Advertisement

Bumbling Incompetence by Chairman FBR Jahanzeb Continues to Disappoint the Government

As predicted in my previous posts, the poor choice of the government for Chairman FBR is coming back to bite it. FBR now has a shortfall of Rs. 175 billion in the first half of the financial year, and this will definitely grow to over Rs. 500 billion if the same state of affairs continues.

1878604-tax-1546312761-650-640x480.jpg


Immediately after the appointment of Jahanzeb Khan as Chairman FBR, Rauf Klasra had pointed out the shortcomings of this man, but unfortunately no one took notice. This is a man closely aligned with the interests of Shahbaz Sharif, who accompanied him for negotiations with Chinese firms, who promoted the idea of 56 private companies used for siphoning off billions of rupees, and who is is currently facing NAB inquiries for his role in Saaf Paani and other dubious schemes.

Jahanzeb Khan is a man who has no leadership qualities. He sits aloof in his office and does not interact with his officers. He seems fond of listening to unverified gossip but is quite indecisive. He got five of his Members transferred out last month, many for no reason, but was later asking different people about who to post as their replacements. Ultimately, he posted two grossly unqualified officers at the key posts of Member Inland Revenue Operations and Member Inland Revenue Policy. Five posts (Member Admin., Member IT, Member HRM, Member Legal (IR), Member FATE) remain vacant till now. Two more posts of DG (BS-21) are going to be vacant soon because of retirements. But Jahanzeb Khan has no clue about what to do in the situation.

A person with poor communication skills, no knowledge of tax laws or FBR's working, and clinging on merely due to his relationship with Arbab Shahzad, he is a deadweight which will sink the PTI government's efforts to improve revenue collection.

https://tribune.com.pk/story/187860...ollection-misses-target-rs175b-economy-slows/
 
Advertisement
Are you trying to blackmail him so that he gives in to your demands???
As far as creating a public company to do public work which the public departments re not doing to Govt Departments inefficiencies is not a bad idea but due to inherent corrupt mindset of PMLn could not get implemented.
 
Are you trying to blackmail him so that he gives in to your demands???
As far as creating a public company to do public work which the public departments re not doing to Govt Departments inefficiencies is not a bad idea but due to inherent corrupt mindset of PMLn could not get implemented.

I find this comment offensive. My post was meant to inform the powers that be of the reasons for poor performance by FBR. No demands are being made from this Chairman, so your suggestion of blackmailing is completely inappropriate.
 
Advertisement
I find this comment offensive. My post was meant to inform the powers that be of the reasons for poor performance by FBR. No demands are being made from this Chairman, so your suggestion of blackmailing is completely inappropriate.
Then be a man and inform prime minister through letter or is it too much to ask???
 
It is an age of specialisation. You have to put the person qualified in a specific field in his specific duties. The whole system of CSS/PCS needs to be overhauled. No longer can you put . .engineers in the customs and excise, doctors in Revenue and lawyers in building projects. The relevant ministries should hire people who have education in the relevant field. Our Finance Ministry lacks a world class economist. The bureau statistics which gives very vital information for future planning and development is ignored and treated like a step-child. In fact our 5 yr plans died in great agony in 1969 along with Family Planning. These should be the priorities of the Govt. to stop further decay
 
It is an age of specialisation. You have to put the person qualified in a specific field in his specific duties. The whole system of CSS/PCS needs to be overhauled. No longer can you put . .engineers in the customs and excise, doctors in Revenue and lawyers in building projects. The relevant ministries should hire people who have education in the relevant field. Our Finance Ministry lacks a world class economist. The bureau statistics which gives very vital information for future planning and development is ignored and treated like a step-child. In fact our 5 yr plans died in great agony in 1969 along with Family Planning. These should be the priorities of the Govt. to stop further decay

Rightly pointed out the root cause of every govt institution's poor performance. Not only civil services but ministries need SMEs to do the job. China's governance model is the best to follow in today's world.
 
I dont know what is the problem hurdle creation by non performing govt employees

not used to work and earn halal rozi.
Targets should be allocated and performance should be monitored.
Performance monitoring is not limited to asking about achievement but to enquire about the strategy adapted and the database created.Other statistical information gained???
 
Advertisement
And in continuity just to add highest number of revenue officers are MBBS doctors come through CSS/PCS so what kind of economic background except civil service academic basic training they may have, we can easily understand that.
It is an age of specialisation. You have to put the person qualified in a specific field in his specific duties. The whole system of CSS/PCS needs to be overhauled. No longer can you put . .engineers in the customs and excise, doctors in Revenue and lawyers in building projects. The relevant ministries should hire people who have education in the relevant field. Our Finance Ministry lacks a world class economist. The bureau statistics which gives very vital information for future planning and development is ignored and treated like a step-child. In fact our 5 yr plans died in great agony in 1969 along with Family Planning. These should be the priorities of the Govt. to stop further decay