Advertisement

Farmers cry foul as new Law passed by Punjab Assembly favors SUGAR MAFIA

Farmers cry foul as new law ‘usurps their rights, favours sugar mills’​

Some of those who have attended meetings of the standing committee tasked with vetting the draft allege that the bill is different from what has been drafted by the body. — File

Some of those who have attended meetings of the standing committee tasked with vetting the draft allege that the bill is different from what has been drafted by the body. — File

LAHORE: The passage of a new law controlling sugar factories early this month has irked the farmers who say that their rights have been compromised in the amendment act, contrary to what they had been given in the ordinance promulgated in October last year.

The Sugar Factories (Control) (Amendment) Act 2021, passed on May 4 by the Punjab Assembly, has caused another controversy as agriculture department officials said they were not made a part of the law-making process.

Some of those who have attended meetings of the standing committee tasked with vetting the draft allege that the bill is different from what has been drafted by the body. However, they could not produce any copy of the ‘original’ draft.

The new act fixes Nov 30 as the last date for starting the sugarcane crushing season while the ordinance had empowered the government to give a date for the purpose. It also allows sugar millers to pay dues to the farmers by June 30 against just 15 days from purchase of the sugarcane in the now repealed ordinance.
Pakistan Kissan Ittehad President Khalid Mahmood Khokhar, in a letter to Prime Minister Imran Khan, regrets that the measures put in place in the ordinance to safeguard rights of the farmers have been abolished through the act under, what he alleges, pressure of the sugar mafia.

“Assemblies are supposed to protect the rights of masses (farmers & consumers) in a democracy. Unfortunately, the Punjab Assembly and the provincial government mischievously passed the amendment act in which the sugar mafia’s exploitation was allowed officially; mills will start functioning till Nov 30, instead of Oct 1, CPR [cane procurement receipt] encashment allowed till June 30, instead of payable within 15 days of issuance of the CPR. The CPR will not be considered as cheque or any legality for any legal action against sugar mills. The government’s control or any authority stands abolished and the sugar mafia has been given full control to exploit the farmers and consumers.”

Demanding immediate withdrawal of the act, he also seeks removal of the chief minister as well as the provincial law minister and threatens to hold a protest in front of the Punjab Assembly till the withdrawal of the law.

The Kissan Board Pakistan says the nexus of sugar mafia and corrupt politicians has broken the back of the poor farmers through the law.

In a statement, the board says under the defunct ordinance, the last crushing season had started on Nov 10 and thus the fields were timely freed from sugarcane to sow wheat, leading to a bumper crop. It says as ‘illegal’ deductions from the dues and non-payment had been non-bailable offences under the earlier ordinance but the new act made them non-cognizable offences.

The KBP regrets that the sugarcane growers will now have to wait for seven months for payment of their dues against just 15 days time set in the ordinance while the cane commissioner has been barred from taking action against the millers for non-payment of dues to the farmers.

Cane Commissioner Muhammad Zaman Wattoo had received around 200 complaints against delayed payments or non-payment or illegal deductions in the last crushing season that ended in the first week of April.

Mr Wattoo says the grieving farmers should now approach him after June 30 as until then, his office cannot act against the offending millers, if any, under the new law.

Published in Dawn, May 19th, 2021
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Advertisement

Farmers cry foul as new law ‘usurps their rights, favours sugar mills’​

The Newspaper's Staff ReporterPublished May 19, 2021 - Updated about 21 hours ago
Facebook Count
Twitter Share

1
Some of those who have attended meetings of the standing committee tasked with vetting the draft allege that the bill is different from what has been drafted by the body. — File

Some of those who have attended meetings of the standing committee tasked with vetting the draft allege that the bill is different from what has been drafted by the body. — File

LAHORE: The passage of a new law controlling sugar factories early this month has irked the farmers who say that their rights have been compromised in the amendment act, contrary to what they had been given in the ordinance promulgated in October last year.

The Sugar Factories (Control) (Amendment) Act 2021, passed on May 4 by the Punjab Assembly, has caused another controversy as agriculture department officials said they were not made a part of the law-making process.

Some of those who have attended meetings of the standing committee tasked with vetting the draft allege that the bill is different from what has been drafted by the body. However, they could not produce any copy of the ‘original’ draft.

