Advertisement

After seeing Mujib public meeting address 1971 video , decide if 1971 military action by Yahya was j

A long standing question of Pakistan's politics is whether the military action of yahya in East Pakistan was justified in 1971 ?

An associated question was whether refusal of Sahibzada Yakub khan to take military action as corp commander laudable or simply cowardice ? .

Another two related questions were could we not have laced Bengali military officers with desire to rule and side line mujib and whether Tikka and Niazi were heroes or despots acting in vaccum ?

Have a look at this you tube video of historic address of Shaikh mujib in 1971 ? what is he up to ? . Was there any other way ?

Before I leave you with this video which has English translation of the address , allow me to remind you that Niazi laid arms in East Pakistan on the order of director of military operations Pakistan , Amir Gulistan Janjua and I have firm proofs of that in presence of testimony of officer who actually sent this message to East Pakistan and is now 80 years of age.

Niazi did not lay down arms on his own. This was directed from West Pakistan and later Bhutto in order to malign army and show it as coward and to make them look little in Hamood commission seem to hide this key fact.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Mujib Address 1971

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Advertisement
Mazi mein jo huwa iss ke ander Boohot bari kutayan huwe. Iss se sabak lena chahye aur aik aur 1971 se bachne ke leye koshish karni chahye. hamara dushman kabi bhi nahi rukkay ga.
 
Advertisement
Eik mulk tha, aur pore mulk mein election hoye, aur mujeeb voh election jeet giya, then, it was his right to claim prim minister ship, but bhutto wanted to become prime minister even after losing the election, To is tatah ke kamu mein, is tarah to hota he,
 
shame on army who call him traitor. he was polling agent in of fatimah jinnah in 1966 election but army rigged that election. that is why shaikh mujeeb formed his own party to gain independence from punjabi hegeomony. Today Bangladesh is ahead of Pakistan in almost all socio-economic indicators so in hindsight shaikh mujiburehman was right.
 
shame on army who call him traitor. he was polling agent in of fatimah jinnah in 1966 election but army rigged that election. that is why shaikh mujeeb formed his own party to gain independence from punjabi hegeomony. Today Bangladesh is ahead of Pakistan in almost all socio-economic indicators so in hindsight shaikh mujiburehman was right.

Have you gone through his speech and I would recommend you to read book on role of Mujib before 1958 and also rest assured that between jan 1971 and this speech the slaughter of punjabis and beharis by his workers had already begun .

his role was similar to what would have been Nimr role had he not been hanged by Saudia .
 
Gen Shahabzada Yakoob Khan ,who was Eastern COmmand in chief and Gen Hasan Vice Admiral -rejected the idea of operation- Asked Punjabi Generals to hand over the Govt to winning Party but Punjabis with Bhutto did the most shameful Job. Aaj Tak Moonh Kala Hai.
Gen Yakoob is the highest awarding General from Defence College of Pakistan.
6958502915_fc4bd8794d_b.jpg
 
Advertisement
Later on they did Fraud Bye Elections.
Same things are repeating in Karachi. Waseem Akhter won but 4 months not yet can get oath of Mayor.

 
بھٹّو اور فوج پر تنقید ہوتی دیکھ کر پاکستان کے پڑوس میں کوئی ہنس رہا ہو گا۔ مجیب ہو بھٹّو یا پھر فوجی جرنیل۔ ان میں فرشتہ تو کوئی بھی نہیں تھا۔ سب انسان ہی تھے اور انسان کبھی خود غرضی بھی دکھا جاتے ہیں کبھی ضد میں بھی آ جاتے ہیں اور کبھی ان سے معاملات کا ادراک کرنے میں غلطی ہو جاتی ہے۔ انگریزی میں شاید اسے مِس کیلکولیٹ کرنا کہتے ہیں۔

اس تقسیم میں اصل کردار بھارت کا تھا جو بہت پہلے سے اپنا گیم پلان بنا کر کھیل رہا تھا اور موقعے کے انتظار میں تھا۔ اگر اگرتلہ سازش کے کرداروں کو سانپوں کی طرح کچل دیا جاتا تو یہاں تک نوبت نہ آتی۔

آج اگر پاکستانی اسٹیبلشمنٹ نے را سے تعلق رکھنے والے سنپولیے کل کے لیے چھوڑ دیے تو ہمارے بچے ان جرنیلوں اور سیاستدانوں کو کوس رہے ہوں گے۔
 
Have you gone through his speech and I would recommend you to read book on role of Mujib before 1958 and also rest assured that between jan 1971 and this speech the slaughter of punjabis and beharis by his workers had already begun .

his role was similar to what would have been Nimr role had he not been hanged by Saudia .

slaughter of bengalis had begun the day jinnah in 1948. Since then bengalis became 3rd class citizen in their own country. It is no surprise how quickly bangladesh has grown since independence and has already overtaken pakistan.
 
