These economic indicators are gimmicks, recall how Asian tigers were made cows over night. Real importance lies in social justice real prosperity where people are content and this can be achieved with social justice nothing else otherwise rest is truck ki bati
Economy wise mushi era was one of the best era in the history of Pakistan but today we are fighting against terrorism just because of his wrong defence policies.
Musharraf's era was good economy-wise but he takes undue credit for it. It was nothing more than an economic bubble owing to the load of aid money that was pouring into Pakistan and the uptake of technology. If he had taken any concrete macroeconomic policies then the growth would have continued past his 'reign'.
No doubt, musharaf and his team achieved the best economic figures in decades. Though pmln and ppp refutes it as they didnt perform ShlT in their era so its easy to blame others who produced the results
Musharraf era was best for economy but only till 2007
the continuous bombs destroyed the economy from 2007 onwards, then his emergency further stopped investment
although economy was good..he didn't do anything for electricity infrastructure
so we suffered load shedding from 2008 which is still not ending because of corrupt people like Zardari and Sharif
Musharraf is in same league...he compromised with all corrupt people though he had full power and the people who were with him are all against him today
Musharraf era was best for economy but only till 2007
the continuous bombs destroyed the economy from 2007 onwards, then his emergency further stopped investment
although economy was good..he didn't do anything for electricity infrastructure
so we suffered load shedding from 2008 which is still not ending because of corrupt people like Zardari and Sharif
Musharraf is in same league...he compromised with all corrupt people though he had full power and the people who were with him are all against him today
these are the figures of economic growth in musharaf's era
Pak Economy in 1999 was: $ 75 billion (Source)
Pak Economy in 2007 is: $ 160 billion (Source) and (Source)
Pak Economy in 2008 is: $ 170 billion (Source)
GDP Purchasing Power Parity (PPP) in 1999: $ 270 billion (Source)
GDP Purchasing Power Parity (PPP) in 2007: $ 475.5 billion (Source)
GDP Purchasing Power Parity (PPP) in 2008: $ 504.3 billion (Source)
GDP per Capita Income in 1999: $ 450 (Source)
GDP per Capita Income in 2007: $ 926 (Source)
Pak revenue collection 1999: Rs. 305 billion (Source)
Pak revenue collection 2007: Rs. 708 billion (Source) and (Source)
Pak revenue collection 2008: Rs. 990 billion (Source)
Pak Foreign reserves in 1999: $ 1.96 billion (Source)
Pak Foreign reserves in 2007: $ 16.4 billion (Source) and (Source)
Pak Foreign reserves in 2008: $ 8.89 billion (Source)
Pak Foreign reserves in 2009: $ 14.3 billion (Source)
Pak Exports in 1999: $ 8 billion (Source)
Pak Exports in 2007: $ 18.5 billion (Source)
Pak Exports in 2008: $ 19.22 billion (Source) and (Source)
Textile Exports in 1999: $ 5.5 billion
Textile Exports in 2007: $ 11.2 billion (Source)
KHI stock exchange 1999: $ 5 billion at 700 points
KHI stock exchange 2007: $ 75 billion at 14,000 points (Source)
KHI stock exchange 2008: $ 46 billion at 9,300 points (Source) and $ 20 billion at 4,972 points (Source)
KHI stock exchange 2009: $ 26.5 billion (Source) at 9,000 points (Source)
Foreign Investment in 1999: $ 301 million (Source)
Foreign Investment in 2007: $ 8.4 billion (Source)
Foreign Investment in 2008: $ 5.19 billion (Source)
Large Scale Manufacturing (LSM) in 1999: 1.5% ( Source)
Large Scale Manufacturing (LSM) in 2005: 19.9% (Source)
Large Scale Manufacturing (LSM) in 2007: 8.6% (Source)
Large Scale Manufacturing (LSM) in 2008: 4.8% (Source)
Debt (External Debt & Liabilities) in 1988: $ 18 billion
Debt (External Debt & Liabilities) in 1999: $ 39 billion
Debt (External Debt & Liabilities) in 2007: $ 40.5 billion
Debt (External Debt & Liabilities) in 2009: $ 50.1 billion
Debt servicing 1999: 65% of GDP
Debt servicing 2007: 28% of GDP
Debt servicing 2008: 27% of GDP
Poverty level in 1999: 34%
Poverty level in 2007: 24%
Literacy rate in 1999: 45%
Literacy rate in 2007: 53%
Pak Development programs 1999: Rs. 80 billion
Pak Development programs 2007: Rs. 520 billion
Pak Development programs 2008: Rs. 549.7 billion
I agree but with the bomb blasts which never stopped during the last year of his tenure, foreign investment dropped to O
Living abroad, I know how much UAE govt backed out on projects after the unstability
As an economics student, bad policies take time to show result
The bad security in the country in his last year had very bad effect next year so show 2009 figures also
He was root cause for that
And no investment in his time for future electricity
one major mistake caused by a person can be more heavy and painful than years on good work
that is the issue with Musharraf..lot of his supporters who belong to educated families were disheartened with his policies in the last year
and his biggest crime in history of Pakistan...NRO which took all these great figures of yours to the trash
جو آج پاکستان میں انویسٹ کرے گا وہ دس سال میں اپنی ساری انویسٹمنٹ نہ صرف ریکوور کرے گا بلکہ ٢٠ فیصد یا ٣٠ فیصد تک منافع بھی کما کر اکانومی سے نکال کر لے جائے گا. وقت کے ساتھ ساتھ کرنسی کی قدر کم ہوتی جائے گی. مشرف صاحب نے کن سیکٹرز میں بیرونی سرمایاکاری کو فروغ دیا؟ میرے خیال میں آئی ٹی سیکٹر میں، ٹیلی کام سیکٹر میں، واپڈا میں؟ مطلب یہ کہ اس سیکٹر میں جو زیادہ تر سروس مہیا کرتی ہیں، یعنی معاشرے میں کوئی ٹھوس اثاثہ Tangible Assets نہیں بنے. کوئی فیکٹری نہیں لگی، کوئی انڈسٹری نہیں لگی. ہم لوگ ریاست کی جیب میں پیسہ نہیں جانے دیتے. مجھے یقین نہیں آتا کے سروس مہیا کرنے والی کمپنی جسے پاکستان ٹیلی کام، واپڈا ، ریلوے یا پی آئی اے کیسے نقصان میں چلی جاتی ہیں. صرف ایک ہی وجہ ہو سکتی ہے وہ یہ کی آپ منافع سے زیادہ اخراجات ظاہر کرتے ہیں تاکہ منافع ریاست کی تجوری میں جانے کی بجاے پرائیویٹ جیبوں میں جائے. اخراجات کی پڑتال کرنے والا ادارہ AGPR بھی فعال نہیں جو ان کی مشکیں کس سکے. ایک سادہ سی مثال دیتا ہوں . ایک کمپنی ہے جو شیئرز میں ڈیل کرتی ہے. اب وہ کمپنی کی equity گورنمنٹ کی ہے. اب اگر اس کمپنی کا ڈائریکٹر جب transaction کرتا ہے تو فائدہ تو اپنے اکاؤنٹ میں ڈال لے گا اور نقصان کو کمپنی کے کھاتے میں ڈال دے گا. جب equity نیگیٹو ہو جائے گی تو کمپنی کو گورنمنٹ کی طرف سے اور فنڈ مل جائیں گے. یعنی گورنمنٹ کے فنڈ کتنی خوش اسلوبی سے پرائیویٹ جیب میں چلے جاتے ہیں. یہی حال دوسرے اداروں کا ہے. جب کو کمپنی نیگیٹو equity میں چلی جاتی ہے یا تو وہ sick unit بن جاتی ہے اور کسی پرائیویٹ ہاتھوں میں فروخت ہو جاتی ہے یا پھر ختم ہو جاتی ہے. ادارے کے نقصان میں لے جانے کا مقصد ہی یہی ہوتا ہے. ایسی صورتحال میں کمپنی کا آڈٹ ہونا چاہے، بوگس اخراجات اور ملازموں کو شناخت کرنی چاہے، سب سے اہم escalated invoices چیک ہونی چاہے. جو چیزfair market میں ١٠کی ملتی ہے اسکی انوائس ٢٠ کی کیوں بنی ہے. کمپنی کا نقصان دراصل پرائیویٹ جیبوں میں منافع کے برابر ہو گا.
لیکن یہ اقتصادی راہداری اس لئے مفید ہے کہ ایک طرف تو یہ tangible asset ہے اور ہماری ملکیت ہو گا دوسری طرف یہ ہمیں محصول اور ایکسائز ریونیو دے گا. یعنی پیسہ باہر سے آے گا.