Advertisement

BBC Speaks Truth on Bangladesh: International Media and Human Rights Group are on their side, why no

  • Thread starter Thread starter gotti
  • Start date Start date
Three people have been killed in Bangladesh after demonstrators protesting against the death sentence on an Islamist party leader clashed with police for a third day running.

Delwar Hossain Sayeedi was sentenced on Thursday on charges including murder, rape and torture during the war of independence in 1971.Since then, at least 46 people have died in riots across the country.
Mr Sayeedi's Jamaat-e-Islami party says the tribunal is politically motivated.

Running battles

The BBC's Anbarasan Ethirajan said Saturday's clashes outside the port city of Chittagong began after hundreds of student activists from Jamaat-e-Islami barricaded a motorway.Police said they tried to remove the barricades and a pitched battle ensued.Police fired live ammunition and rubber bullets to disperse the protesters, who attacked with bamboo sticks and stones.

Mr Sayeedi is the third defendant to be convicted by the tribunal, which was set up in 2010 by Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina's government to deal with those accused of collaborating with Pakistani forces who attempted to stop East Pakistan (as Bangladesh was then) from becoming an independent country.
Earlier this month, another Jamaat leader, Abdul Kader Mullah, was sentenced to life for crimes against humanity.In January, former party leader Abul Kalam Azad was found guilty in absentia of eight charges of crimes against humanity and sentenced to death.


'Politically motivated'


The tribunal is trying a total of nine Jamaat leaders and two members of the opposition Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP).
[HI]But human rights groups have said the tribunal falls short of international standards[/HI]. Jamaat is an ally of the BNP, which is led by former Prime Minister Khaleda Zia. Ms Zia says the war crimes trials are politically motivated to target the opposition. The government has denied the allegation. Jamaat and Ms Zia's party have called for a three-day nationwide general strike starting Sunday.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-21639831
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Advertisement
There is no sound and sane reason for Pakistan to interfere in another sovereign country's internal issue as Pakistan is a signatory to the UN resolutions period.
 
Advertisement
personally i dont like these jamatyaaas but tehre is no reason to dig up dead graves right now... 1971 is closed and past transaction... bangladesh is using it for political purpose...
 
personally i dont like these jamatyaaas but tehre is no reason to dig up dead graves right now... 1971 is closed and past transaction... bangladesh is using it for political purpose...

Kindly leave support for Musharraf if you are going to be of this opinion because it is the first agenda on Musharraf's plate when it comes to the dealings with India - '71. Kashmir is a current issue but '71 cannot be forgotten.

The generation who saw it happen, saw a part of their country and people separate from them. If, God Forbid, such an event takes place in Baluchistan, will you forget the pro-Pakistan elements in Baluchistan in 5 or even 10 years?

This is an event from our recent history and these are, technically our people. Forgetting their existence will only serve to prove to other communities that Pakistanis don't think you belong to them, because if they don't care about you after, it is natural to assume they never did, before, either.
 
Why is BBC a credible source all of a sudden when it echoes something we like to think is true?

If the same BBC says something bad about the conduct of our Army in 1971 everyone will diss it as propaganda.
 
If Pakistan say some thing it will harm people of Bangladesh, you shall understand this.

I disagree.

The pro-Pakistani sentiment is at an all-time high in Bangladesh because this woman is being perceived as an Indian puppet who came to power in a joke of an election like Zardari did, and implemented the most heinous resolutions like calling Mujeeb the founder of the country, legislatively. Although, the reality is that, Zia-ur-Rehman was the founder and most people agree to this fact, in Bangladesh.

I have been telling people to read the countless posts I have made on this and I will regard you for doing the same at my request.
 
Advertisement
im talking abt bangladesh not pakistan..and musharraf only bring bangladesh in when india brings kargil and kashmir issue....
Kindly leave support for Musharraf if you are going to be of this opinion because it is the first agenda on Musharraf's plate when it comes to the dealings with India - '71. Kashmir is a current issue but '71 cannot be forgotten.

The generation who saw it happen, saw a part of their country and people separate from them. If, God Forbid, such an event takes place in Baluchistan, will you forget the pro-Pakistan elements in Baluchistan in 5 or even 10 years?

This is an event from our recent history and these are, technically our people. Forgetting their existence will only serve to prove to other communities that Pakistanis don't think you belong to them, because if they don't care about you after, it is natural to assume they never did, before, either.
 
Why is BBC a credible source all of a sudden when it echoes something we like to think is true?

If the same BBC says something bad about the conduct of our Army in 1971 everyone will diss it as propaganda.

No one disagrees with the questionable conduct of the army.

BBC made points about the number of massacres being overblown and stated that it was around 300,000-500,000, although, it flickered the numbers it gave so as to not seem obvious in choosing sides.

If the numbers are questionable, then many other things that took place during those events may also be up for debate and since neither of us were there or know people that took part in the atrocities (on both sides), we can't possibly be sure, given that we have to rely on the written records we are provided. If they are conflicting, we usually end up choosing sides.

As we have discussed on plenty of occasions before, I will be forced to do the same, here, again. Even if it comes off as rude or harsh.

Unfortunately, your opinions are not shaped by your head but what you feel will be acceptable in the majority of the place you currently live in. Why? only, in order to prevent having to face vigilantism or backlash from the local populace, which will seem to showcase you as a "foreigner" in any conflicting opinion you may hold.

Had you been a loyal citizen of the nation you're in, you would've spoken out and felt at home at criticizing whoever and indulging in the democratic process of expressing your opinion - kind of like you do here - this goes to show that you hold Pakistan more close to your heart than your place of residence.

There was a time when attacking Muslims was okay, till the concept of Islamophobia and Muslim civil rights was enacted. People such as yourself decided on whatever opinion you felt was acceptable to the masses and transitioned, accordingly.

There was a time when Guantanamo was okay, but then it wasn't. Your train stopped at the same station as everyone else (given that you were riding on a train and not your own car, it was bound to travel with everyone else).

Similarly, we see the perceptions about the drones changing and the same goes for the Shiites. There was a time when America was Shiite-friendly but now the the convergence of interests has ended and we are all anti-Iran (although Bush did include Iran in the axis-of-evil).

Palestine, again, same thing. First the perception was negative and now it's positive. You went along with it, which is why I will request you to do the same, here.

In short, I would like to advise you to, in advance, take the opinion of the masses in the nation, you have conveniently called home, but haven't owned up to or lived in as a proud citizen.

They are pro-Pakistan and anti-Hitler Wajid, right now. It would be good if you toed that line just like you always do ;)
 
Last edited by a moderator:
im talking abt bangladesh not pakistan..and musharraf only bring bangladesh in when india brings kargil and kashmir issue....

Read "In the Line of Fire". Till then, I take your leave.

P.S. No Army officer, new or old, only brings in Bangladesh "because of Kargil". Bangladesh was an integral part of Pakistan and so is Kashmir. There aren't any conflicting opinions on this. Also, read the response I am about to give the PPP guy so you know why this is "our" issue.

Kaisi qaum hai yeh. Azaadi e raye kiya mil gayi, har koi raye rakhnay lag gaya aur tabsaray kernay lag gaya :(
 
Advertisement
There is no sound and sane reason for Pakistan to interfere in another sovereign country's internal issue as Pakistan is a signatory to the UN resolutions period.

If Pakistan is a signatory to the UN resolutions, then, so was India and had not been granted any moral or legal right to interfere in our territory to apparently "liberate" the people of East Pakistan.

You have absolutely no moral authority on this issue, given that your roohani daddy caused the political deadlock by not giving up the throne that he had usurped from Mujeeb.

However, we will give him credit for ripping up the UN resolution and he did that with absolute moral authority because the Indians had no legal right to enter into Pakistani territory and occupy our lands alongside armed rebels that they helped arm. Thus, if Musharraf entered Kargil to free Kashmir, which is a legally, UN-recognized disputed territory and Pakistani territory under the terms of the agreement with the British, no one should have an issue.

But people do and still support India, why? As I said above, no morals (although I added "authority", which gives a different meaning, but I had to make it sound clever, so I wrote what I wrote, just like that - kind of like you writing anything you want, whenever you want, without putting any thought into it - just like that).

Indian adventurists were not UN forces and neither were they recognized by the entire community of nations before the underwent that endeavor. They utilized Russian support and the cold war-era, end of the world scenarios to trump American involvement to get away with this non-sense. If they tried such an invasion now, it was be labelled as crimes against humanity alongside the American invasion of Iraq and the Russian invasion of Georgia.

They illegally invaded our land, period.

Also, the Mujeebists had been slaughtered by the Bengalis, themselves, for betraying Pakistan and the newly-formed Bangladesh (by cozying up to India, to the point that they were about to give up the country).

You, self-appointed propagators of the leftist philosophy are completely unaware of the issue, at hand, and out of dogmatic, hardheadedness, continuously shoving in your ideological issues into a concept that has more to do with Pakistan than your ideology.

When a nation and its people's interests come into play, people don't care about ideological relations like you emotional buffoons. People, instead, focus on what's best for their country.

Case in point: America is now in bed with the neo-Ottomans and the Islamists because they believe in parliamentary democracy whilst other extremists do not. Prior to this, they had been supporters of theirs out of ideology during the Reagan-era of God vs. Communism. Right now, there is an atheistic regime in America yet they are still supporting those who they don't believe are of the same philosophy.

Similarly, Russian Putin, a KGB spy and atheist, got the support of the Orthodox church to come into power.

Zardari, got the support of JUI-F and was in bed with PML-N for three years (who they are referring to now, as extremists).

A party that never cared for ideology, has a supporter that does?

In politics, politics and self-interest is key, not ideology.

Sooner you realize it, the better.

P.S. Even Iran funded Hamas (although, they killed them after in Syria). And are supporting an Alawite, now. It's politics, stupid.


P.P.S. Bhutto, the secular communists, alongside the Mullahs (of all schools of thought, including Shiites) declared Qadiyanis as non-Muslims. Oh the Irony! No one can possibly support PPP with logic, morals and a straight face
 
Last edited by a moderator:
BBC Speaks the truth :lol::lol::lol:

yes kafi dekha hai "truth":)

If someone lies on many occasions and is truthful in one, we can't call that person's truth a lie, just because he lied in the past or had developed that reputation.

Take this analogy as an example:

If you keep calling day, night, and vice versa, you're a liar. But let's say that one day you say that it's day, and it is, we can't call you a liar because that's the truth.

Even though, you have this image of a liar, you can't be called one, when you're speaking the truth.

Another example is the kid who kept crying wolf. One day, the day when the wolf actually came, people thought he was lying while he was not.

What was the result?

People let someone die alongside sheep that they could've used as food - it was their own loss, but they didn't realize it - they were caught up on the fact that the boy deceived them or lied to them in the past about the wolf coming when there really wasn't one.

In short, this time, they are right, the wolf is here and you should heed their warning, or, in other words, accept their news report.
 
There is no sound and sane reason for Pakistan to interfere in another sovereign country's internal issue as Pakistan is a signatory to the UN resolutions period.

yes because you enemies of islam support bangaldesh government .as its your ppp who broke pakistan in 1971 and its ppp who supports pro pakistani muslims massacre in bangaldesh at present
 
Advertisement

They will agree, eventually.

The only issue with these people is that they lack the capacity to formulate their own opinions and wait till their opinion-maker tells them whether one thing is good or bad.

Now, that the international media, eventually picked up on this tyranny, they will eventually follow along. The only resistance in their minds will be the previously developed mindset, which will take time to change. A few more articles and clips from lighter skinned people (or the people of their choice) and they will digest everything, in a second.

To quote a commenter on the clip you shared:

"This is open prove that who did violence and killed people in 1971 ... this Awami League are ******** and enemy of islam"

He meant to say "proof".

These people will eventually accept this, too because that's the truth and BTW, the reason the West is accepting the facts of the atrocities being conducted by Hitler Wajid is because, it is a fact.

What's funny is that the last part of "enemy of Islam" will be a thorn on their side but they don't realize this, living abroad where they have the freedom to go to their mosques and places of worship without question. No matter how "moderate" you are, or secular, you cannot accept places of worship being closed down, religious figures being beaten and worshipers stopped from assembling in front of God.

No Church, Temple or any other place of assembly in front of the Almighty can be shut down, even in a leftist or secular society as it allows freedom of religion to even people who believe in Scientology.

This is a right that these people are granted living in the comfort of their homes in the West and a basic human right, too. However, as I've pointed out, this is not a religion vs secular issue but that of tyranny and imposition of Hitler Wajid rule who is imposing her version of history and Bengali nationalism on the vast majority of Bengalis.

It is a slight hesitance that is stopping them from condemning this because they are still stuck on hating fundamentalists.

As the death list eventually comes to moderate and secular individuals, they will take notice but not condemn it despite being proven everything and leaving them with no arguments. They will say, no, it's none of our business, but still not be ready to accept it.

What are they waiting for, you ask?

They are waiting for a Chuck Hagel to speak up and say that "India is funding trouble for Pakistan". Now, me and you can say this as much as we want but they will laugh and ignore until Chuck Hagel says it and then, they will zip their lips and follow along.

Similarly, when someone like, let's say John Kerry says this is wrong, the situation will be concluded in their favour and these people will follow.

They don't think from their brains but only what they feel is acceptable to whoever they idolize. It could be Musharraf, Bhutto, or Obama.

They don't have an individual thought process and can't think for themselves - yet, they will come out and argue in favor or against issues with so much zeal, you'd think they were firm believers of this ideology - no, in a couple minutes, they would switch their allegiance, when an indication from their idols, is made.

These idiots are not even fit for the West because the empowerment that the West provides its citizens is beyond comprehension.

These people are basically, worthless zombies, running around on fuel that they feel makes sense to them only on the basis of what their self-concocted idols guide them toward.

Yeh wohi jaahil hongay jo accept keraingay Hitler Wajid ki ghalazat ko jab inko ehsaas kahien aur say dilaya jayega (yeh jaga zaruri nahi maghrib ho, Iran, Saudi, aur India bhi ho sakti hai)

Misaal kay taur per, SAFMA walon ko agar bataya jaye kay Jaswant Singh aur Manmohan maantay hain kay musalmaano kay saath ziyaadti ho rahi hai to woh maan laingay - tab tak, aap per ilzaam aur tuhmatain lagatay rahingay - jahil kay bachay
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Gotti I ain't replying your hollow rhetorics. I'm just pointing out the link between the last Moghul emperor and his relatives, Mirza Aslam Baig and there ilks. And guess what I found this out from none other than BBC....Sometimes I feel sorry for barbarian ideology.

http://m.bbc.co.uk/news/health-21613924

Autism, attention deficit-hyperactivity disorder, bipolar disorder, major depressive disorder and schizophrenia all share several genetic risk factors, according to a major study.


Versions of four genes increased the odds of all five disorders.


Researchers hope to move the psychiatry away from describing symptoms towards fundamentally understanding what is going wrong in the brain.


The findings were reported in the Lancet medical journal.


The international study compared the genetic codes of 33,000 people with a psychiatric disorder with 28,000 people without a psychiatric disorder.


Four genetic variants appeared to increase the risk of all five disorders studied. Two genes were involved in the balance of calcium in the brain.


Hundreds of genes and the environment are likely to affect the odds of developing such conditions.


However, the rapidly advancing field of psychiatric genetics is trying to describe these disorders on the basis of what is causing them, rather simply by symptoms.


One of the researchers Nick Craddock, a professor of psychiatry at Cardiff University, said: "It signals the opening of a potential new era for psychiatry and mental illness.


"This is a scientific method that helps understand what is going wrong in the brain, the chemicals, the brains systems, that are important in illness."


He said that ultimately it could help devise treatments and better ways of diagnosing patients.


Dr Gerome Breen, from the Institute of Psychiatry at King's College London, said: "It points out fairly clearly that there is a common genetic effect between these disorders.
 
