Advertisement

Indiana woman who said she had a miscarriage convicted of feticide

Patel came from a conservative Hindu family who looked down on sex outside marriage.


1427927044173.jpg



Twenty years in prison: Purvi Patel is taken into custody. Photo: AP

040115_purvi_patel.si.jpg
​

  • Why Patel's jailing matters
A woman in the US state of Indiana has been sentenced to up to 20 years in prison on charges of feticide and neglect of a dependent, despite claiming she gave birth to a stillborn fetus.
Purvi Patel, 33, an Indian immigrant living in South Bend, Indiana, said she gave birth at home and left the fetus in a dumpster on her way to hospital.

On July 13, 2013, Patel arrived at the emergency department at St Joseph Hospital in Mishawaka, Indiana, with vaginal bleeding, court papers say.

When asked if she had given birth, Patel denied that she had.
The doctor who examined her, Tracy Byrne, found a protruding umbilical cord.
A second doctor, Kelly McGuire, confirmed she delivered a baby.
Court documents say that, eventually, Patel told the doctors she delivered a baby in her home but the child was not breathing.

She put the body in a bag and placed it in a dumpster behind a discount store, Super Target.
In the documents, she said she was two months pregnant and had a miscarriage.
However, the doctors said that, on examination, Patel was at least 28 to 30 weeks pregnant.
Dr McGuire went to look for the baby and also alerted the police. The dead child was found in a dumpster behind Moe's Southwest Grill.

"I assumed because the baby was dead there was nothing to do," Patel said in a taped interview with County Metro Homicide Unit Detective Galen Pelletier, the South Bend Tribune reported.
"I've never been in this situation. I've never been pregnant before."
Patel's lawyers argued she panicked when she realised she was in labour.

News reports said "the baby fell out" in her bathroom.
Her lawyers said in court that
Patel came from a conservative Hindu family who looked down on sex outside marriage.
Lawyers said the pregnancy was a result of an affair Patel had with a co-worker.

In their investigations, police downloaded text messages from her phone that showed she disclosed the pregnancy to one friend.

Patel told the friend she had ordered abortion medication from Hong Kong and started taking the drugs a few days before the miscarriage.
Court documents indicated one drug would induce labour and the other drug would kill the fetus if it was under nine weeks old.

The case became contentious because a toxicology report revealed no traces of the drugs in Patel's blood nor could police find evidence the drugs were purchased, al-Jazeera reported.
In the US, at least 38 states, including Indiana, have fetal homicide laws.
While Patel is the first woman in Indiana to be convicted under the state's feticide law, she was not the first woman to be charged with killing a fetus.

In 2010, Chinese immigrant Bei Bei Shuai took rat poison when her boyfriend left her, leading to the death of their unborn child, named Angel.

She was charged with murder and feticide in 2011 but, in 2013, Indiana prosecutors dropped the charges after she pleaded guilty to a misdemeanour charge of criminal recklessness for the death of her daughter.
Patel's case raised the issue of states using the law to prosecute women who either had a self-induced abortion or suffered a stillbirth.

The National Advocates for Pregnant Women (NAPW), acting as amicus curiae (or friend of the court), said Patel's case should be dismissed because she did not give birth to a child whom she then neglected.
"Stillbirths, miscarriages, abortions including those that are self-induced and do not conform to abortion regulations, and women's mental health during pregnancy are health issues, not matters for the criminal justice system," said a document submitted by US National Advocates for Pregnant Women to the St Joseph Superior Court.

"This case presents significant questions about the constitutional, health and social ramifications for all women if pregnancy loss and medical self-help become the subject of criminal investigations, arrest, prosecution and incarceration."

NAPW said every major health association in the US opposed such prosecutions, because they discourage pregnant women from seeking care needed for their pregnancies.
The American Medical Association also said pregnant women who had had a history of substance abuse would avoid seeing a doctor for fear of being convicted of a crime.

These two feticide cases raised concerns "women of colour" and economically disadvantaged women were disproportionately targeted by feticide laws. A study by NAPW and Fordham University also found that trend in the US.

http://www.smh.com.au/world/indiana...ge-convicted-of-feticide-20150401-1mcy93.html

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Advertisement
Re: Indiana woman first in USA History to be convicted of feticide

Oh Man ! This is so sad .... (cry):((cry)

I know plenty of my american friends have filed for adoptions in China etc .... They would have gladly accepted her baby !
 
Re: Indiana woman first in USA History to be convicted of feticide

whats even more is that 1 million girls are annually killed in india due to female foeticide
Oh Man ! This is so sad .... (cry):((cry)

I know plenty of my american friends have filed for adoptions in China etc .... They would have gladly accepted her baby !
 
Advertisement
Re: Indiana woman first in USA History to be convicted of feticide

Oh Man ! This is so sad .... (cry):((cry)

I know plenty of my american friends have filed for adoptions in China etc .... They would have gladly accepted her baby !


yeah, its ironic how so many people actually want babies can't have them...
 
Re: Indiana woman first in USA History to be convicted of feticide

She did it as she did not want her parents and family to know her illigtimate affair and killed the baby , Her lawyers said in court that Patel came from a conservative Hindu family who looked down on sex outside marriage.