balochi, punjabi ,pathan ,mahajir we not want to get mixed with each other we prefer to inter marry within own ethnicity and castes
 
Advertisement
I am Pakistani living abroad... I lived in middle east and USA and never felt ashamed. Indians are getting lesser than Pakistanis in middle east. In US it doesnt matter as the structure is alyogether different
.
i am proud of my country and people as with such low resources we have educated and trained the world class human capital.
.
To be fair i sometimes feel bad due to visa regulations in some countries but these regulations are for all countries except few.
.
Many nationalities are facing worst racism in many countries. Infact in middle east Pakistanis are far better than many countries and in US either you see an edicated well settled Pakistani or not at all.
.
 
The intention of posting this here was to sow how some of us think. It doe not reflect my opinion................. It seem sI had to clarify that going by the dislikes this post received.
So, dont shoot the messenger. I actually came to know of this today as it was posted by a zionist troll on a blog else where and promoted by our neighbors.
What i dotn get is what the heck are pakistanis doing in pakistan? too busy watching TV and not taking these self haters to task?

see post # 10.


You are intentionally spreading filth.

If you find **** in the street, do you take it home to show it to your family????
 
By observing the recent (since ca. 2006) trends in English newpapers' blogs, I am sure there is a huge effort being spent on anti-Pakistan propaganda (Pakistani identity, i.e. the sense of being a Pakistani), especially if you look at the comments on every article/blog, almost 90% of the comments' writers are Indians.
... and ...
the malnutritioned tiny-mini indians forget (while posting the **** on blogs/forums) whatever filth is piled up in their own homeland
:lol:
 
Advertisement
What a loads of BS. When it comes to Pakistan bashing Tribune, Dawn and The News are exactly the same.

IF tomorrow I write an honest and full of proofs article against Nawaz Sharif, none of them would publish it.
This is the reality of Pakistan journalism. They can print the full nauseating crap, but would not print something which is fully backed up wtih facts, proofs and supporting arguments.
 
I worked in a top semiconductor manufacturing company in the US. There are 13,000 employees. Many are from India. I found most of them mentally sick and full of inferiority complex. Never found them worthy of a super power and rightly so that bubble has busted.

and they stink.
 
What a ghatya aurat. Inferiority complex ki maaari. Identity crisis mein he.
Well you should first be ashamed of being a human cuz people with a mentality like you do not deserve to be called humans.
They aint able to do something themselves, just sitting on their stinky asses behind computers and just hate themselves. Mental disorder, some kind of paranoia.
What you can do is to throw your useless existence in a trash can, cuz people like you are such a pain in the *** that they need some kind of therapy.
Hate your self. We other pakistanis are proud to be what we are.
And do not need people like you to tell stories about how loosers like you hate yourself.
Go and jump from a high building with your head first and make an end to your pathetic looser life lolz
 
You are intentionally spreading filth.

If you find **** in the street, do you take it home to show it to your family????
it has already been promoted, trust me. some times **** needs to be exposed as well.
 
The intention of posting this here was to sow how some of us think. It doe not reflect my opinion................. It seem sI had to clarify that going by the dislikes this post received.
So, dont shoot the messenger. I actually came to know of this today as it was posted by a zionist troll on a blog else where and promoted by our neighbors.
What i dotn get is what the heck are pakistanis doing in pakistan? too busy watching TV and not taking these self haters to task?

Please do not think that my critique was towards you. In your Original Post, you have written that it was not written by you and copying someone's else Blog to discuss. My apologies if my post gave the wrong impression.