Advertisement

Aapas Ki Baat - 10th September 2012 - Najam Sethi Unveils The Story Behind Local Bodies Elections &



kpukX.png
 
Last edited:
Advertisement
about the first part.....................so he says mqm is doing all this to stop pti and pmln from getting any seats from karachi.............

i don't fully agree..................pmln don't seem likely to be getting anything from karachi (maybe maybe from rural sindh.....cus of few sardars who joined them)
its mqm demand to have local elections......so that they can be in power somehow to be able to be part of intrim govt.........and then possibly rig elections...........
This is the whole game.............
Is PTI leadership aware of that?
cus right now sindhis/nationalists are unhappy about divided rule in sindh but once zardar/ppp break some sort of deal with them...they might go quiet too.............PTI will be the sole loser in there.............they should react and react fast and agressively.............
@mrk123
 
Advertisement
about the first part.....................so he says mqm is doing all this to stop pti and pmln from getting any seats from karachi.............

i don't fully agree..................pmln don't seem likely to be getting anything from karachi (maybe maybe from rural sindh.....cus of few sardars who joined them)
its mqm demand to have local elections......so that they can be in power somehow to be able to be part of intrim govt.........and then possibly rig elections...........
This is the whole game.............
Is PTI leadership aware of that?
cus right now sindhis/nationalists are unhappy about divided rule in sindh but once zardar/ppp break some sort of deal with them...they might go quiet too.............PTI will be the sole loser in there.............they should react and react fast and agressively.............
@mrk123

I also partly agree with NS's analysis. I think you have to analyze it from PPP and MQM's perspective. From PPP's perspective the goals are short term - they need MQM until the election - especially, as NS said, if they have to elect a new PM if raja rental is kicked out too. From MQM's perspective the goal is long term. I don't think that they are thinking about national assembly or Sindh assembly at this time. They know that their seats are going to be more or less intact - give or take a few seats.

MQM always gets its way when it is a sidekick of the party that is ruling in the center - they have shown that they don't care who it is - they even allied themselves with a military dictator. In the coming election they know that the support they got from the military government of Musharraf will not be available. Given that people have found out about the bogus votes and with Farkhroo Bhai as CEC the chances are that the elections would be a little more free and fair this time. When that happens then you can't predict for sure that MQM will win as many seats - they may lose somewhere from 2-3 seats. If the party that forms the government at the center is either PTI or PMLn then MQM will be in the wilderness. To counter this scenario they want to at least solidify themselves at the local bodies elections while they can with the bogus votes and current government's machinery still supporting them. I am sure that right after they win the LB elections their next demand will bethey will be for funds to run the local government. This way they somehow remain relevant and also have nuisance factor for the government in the center to claim that they are representatives of the population of urban sindh and can't be ignored even if they are not part of the government.

I agree with you that PTI needs more viable candidates in Sindh. They will have a very good chance if they put up Asad Umar from the defence area. If they could have found another couple of Asad Umar clones and give them tickets from the upper middle class localities then they stand a good chance. In rural Sindh I am not sure if they could have done anything other than recruiting a few sardars/feudals/tribal sardars.

This is the reason I think that parliamentary system doesn't suit Pakistan. Already complicated situation is further complicated by parliamentary politics :-)
 
I also partly agree with NS's analysis. I think you have to analyze it from PPP and MQM's perspective. From PPP's perspective the goals are short term - they need MQM until the election - especially, as NS said, if they have to elect a new PM if raja rental is kicked out too. From MQM's perspective the goal is long term. I don't think that they are thinking about national assembly or Sindh assembly at this time. They know that their seats are going to be more or less intact - give or take a few seats.

MQM always gets its way when it is a sidekick of the party that is ruling in the center - they have shown that they don't care who it is - they even allied themselves with a military dictator. In the coming election they know that the support they got from the military government of Musharraf will not be available. Given that people have found out about the bogus votes and with Farkhroo Bhai as CEC the chances are that the elections would be a little more free and fair this time. When that happens then you can't predict for sure that MQM will win as many seats - they may lose somewhere from 2-3 seats. If the party that forms the government at the center is either PTI or PMLn then MQM will be in the wilderness. To counter this scenario they want to at least solidify themselves at the local bodies elections while they can with the bogus votes and current government's machinery still supporting them. I am sure that right after they win the LB elections their next demand will bethey will be for funds to run the local government. This way they somehow remain relevant and also have nuisance factor for the government in the center to claim that they are representatives of the population of urban sindh and can't be ignored even if they are not part of the government.

I agree with you that PTI needs more viable candidates in Sindh. They will have a very good chance if they put up Asad Umar from the defence area. If they could have found another couple of Asad Umar clones and give them tickets from the upper middle class localities then they stand a good chance. In rural Sindh I am not sure if they could have done anything other than recruiting a few sardars/feudals/tribal sardars.

This is the reason I think that parliamentary system doesn't suit Pakistan. Already complicated situation is further complicated by parliamentary politics :-)

Don't worry, MQM will support PTI in Pakhtoon areas of Karachi just to defeat ANP. This way MQM will be a winner and the rests will be losers for sure.
My assesment, this time MQM will get more seats than ever before.
As a Karachi citizen I know what the people think about MQM and especially the success model of Mustafa Kamal will never let MQM down.
 
Don't worry, MQM will support PTI in Pakhtoon areas of Karachi just to defeat ANP. This way MQM will be a winner and the rests will be losers for sure.
My assesment, this time MQM will get more seats than ever before.
As a Karachi citizen I know what the people think about MQM and especially the success model of Mustafa Kamal will never let MQM down.

I am not worried about anything Aijaz Bhai. I am used to this crazy happenings all over Pakistan and specially in Pakistan. This petty ethnic, tribal, sectarian, biradari politics have been destroying Pakistan and will keep doing that. There are people who get entangled and thrive on this type of politics and then there are people like me who hope and wish that people get out of their cocoons and think on a bigger level otherwise we will be history.

I respect your opinion but I beg to differ and since I am a co-citizen of Karachi I have my own opinion on how things will turn out ;-) We will know after the elections if MQM gains more seats as you say or will lose a couple as I am predicting.

By the way without the unlimited support and funding by a military dictator and the machinery of the federal government there is not much difference in the performance of MK or any other mayor of Karachi or for that matter anywhere in the world ;-)
 
Advertisement
Don't worry, MQM will support PTI in Pakhtoon areas of Karachi just to defeat ANP. This way MQM will be a winner and the rests will be losers for sure.
My assesment, this time MQM will get more seats than ever before.
As a Karachi citizen I know what the people think about MQM and especially the success model of Mustafa Kamal will never let MQM down.

Yeah right, success model, all exposed on one season of rains right after their rule. Previously, you were the only one ruling so media wont show your blunders but now, owing to other players, mqm is partially exposed on and off. You means mqm supporter, if you are not, you will be soon :P
 
I am not worried about anything Aijaz Bhai. I am used to this crazy happenings all over Pakistan and specially in Pakistan. This petty ethnic, tribal, sectarian, biradari politics have been destroying Pakistan and will keep doing that. There are people who get entangled and thrive on this type of politics and then there are people like me who hope and wish that people get out of their cocoons and think on a bigger level otherwise we will be history.

I respect your opinion but I beg to differ and since I am a co-citizen of Karachi I have my own opinion on how things will turn out ;-) We will know after the elections if MQM gains more seats as you say or will lose a couple as I am predicting.

By the way without the unlimited support and funding by a military dictator and the machinery of the federal government there is not much difference in the performance of MK or any other mayor of Karachi or for that matter anywhere in the world ;-)
Agreed, MK got support from a dictator Musharaf, but he and his party made positive use of the funds. They might have grabbed some portion of it, but people saw that still a big portion was utilized.That's what people want, don't you?
People of Karachi don't care who was behind MK, Ok, it was Musharaf, so don't they like both of them?
BTW, another fact, both MK and PM are Muhajirs, and people love them because of their ethinicity also. I admit. Unfortunate, but this is true in all over Pakistan, as you just said.
 
Last edited: