- Joined
- Jun 25, 2013
- Posts
- 4,503
- Reaction score
- 1,123
- Points
- 113
Now here is thread where my intention is to learn. I am certainly not an Islamic scholar but I bear three impressions which I want others to clarify as being right or wrong :
ARE JAIL PUNISHMENTS UNISLAMIC ?
1.Jail imprisonments are not the main form of punishments in Quranic law and Islamic law.
I have heard a former supreme court judge that there is nothing unislamic in Pakistan penal code and criminal or civil procedure code . The Pakistani laws are full of hundreds of ways to punish anybody with jail .Even minor traffic violations carry jail. So was there any substance in the claims of Mr.Ramday who stated that Pakistani laws do not contain anything unislamic sections ? .
Can imprisonments be the main form of punishment in an Islamic society ? Is imprisonment not the main form of punishment in kingly systems and not in Abrahamic religions like Islam?
IS ZAKAT A RELIGIOUS WEALTH TAX OR A RELIGIOUS LEVY ON IMMEDIATELY CASHABLE ASSESTS OR SOMETHING DIFFERENT ALTOGETHER ?
2. I am somewhat confused on Zakat , my impression is that it is not a religious wealth tax but rather that it a religious tax on immediately cashable items of wealth at any time once a year .Was there not letter of the holy Prophet about payable zakat on cattle?
IS RIBA MERE INTEREST ? OR ANY UNFAIR FINANCIAL TRANSACTION WHICH IS OPPRESSIVE TO ANY OF PARTIES INCLUDING END USER THIRD PARTY OR THAT PROFIT EXPECTED IS UNREALISTIC OR IMMORAL ELEMENT TO IT OR IS INEXACT?
3. Correct or confirm my impression about nature of Riba . My impression is that fixing or predicting some realizable margin or percentage is not riba unless it is unrealistic for any party to transaction and does not hurt any third user party of merchandise. Say for example loaning at rate of 25% per months for marriage is riba as no profit was expected but loaning at 25% per month to a business party which knows business well and which is legitimate under sharia and profits do not result in oppressive price for end user of item will not be Riba . My impression is bank profit can be combination of genuine profit , real Riba and state help from publishing notes all at the same time and they should specify their percentage of income from each route for account holders .
MONARCHY IS NOT THE RECOMMENDED FORM OF GOVERNMENT BUT HEREDITARY LEADERSHIP IS ACCEPTED IN ISLAM IN DAY TO DAY POLITICS.
4. What impression one gets from stories of prophet kings of Banu Israel ? .Is there any evidence that Prophet of Islam ordered tribes to change their chiefs. If they subject to discipline of Islam of equality in the heart.?
IS DEMOCRACY SAME AS SHURA OF ISLAM ?
5. My impression is that Shura of Islam is the Shura of the pious and selected and wise , it is not the same as
democracy where distinction between novice , young , old , uneducated , criminal is non existent , all can vote equally . They can even vote that Male can marry male like Obama , French and British PM and their parliaments have voted so .
IS PERPETUAL RIGHT OF PROPERTY NOT PART OF ISLAMIC LAW ? HOW PAKISTANI GOVERNMENTS ARE AWARDING LEASES NOT PERPETUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS WHERE PROPERTY WAS BOUGHT AT MARKET RATE ?
6. An Islamic right of property is perpetual in my view and if any urban governmental body could not get more price
at a given time from a buyer then it is considered bought with perpetual right of person and his heirs , it cannot be said that government has any right of lease still present over it . The idea that all property of a Muslim belongs to king or state is alien to Islam . Are Governmental bodies of Pakistan not violating this right of Muslims.
ARE JAIL PUNISHMENTS UNISLAMIC ?
1.Jail imprisonments are not the main form of punishments in Quranic law and Islamic law.
I have heard a former supreme court judge that there is nothing unislamic in Pakistan penal code and criminal or civil procedure code . The Pakistani laws are full of hundreds of ways to punish anybody with jail .Even minor traffic violations carry jail. So was there any substance in the claims of Mr.Ramday who stated that Pakistani laws do not contain anything unislamic sections ? .
Can imprisonments be the main form of punishment in an Islamic society ? Is imprisonment not the main form of punishment in kingly systems and not in Abrahamic religions like Islam?
IS ZAKAT A RELIGIOUS WEALTH TAX OR A RELIGIOUS LEVY ON IMMEDIATELY CASHABLE ASSESTS OR SOMETHING DIFFERENT ALTOGETHER ?
2. I am somewhat confused on Zakat , my impression is that it is not a religious wealth tax but rather that it a religious tax on immediately cashable items of wealth at any time once a year .Was there not letter of the holy Prophet about payable zakat on cattle?
IS RIBA MERE INTEREST ? OR ANY UNFAIR FINANCIAL TRANSACTION WHICH IS OPPRESSIVE TO ANY OF PARTIES INCLUDING END USER THIRD PARTY OR THAT PROFIT EXPECTED IS UNREALISTIC OR IMMORAL ELEMENT TO IT OR IS INEXACT?
3. Correct or confirm my impression about nature of Riba . My impression is that fixing or predicting some realizable margin or percentage is not riba unless it is unrealistic for any party to transaction and does not hurt any third user party of merchandise. Say for example loaning at rate of 25% per months for marriage is riba as no profit was expected but loaning at 25% per month to a business party which knows business well and which is legitimate under sharia and profits do not result in oppressive price for end user of item will not be Riba . My impression is bank profit can be combination of genuine profit , real Riba and state help from publishing notes all at the same time and they should specify their percentage of income from each route for account holders .
MONARCHY IS NOT THE RECOMMENDED FORM OF GOVERNMENT BUT HEREDITARY LEADERSHIP IS ACCEPTED IN ISLAM IN DAY TO DAY POLITICS.
4. What impression one gets from stories of prophet kings of Banu Israel ? .Is there any evidence that Prophet of Islam ordered tribes to change their chiefs. If they subject to discipline of Islam of equality in the heart.?
IS DEMOCRACY SAME AS SHURA OF ISLAM ?
5. My impression is that Shura of Islam is the Shura of the pious and selected and wise , it is not the same as
democracy where distinction between novice , young , old , uneducated , criminal is non existent , all can vote equally . They can even vote that Male can marry male like Obama , French and British PM and their parliaments have voted so .
IS PERPETUAL RIGHT OF PROPERTY NOT PART OF ISLAMIC LAW ? HOW PAKISTANI GOVERNMENTS ARE AWARDING LEASES NOT PERPETUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS WHERE PROPERTY WAS BOUGHT AT MARKET RATE ?
6. An Islamic right of property is perpetual in my view and if any urban governmental body could not get more price
at a given time from a buyer then it is considered bought with perpetual right of person and his heirs , it cannot be said that government has any right of lease still present over it . The idea that all property of a Muslim belongs to king or state is alien to Islam . Are Governmental bodies of Pakistan not violating this right of Muslims.