Later on they did Fraud Bye Elections.
Same things are repeating in Karachi. Waseem Akhter won but 4 months not yet can get oath of Mayor.


mqm itself is a creation of zia ul haq and punjabi establishment. his plan was to destroy PPP so he created pmln in punjab to kick out ppp from urban punjab. in a similar manner he created mqm to kick out ppp from urban sindh. Since then pmln and mqm are two nasooors that have damaged pakistan and brought its destruction. mqm was part of IJI alliance against PPP in 1988 elections.

Till 1980 there is was no such thing as dubai. All foreigners and tourists used to come to karachi to do business deals, enjoy night life and the sea. Since mqm launched to karachi, all the money goes to dubai. Waseem akhtar will just cry for rights and do nothing for karachi as he hasnt done anything in the past. he is only good at doing tv shows and speeches.

the 3rd baby army created in 1980's is taliban. so today raheel shareef is killing the monsters his predecessors created.
 
Advertisement
بھٹّو اور فوج پر تنقید ہوتی دیکھ کر پاکستان کے پڑوس میں کوئی ہنس رہا ہو گا۔ مجیب ہو بھٹّو یا پھر فوجی جرنیل۔ ان میں فرشتہ تو کوئی بھی نہیں تھا۔ سب انسان ہی تھے اور انسان کبھی خود غرضی بھی دکھا جاتے ہیں کبھی ضد میں بھی آ جاتے ہیں اور کبھی ان سے معاملات کا ادراک کرنے میں غلطی ہو جاتی ہے۔ انگریزی میں شاید اسے مِس کیلکولیٹ کرنا کہتے ہیں۔

اس تقسیم میں اصل کردار بھارت کا تھا جو بہت پہلے سے اپنا گیم پلان بنا کر کھیل رہا تھا اور موقعے کے انتظار میں تھا۔ اگر اگرتلہ سازش کے کرداروں کو سانپوں کی طرح کچل دیا جاتا تو یہاں تک نوبت نہ آتی۔

آج اگر پاکستانی اسٹیبلشمنٹ نے را سے تعلق رکھنے والے سنپولیے کل کے لیے چھوڑ دیے تو ہمارے بچے ان جرنیلوں اور سیاستدانوں کو کوس رہے ہوں گے۔

why was raw agent in alliance with mushraff army chief from 2002-2007. fact is that army rulers protects their own interests and doesnt care about the country. before mushi made deal with mqm, they couldnt even win more than 10 seats from karachi.
 
why was raw agent in alliance with mushraff army chief from 2002-2007. fact is that army rulers protects their own interests and doesnt care about the country. before mushi made deal with mqm, they couldnt even win more than 10 seats from karachi.
All of Musharraf's actions are not appriciable. Furthermore, in Musharraf's era, there were more external pressures and internal security challenges preventing such a massive intel based operation in urban areas. After operation against externally supported armed rebels like TTP, this is rite time to take these urban terrorists in disguise of political workers.
 
Last edited:
All of Musharraf's actions are not appriciable. Furthermore, in Musharraf's era, there were more external pressures and internal security challenges preventing such a massive intel based operation in urban areas. After operation against externally supported armed rebels like TTP, this is rite time to take these urban terrorists in disguise of political workers.

actually deal has already happened between mqm and army on minus altaf formula which is unfolding right now. qaim khani was involved in balida town fire and he is now going to bring his hard core gutkays from altaf group into his group. Mustafa kamal is just show piece for media consumption because he speaks well.
 
actually deal has already happened between mqm and army on minus altaf formula which is unfolding right now. qaim khani was involved in balida town fire and he is now going to bring his hard core gutkays from altaf group into his group. Mustafa kamal is just show piece for media consumption because he speaks well.
Deal never happens; it is always made. Let us wait and see, its better to comment than predict.
 
