Advertisement

A slow roll-out: Eight months on, K-Ps promises of change remain tied up in red

PESHAWAR: Brimming over with enthusiasm to bring change from the outset, the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) led government in Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa (K-P) is yet to make its presence felt in terms of development work in the region. It has been in power for almost eight months.


The government has made little progress on the annual development programme (ADP) visualised for the fiscal year 2013-14. There are several factors, including a lack of disbursement of funds from the centre, which have resulted in the negligible gain on the ADP.



Yet, PTIs inability to match the rapid change that it visualised in its manifesto is also to be blamed. Imran Khans party has adopted a very conservative path towards development, seemingly to avoid any labels of financial corruption which marred Awami National Partys (ANP) rule in the province.



Many reasons have been cited to explain the delay in releasing funds for development work. The process to hire consultants for various departments has played a contributory factor. K-P Minister for Health Shaukat Yousufzai has said on one occasion, We entered the government with hardly any infrastructure or good baseline for governance left by ANP. Alluding through metaphors, the minister contended a train requires a proper railway track on which to run, and while the government needs to build that track, there is still time before things will get in to order.



A finance department officer of the Civil Secretariat revealed the PTI government has only received 25% of the total funds allocated to ADP. From the total planned budgetary outlay of Rs344 billion for the financial year 2013-14, Rs118 billion was set aside for development projects in K-P.



So far, only departments that have hired consultants have received funds from the ADP, added the official. Public health, irrigation and Auqaf departments have so far been successful in receiving the money. The idea behind hiring consultants is to carry forward the development agenda, to supervise and evaluate works carried out by the government apparatus.



Lean machinery



Another official, from the planning and development department, did not seem convinced about hiring consultants. Consultants cost and these will have to be borne by the government.
But, the official insisted, delays in utilising the ADP was only linked with the governments efforts to take every precautionary measure against financial loopholes. The entire process of establishing working groups for government departments, and later, the hiring of consultants, is aimed at ensuring efficient utilisation of resources this is what took the government half a fiscal year, he added.
Communication breakdown
Financial hiccups can also be traced to the lingering monetary disputes with the centre.



The provincial government has incessantly complained about the federal governments attitude towards timely disbursement of outstanding dues.
As recently as December 17, the provincial finance minister Sirajul Haq complained the centre is yet to release a previous liability of Rs1.5 billion as well as Rs7.5 billion under the head of net hydel profits for the current fiscal year.



The K-P government remains displeased with what it termed the federal governments attempts to level the fuel price adjustment surcharge with the province instead of ensuring power for the region. The provincial economy has not only suffered at the hands of the law and order situation in the region but also frequent and debilitating power outages.



Haq also alleged the centre harboured a hostile attitude towards K-P. While several mega development projects were planned, they are still awaiting approvals from the Central Development Working Party and the Executive Committee of the National Economic Council.



During a recent news conference, the minister revealed K-P has only received Rs19 billion against a promised Rs93 billion from the Public Sector Development Programme (PSDP), which he said was an indication of the federal governments discrimination towards the province.

source
 
Advertisement
Other than clamping down on corruption, PTI did not promise any fast track results in anything. There was no promise of ending loadshedding in 6 months, or building motorways in 8 months, or metrobuses in 1 year. The party promises revolved around strengthening institutions, and more importantly, devolution of power to the local level. If the KPK govt spends all the funds at the provincial level, it may end up making bad decisions on where to spend that money..and more over, having local bodies elections would become fruitless. As local bodies elections are just around the corner, it would be better to wait till local govts are in place, and then fund them in order to allow them to carry out development projects as they deem best, rather than based on what the central govt deems best.
 
The answer is also given by the article. It is good to have a slow start than giving away funds and lose most of it in corruption. PTI is right that there are no effective methods and check and balances so they have to set the rules of engagement first and then they should start giving funds for the developmental work. So far PTI is doing good by trying to strengthen the institutions and once the institutions are strong and self accountable then majority of funds will be used for good purpose out of fear of being caught by the accountability authorities.
 
Advertisement
i am feeling the change
i have seen the change
i am monitoring the change
and i am happy with this change as promised by PTI,
those people who are not aware of the change or don't want to realize the change and bashing PTI for nothing so Guy's first visit Peshawar or ask me or do some little research i would tell what real change is. don't be so foolish and selfish and degrading PTI who is at least on the right track.
 
The answer is also given by the article. It is good to have a slow start than giving away funds and lose most of it in corruption. PTI is right that there are no effective methods and check and balances so they have to set the rules of engagement first and then they should start giving funds for the developmental work. So far PTI is doing good by trying to strengthen the institutions and once the institutions are strong and self accountable then majority of funds will be used for good purpose out of fear of being caught by the accountability authorities.
 
It seems that Fed. Govt has intentionally blocked NFC funds of KPK a bureaucratic attitude, to stop any development and hence any credit to incumbent Govt.
 
The article heading is somewhat blameworthy but the article in itself is well balanced and self explanatory of all the points raised in the article.
Its better to Start late and on solid basis rather than Start early and doing the same things which Previous govts did. This is the change in itself that
The govt is trying to avoid all the already beaten corrupt path of previous Govts.
And they say


SLOW AND STEADY WINS THE RACE
 
Advertisement
PESHAWAR: Brimming over with enthusiasm to bring change from the outset, the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) led government in Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa (K-P) is yet to make its presence felt in terms of development work in the region. It has been in power for almost eight months.

The government has made little progress on the annual development programme (ADP) visualised for the fiscal year 2013-14. There are several factors, including a lack of disbursement of funds from the centre, which have resulted in the negligible gain on the ADP.
Yet, PTIs inability to match the rapid change that it visualised in its manifesto is also to be blamed. Imran Khans party has adopted a very conservative path towards development, seemingly to avoid any labels of financial corruption which marred Awami National Partys (ANP) rule in the province.

Many reasons have been cited to explain the delay in releasing funds for development work. The process to hire consultants for various departments has played a contributory factor. K-P Minister for Health Shaukat Yousufzai has said on one occasion, We entered the government with hardly any infrastructure or good baseline for governance left by ANP. Alluding through metaphors, the minister contended a train requires a proper railway track on which to run, and while the government needs to build that track, there is still time before things will get in to order.


A finance department officer of the Civil Secretariat revealed the PTI government has only received 25% of the total funds allocated to ADP. From the total planned budgetary outlay of Rs344 billion for the financial year 2013-14, Rs118 billion was set aside for development projects in K-P.


So far, only departments that have hired consultants have received funds from the ADP, added the official. Public health, irrigation and Auqaf departments have so far been successful in receiving the money. The idea behind hiring consultants is to carry forward the development agenda, to supervise and evaluate works carried out by the government apparatus.


Lean machinery


Another official, from the planning and development department, did not seem convinced about hiring consultants. Consultants cost and these will have to be borne by the government.

But, the official insisted, delays in utilising the ADP was only linked with the governments efforts to take every precautionary measure against financial loopholes. The entire process of establishing working groups for government departments, and later, the hiring of consultants, is aimed at ensuring efficient utilisation of resources this is what took the government half a fiscal year, he added.

Communication breakdown

Financial hiccups can also be traced to the lingering monetary disputes with the centre.

The provincial government has incessantly complained about the federal governments attitude towards timely disbursement of outstanding dues.
As recently as December 17, the provincial finance minister Sirajul Haq complained the centre is yet to release a previous liability of Rs1.5 billion as well as Rs7.5 billion under the head of net hydel profits for the current fiscal year.

The K-P government remains displeased with what it termed the federal governments attempts to level the fuel price adjustment surcharge with the province instead of ensuring power for the region. The provincial economy has not only suffered at the hands of the law and order situation in the region but also frequent and debilitating power outages.

Haq also alleged the centre harboured a hostile attitude towards K-P. While several mega development projects were planned, they are still awaiting approvals

from the Central Development Working Party and the Executive Committee of the National Economic Council.


During a recent news conference, the minister revealed K-P has only received Rs19 billion against a promised Rs93 billion from the Public Sector Development Programme (PSDP), which he said was an indication of the federal governments discrimination towards the province.

Published in The Express Tribune, January 7[SUP]th[/SUP], 2014.

http://tribune.com.pk/story/655654/...change-remain-tied-up-in-red/#comment-1956781
 
Honestly there is nothing more than cleaning roads and making promises in KPK

The PTI MPS are involved in meddling the day to day affairs of the officials
and pressurizing officers to get their shares in KPK.

The job of MPS are to do legislation and initiate new projects and expedite
the old one.

There are two groups in the PTI led govt ,one of the CM and the other one is
of Speaker.

There is a fighting within these tow groups and both of them
try to get hold of the civil administration and some time they bring their
own choice without looking at the reputation and record of the officer.

As I know it and very closely watching them.Recently a very competent
and a clean young officer of DMG group has been transfered from Malakand Agency
on the order and influence of the MPA Shakeel Ahmad and a very incompetent and corrupt
ranker has been posted ,who is not only corrupt but incompetent and MPA SHAKEEL AHMAD
is fully involved in all this drama.


I tell you now that both these seats will be lost if election is conducted.
MNA(junaid) from the same area is in group with Speaker KPK
while MPA (Shakeel)is in group with CM KPK

The PTI officials are requested that this matter should be looked into and
some clean and competent Political agent/DCO should be posted to run
the affairs on merit .I hope that the PTI supporters on this forum will raise
this issue with IK and other responsible
.
 
Last edited:
Honestly there is nothing more than cleaning roads and making promises

The PTI MPS are involved in meddling the day to day affairs of the officials
and pressurizing officers to get their shares.

The job of MPS are to do legislation and initiate new projects and expedite
the old one.

There are two groups in the PTI led govt ,one of the CM and the other one is
of Speaker.

There is a fighting within these tow groups and both of them
try to get hold of the civil administration and some time they bring their
own choice without looking at the reputation and record of the officer.

As I know it and very closely watching them.Recently a very competetnt
and a clean young officer of DMG group has been transfered from Malakand Agency
on the order and influence of the MPA Shakeel Ahmad and a very incompetent and corrupt
ranker has been posted ,who is not only corrupt but incompetent and MPA SHAKEEL AHMAD
is fully involved in all this drama.


I tell you now that both these seats will be lost if election is conducted.
MNA(junaid) from the same area is in group with Speaker KPK
while MPA (Shakeel)is in group with CM KPK

The PTI officials are requested that this matter should be looked into and
some clean and competent Political agent/DCO should be posted to run
the affairs on merit .I hope that the PTI supporters on this forum will raise
this issue with IK and other responsible
.

people have seen a lot of changes in patwari/ police/hosp/school system. Kashif Abbasi interviewed people and they told him.
 
Honestly there is nothing more than cleaning roads and making promises in KPK

As I know it and very closely watching them.Recently a very competent
and a clean young officer of DMG group has been transfered from Malakand Agency
on the order and influence of the MPA Shakeel Ahmad and a very incompetent and corrupt
ranker has been posted ,who is not only corrupt but incompetent and MPA SHAKEEL AHMAD
is fully involved in all this drama.


I tell you now that both these seats will be lost if election is conducted.
MNA(junaid) from the same area is in group with Speaker KPK
while MPA (Shakeel)is in group with CM KPK

The PTI officials are requested that this matter should be looked into and
some clean and competent Political agent/DCO should be posted to run
the affairs on merit .I hope that the PTI supporters on this forum will raise
this issue with IK and other responsible
.

people have seen a lot of changes in patwari/ police/hosp/school system. Kashif Abbasi interviewed people and they told him.


Yes PTI is doing good, And AlhamdoLillah, you can see that even single postings are quite obvious and difficult these days while no one cared about postings in the previous governments. 100% corruption free cannot be guaranteed and people will always want to exploit the loopholes and get benefit out of it but it is only the vision of a leader that can make the difference. No country of the world is 100% corruption free, and such cases(stated by Khan Afghan1) happens even in developed worlds but they are corrected in the long run. We are happy that these days illegal things are not impossible but difficult to do, which is a success in itself in a country when such things hardly ever mattered to us.
 
Advertisement
If that news is true as quoted by Khan Afghan1, then KP govt needs to take action. We being Insafians, wont tolerate the 2 group drama as quoted by the poster that CM group and Speaker group are spreading shhhiiiit.
 
If that news is true as quoted by Khan Afghan1, then KP govt needs to take action. We being Insafians, wont tolerate the 2 group drama as quoted by the poster that CM group and Speaker group are spreading shhhiiiit.

I am PTI supporter as the rest of you .I just want to bring the corruption and want it to be looked into.
I m not a candidate for any of such job.