- Joined
- Aug 26, 2010
- Posts
- 9,754
- Reaction score
- 10,623
- Points
- 0
After 15 Year Ch. Sugar Mill (of SHARIF FAMILY) GAS Theft Case Settled
PMLN kay gov mein attey hi 15 saal ka case haal (clap)
PAC settles Chaudhry Sugar Mills gas theft case
The Public Accounts Committee (PAC) Thursday settled 16-year old pending para of theft of Rs3.57 million gas by Chaudhry Sugar Mills Gojra owned by Sharif family on the recommendations of Auditor General of Pakistan (AGP) and Sui Northern Gas Pipeline.
The AGP in 1998 pointed out gas theft by Chaudhry Sugar Mills and made an audit para that remained pending for last 12 years as the audit department did not accept the management’s reply over the issue.
The AGP was of the opinion that SNGPL, Area Office, Faisalabad, billed 16788 HM3 gas consumption to M/s Chaudhry Sugar Mills Gojra for the period from March to May 1998 as against actual gas aggregating to 26605 HM# that passed through SMS during the period; thus 9817 HM3 gas was short-billed to the consumer and SNGPL had to sustain a loss of Rs3.520 million on this accounts.
According to documents presented in the PAC, the auditors pointed out this issue in July 20, 1999, October 15, 1999 and November 17, 1999 but no action was taken on.
The documents showed that on July 26, 2011 and again on July 29, 2011 the issue was raised and SNGPL replied that M/s Chaudhry Sugar Mills, M/s Hamza Paper Board Mills and Housing Colony was provided the gas.
Interestingly, the audit department stuck to their stance and sought explanations from the SNGPL but after the present government comes into power, the Departmental Accounts Committee (DAC) in its meeting on January 10, 2014, the audit department and SNGPL agreed to settle the issue.
On Thursday the documents for settling the para were presented before the PAC. Managing Director of the SNGPL Arif Hameed was of the opinion in the meeting that Chaudhry Sugar Mills was not involved in gas theft but it was a technical mistake as three meters were installed but the billing of the two meters were not conducted and this difference is mainly owing to different meter reading dates, different pressure, temperature and super compressibility factors applied in computing volume by distribution and transmission department.
However, he said when the meter reading of all three meters were compiled, the loss was less than one percent.
The stance of SNGPL was also accepted by the department of the Auditor General of Pakistan and the PAC settled the audit para amicably.
In the PAC, Sheikh Rohail Asghar observed that it was a mistake of the department of Auditor General of Pakistan that created a technical mistake.
In the meanwhile, the PAC referred the cases of gas theft of Rs90 million of 1998-99 by nine steel re-rolling factories of Lahore to the National Accountability Bureau.
The department of the Auditor General of Pakistan pointed out the gas theft by nine factories of Lahore in 1998-99.
Managing Director of the SNGPL Arif Hameed told the PAC that the owners of these factories has run away from the country and factories were closed.
Chairman PAC Syed Khursheed Shah remarked that under the law, gas connections could not be given to the place of the defaulters so why the connections were given to the new factories which were open again there.
Mian Abul Manan observed that private houses were being sealed if they default on gas bills but why the big fish were not catch.
The MD SNGPL told the PAC that the government has drafted the Gas Theft Act that was sent to the cabinet for the approval and once the Cabinet approved, it would be presented before the parliament for the approval. “Currently there is no law in the country against the gas theft,” he added.
The PAC referred this issue to the NAB and directed to furnish a report on it to the committee within next 15 days.
While examining the audit paras of devolved Ministry of Ministry of Environment, the PAC was told that some record of the ministry was burnt in a fire at Shaheed-Milat Secretariat and CDA Block No IV near Lal Masjid.
Sheikh Rashid Ahmed said that the administration has no facility to handle the fire at a top floor of the Shaheed-e-Millat Secretriat.
Mehmood Khan Achackzai questioned whether the inquiry was ordered on how the fire reached the top floor of Shaheed-e-Millat Secretariat.
The PAC sought a report of inquiry of fire at the Shaheed-e-Millat Secretariat.