Gotti I ain't replying your hollow rhetorics. I'm just pointing out the link between the last Moghul emperor and his relatives, Mirza Aslam Baig and there ilks. And guess what I found this out from none other than BBC....Sometimes I feel sorry for barbarian ideology.

http://m.bbc.co.uk/news/health-21613924

Autism, attention deficit-hyperactivity disorder, bipolar disorder, major depressive disorder and schizophrenia all share several genetic risk factors, according to a major study.


Versions of four genes increased the odds of all five disorders.


Researchers hope to move the psychiatry away from describing symptoms towards fundamentally understanding what is going wrong in the brain.


The findings were reported in the Lancet medical journal.


The international study compared the genetic codes of 33,000 people with a psychiatric disorder with 28,000 people without a psychiatric disorder.


Four genetic variants appeared to increase the risk of all five disorders studied. Two genes were involved in the balance of calcium in the brain.


Hundreds of genes and the environment are likely to affect the odds of developing such conditions.


However, the rapidly advancing field of psychiatric genetics is trying to describe these disorders on the basis of what is causing them, rather simply by symptoms.


One of the researchers Nick Craddock, a professor of psychiatry at Cardiff University, said: "It signals the opening of a potential new era for psychiatry and mental illness.


"This is a scientific method that helps understand what is going wrong in the brain, the chemicals, the brains systems, that are important in illness."


He said that ultimately it could help devise treatments and better ways of diagnosing patients.


Dr Gerome Breen, from the Institute of Psychiatry at King's College London, said: "It points out fairly clearly that there is a common genetic effect between these disorders.

I would be forced to admit that you are definitely going to be diagnosed for the attention-disorder, ADHD, professionally, when your family takes you in for a treatment, given that you are likely stuck staring at a blank wall for hours and not able to concentrate in five-minute conversations. You have clearly displayed your lack of concentration by connecting this to something that has no relevance to it, in the farthest of ways.

This has nothing to do with Barbarianism, Aslam Beg was against the Bangladesh operation and was court-martialed (only being reinstated after the war ended).

The details of what happened in Bangladesh are debatable (and this will be fathomable to you) only until we see some Western, honest resource, accepting the facts. We already have them stating that the numbers they quoted are 3-5 million whilst the real numbers are around 300,000-500,000. No independent research has been conducted on the issue, which clearly indicates that if there is a discrepancy here, then there is a discrepancy in other parts of the war, as well.

There is a book by a Bengali Hindu lady by the last name Bose (which is acceptable to you, as a reference) about what really happened, in her view. The name of the book is Dead Reckoning: Memories of the 1971 Bangladesh War. If you are as knowledgeable as you claim, you would know that Bose is a Bengali last name.

Furthermore, it is important for idiots like you to realize that many pro-Pakistan Bengalis and Biharis were slaughtered but no one would care about it until, except of course, we have a Hagel moment where his point of view comes into the limelight despite having been held by others for years and then, accepted, immediately.

BTW, he said what he said, in 2011 but even until recently, you were trying to ignore his perspective by stating that his nomination has not yet been confirmed. Now, this isn't an issue with you, it is also an issue with others who would wait for Iran, Arabs or even India to dictate their way of thinking and create their opinions for them, on different issues.

In short, a BBC article is enough to shut you and your likes up because had you been so strongly opposed to others or firmly adamant in your philosophy, you would, firstly, base it on logic and not have it at all, and secondly, not be influenced by others because of holding it. Even the communists of China created Maoism and not stick with Leninism as they tried to make it specific to their society, culture and local customs and not copy everything, regardless of whether it fits in their system, or not.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
No one disagrees with the questionable conduct of the army.

BBC made points about the number of massacres being overblown and stated that it was around 300,000-500,000, although, it flickered the numbers it gave so as to not seem obvious in choosing sides.

If the numbers are questionable, then many other things that took place during those events may also be up for debate and since neither of us were there or know people that took part in the atrocities (on both sides), we can't possibly be sure, given that we have to rely on the written records we are provided. If they are conflicting, we usually end up choosing sides.

As we have discussed on plenty of occasions before, I will be forced to do the same, here, again. Even if it comes off as rude or harsh.