The new act fixes Nov 30 as the last date for starting the sugarcane crushing season while the ordinance had empowered the government to give a date for the purpose. It also allows sugar millers to pay dues to the farmers by June 30 against just 15 days from purchase of the sugarcane in the now repealed ordinance.
Pakistan Kissan Ittehad President Khalid Mahmood Khokhar, in a letter to Prime Minister Imran Khan, regrets that the measures put in place in the ordinance to safeguard rights of the farmers have been abolished through the act under, what he alleges, pressure of the sugar mafia.

“Assemblies are supposed to protect the rights of masses (farmers & consumers) in a democracy. Unfortunately, the Punjab Assembly and the provincial government mischievously passed the amendment act in which the sugar mafia’s exploitation was allowed officially; mills will start functioning till Nov 30, instead of Oct 1, CPR [cane procurement receipt] encashment allowed till June 30, instead of payable within 15 days of issuance of the CPR. The CPR will not be considered as cheque or any legality for any legal action against sugar mills. The government’s control or any authority stands abolished and the sugar mafia has been given full control to exploit the farmers and consumers.”

Demanding immediate withdrawal of the act, he also seeks removal of the chief minister as well as the provincial law minister and threatens to hold a protest in front of the Punjab Assembly till the withdrawal of the law.

The Kissan Board Pakistan says the nexus of sugar mafia and corrupt politicians has broken the back of the poor farmers through the law.

In a statement, the board says under the defunct ordinance, the last crushing season had started on Nov 10 and thus the fields were timely freed from sugarcane to sow wheat, leading to a bumper crop. It says as ‘illegal’ deductions from the dues and non-payment had been non-bailable offences under the earlier ordinance but the new act made them non-cognizable offences.

The KBP regrets that the sugarcane growers will now have to wait for seven months for payment of their dues against just 15 days time set in the ordinance while the cane commissioner has been barred from taking action against the millers for non-payment of dues to the farmers.

Cane Commissioner Muhammad Zaman Wattoo had received around 200 complaints against delayed payments or non-payment or illegal deductions in the last crushing season that ended in the first week of April.

Mr Wattoo says the grieving farmers should now approach him after June 30 as until then, his office cannot act against the offending millers, if any, under the new law.

Published in Dawn, May 19th, 2021
Khan should take a notice of this new law which openly defies the ordinance issued by the federal government.
 
Advertisement
Khan should take a notice of this new law which openly defies the ordinance issued by the federal government.
But the damage has been done. Once an Act is passed by the Assembly and signed by the Governor, then it cannot be taken back. Only a new amendment bill is to be moved, which will again be debated in the assembly and will take at least six months to become a legislation. Until then, the recently passed Ordinance stands repealed and this new draconian Act will remain in force.

Too late for anyone to take notice now. Sugar Mafia will rule this year, no matter what.

This is deliberate backstabbing by Buzdar
 
But the damage has been done. Once an Act is passed by the Assembly and signed by the Governor, then it cannot be taken back. Only a new amendment bill is to be moved, which will again be debated in the assembly and will take at least six months to become a legislation. Until then, the recently passed Ordinance stands repealed and this new draconian Act will remain in force.

Too late for anyone to take notice now. Sugar Mafia will rule this year, no matter what.

This is deliberate backstabbing by Buzdar
It is really depressing. I hope Khan kick out this bozo Buzdar and the other complacent for passing this immoral legislative act of suppressing the poor farmers livelihoods.
Mafia is too strong i guess.
 
Advertisement
اب پھر سے کسان کا پیسہ آٹھ ماہ تک دبایا جا سکے گا۔ پنجاب میں پچھلے سال کے آرڈینس سے بلکل الٹ قانون بنا دیا گیا۔
گنے کو بیس دن مزید سوکھنے دیا جائے گا اور شوگر ملیں دس نومبر کی بجائے ۳۰ نومبر کو چلیں گیں حالانکہ شوگر ملوں کا مطالبہ تو ۲۵ نومبر تھا۔۱۵ دن میں پے منٹ والی جھلکی بند۔
کین آفیسر کے جرمانے کرنے اور کرکی کے اختیارات واپس لے لئے گئے۔
ویٹ سلپ کو چیک کا درجہ دینے کے احکامات بھی واپس۔
شوگر انکوائری رپورٹ بھی سردخانے میں رکھ دی گئی اور نہ کسی پر کیس بنا اور نہ کسی کو سزا ہونے کے امکانات ہیں۔
.
کہا جا رہا ہے کہ احکامات اسلام آباد کے بجائے راولپنڈی سے آرہے ہیں

اللہ اللہ خیر صلہ
​
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It is really depressing. I hope Khan kick out this bozo Buzdar and the other complacent for passing this immoral legislative act of suppressing the poor farmers livelihoods.
Mafia is too strong i guess.

خان صاحب نے زراعت پر نوٹس لیا تھا اور کہا تھا کہ زراعت کو خود ڈیل کروں گا...
اتنا کافی نہی زراعت کی بربادی کے لیے ؟
​
 
Last edited:
اب پھر سے کسان کا پیسہ آٹھ ماہ تک دبایا جا سکے گا۔ پنجاب میں پچھلے سال کے آرڈینس سے بلکل الٹ قانون بنا دیا گیا۔
گنے کو بیس دن مزید سوکھنے دیا جائے گا اور شوگر ملیں دس نومبر کی بجائے ۳۰ نومبر کو چلیں گیں حالانکہ شوگر ملوں کا مطالبہ تو ۲۵ نومبر تھا۔۱۵ دن میں پے منٹ والی جھلکی بند۔
کین آفیسر کے جرمانے کرنے اور کرکی کے اختیارات واپس لے لئے گئے۔
ویٹ سلپ کو چیک کا درجہ دینے کے احکامات بھی واپس۔
شوگر انکوائری رپورٹ بھی سردخانے میں رکھ دی گئی اور نہ کسی پر کیس بنا اور نہ کسی کو سزا ہونے کے امکانات ہیں۔
.
کہا جا رہا ہے کہ احکامات اسلام آباد کے بجائے راولپنڈی سے آرہے ہیں

اللہ اللہ خیر صلہ​
بزدار کی طرف سے کہا جارہا ہے کہ قانون میں ترامیم واپس لی جائینگی۔ لیکن مجھے سمجھ نہیں آرہا کہ جب گورنر تک دستخط کر بیٹھا ہو تو اصلاحات کے نئے بل کے بغیر کیسے اس ایکٹ کو روکا جاسکتا ہے؟
اور نئے بل کا مطلب ہے ٹرک کی نئی بتی۔ لگے رہو ایک سال تک تو اس پر بحث ہی ختم نہیں ہونی۔

Loading X post…
Open original post on X
​


 
Advertisement
It is really depressing. I hope Khan kick out this bozo Buzdar and the other complacent for passing this immoral legislative act of suppressing the poor farmers livelihoods.
Mafia is too strong i guess.
I hope so, but after the new block from JKT, it seems quite impossible to replace Buzdar and remain in power in Punjab too. Removing Buzdar will mean handing over Punjab to some other Government.

However, I am not sure, but maybe the Governor has an authority to withhold this act, or call it back or may be issue orders of its suspension. I am still researching on this topic, will let you know if any such power is vested with the Governor. Otherwise, there will be no cure for this deliberate backstabbing.
 
Advertisement
If it can be passed the it can be unpassed. Buzdar the *******
Under Article 116 (5) of Constitution of Pakistan, No Act of a Provincial Assembly, and no provision in any such Act, shall be invalid by reason only that some recommendation, previous sanction or consent required by the Constitution was not given if that Act was assented to accordance with the Constitution.

But under Article 128(1)
(1)The Governor may, except when the Provincial Assembly is in session, if satisfied that circumstances exist which render it necessary to take immediate action, make and promulgate an Ordinance as the circumstances may require.

Yet to exercise such powers, the Governor has to dissolve the assembly first. Right now, it does not seem possible.

Otherwise, when the bill passed by the assembly is endorsed by the Governor, then there is no way to call it back. Unless a new bill for the amendment is introduced for the said Act and it again gets approved by the assembly and then is signed by the Governor.


Article 139 of Const of Pak.
(1)Orders, and other instruments made and executed in the name of the Governor shall be authenticated in such manner as may be specified in rules to be made by the Provincial Government, and the validity of an order or instrument which is so authenticated shall not be called in question on the ground that it is not an order or instrument made or executed by the Governor.