Advertisement

As Pakistan Nears Bankruptcy,Patience Of Foreign Lender's Wear Thin: By Graeme Smith !!!

webpakistan28nw_1093101cl-3.jpg

Pakistan analysis

As Pakistan nears bankruptcy, patience of foreign lenders wears thin

GRAEME SMITH

ISLAMABAD From Tuesday's Globe and Mail

Published Tuesday, Dec. 28, 2010 12:14AM EST


pixel.php

A terrifying kind of mathematics has become popular among aid workers, analysts and others who spend their lives tracking the fate of Pakistan. Its a back-of-the-envelope calculation about how the country will get through the coming years without declaring bankruptcy: take the countrys foreign debt ($53-billion), add interest, subtract the $1.8-billion that wont arrive as scheduled on Jan. 1 from the International Monetary Fund because Islamabad failed to meet loan conditions. Add the staggering cost, perhaps $10-billion, of rebuilding after summer floods.

A Village Saved, a Village Lost


The numbers seem bleak. The government floated the possibility last week of running a deficit for the coming year of $15-billion.
Islamabads latest plan to raise revenue, a reformed tax law, has become bogged down by stubborn opposition parties, front-page criticism and street protests. The cabinets economic team is threatening to quit.
Pakistan needs a bailout. But is the country still a good investment?
Thats the conversation people are having now, about whether youd be throwing good money after bad, said Mosharraf Zaidi, a development expert and policy analyst based in Islamabad.
The international community has accused Pakistan of poor financial management for years. Cables recently posted by the website WikiLeaks show a U.S. intelligence official complaining in 2008 about the countrys preference for spending money on strategic military hardware instead of development: Despite pending economic catastrophe, Pakistan is producing nuclear weapons at a faster rate than any other country in the world.
Patience with such behaviour wore especially thin as the government failed to honour several promises for cleaning up its balance sheet in recent months. As part of its IMF loan deals, Islamabad had vowed to cut electricity subsidies and find new ways of bringing in revenue. In particular, foreign donors wanted the country to crack down on its upper classes, notorious for shirking taxes.
Instead, the government responded by calling for debt forgiveness not an absurd idea, in a country that spends up to 40 per cent of its annual budget servicing its debts, but still galling for international lenders.
The government also continued printing money to cover its costs.
Islamabad had promised to stop borrowing from its own state bank, but instead took almost $4-billion to prop up the budget contributing to crippling inflation.
Defence spending increased this year, and will likely continue rising, while the government cut its development budget in half.
If something like this happened in Canada, there would be a revolution, Mr. Zaidi said recently at a fashionable coffee shop in Islamabad. Outside the window, however, in the leafy neighbourhood where expats shopped for Christmas decorations and luxury vehicles cruised slowly along well-paved streets, there was no sign of a revolt. That has been an enduring feature of Pakistani politics, the willingness of the middle and lower classes to absorb hardships. It remains an open question how long that trend will continue. Recent protests against the new Reformed General Sales Tax (RGST) were not widespread, but economists say the gross domestic product must grow an average of 7 per cent per year to keep up with the explosive number of young Pakistanis joining the work force.
The economy achieved that average rate of growth from 2000 to 2007, a period of declining poverty and unemployment, when Pakistan was mentioned among the so-called Next Eleven emerging economies by the U.S. investment bank Goldman Sachs.
But the growth streak slowed down as militancy erupted, particularly after the bloody storming of Islamabads Red Mosque in 2007. The government had hoped for 4.5 per cent growth in this fiscal year, but revised that down to 2.8 per cent after the recent floods.
Many of the nightmare scenarios envisioned after the floods have not emerged, however. Epidemics did not ravage the country as some predicted. The biggest export industry, cotton textiles, limped through the disaster but survived.
Pakistans own expatriate community abroad, which already sends home almost $10-billion per year, proved generous with their countrymen. In some backwater corners of the country, flood victims forced to live in camps have experienced better hygiene, education and health care than in their own villages. Those people could get a fresh start, if the international community decides to invest in major reconstruction.
Lets build better, this time, Mengesha Kebede, the Pakistan head of the UN High Commission for Refugees. There could be a qualitative improvement in the quality of life.
Others say that demographic forces, and a thirst for education, will ensure that the country eventually pulls itself out of its current problems.
Tahir Andrabi, an economist at Pomona College who has been working on a four-year study of education in rural parts of central Pakistan, said the country already has the falling fertility rates and a growing cohort of educated women usually associated with strong development.
Its remarkable, whats happening in Pakistan, Mr. Andrabi said.
This is supposed to be the most dangerous country in the world, and female education is skyrocketing.
 
Advertisement
yeah thanks to the stupid and greedy leech Mr. Zardari and his looters, foolish, and bast-ards friends we had to see this day........ Such a looser...
 
The rich do not pay their share of income tax throughout the world and the poor can't. Its the middle class that carries both. GST is a good form of tax its a tax that rich can't avoid as they avoid income tax. Expanding the middle class is the key a shrinking middle class is disaster for any country.
 
Oh well. I don't know much about economy and its dynamics but as an ordinary Pakistani, I strongly believe that what ever happens we will never be bankrupt. Because that would mean that we cannot pay our loans and interest hence our lenders won't get a penny from us. And of course they cannot accept that. ;)
 
Oh well. I don't know much about economy and its dynamics but as an ordinary Pakistani, I strongly believe that what ever happens we will never be bankrupt. Because that would mean that we cannot pay our loans and interest hence our lenders won't get a penny from us. And of course they cannot accept that. ;)

PPP should pass a resolution that all debts since Mush Martial Law is void ab initio because:

1. The west installed the Mush govt to punish NS for his nuke, hence they were part of the Mush clan

2. All loans were given to buy favors and puppets therefore they are void

3. A need or situation was created by the west and Free Masons so Pak could bend on knees to beg for loan. Therefore the loans are void. Installing of PPP is one classical proof the West's interference in our affairs.

Pakistan Zindabad
 
This is the time to get all possible loans writtenoff while The War on terror is still going on.Lot of liabilities have accrued due to this damn war.Unless The Govt somehow gets this done from International donors/Govt we will have nothing left after paying for running state expenses,interest on local and foreign borrowings and ever escalating Defence expenditure.
 
Advertisement
WASHINGTON DIARY: Borrow until broke: how to make a nation fail —Dr Manzur Ejaz
20101229_05.jpg
The lack of governance, irresponsible spending by the governing elite and non-collection of income taxes are the biggest hurdles. Power shortages, corruption and nepotism are major hurdles for the private sector to increase production. The opportunism of different political parties does not allow any government to devise a rational policy


When Pakistani governing elites go around distributing grants in the name of various programmes — from the Benazir Income Support Programme to flood relief — one wonders where all this money is coming from. Every year salary levels are raised around budget time and money is thrown at various professional groups (like bar councils) without any reference to the source of these funds. The result is that inflation is roaring in Pakistan and necessary goods are becoming too expensive for the common citizen. And yet every political party wants funding for its pet programmes without any clue to the available national resources.

Last week, the Governor of the State Bank, Mr Shahid Hafiz Kardar, let the cat out of the bag by saying that heavy government borrowing was causing the rise of price levels. The Pakistani media is immune to such statements and it was perceived as a minor note compared to the WikiLeaks story. There was nothing new in his statement because it has been said over and over again, and we all know it. But no one takes it seriously enough to make it a national issue and protest in the legislative bodies. On the contrary, almost every political party opposes corrective measures in the name of the “poor masses” without suggesting any workable remedy.

Excessive government borrowing has been the biggest story in Pakistan for many years and many successive governments. This issue is even bigger than fighting the Taliban or Kashmir because it keeps Pakistan’s basic economy unstable and deep in the ditches. It simply means that governments spend money that they do not have.

The government asks the State Bank of Pakistan for a loan. The central bank floats bonds and other financial instruments to raise the funds. In the ultimate analysis, the central bank increases money supply, which is called money printing in common parlance. Because of increased supply, too much money chases goods that are always in limited quantity. Therefore, the price of every good goes up by the strength of the hike in money supply. Therefore, when the government increases salaries or distributes funds, the recipients should know that they are given something by one hand and are having something taken away by the other. Pakistan has been mired in this cycle for decades.

Pakistan’s economic scenario is a typical example of stagflation in which inflation and unemployment rise simultaneously. If the economy is running smoothly then there is a trade off between inflation and the level of unemployment, i.e. to bring unemployment down, inflation is accepted. However, in stagflation this process breaks down and rising inflation does not decrease unemployment, rather it increases it. The US was trapped in stagflation during the 1970s.

In such conditions the government is supposed to decrease its spending, borrow less from the central bank and stop printing money. At the same time, the government undertakes policies to provide incentives to the private sector to increase production and create more employment. During the Reagan administration, the US government tried to bring down spending on social welfare programmes and gave tax cuts to the private sector so that it had more funds to invest. Somehow it worked for a while and the US came out of stagflation. During the Clinton era, not only was the deficit eliminated, the government had a huge surplus fund that the Bush administration squandered.

Pakistan’s case is very different because the government has no tool other than using or misusing the central bank. The idea of tax cuts to the private sector is irrelevant because very few pay taxes anyway. Sales tax is no solution for this problem because the burden is borne by the common citizens. The government will reduce its borrowing from the central bank but the sales tax will create inflationary pressure. Therefore, again the government will be giving something with one hand and taking away with the other. The only way Pakistan can come out of stagflation is by strict austerity and creating a conducive environment for the private sector to boost production.

Presently, the lack of governance, irresponsible spending by the governing elite and non-collection of income taxes are the biggest hurdles. Power shortages, corruption and nepotism are major hurdles for the private sector to increase production. The opportunism of different political parties does not allow any government to devise a rational policy. For example if the MQM or ANP facilitates electricity thieves or the PPP protects its feudal backers, no economic manager can stabilise this economy.

Pakistan’s new economic managers led by Dr Abdul Hafeez Sheikh and Dr Nadeem-ul-Haque may be competent and well meaning but they cannot do much because the root cause of Pakistan’s economic problem is in the political arena. Therefore, unless a competent political force (not military or technocracy) takes the reins in its hands, there will be no end to government borrowing, inflation and impoverishment.

The writer can be reached at [email protected](WWW.DAILYTIMES.COM)
 
This is the time to get all possible loans writtenoff while The War on terror is still going on.Lot of liabilities have accrued due to this damn war.Unless The Govt somehow gets this done from International donors/Govt we will have nothing left after paying for running state expenses,interest on local and foreign borrowings and ever escalating Defence expenditure.

Thats exactly what the US/Israel/India has in plans, to break us down then break us apart, this is not going to happen. This is not bangladesh, all provinces and agencies are land linked and there is separation movement except where India is agitating trouble for us.

India on the other hand has 13 provinces that need just a blow to the chingari of separation, phir tamasha dekho. Khalistan, Kashmir, and Maoist
top the list.
 
مدینہ ثانی یعنی پاکستان کےاندرونی بیرونی بد حواہ اپنے خواب دل میں لیے ہی مر جائیں گے. موجودہ جونکیں، لگڑ بھگے، بجو، سانپ، کتے، کینچوے، کیڑے مکوڑے، اور نیچ پلید سیاست دان اپنے انجام کو پوھنچ جاییں گے. مدینہ ثانی تا قیامت تابندہ و پایندہ رہنے کے لیے ہے.
​

:pakistan-flag-wavin:pakistan-flag-wavin:pakistan-flag-wavin:pakistan-flag-wavin:pakistan-flag-wavin
​
Oh Yes, I am incorrigible optimist(clap)

تندی باد مخالف سے نہ گھبرا آیے عقاب
یہ تو چلتی ہے تجھے اونچا اڑانے کے لیے

And I request you all that instead of rebuking the rebuked, let us

آؤ کہ جسم چن دیں اینٹ پتھر کی جگہ
بے در و دیوار ہے مگر گھر تو اپنا ہے

​