Main Abdul Manan was of the opinion that the PAC should itself inquire the incident. However, the concerned department conceded before the PAC that it did not know whether the inquiry was made or not as the Public Works Department was responsible for caretaking of the Shaheed-e-Millat Secretariat.
The PAC has also took the note of non-serious attitude of the bureaucracy in budget making process of their departments and observed that some department even did not have the capacity of spending of the.
In one of the aduit para of the Environment Division, the department of audit pointed out that in 1998-99 a bonus of Rs600,000 was given to the employees despite the fact that company sustained a loss of Rs10 million.
The PAC was of the opinion that though the low grade employees justified to get the bonus but the top grade officials did not have a right to get the bonus so the bonus should be recovered from the senior officers.
The Audit officials told the PAC that the bonus was given to 30 senior officers of the department.
The PAC directed to recover the bonus from all the employees.
While examining the audit accounts of the Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Resources, the Audit department presented the report to the PAC that in 1998-99, the PSO gave Rs3.6 million for the land for using as a oil storage but the plot did not exist.
The PSO made the payment of Rs3.6 million to M/s Gilanni Traders as advance.
Chairman PAC Syed Khursheed Shah directed the PSO to register a criminal case and FIR against those who made a fraud.
The PSO officials told the PAC that they were tracing NID card of the owner of the M/s Gilanni traders and the issue is in the courts of Law.
In reply to a question of Sheikh Roheel Asghar, the PSO officials told the committee that Rs one million has been spent on litigation in the courts of law.
Dr Arif Alvi observed that no single official or cashier alone was involved in such a big fraud. “Why the responsibility was not fixed in the inquiry report,” he questioned from the PSO.
The PAC also referred this case to the NAB and directed to submit the report to the committee within next two months.
In the meanwhile, the Committee sought details of those 3200 assignment accounts through which payments were made without any check and balances and remained unaudited.
The PAC directive come up after the revelation made by deputy AGP that there are 3200 assignment accounts in the country through which the payments were made without any check and balances and even they were out of the purview of the audit.
Khursheed Shah directed the AGP to furnish details of assignment accounts before the PAC in its next meeting.
http://www.thenews.com.pk/Todays-News-6-227109-PAC-settles-Chaudhry-Sugar-Mills-gas-theft-case
PMLN kay gov mein attey hi 15 saal ka case haal (clap)
PAC settles Chaudhry Sugar Mills gas theft case
The Public Accounts Committee (PAC) Thursday settled 16-year old pending para of theft of Rs3.57 million gas by Chaudhry Sugar Mills Gojra owned by Sharif family on the recommendations of Auditor General of Pakistan (AGP) and Sui Northern Gas Pipeline.
The AGP in 1998 pointed out gas theft by Chaudhry Sugar Mills and made an audit para that remained pending for last 12 years as the audit department did not accept the management’s reply over the issue.
The AGP was of the opinion that SNGPL, Area Office, Faisalabad, billed 16788 HM3 gas consumption to M/s Chaudhry Sugar Mills Gojra for the period from March to May 1998 as against actual gas aggregating to 26605 HM# that passed through SMS during the period; thus 9817 HM3 gas was short-billed to the consumer and SNGPL had to sustain a loss of Rs3.520 million on this accounts.
According to documents presented in the PAC, the auditors pointed out this issue in July 20, 1999, October 15, 1999 and November 17, 1999 but no action was taken on.
The documents showed that on July 26, 2011 and again on July 29, 2011 the issue was raised and SNGPL replied that M/s Chaudhry Sugar Mills, M/s Hamza Paper Board Mills and Housing Colony was provided the gas.
Interestingly, the audit department stuck to their stance and sought explanations from the SNGPL but after the present government comes into power, the Departmental Accounts Committee (DAC) in its meeting on January 10, 2014, the audit department and SNGPL agreed to settle the issue.
On Thursday the documents for settling the para were presented before the PAC. Managing Director of the SNGPL Arif Hameed was of the opinion in the meeting that Chaudhry Sugar Mills was not involved in gas theft but it was a technical mistake as three meters were installed but the billing of the two meters were not conducted and this difference is mainly owing to different meter reading dates, different pressure, temperature and super compressibility factors applied in computing volume by distribution and transmission department.
However, he said when the meter reading of all three meters were compiled, the loss was less than one percent.
The stance of SNGPL was also accepted by the department of the Auditor General of Pakistan and the PAC settled the audit para amicably.
In the PAC, Sheikh Rohail Asghar observed that it was a mistake of the department of Auditor General of Pakistan that created a technical mistake.
In the meanwhile, the PAC referred the cases of gas theft of Rs90 million of 1998-99 by nine steel re-rolling factories of Lahore to the National Accountability Bureau.
The department of the Auditor General of Pakistan pointed out the gas theft by nine factories of Lahore in 1998-99.
Managing Director of the SNGPL Arif Hameed told the PAC that the owners of these factories has run away from the country and factories were closed.
Chairman PAC Syed Khursheed Shah remarked that under the law, gas connections could not be given to the place of the defaulters so why the connections were given to the new factories which were open again there.
Mian Abul Manan observed that private houses were being sealed if they default on gas bills but why the big fish were not catch.
The MD SNGPL told the PAC that the government has drafted the Gas Theft Act that was sent to the cabinet for the approval and once the Cabinet approved, it would be presented before the parliament for the approval. “Currently there is no law in the country against the gas theft,” he added.
The PAC referred this issue to the NAB and directed to furnish a report on it to the committee within next 15 days.
While examining the audit paras of devolved Ministry of Ministry of Environment, the PAC was told that some record of the ministry was burnt in a fire at Shaheed-Milat Secretariat and CDA Block No IV near Lal Masjid.
Sheikh Rashid Ahmed said that the administration has no facility to handle the fire at a top floor of the Shaheed-e-Millat Secretriat.
Mehmood Khan Achackzai questioned whether the inquiry was ordered on how the fire reached the top floor of Shaheed-e-Millat Secretariat.
The PAC sought a report of inquiry of fire at the Shaheed-e-Millat Secretariat.
Main Abdul Manan was of the opinion that the PAC should itself inquire the incident. However, the concerned department conceded before the PAC that it did not know whether the inquiry was made or not as the Public Works Department was responsible for caretaking of the Shaheed-e-Millat Secretariat.
The PAC has also took the note of non-serious attitude of the bureaucracy in budget making process of their departments and observed that some department even did not have the capacity of spending of the.
In one of the aduit para of the Environment Division, the department of audit pointed out that in 1998-99 a bonus of Rs600,000 was given to the employees despite the fact that company sustained a loss of Rs10 million.
The PAC was of the opinion that though the low grade employees justified to get the bonus but the top grade officials did not have a right to get the bonus so the bonus should be recovered from the senior officers.
The Audit officials told the PAC that the bonus was given to 30 senior officers of the department.
The PAC directed to recover the bonus from all the employees.
While examining the audit accounts of the Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Resources, the Audit department presented the report to the PAC that in 1998-99, the PSO gave Rs3.6 million for the land for using as a oil storage but the plot did not exist.
The PSO made the payment of Rs3.6 million to M/s Gilanni Traders as advance.
Chairman PAC Syed Khursheed Shah directed the PSO to register a criminal case and FIR against those who made a fraud.
The PSO officials told the PAC that they were tracing NID card of the owner of the M/s Gilanni traders and the issue is in the courts of Law.
In reply to a question of Sheikh Roheel Asghar, the PSO officials told the committee that Rs one million has been spent on litigation in the courts of law.
Dr Arif Alvi observed that no single official or cashier alone was involved in such a big fraud. “Why the responsibility was not fixed in the inquiry report,” he questioned from the PSO.
The PAC also referred this case to the NAB and directed to submit the report to the committee within next two months.
In the meanwhile, the Committee sought details of those 3200 assignment accounts through which payments were made without any check and balances and remained unaudited.
The PAC directive come up after the revelation made by deputy AGP that there are 3200 assignment accounts in the country through which the payments were made without any check and balances and even they were out of the purview of the audit.
Khursheed Shah directed the AGP to furnish details of assignment accounts before the PAC in its next meeting.
http://www.thenews.com.pk/Todays-News-6-227109-PAC-settles-Chaudhry-Sugar-Mills-gas-theft-case
Last edited by a moderator:





