Advertisement

Had Zia not fought Afghan jehad we could not have become nuclear at all or without full economic san

Would western powers not have imposed sanctions on us were we not helping them in Afghan jehad against soviet union ? our plight would have been that of Iran would it be not ?

Would we have got F16 and additional loans from them as well as making Atomic bomb under their nose had we not got them embroiled in Afghan war ?

Could we have got A bomb without funding of Arabs sunni states ?

So why this daily curse of Zia ul Haq and of Afghan jehad .May i ask.

Before we got nuclear , every time a big exercise started near Indian borders our FM had to travel in Islamic countries and invoke USA and european help in averting war and also used Saudi mediation. Every time Afghanistan prosoviet and proindian regime created border trouble our PMs had to run to Shah of iran to request counterbalance Afghanistan .

Life for Pakistan was not easy security wise , then before 1971 , we also had to protect East Pakistan , we had to seek western powers and countries like Indonesia to counterbalance India there , we looked to china as well to counter balance india but that did not work for long or much .

Younger generation before cursing Zia ul Haq should remember all this , we should be thankful to Qadeer , zia , Ishaq , Army engineers , sunni arabs regimes , shah of Iran and may be China and that today respectable powers ask us for help . We are even welcomed for security of Mecca and Medina but we are running from that honour and necessity saying that Shia might not get angry , are we mad ???

Cursed not be Zia ul haq , but cursed be the media and politicians of today who have no understanding how difficult was life security wise for Pakistan before the Atomic Bomb and missiles .

We unfortunately have now in saddle people like Raza Rabbani who is doing all he can to fragment centre , even current load shedding of gas has to do with some recently got provincial controls making organized gas production difficult .I did not believe the reasons for this when I first heart it.

The younger generation should not be fooled by Pro indian and prowestern pseudo historians and politicians and NGO , they have to understand the past .

Law and order broke only during Afghan jehad when junejo was brought in as PM , his dismissal by zia was entirely justified as the later had no strategic vision and helped corruption amongst politicians and helped PPP come from death bed to the detriment of Pakistan , just as Gen.Kiani brought PPP from death bed along with stupidity of Musharaf.

Probably no body improved Pakistan's military than Ayub and Zia , as a fighting force and even Raheel Sharif will have to impose some law and remove current judicial and police system and side line politicians and political parties if army is to achieve target of removing terrorism in 2016 . THIS IS FOR SURE.

I often ask educated lot not to look to people like recent journalists or politicians for wisdom , ask former senior diplomats, administrators , professors ,technocrats , big business man what is the way forward .
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Advertisement
No doubt that Pakistan been in trouble ever since its inception by Indians. Zia did what he could along with his stupidities, he was more of a molvi than a general or politician. Zia came into power and brought religion into politics and tried to become ameer-ul-momneen, he committed blunders in his tenure and paid his life. After that came Mushriff, you can see what he did, people worshiped him when he took over, the thieves he got rid of at first place he brought them back with teeth n nails was a biggest blunder, this was a mafia gang who ruined the country and mushriff is suffering himself as well. This country needs a committed and honest leader who has no mercy for thieves and traitors.
 
the dilemma is that the newer generations believe Google and Wikipedia are the right info sources. we have seen both the times with and without modern media and can easily understand how media distorts the facts but they can't and forces controlling the media take advantage of it.
 
Advertisement
ha ha ha ha ha................atom bomb ,can atom bomb ensure food education ,infrastructure for pakistan?(bigsmile)
 
And now Zia's Spiritual son Nawaz Shareef is borrowing so much money that Pakistan might have to rollback like Iran.
 
No problem in Zia policy of running proxies across the border. Problem is with training your own people and land. What zia did was not proxy but mroxy war. Also, what was the point of making jihadi groups to go and fight in Kashmir? Kashmir cause gets destroyed by these so called Jihadi groups and turned a justify cause into a terrorism problem.
 
There was two supper powers, USSR and USA, there was a balance of power and Pakistan was able to make Atomic bomb. Same as today North Korea has made one because of China ( no Arab Suni states helping them).

In your article, no mention of Bhutto who started training afghans for the USSR before they invaded. He also started the Nuclear program.
 
Advertisement
No problem in Zia policy of running proxies across the border. Problem is with training your own people and land. What zia did was not proxy but mroxy war. Also, what was the point of making jihadi groups to go and fight in Kashmir? Kashmir cause gets destroyed by these so called Jihadi groups and turned a justify cause into a terrorism problem.

now these rogue elements are giving trouble to pakistan ,
 
No problem in Zia policy of running proxies across the border. Problem is with training your own people and land. What zia did was not proxy but mroxy war. Also, what was the point of making jihadi groups to go and fight in Kashmir? Kashmir cause gets destroyed by these so called Jihadi groups and turned a justify cause into a terrorism problem.
Main team of Zia died in crash , the remainder did not have any strategy and did odd acts , out of place , done deliberately in a way to show that Pakistani policy has not changed but executed in a fashion to make sure that neither Kashmir struggle suceeds ,nor Sikhs get anything , nor jalalabad falls .
 
Advertisement
attention @shaikh

انتہائی احترام کے ساتھ عرض ہے کہ آپ نے جنرل ضیاء مرحوم اور انکے دور کے بیان میں یکطرفہ انداز بیان اپنایا ہے ،اور موضوع سے ایسا انصاف نہیں کیا ہے جسکا وہ حقدار ہے

کسی بھی انسان کے بد کردار ہونے کیلئے یہ کافی ہوتا ہے کہ وہ اپنے ملک کے قانون سے غداری کرے،اسے اپنے مفاد کےلئے توڑ دے، پھر جنرل تو کسی قوم کیلئے ایک ایسا شخص ہوتا ہے جسے پر قوم اپنی جان سے زیادہ بھروسہ کرتی ہےاگر ایسا شخص ہی قانون توڑ کر اقتدار پر قبضہ کرلےتو اسکے کردارکی کجی میں کسی قسم کا شک نہ کرنے کی کوئی وجہ باقی نہیں رہ جاتی،اس سے سرزد ہونے والے دوسرے کاموں پر شک کے سائے منڈلاتے رہتے ہیں کہ آیا وہ کام اس نے قوم کی خاطر کئے،یا اپنا اقتدار بچانے یا کسی اور مفاد کیلئے؟
اردن میں فلسطینوں کو تہہ وبالا کرنے سے لیکر پاکستان میں حکومت کا تختہ الٹنے تک ،،محسوس ہوتا ہے کہ مرحوم کے مغرب سے مستحکم روابط تھے،امریکہ کے بھٹو کو عبرت کا نشان بنانے کے اعلان کے بعد، ضیاء مرحوم کا اسکی حکومت کا تختہ الٹنا، اور پھر پھانسی، یہ سوال اٹھانے کیلئے کافی ہے کہ کیا ضیاء کا مارشل لاء امریکہ کا بھٹو کو سبق سکھانے کیلئے تھا؟
اگر ایسا تھا توجہاد کے نام پر پاکستانی قوم کو افغانستان میں روس کے خلاف امریکن جنگ کا ایندھن بنانا بھی، انہیں روابط کے تحت ہوگا جسکا شبہ ا ب ہوتاہے،،
بھٹو مرحوم اور ضیاء مرحوم کا دور ہی وہ دور تھا جس میں اس ملک اور قوم کی جڑ بنیاد ہلادی گئی،بھٹو نے اگر شیعہ فرقہ بازی کو ہوا دی تو ضیاء نے سنی انتہاہ پسندی کو،،،نتیجہ میں قوم کو ایسی جگہ پہونچا دیا کہ اگر جان بر ہوجائے،تو اللہ کی طرف سے ایک معجزہ جیسی نعمت ہوگی
آپ نے جنرل کی تعریف میں جولکھا ہےاور جس رخ کو اجاگر کیاہے،ہو سکتا ہے وہ ویسا ہی ہو جیسا آپ فرمارہےہیں،آپکی علمیت دیانتداری اور رائے کا احترام کرتے ہوئے،

،میری درخواست ہے آپ اس پر نظرثانی فرمائیں، اور جیسا ہوا ہے اسے مکمل طور پر نوجوان نسل کی آگاہی کیلئے تحریر کریں
اور پھر اس پر تبصرہ فرما کراس دور کو ہمارے سمجھنے کیلئے آسان فرمائیں

ا



ا
​
 
Instead of the strong army plus nuclear if we spent all this money on the people of Pakistan for the last 69 long years so we would be one of the powerful nation of the world.
 
No doubt that Pakistan been in trouble ever since its inception by Indians. Zia did what he could along with his stupidities what stupidities yaar, educate me please. During the entire Zia era I was not in Pak.

, he was more of a molvi than a general or politician. Zia came into power and brought religion into politics and tried to become ameer-ul-momneen, he committed blunders in his tenure and paid his life

whats wrong with being a general and Maulvi at the same time? Whats wrong with bringing religion into politics. Please tell me at least two blunders that he allegedly committed. juda ho deen siasat sey to rah jaati hai chungezi

. After that came Mushriff, you can see what he did, people worshiped him when he took over, the thieves he got rid of at first place he brought them back with teeth n nails was a biggest blunder, this was a mafia gang who ruined the country and mushriff is suffering himself as well. This country needs a committed and honest leader who has no mercy for thieves and traitors.

one more question for you. Are you a secular.
 
Why do we always consider weapons, bombs, jihadi extremist as progress? I mean what a perverted way of thinking. Zia destroyed Pakistan, Musharraf raped our country, Ayub laid the foundation of military coups. And we have clowns on keyboard, who every now and then start a thread praising Zia. And they get a brutal beat down by almost every forum member. Most forum members hate each other, let alone form any sort of agreement, but they are all unanimous when it comes to trashing Zia. lol
 
Advertisement
Why do we always consider weapons, bombs, jihadi extremist as progress? I mean what a perverted way of thinking. Zia destroyed Pakistan, Musharraf raped our country, Ayub laid the foundation of military coups. And we have clowns on keyboard, who every now and then start a thread praising Zia. And they get a brutal beat down by almost every forum member. Most forum members hate each other, let alone form any sort of agreement, but they are all unanimous when it comes to trashing Zia. lol

The only difference between most others on this forum and me is that I have personally seen Ayub , Zia , Bhutto, and their periods and their problems , while most others have only read about them . Army coup was warmly welcomed in 1958 and in 1977 and partly welcomed in 1999.

Politicians regarded country as milching cow and no vision and had to be kicked out . They had become very unpatriotic and fractious . Un trained they already were and mostly still are . Time to kick them out again may be .
 
its funny that mostly those people defend Zia ul haq who are against west and always misquoting verses related to yahoodo nasara cant be your friends. But when it comes to Zia ul Haq then they even defend Jihad with the help of Yahoodo Nasara.

A person who started his tenure with making a false promise , who lied again and again is a role model for some so called pure muslims.