Advertisement
Gen Shahabzada Yakoob Khan ,who was Eastern COmmand in chief and Gen Hasan Vice Admiral -rejected the idea of operation- Asked Punjabi Generals to hand over the Govt to winning Party but Punjabis with Bhutto did the most shameful Job. Aaj Tak Moonh Kala Hai.
Gen Yakoob is the highest awarding General from Defence College of Pakistan.
6958502915_fc4bd8794d_b.jpg

If you have a corp commander in East Pakistan in East Pakistan , and you learn that several units with Bengali officers have changed loyalties and East Bengal regiment is antagonistic , what kind of military leader are you . These things happened under your nose for several months . Then when Mujib goondas started to kill Beharis and West Pakistanis , already several thousand by March , this corp commander does nothing , then when he is asked to correct things , he resigns and gives odd advises . If he were that good , either he would have known of Bengali officers network or he would have laced these Bengali officers with desire to eliminate Mujib and share power of East Pakistan like west Pakistani officers did in west wing . He proved dull and dumb both as military leader and politician .

As we do not have much political sense in our people , Sahibzada was to become hero as he refused to protect Beharis and West Pakistanis essentially in East Pakistan.

Seems nobody has gone through video of mujib and see his tone and demands.

Sahibzadas long serving PA used to jump if you criticize Sahibzada . However if he did well as foriegn minister later on I do not know . but he chickened out of protecting Beharis and patriotic Bengalis at the last moment and like S.M.Ahsan also responsible for breakage of Pakistan .
 
Last edited:
Bangalies played great role in the freedom of pakistan, but then later our stupid politician and Army let people be divided into different sect and casts , so they could divide and rule.
no doubt it was mujeebs right to rule the country but inseated we made enemy out of bangali people and mujeeb.

MQM was made by army on the basis of divide and rule and diminish Jamat e islami from Karachi, and Ary succeeded but the country failed.
 
Last edited:
Difference between Bangalies and MQM.
Bangalies had their own land, Mujeeb's party was awami leag not based on one cast.
MQM calls them selves muhajir, kion bhai 50 years main bhi muhajir ho tu pakistani kab bano gay?
 
The thread shows you a video and English script along with it if Mujeeb speech 1971 two weeks before military action. Question was that was military action justified after studying this speech .

There are some youngsters and some novices who think that anyone who got votes deserves to be given the charge of the country , whatever they stand for or what ever their affiliations are , this fortunately was not the culture of 1960s , if anybody was not clearly patriotic on basics of country he was deemed not fit to be given reins .

Mujib was a deeply tainted from mid 1950s onwards , he was a Goondha of Sahrawardy . He could not be trusted to give reins of paksitan to . He was heard by intelligence saying to his friends that he will get independence after elections , when Yahya asked Ahsan about this tape played to him from the governor , silly Ahsan said , "Shaikh Sahib humare saat aisa nai kar sakte" as Ahsan was close to Mujib .

Chou en lai was reported to have said later say that whole East Pakistan scenario was created by USA to try to arrange a war between Russia and China , USSR then had a military treaty with india , kissinger wanted China to come to Pakistan assistance to get that war and US seventh fleet was meant not to help Pakistan but to befool Pakistan .China too ran away from our help .
 

If you have a corp commander in East Pakistan in East Pakistan , and you learn that several units with Bengali officers have changed loyalties and East Bengal regiment is antagonistic , what kind of military leader are you . These things happened under your nose for several months . Then when Mujib goondas started to kill Beharis and West Pakistanis , already several thousand by March , this corp commander does nothing , then when he is asked to correct things , he resigns and gives odd advises . If he were that good , either he would have known of Bengali officers network or he would have laced these Bengali officers with desire to eliminate Mujib and share power of East Pakistan like west Pakistani officers did in west wing . He proved dull and dumb both as military leader and politician .

As we do not have much political sense in our people , Sahibzada was to become hero as he refused to protect Beharis and West Pakistanis essentially in East Pakistan.

Seems nobody has gone through video of mujib and see his tone and demands.

Sahibzadas long serving PA used to jump if you criticize Sahibzada . However if he did well as foriegn minister later on I do not know . but he chickened out of protecting Beharis and patriotic Bengalis at the last moment and like S.M.Ahsan also responsible for breakage of Pakistan .

Dear Gen Yakoob left Eas Pakistan, before Mukti Bahni revolted .He was of view ,if Bengalis won ,hand over Govt to them. He was sacked and asked for resignation by GHQ Punjabis.