- Joined
- Apr 7, 2011
- Posts
- 3,995
- Reaction score
- 6,438
- Points
- 113
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
This is the outcome of judiciary getting involved in political issues.
There is clearly an unspoken martial law in Pakistan and as always, judiciary is standing shaana bashaana with boots.
Which political issues?
Are you an unfortunate victim of your own overly repeated propaganda? Perhaps the noon league propagandists and the people of Pakistan reside on different planets.
Which political issues?
Are you an unfortunate victim of your own overly repeated propaganda? Perhaps the noon league propagandists and the people of Pakistan reside on different planets.
politically motivated issues such as panama, 35 puncture, memo gate, dawn leaks etc.
In all these cases, there is nothing like "political motivation" except for the misplaced politics and a convoluted mode of defense in the courtroom and the court of the public. All of these are strictly legal, and constitutional issues within the books of the law of the land and have always been the primary responsibility of the courts.politically motivated issues such as panama, 35 puncture, memo gate, dawn leaks etc.
In all these cases, there is nothing like "political motivation" except for the misplaced politics and a convoluted mode of defense in the courtroom and the court of the public. All of these are strictly legal, and constitutional issues within the books of the law of the land and have always been the primary responsibility of the courts.
The courts around the world deal with such legal and constitutional issues - if you are short of such examples, I may dare to have a cursory look at the legal cases put to the courts around the world.
Of course you would raise, once again a misplaced, objection pointing towards partial or selective justice. While this constitutes a usual and common ploy of defense to gain public sympathies; even if for the argument sake it is so that a genuine argument can made (and which can be easily raised in 90% of cases under trial due to different legal and political points in the kitty of defense experts), that DOES NOT make these cases politically motivated.
Even with usual legal game of narrating a cooked up history or a tale of suffering and vindication it WOULD NOT make these cases politically motivated. Just to mention that this constitutes the usual defense in about all high profile legal cases where the accused has calculated that public sympathy would result in pressurizing the court, or at least that would minimize the damage and the final sentence.
Now, we may point towards a broader canvas on which these and the majority of the legal and constitutional case regarding the law of the land, especially the high profile cases can be pained as political.
In the final analysis, the courts, the administration and the constitution of laws, all collectively, are subjected to the politics and the relative power of the different classes and interests.
First: in all legal cases there are interested parties which seek a certain outcome and in the present cases involving the fate of a political party and leader, naturally the political opposition is the interested yet an outsider party - Still, does this fact make them the politically motivated cases? In my strictly legal opinion , no, it doesn't.
Second, there is another dimension regarding the nature and the scope of the law. For example, for centuries, the king were considered the custodians of the law hence they were beyond law, but to the the will of the god. Or in China, not just the law, but the life of the subjects was owned by the king who possessed the souls. This may seem far fetched but, in our case, Bhutto zinda murda, or the majority of the events, today and in the past, fall under this dimension- i.e. not about the law but the nature and scope of the law. You might had put your case in such terms and we may have talked.
Unfortunately, at present, this dimension of the law cannot be raised in our present parliamentary democracy which has consensus regarding the equal justice (as per book) and the rule of law.
I have used the words "misguided and propaganda" since, at least in your case, I suspect your usage of term 'politically motivated' comes from your true feelings extracting from your readings of the political and legal history of our nation. We may discuss such issues issues and events (one by one) that have led to these feelings, however, always, the devil is in the details, and to disengage history from the disease of Presentism.---As usual my answer is loong. sorry.
Memo gate? How? All the facts were correct and proven with testimonies, from here at our end up to the US congress and Pentagon. There was no doubt that the law of the land was breached. However, the pertinent question only related to assessment that such a trial would be beneficial or not for the country. This problem was not about legality but again the scope of the law at a certain point of time. IMO, it was handled well, where all the facts were put in the books for the future historian with minimal adverse and unbearable consequences.politically motivated issues such as panama, 35 puncture, memo gate, dawn leaks etc.
© Copyrights 2008 - 2026 Siasat.pk - All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | Disclaimer|