Advertisement

کالا باغ ڈیم: پاکستان سے غداری اور خیانت کی المناک داستان

KBD_01.jpg

KBD_02.jpg

KBD_03.jpg

KBD_04.jpg

KBD_05.jpg

KBD_06.jpg

KBD_07.jpg

KBD_08.jpg

KBD_09.jpg
 
Advertisement
وڑائچ صاحب یہ مضمون کس نے لکھا ہے؟
 
unfortunately does not look like this dam going to be built. Its not in the 100 days plan of PTI and no other major parties have it in their plan.

Rightly or wrongly awami mood in smaller provinces is against this dam. Musharraf tried his best but it did not work out. As far as I remember smaller provinces wanted a fool proof security that punjab not going to stop sindh's water and they demanded UN or world bank as a guarantor. Government thought its against the national integrity to involve external bodies for internal matter.

Given the importance of this project, the government should agree on third party solicitation in this matter and accept world bank or UN as the guarantor.
 
Advertisement
unfortunately does not look like this dam going to be built. Its not in the 100 days plan of PTI and no other major parties have it in their plan.

Rightly or wrongly awami mood in smaller provinces is against this dam. Musharraf tried his best but it did not work out. As far as I remember smaller provinces wanted a fool proof security that punjab not going to stop sindh's water and they demanded UN or world bank as a guarantor. Government thought its against the national integrity to involve external bodies for internal matter.

Given the importance of this project, the government should agree on third party solicitation in this matter and accept world bank or UN as the guarantor.

I agree with you that this dam must be constructed even if we have to get WB guarantee to pacify smaller provinces. PTI (if it ends up forming the next government) will be hit by the harsh reality of water scarcity and will have to do something to bring provinces onboard. I am not sure why it was sleeping on this issue for the last five years in KPK (probably due to parliamentary minority position). However this should be their number 1 priority. The agricultural reforms agenda in their 100-day plan will be meaningless if nothing is done on water management.
 
I agree with you that this dam must be constructed even if we have to get WB guarantee to pacify smaller provinces. PTI (if it ends up forming the next government) will be hit by the harsh reality of water scarcity and will have to do something to bring provinces onboard. I am not sure why it was sleeping on this issue for the last five years in KPK (probably due to parliamentary minority position). However this should be their number 1 priority. The agricultural reforms agenda in their 100-day plan will be meaningless if nothing is done on water management.

I think, main reason is: they had coalition govt. in KPK....
 
I agree with you that this dam must be constructed even if we have to get WB guarantee to pacify smaller provinces. PTI (if it ends up forming the next government) will be hit by the harsh reality of water scarcity and will have to do something to bring provinces onboard. I am not sure why it was sleeping on this issue for the last five years in KPK (probably due to parliamentary minority position). However this should be their number 1 priority. The agricultural reforms agenda in their 100-day plan will be meaningless if nothing is done on water management.

PTI has bhasha dam in their agenda, not kala baagh.
 
Advertisement
زید حامد نے ٹیکنکل دلائل کی بجائے کوسنوں کا ذیادہ استعمال کیا ہے۔
ویسے کالاباغ ڈیم سے کہیں بہتر اور قابل قبول منصوبہ ڈھوک پٹھان ڈیم ہے جس کی سٹوریج کالاباغ سے 6 گنا ذیادہ ہے۔

https://twitter.com/inamre

23755009_1678069318903403_3647844170581070227_n.jpg
 
Kala bagh kai elawa tw koi dam ban hi nahi sakta Pakistan mai? Agar kisi ko zara bhi ehsas hota tw woh kala bagh par larnay kai bajay Diamer bhasha dam aur Dasu dam bana chuka hota. Agar sirf dam bana kat hydro power and water storage ki neat hoti tw yeah dono dam complete ho chukay hotay aur koi kala bagh dam ki bat nahi kar raha hota
 
Advertisement
زید حامد نے ٹیکنکل دلائل کی بجائے کوسنوں کا ذیادہ استعمال کیا ہے۔
ویسے کالاباغ ڈیم سے کہیں بہتر اور قابل قبول منصوبہ ڈھوک پٹھان ڈیم ہے جس کی سٹوریج کالاباغ سے 6 گنا ذیادہ ہے۔


https://twitter.com/inamre
23755009_1678069318903403_3647844170581070227_n.jpg
Wouldn't this dam also have the same political issues a s Kalabagh dam?
 
Wouldn't this dam have the same political issues a s Kalabagh dam?
No, for following reasons.
1. It is located in Punjab and no KPK land is effected.
2. It can completely absorb the Indus floods from Tarbela to Thatta.
3. Having a storage size of 38 MAF, It can store all the 35 MAF water that spills into sea during flood month. Kalabagh and Diamer Basha are just 6.4 and 6.2 MAF each.
4. Both Sindh and Punjab can get about 14 MAF extra water each, per year which is more than Tarbela and Mangla put together.
 
No, for following reasons.
1. It is located in Punjab and no KPK land is effected.
2. It can completely absorb the Indus floods from Tarbela to Thatta.
3. Having a storage size of 38 MAF, It can store all the 35 MAF water that spills into sea during flood month. Kalabagh and Diamer Basha are just 6.4 and 6.2 MAF each.
4. Both Sindh and Punjab can get about 14 MAF extra water each, per year which is more than Tarbela and Mangla put together.

All good but will Sindh agree. They will have the same political rhetoric as they had with Kalabagh dam.
 
Advertisement
All good but will Sindh agree. They will have the same political rhetoric as they had with Kalabagh dam.
It can be built for all provinces, but if Sindh does n't want to participate, project can be built with a smaller capacity of about 20 MAF to park the water for other three provinces only.
 
It can be built for all provinces, but if Sindh does n't want to participate, project can be built with a smaller capacity of about 20 MAF to park the water for other three provinces only.

If provinces can agree then we should build as many dams as we can.
 
If provinces can agree then we should build as many dams as we can.
We will hardly need any other storage dam if DhokPthan is built. however hydel power ROR dams can be built all along Indus and Jhelum