All Pakistanis want tabdeeli, but noone is willing to make the sacrifices associated with it. They want tabdeeli to come, while they continue to steal, loot, evade taxes, overcharge, hoard, break traffic laws, and defraud people.
This is unfortunately, the hellish generation our past rulers have created in Pakistan. We will live with this scum for years to come.
Tabdeeli was never an overnight affair. It is a process, and will take time. Live with it.
All Pakistanis want tabdeeli, but noone is willing to make the sacrifices associated with it. They want tabdeeli to come, while they continue to steal, loot, evade taxes, overcharge, hoard, break traffic laws, and defraud people.
This is unfortunately, the hellish generation our past rulers have created in Pakistan. We will live with this scum for years to come.
Tabdeeli was never an overnight affair. It is a process, and will take time. Live with it.
Mazay ki baat kay it was Ishaq Dar who lied about this $200 billion figure....and then ran away.
PMLN has fallen to now simply picking out 'joshe khitabats'. Duty karo bhai.
Mazay ki baat kay it was Ishaq Dar who lied about this $200 billion figure....and then ran away.
PMLN has fallen to now simply picking out 'joshe khitabats'. Duty karo bhai.
Ishaq Dar denied this news item in 2014
But the news reports have attributed the words to the finance minister. When I asked the minister about the veracity of this number he denied ever having said such a thing. So where did these numbers come from? And why are they being attributed to the minister?
Here’s what happened. Back in May of this year (2014), Dr Arif Alvi of the Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf asked the finance minister about the “steps being taken by the government to bring back assets of the country which are illegally deposited in Swiss Banks; and whether there is any proposal under consideration of the government to take help of the 2010 Swiss Law, the ‘Restitution of Illicit Assets Act (RIAA)’”.
The minister replied in writing that the government intends to take advantage of the RIAA but in order to do this the government needs to renegotiate the Pak-Swiss Tax Treaty currently in force. These negotiations are set to begin on Aug 26. That’s all.
But the minister’s reply was furnished in writing, in his absence, by the Parliamentary Secretary for Finance, Rana Mohammad Afzal Khan. The good secretary decided to go on the record himself, and speaking on behalf of the finance minister threw out the two additional bits of information on his own.
The next day the headlines zoomed in on the $200bn figure. When reporting the exchange one paper attributed the statement to “the government,” another attributed it to the secretary by name, and a third followed an older reporting convention and attributed it to the finance minister himself, since the secretary was speaking on the minister’s behalf.
The serious matter of retrieving ill-gotten gains has been turned into a joke.
www.dawn.com
اسحاق ڈار نے نہیں ایک این جی او نے رپورٹ بنائی ، اسے سب سے پہلے عمران خان نے پھیلانا شروع کیا ، اسحاق ڈار نے اس رپورٹ پر کاروائی شروع کی ، سوئس حکومت سے اس عالمی ایجنسی سے معلومات کے تبادلے کے معاہدے کئے ، ان معاہدوں کی رپورٹ اس حکومت میں آئی جس کے مطابق ایسا کچھ نہیں تھا
All Pakistanis want tabdeeli, but noone is willing to make the sacrifices associated with it. They want tabdeeli to come, while they continue to steal, loot, evade taxes, overcharge, hoard, break traffic laws, and defraud people.
This is unfortunately, the hellish generation our past rulers have created in Pakistan. We will live with this scum for years to come.
Tabdeeli was never an overnight affair. It is a process, and will take time. Live with it.
But the news reports have attributed the words to the finance minister. When I asked the minister about the veracity of this number he denied ever having said such a thing. So where did these numbers come from? And why are they being attributed to the minister?
Here’s what happened. Back in May of this year (2014), Dr Arif Alvi of the Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf asked the finance minister about the “steps being taken by the government to bring back assets of the country which are illegally deposited in Swiss Banks; and whether there is any proposal under consideration of the government to take help of the 2010 Swiss Law, the ‘Restitution of Illicit Assets Act (RIAA)’”.
The minister replied in writing that the government intends to take advantage of the RIAA but in order to do this the government needs to renegotiate the Pak-Swiss Tax Treaty currently in force. These negotiations are set to begin on Aug 26. That’s all.
But the minister’s reply was furnished in writing, in his absence, by the Parliamentary Secretary for Finance, Rana Mohammad Afzal Khan. The good secretary decided to go on the record himself, and speaking on behalf of the finance minister threw out the two additional bits of information on his own.
The next day the headlines zoomed in on the $200bn figure. When reporting the exchange one paper attributed the statement to “the government,” another attributed it to the secretary by name, and a third followed an older reporting convention and attributed it to the finance minister himself, since the secretary was speaking on the minister’s behalf.
The serious matter of retrieving ill-gotten gains has been turned into a joke.
www.dawn.com
اسحاق ڈار نے نہیں ایک این جی او نے رپورٹ بنائی ، اسے سب سے پہلے عمران خان نے پھیلانا شروع کیا ، اسحاق ڈار نے اس رپورٹ پر کاروائی شروع کی ، سوئس حکومت سے اس عالمی ایجنسی سے معلومات کے تبادلے کے معاہدے کئے ، ان معاہدوں کی رپورٹ اس حکومت میں آئی جس کے مطابق ایسا کچھ نہیں تھا
This news was published on May 11, 2014 while the news item I shared earlier was in response of this news item which was published on August 07, 2014.
As per the news you shared, it has two portion first three paragraphs are about the question, all the gigures about $200 were mentioned in the question. This was his response:
Mr Dar said the situation called for immediate corrective action. To put the enormity of this find into perspective, Pakistan’s total external debt stands at $150 billion and its gross domestic product is said to be around $300 billion. The country can, theoretically, pay off all its debt with the money in Swiss banks and still have nearly a quarter of it left over.
The finance minister said the government was working under the ambit of a new Swiss law, known as ‘The Restitution of Illicit Assets Act, 2010’ (RIAA), which allows the Swiss government to exchange information — which was considered confidential up to now — regarding money that may have been obtained illegally and deposited in Swiss banks. He also briefed the house on the steps the government was taking to get the money back.
The minister said the federal cabinet in a meeting on Sept 20 last year had already approved renegotiation of the current Pak-Swiss tax treaty and Federal Board of Revenue officials and the Swiss authorities concerned had agreed to meet in August this year to upgrade the existing agreement.
In his reply, Mr Dar also referred to various international pressures that had forced the Swiss government to review its policy on clandestine banking.
This news was published on May 11, 2014 while the news item I shared earlier was in response of this news item which was published on August 07, 2014.
As per the news you shared, it has two portion first three paragraphs are about the question, all the gigures about $200 were mentioned in the question. This was his response:
Mr Dar said the situation called for immediate corrective action. To put the enormity of this find into perspective, Pakistan’s total external debt stands at $150 billion and its gross domestic product is said to be around $300 billion. The country can, theoretically, pay off all its debt with the money in Swiss banks and still have nearly a quarter of it left over.
The finance minister said the government was working under the ambit of a new Swiss law, known as ‘The Restitution of Illicit Assets Act, 2010’ (RIAA), which allows the Swiss government to exchange information — which was considered confidential up to now — regarding money that may have been obtained illegally and deposited in Swiss banks. He also briefed the house on the steps the government was taking to get the money back.
The minister said the federal cabinet in a meeting on Sept 20 last year had already approved renegotiation of the current Pak-Swiss tax treaty and Federal Board of Revenue officials and the Swiss authorities concerned had agreed to meet in August this year to upgrade the existing agreement.
In his reply, Mr Dar also referred to various international pressures that had forced the Swiss government to review its policy on clandestine banking.
The statement was red by Rana Afzal on behalf of Ishaq Dar. Mr. Alvi asked supplementary question whether you agree about figures in question, Rana Afzal answered that as the statements never denied by Swiss authorities so we have to believe them. That was it. All other was blown out by the PTI and media.