Unfortunately, your opinions are not shaped by your head but what you feel will be acceptable in the majority of the place you currently live in. Why? only, in order to prevent having to face vigilantism or backlash from the local populace, which will seem to showcase you as a "foreigner" in any conflicting opinion you may hold.

Had you been a loyal citizen of the nation you're in, you would've spoken out and felt at home at criticizing whoever and indulging in the democratic process of expressing your opinion - kind of like you do here - this goes to show that you hold Pakistan more close to your heart than your place of residence.

There was a time when attacking Muslims was okay, till the concept of Islamophobia and Muslim civil rights was enacted. People such as yourself decided on whatever opinion you felt was acceptable to the masses and transitioned, accordingly.

There was a time when Guantanamo was okay, but then it wasn't. Your train stopped at the same station as everyone else (given that you were riding on a train and not your own car, it was bound to travel with everyone else).

Similarly, we see the perceptions about the drones changing and the same goes for the Shiites. There was a time when America was Shiite-friendly but now the the convergence of interests has ended and we are all anti-Iran (although Bush did include Iran in the axis-of-evil).

Palestine, again, same thing. First the perception was negative and now it's positive. You went along with it, which is why I will request you to do the same, here.

In short, I would like to advise you to, in advance, take the opinion of the masses in the nation, you have conveniently called home, but haven't owned up to or lived in as a proud citizen.

They are pro-Pakistan and anti-Hitler Wajid, right now. It would be good if you toed that line just like you always do ;)


So basically its pick and choose.

If something makes sense to your sensibilities you accept it as fact even if you have expressed doubts about the source of information on previous occasions.

Unfortunately, your opinions are not shaped by your head but what you feel will be acceptable in the majority of the place you currently live in. Why? only, in order to prevent having to face vigilantism or backlash from the local populace, which will seem to showcase you as a "foreigner" in any conflicting opinion you may hold.

I dont know if this was expressly directed to me or if it was a general comment...
 
So basically its pick and choose.

If something makes sense to your sensibilities you accept it as fact even if you have expressed doubts about the source of information on previous occasions.

:(

I am sure that's how it is for everyone and should be.

If that wasn't the case, I would have to accept every single piece of information given to me from every single source I quote as a reference, at all times, without adding the slightest grain of salt to their previous or even current "revelations".

As a higher education student, you probably also do not accept every researcher's quoted information, unconditionally. No field does. Art, Science, Technology and especially not Politics.

Similarly, accepting a Christian, Jew or Atheist as a reference in your thesis does not necessarily mean you subscribe to the same religious philosophy and what they had to say about their idea of God, only because you agreed with a specific part of what they contributed in their field of research.

Andhi taqleed to koi bhi, kisi waqt bhi nahi ker sakta. Hata kay Islam main bhi her koi her Imam ya Alim ki baat nahi maanta ya maan sakta (chahay jitna bhi kahain kay hum uskay maan nay walay hain).

In short, I agree with them here, whilst I fail to comply to the false impression you're trying to create that I had disagreed with them on some different point in the past - this assumes that you have seen me extremely adamant at disagreeing with something they had said or published on a different occasion - since, I am completely unaware of such an incident, if you can bring it to light, I would be glad.

While you're at it, also try to convince us, how that would be relevant to the discussion of trampling over civil liberties of the citizens of a country, which was once our own and the people being killed there, still believe in good relations with Pakistan.

Stubbornly trying to prove that I am hypocritical or contradictory will serve no purpose in a political discourse in which I do not have a significant role. If you're concerned about the topic at hand or have some comment, we can continue. If, however, you want to throw red herrings about BBC or agreeing or disagreeing with them, then, they won't be responded to as they are irrelevant.

Your opinion on the matter at hand, would much rather serve a better purpose than discussing the news media organization or who or what agreed or disagreed with them at one point in time or the other.

I dont know if this was expressly directed to me or if it was a general comment...

Everything I write is general and aimed at addressing a larger school of thought or mentality. Individuals can never create a mindset, individually. It almost always has to be collective, in nature.
 
Last edited by a moderator: