- Joined
- Dec 22, 2010
- Posts
- 2,040
- Reaction score
- 2,519
- Points
- 0
Foreign Minister John Baird took criticism Wednesday for taking a hard line with UNESCO for giving Palestinians a seat at the table but refusing to condemn Israel's plan to expand illegal settlements in the West Bank and East Jerusalem.
"If Canadian policy is rooted in the desire to enhance the prospects for peace in the Middle East, we should be far more concerned with the Israeli announcement of new settlement construction than we are with events at UNESCO," said Rex Brynen, a Middle East peace expert at McGill University in Montreal.
"To date, however, the government's reaction doesn't appear to reflect such considerations."
On Wednesday, the U.S. and European Union condemned the Israeli government's decision to accelerate construction on 2,000 settler homes in the occupied West Bank and East Jerusalem in retaliation for Palestinians joining UNESCO.
When asked for Canada's position on the settlement decision, an official within Baird's office said any unilateral action "is ultimately unhelpful" and that Canada "urges the parties to resume direct peace talks, without delay or preconditions."
"We are committed to a comprehensive, just and lasting peace in the Middle East whereby two states live side-by-side in peace and security," spokesman Joseph Lavoie added.
Critics noted the statement was much softer than comments Baird had made the day before when he said the government needed to send a message to UNESCO that it was not happy with the body's decision to include the Palestinians.
"Canada has decided to freeze all further voluntary contributions to UNESCO," Baird told reporters Tuesday.
"The bottom line is there's going to be a large hole in UNESCO's budget because of the American law which withdraws funding, and people at UNESCO should not look to Canada to fill that budget hole. They'll have to go to the countries who supported this resolution, that caused this budget loophole."
Brynen said the discrepancy in Baird's statements is notable because Israeli settlement construction represents a far more fundamental threat to Middle East peace than does Palestinian membership in UNESCO.
"Palestinian membership in UNESCO is perfectly legal, took place because it was the wish of an overwhelming majority of the international community, and in no way creates obstacles to peace," he said.
"Settlement activity, on the other hand, is clearly illegal under international law and is designed to make it more difficult to achieve territorial compromise."
Thomas Woodley, president of Montreal-based Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East, was more critical.
"While the Harper government often seeks to position its response to developments in the Middle East as principled, it is difficult to find any principle in its response this week," he said.
"On the one had, it responds to an innocuous UNESCO vote very rapidly and dramatically. Yet when Israel again flouts international law with more settlement construction, the government's response is reluctant and tentative."
But Paul Michaels, director of research at the Toronto-based Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs, said he agreed with Baird's call for a return to direct negotiations and was "pleased that Israel was quick to welcome the announcement without preconditions."
Read more: http://www.windsorstar.com/news/Baird+tough+UNESCO+comments+raise/5649192/story.html#ixzz1cere1C3X
http://www.montrealgazette.com/news/Baird+tough+UNESCO+comments+raise/5649192/story.html
Last edited by a moderator:





