- Joined
- Jun 25, 2013
- Posts
- 4,503
- Reaction score
- 1,123
- Points
- 113
Thread Starter's comments :
The narration of this interesting documentary is done by some one who claims to be grandson of Raja Sahib Mahmudabad who was one of the stalwart of Muslim league and friend of creator of Pakistan Mr.Jinnah and a philanthropist of high order .
The subject is Shia of India .
The pathetic aspect is that grandson of Raja sahib should not have narrated this you tube documentary because of its content.
Three points here may be noted :
1. The early part of documentary has claims which do not add to facts and seem fable like to make look good Hindu Rajas and also contains vague type of a hint like claim of Ali Bin Abu Talib having visited India.
2. The claim of percentage of shias is also grossly wrong and over estimated in the documentary correct figures are available from British Gazette who counted caste , sects and even income of people in census-
thefollowing sentence is from a book edit footnote in book by a European lady who was wife of a noble man of Oudh - it says quote in mid 1880s , Sunnis very largely preponderating over Shi'ahs. According to the latest information there were in the United Provinces of Agra and Oudh, nearly 6-1/2 million Sunnis and 183,000 Shi'ahs (Imperial Gazetteer (1908), xxiv. 172). This information was not collected in recent census reports. In the whole of India, in 1881, there were 46-3/4 million Sunnis, as compared with 809,561 Shi'ah-
my view is this figure again is incorrect being very low
3. There is tendency to overemphasize persecution by others as is common in such narratives .
But overall this is good academic documentary and is factually correct after year 1300 AD or approximately correct .
One tragedy common to sunni and shia muslims of India is that pressure of Hindus force them to offer an apologetic view on Pakistan and try to tie their own community with Gandhi etc . This reflects failure of power of Pakkstan and OIC countries not imposing any conditions on Indian government .
Documentary
The narration of this interesting documentary is done by some one who claims to be grandson of Raja Sahib Mahmudabad who was one of the stalwart of Muslim league and friend of creator of Pakistan Mr.Jinnah and a philanthropist of high order .
The subject is Shia of India .
The pathetic aspect is that grandson of Raja sahib should not have narrated this you tube documentary because of its content.
Three points here may be noted :
1. The early part of documentary has claims which do not add to facts and seem fable like to make look good Hindu Rajas and also contains vague type of a hint like claim of Ali Bin Abu Talib having visited India.
2. The claim of percentage of shias is also grossly wrong and over estimated in the documentary correct figures are available from British Gazette who counted caste , sects and even income of people in census-
thefollowing sentence is from a book edit footnote in book by a European lady who was wife of a noble man of Oudh - it says quote in mid 1880s , Sunnis very largely preponderating over Shi'ahs. According to the latest information there were in the United Provinces of Agra and Oudh, nearly 6-1/2 million Sunnis and 183,000 Shi'ahs (Imperial Gazetteer (1908), xxiv. 172). This information was not collected in recent census reports. In the whole of India, in 1881, there were 46-3/4 million Sunnis, as compared with 809,561 Shi'ah-
my view is this figure again is incorrect being very low
3. There is tendency to overemphasize persecution by others as is common in such narratives .
But overall this is good academic documentary and is factually correct after year 1300 AD or approximately correct .
One tragedy common to sunni and shia muslims of India is that pressure of Hindus force them to offer an apologetic view on Pakistan and try to tie their own community with Gandhi etc . This reflects failure of power of Pakkstan and OIC countries not imposing any conditions on Indian government .
Documentary
Last edited:





